News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by caymanjim on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @09:51PM (#23696868)
I love YoutubeTV, and I've been using it for years. This is probably enough to get me to cancel, though. It started at $40 when I signed up a couple years ago, they raised it to $50 last year, and now $65 for just a few more channels (and among them, only one I even want).

I wish they'd offer a more a la carte option. I'd be willing to pay $10-15 per major broadcaster's channel collection, or $2-7 for individual channels (depending on quality of programming). I might even land at $50 or more with my channel choices, but I'd prefer to pick what I'm paying for instead of subsidizing dozens of channels of programming I dislike (and quite a few that I would prefer to boycott entirely).

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by burlesona on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:22PM (#23697430)
The conventional TV channels don't allow their networks to be sold a-la-carte because they all make more money via the bundle than anyone would be willing to pay for their channels individually. Remember that most of these channels are related - for example, NBC owns Telemundo, SyFy, USA, Bravo, E!, Oxygen, etc. They sell all of those through bundles and keep $20/mo or so, but how many people would pay that much for any one of the channels, and how many people would actually buy them all?

I think everyone would love to just get their favorite channels for (let's say) $3/mo/channel with no ads... but that would be a huge loss for the media companies, so they won't sell that way.

Instead what we're seeing is disruption via alternative models, like Netflix, HBO, Apple TV+, and now even the biggest media owner (Disney) offering Disney+ and ESPN+ direct.

I'm not sure if conventional TV will still exist in its current form in a decade, but I don't think we'll ever see today's bundled TV become available a-la-carte, because it isn't compatible with that business model.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by voodootrucker on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @06:14AM (#23699866)
America has a lot of problems, but they all look strangely like anti-trust: https://mattstoller.substack.com/
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by adamrezich on Thursday July 02, 2020 @03:07AM (#23710719)
really turned off by that landing overlay
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by Zenbit_UX on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:22PM (#23709633)
What about obesity?
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by voodootrucker on Monday July 06, 2020 @08:12AM (#23747054)
Large chains pushing cheap, processed crap food in food deserts that the poor are trapped in?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_desert https://diabetes.diabetesjournals.org/content/60/11/2667

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by FeepingCreature on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @04:15AM (#23699123)
Mind you, they're also not getting any money from the people who are currently not interested because the price is too high.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by strangescript on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:06PM (#23696947)
It's not the services fault. These big tv conglomerates don't want their channels optional because they know no one wants them for the most part. Or, at the very least, you won't accidentally start watching something on their network if you don't even have the channel.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by sutterbomb on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:23PM (#23697064)
Everyone thinks they want a la carte, but (most) everyone is wrong. Bundling is generally better for consumers and producers.

https://cdixon.org/2012/07/08/how-bundling-benefits-sellers-...

Stratechery also has written about this

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by newbie789 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:41PM (#23697181)
That's an interesting perspective, but it kind of looks like a lot of graphs saying "You should pay for stuff you don't want because otherwise it would incentivize the sellers to price gouge you for the stuff you do want"

I'm kind of confused, if it's an adversarial relationship where the seller is going to extract as much money from you as possible in either scenario, wouldn't some consumers prefer to pay specifically to starve out content they'd prefer not to see?

Maybe I'm not understanding this page, but it looks like it's "good" for me because instead of paying $9-10 for the History Channel alone I'll be paying $11.70 for History Channel + ESPN (which I will literally never watch)?

I'm not a calculus genius but I'd prefer to spend less money and only have what I want. This model assumes that I'd be willing to spend $3 per month on ESPN, but how does the graph look if I were willing to spend $0 per month on it? Or hell, since pricing is arbitrary, I'd like to pay -$3 per month as a courtesy for having to scroll past content I genuinely do not want to consume let alone subsidize?

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by ridaj on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:47AM (#23698159)
The argument is not about your buying preferences as a consumer. Of course if you had a choice between (a) paying X for watching stuff, or (b) paying Y for the ability to watch exactly the same thing, but Y is overall less money because it is somehow dependent of the amount that you consume, that is the better choice.

However, the economic equilibrium of a perfectly unbundled system is not that you get to watch the same thing for less money. It is, in the general case, that you either get less content, or pay more, or both.

To take your example, realize that it is outlier behavior to be willing to pay $9/mo for History and $0/mo for ESPN. If you took History channel, with the content that it has now, out of the cable bundle and tried to sell it $9/mo, or even $1/mo, there would be way too few interested customers to make such a proposition economically viable.

In a perfectly unbundled world, content such as the History channel does not exist. You only have marquee content like ESPN, movies for rental or purchase, or (if lowercase history is your thing) highly produced documentaries, i.e. the kind of content that willingness to pay for is high enough to justify the high customer acquisition cost. You do not have content like History channel because it lies in that tier of things that many people are kind of interested in watching, but only if it comes with something else more valuable that they already paid for.

One can debate the societal value of the existence of content such as the History channel to begin with, but that's what the argument is about, not about the consumer's individual preferences in a hypothetical world where it would be possible to watch the same content for cheaper.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by angry_octet on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:39AM (#23700348)
This misunderstands the market. I would pay for the History Channel but I wouldn't pay for ESPN. And I won't pay for a bundle because then 'analysts' will think I'm getting it for ESPN.

History Channel is cheap to make compared to sports, would definitely be able to pay for itself with cheap subscriptions.

Cable TV with bundling is just a local maxima established decades ago. The long tail of interest that drives regular youtube is the proof.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by ridaj on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:23AM (#23701655)
If this misunderstands the market, I'd be interested in a positive proof of a channel like History making it as an independent offering. I don't personally know of any.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by FeepingCreature on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @04:16AM (#23699137)
> You do not have content like History channel because it lies in that tier of things that many people are kind of interested in watching, but only if it comes with something else more valuable that they already paid for.

This seems like you're saying "bundling mis-serves the customer." If the History Channel would not exist if people could pay for it directly, then why should it ought to exist?

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by Jweb_Guru on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @05:37AM (#23699643)
The idea the article is trying to get at is (I think) that people are willing to pay for the history channel, but as long as they're more willing to pay for some other channels, studios will just jack up the price of the other channels to the point where their funds for discretionary spending on television are exhausted very quickly. This is because it's cheaper for the studios to get people to pay more per show while producing fewer shows, as this increases their profit margins to the maximum they can get away with. The argument that this is bad for consumers is pretty straightforward, but I will point out that these incentives only work so long as consumers have no choice about their cable provider. i.e., the problem is that cable providers are monopolies, not the bundling specifically. Moreover, we've clearly seen over the last two decades that these monopolistic practices have driven huge numbers of people away from television... unfortunately, usually the competition requires the internet, and the same cable companies control internet access, so there's no particular reason for them to change their business model.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by ridaj on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:16AM (#23701552)
That's what I meant by, we can debate the merits of the History channel to begin with. I only took challenge to the notion that there is a world in which unbundling happens and consumers get to watch the same content for less money.

Whether or not it is "mis-serving customers" depends a bit on whether there's abuse of monopoly power, which is an argument one can make about the cable companies, but not so much about the over-the-top services like HBO Go, Disney+, Netflix, or Prime, all of which are structured as a bundle. I'm not sure Prime customers, for example, are unhappy or feel mis-served by being able to watch TV shows on top of being able to order items with fast, free shipping. Bundling can be used for nefarious value-extraction in a monopolistic market, but it can also bring consumers value, so we shouldn't conflate the two.

In many competitive markets, bundling is often a consumer's preference that does serve customers well. For example, most coffee shops don't charge for sugar, creamer, and other condiments, and you maybe have some aggrieved consumers complaining that they should get a discount for drinking only black coffee. It's likely that coffee creamer companies would go bankrupt if people had to pay for condiments at every coffee shop, and we can debate whether it's even a good idea then. But on the whole, I don't think that turns into an argument that coffee shops are mis-serving customers by providing condiments that are free of charge, that is to say, bundled with the price of coffee.

Personally I live in an almost perfectly unbundled world of content already, because I tend to buy or rent the TV shows that I'm personally interested in. This works for me because I have little time to watch, don't like ads, and have enough disposable income that I'm not thinking twice about cost, but I'm not sure that many other consumers would be satisfied with the kind of entertainment experience where they have to pay $2 per episode of their favorite show.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by s17n on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:20AM (#23698004)
You aren't going to be able to spend less money though. Since there's zero marginal cost to adding extra channels, you should assume that the price you're getting charged isn't actually based on the number of channels you subscribe to.

A better way to think about bundle pricing is that the channels you really want cost $50, and they throw in a whole bunch of other crap for free. Why turn down free stuff?

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by newbie789 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:36AM (#23698099)
If those channels are free (and by that reasoning, not actually factored into the price of my package) then why am I unable to get individual channels or create my own bundle? Either I'm subsidizing stuff that I don't want to watch, or I'm not.

Is your point that I can't spend less because... they're going to get $50 out of me either way? Except that's impossible because there is no other way so there's literally no way of knowing a theoretical cost so it's safest to assume it's going to be $50 or more?

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by Ruthalas on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:34AM (#23698081)
The parent comment lists a specific reason why they'd turn directly the 'free' stuff. It requires more effort to then access the content they want to get to when they have to navigate around the cruft.

Whether that factors much into your personal value assessment or not, that is a valid downside to having a bunch of extra channels you don't intend to watch.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by lotsofpulp on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:33AM (#23698079)
People don't turn down free stuff. It's just that they no longer value the content provided via TV channels at the price they are asking. The fundamental problem is content that used to be delivered via TV is no longer worth what it once was.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by s17n on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @09:53AM (#23701314)
If that's the case, then the prices should go down for bundled content (and this does in fact appear to be what is happening).

A la carte makes no sense.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by baddox on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:45AM (#23698149)
Except this article is about YouTube TV adding more channels and charging everyone more.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by s17n on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @09:56AM (#23701347)
They're announcing these things at the same time for obvious reasons, but you can assume the prices would have gone up anyway.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by baddox on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:19PM (#23703986)
That seems like an awful lot of assuming. Even if it's true that they needed to raise the price of their existing channel offering, and only added new channels to help justify the price increase, that still counts as bundling being used to increase the price.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by listenallyall on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @03:21AM (#23698723)
Anti-bundling rants based on subsidizing unwanted channels are illogical. You're annoyed at paying for cable channels you don't watch but OK paying full freight for Netflix where you'll watch less than 5% of the available content? You're subsidizing the other 95%! Or that a-la-carte channel you want, you won't be watching it 24 hours per day so why subsidize programming that's on when you're sleeping or at work? Do you listen to every genre on Spotify? Use every machine at your gym? Drive on every road in your town? Read every article in the local newspaper (if your town still prints one)? Refuse to subsidize! Demand some money back!

Its not unbundling you really want, or a-la-carte, it's just a lower price tag.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by FeepingCreature on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @04:18AM (#23699150)
> Or that a-la-carte channel you want, you won't be watching it 24 hours per day so why subsidize programming that's on when you're sleeping or at work?

You have correctly identified the business case for cinema and DVDs.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by TulliusCicero on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:07AM (#23700154)
And buying DVD's is a terrible value compared to a service like Netflix, so congrats, you just reinforced their point.

Like, a single movie DVD/Blu Ray costs about as much as an entire month of Netflix. Unless you're hardly watching any TV shows or movies on Netflix, that's just an awful value.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by muffinman26 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:44AM (#23701889)
I can get an entire season of one of my favorite TV shows on DVD at the used bookstore for an average of $15. Not only does it usually take me a month to go through the 24 episodes in a typical season, but there's special features to enjoy and I can re-watch the show at any time without paying for it a second time.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by FeepingCreature on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:14AM (#23700198)
I watch less than one movie a month.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by listenallyall on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @08:18PM (#23708467)
There's something about your use of "correctly" here that seems hostile, arrogant and antagonistic. This isn't a quiz, nobody was even talking about movies or DVDs, and I certainly wasn't seeking "FeepingCreature"'s validation.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by quickthrower2 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @04:27AM (#23699203)
The cinema business case is “going out” “big screen” and “new release” but this could all be disrupted. It’s not a payg model that attracts people to the cinema and many movie chains have a subscription model!
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by aswanson on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @06:53AM (#23700080)
There are certain channels whose content I feel causes societal damage. Namely, Fox news. Id happily pay a buck or two more to ensure not a dime of my bill subsidizes that channel.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by mkhpalm on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:49PM (#23697244)
I'm not sure about other people but I don't "think" I want a la carte, I absolutely know I do. So much so that I don't pay for anything because nobody offers what I'm willing to pay for.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by TulliusCicero on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:09AM (#23700163)
No you don't.

It's like saying that you'd be willing to pay for a $2/month Spotify subscription for only the genres of music you want. That's not how the economics work. Going a la carte would mean paying as much as a bundle, for less content.

The problem here is that people's mental models are fundamentally self-centered. They imagine paying half or less for just the channels they want.

But in total, that would mean media companies getting half or less the revenue, for producing the same content -- since the marginal cost of giving extra channels is basically zero, they don't gain any money back by giving you fewer channels. Now, media companies aren't that profitable, the math simply doesn't work out, they wouldn't be able to actually make all that content. Many channels would simply be cut.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by acdha on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:54AM (#23700429)
Spotify pays artists based on the number of times their work is played, so that comparison isn’t valid. Most people have no trouble paying $10/month for what they actually use - and if the $50/month for cable was divided similarly I’m sure there would be far less complaining.

Of course, broadcast technology doesn’t support that and we have decades of industry built around a different model, giving all of the incumbents a strong incentive to resist any sort of change.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @03:16PM (#23705292)
>Going a la carte would mean paying as much as a bundle, for less content. //

You're arguing past people. Plenty have said they're fine paying the same or more for access to less content.

I used to watch about 2 shows a week on BBC (UK; 1-1.5hrs) and disagreed with paying £M to TV show presenters who just preside over long, talky adverts for Hollywood movies and mainstream media. So I don't pay (nor watch) anymore.

I'd pay to watch those couple of shows separately. As it happens though they occasionally make their way to Netflix, so I don't have to ... but I'd still pay to watch them when they're still current.

Looks to me like there's money left on the table.

Personally I'd like to see some form of legislation that requires shows to be made available to consumers if they are available to other channels - I could pay double to BBC what Netflix pay them to get the show and we'd both win; and I wouldn't mind having it on Netflix, might watch it again.

Now BBC is a special case; I can't work out why they need to compete commercially, nor why we allow showmakers to form companies to be paid through, etc.. they should work on salaried staff paid on civil service pay scales IMO.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by TulliusCicero on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @03:49PM (#23705697)
> Plenty have said they're fine paying the same or more for access to less content.

Really? I haven't seen anyone say they want to pay more for less content. The unspoken assumption always seems to be "if I was getting fewer channels I'd be paying less", logic which works fine for tangible goods, but less so for ones with nearly zero marginal cost to produce.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by cableshaft on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @09:53AM (#23701313)
I find it funny that people are arguing that you don't want this and actually want bundling services when you're flat out saying you aren't currently paying for what's being offered.

I don't even want a la carte, I'm fine with just "It's on Netflix/Hulu/HBO Max or I don't need to watch it." I'm not willing to pay more than $20 a month for TV most months, with the rare extra service to get caught up on a show I really like.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by TylerE on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:50PM (#23697579)
Many of those channels you "don't want" actually subsidize the channels you do want.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by listenallyall on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @02:01AM (#23698239)
Further, most channels he does want can only exist in a bundled world, since too few people would pay for that specific channel a la carte
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by RHSeeger on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:29AM (#23698050)
At least for me, I find that unlikely. I'm paying a fee for sports channels I have no interest in (because you can't not pay it), I'm buying a bundle that I only want a couple channels in, and those are the channels most people want. I would guess that I fall into the majority that are subsidizing the minority.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by TylerE on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:57AM (#23698209)
Things like Home Shopping and religious networks pay the cable company for carriage.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by kangaroozach on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:38PM (#23697153)
In aggregate sure, but individuals only care about optimizing their own purchase.

Ie more choice more better.

Personally I was pissed when my reward for early evangelization of YoutubeTV was a Hike from $35 to $50. But now that it’s $65, I’m donzo.

This will take people back to the days of torrents and piracy.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by edoceo on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:53PM (#23697268)
Back to?
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by zucker42 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:56PM (#23697291)
I'm not a professional economist, but to my eye this assumes that if I'm willing to pay $10 for one channel and $3 for another, I'm willing to pay $13 for both. This seems like a bad assumption especially for media, because since TV channels serve as substitutions for each other; if I watch one I'm not going to watch another. I'm not sure if this simplification preserves the results.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by rbritton on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:24AM (#23698018)
I’m actually more of a fan of a la carte content than channels. I typically spend $0-100/mo on TV shows and movies, which I strip the DRM from and copy into my permanent collection. In aggregate, I probably spend something comparable to what cable would cost. It’s all content I want with no filler or commercials, and I’m not held hostage by some subscription.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by sails on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @02:10AM (#23698279)
This [1] article on the four myths of bundling agrees

[1] https://coda.io/@shishir/four-myths-of-bundling

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by Analemma_ on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:44PM (#23697203)
Thank goodness I have economists around to tell me I'm wrong about my own buying preferences.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by FeepingCreature on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @04:21AM (#23699171)
The economists are wrong about economics too.

That article is an absurdly oversimplified model. In the real world, the networks would find some way to diversify between the $3 and $10 channel offerings, letting them get $3 from the $3 person and $10 from the $10 person.

edit: Correction, they do mention this common and widespread approach... in a footnote. Without saying anything about why it wouldn't work.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by prepend on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:18PM (#23697025)
You think Youtube is getting strongarmed by Comcast? That’s surprising. Google could easily hold out for a la carte if they wanted to.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by judge2020 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:37PM (#23697150)
Comcast? Viacom recently merged with CBS and is effectively its own company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ViacomCBS.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by draz on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:45PM (#23697207)
You need to think about it more holistically - not just YouTube, but Google as a whole (think about all the various Google enterprise products, cloud, etc).
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by CivBase on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:52PM (#23697258)
I don't understand why they don't do that with YouTube channels too [edit: as in "sub to each channel a la cart"]. Let users pay $1 or $2 a month to disable ads on a channel (or $10 a month for "YouTube Premium"). That seems much more sustainable than relying exclusively on ads for income and loosing potential subscription customers to Patreon. They could even offer higher priced, per-channel subscription tiers that add flairs to comments and unlock emojis like Twitch.

Twitch, Floatplane, and Patreon are all proof it's a viable strategy.

Ad revenue has proven to be terribly unstable and YouTube is extremely expensive to maintain. They should be desperately trying to diversify their revenue.

Right now, every video that isn't "advertiser friendly" is dead weight and money on the table.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by justapassenger on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:20PM (#23697408)
> I don't understand why they don't do that with YouTube channels too. Let users pay $1 or $2 a month to disable ads on a channel (or $10 a month for "YouTube Premium"). That seems much more sustainable than relying exclusively on ads for income and loosing potential subscription customers to Patreon. They could even offer higher priced, per-channel subscription tiers that ad flairs to comments and unlock emojis like Twitch.

Complex subscription options are one of the easiest way to lose subscribers.

> Twitch, Floatplane, and Patreon are all proof it's a viable strategy.

It's far from being proven:

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/01/23/crowd-funding-platform-patre... https://www.fool.com/investing/2020/01/15/amazons-twitch-hit...

> Ad revenue has proven to be terribly unstable and YouTube is extremely expensive to maintain. They should be desperately trying to diversify their revenue.

Source? Alphabets ad revenue is extremely stable for the company and keeps on growing. So is YouTube share in it. Ad revenue for creators tho - that's a different story.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by CivBase on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:05AM (#23697646)
> Complex subscription options are one of the easiest way to lose subscribers.

Source? Twitch and Patreon get along just fine. The existing options can continue as they are.

> It's far from being proven.

YouTube has already swallowed the expensive part of the deal - creating a video hosting platform. I'm just asking them to augment their monetization scheme that other platforms have already demonstrated demand for.

> Source? Alphabets ad revenue is extremely stable for the company and keeps on growing.

Source for what? Of course YouTube is expensive. It's expensive to host content at that scale. It's expensive to regulate content at that scale to comply with the law and satisfy ad partners. I don't know what else to say. I don't know if YouTube operates at a profit or not, but that's not really relevant.

What matters is YouTube's profit is almost completely dependent on their ability to sell ads. Content without ads can only benefit the platform if it drives premium subscriptions or drives users towards content with ads.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by justapassenger on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @02:08AM (#23698267)
> Source? Twitch and Patreon get along just fine. The existing options can continue as they are.

It’s how human brain operates. We’re very easily overwhelmed with multiple options.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/iese/2018/11/05/cant-decide-wha...

> Source for what?

Source for a claim that selling ads is extremely unstable. Check alphabet or Facebook earning reports from last 10 years.

> I don't know if YouTube operates at a profit or not, but that's not really relevant.

How is operating at profit not relevant in a context of a business model? Especially when suggested business models of companies that lose money, like patreon, as a something that YouTube should be doing.

We’re so deep in the bubble now. Real business models and profits are irrelevant as long as they seem cool.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by CivBase on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:52AM (#23701991)
> It’s how human brain operates. We’re very easily overwhelmed with multiple options.

Then just present those options intelligently. Without overwhelming the user. I'm not convinced the model I'm proposing is that complex. Many content creators supplement their income with this exact model, but YouTube doesn't get a cut.

> Source for a claim that selling ads is extremely unstable. Check alphabet or Facebook earning reports from last 10 years.

Earning reports do not reflect the revenue earned from each ad. Alphabet is a massive company that serves ads on much more than just YouTube. The mounting interest YouTube has shown in "advertiser friendly" and "kid friendly" content demonstrates how concerned they are regarding their ad revenue.

> How is operating at profit not relevant in a context of a business model? Especially when suggested business models of companies that lose money, like patreon, as a something that YouTube should be doing.

You keep bringing up how Patreon isn't doing well as though it's obviously the fault of the monetization model, rather than the extraordinary cost of deploying a diverse content hosting service that has to compete with established giants like YouTube. YouTube already has that part done. They are paying to host the content no matter how they monetize it. Why do you think deploying a new, optional monetization option will result in a net loss?

I brought up Patreon, Twitch, and Floatplane because they demonstrate there is demand for that model. If YouTube offers it, people will certainly buy it. Just the a la cart, per-channel, tiered subscription model. That's it.

Whether or not YouTube operates in the black is not particularly relevant. I'm talking about augmenting their existing ad-based revenue model, not replacing it. For the overwhelming majority of users, it wouldn't change a thing, but YouTube could stand to bring in a lot more revenue from the minority who would be willing to purchase payed subs to support the platform and creators.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by asdfasgasdgasdg on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:16PM (#23697389)
> Let users pay $1 or $2 a month to disable ads on a channel (or $10 a month for "YouTube Premium"). That seems much more sustainable than relying exclusively on ads for income

They already do and have for quite some time.

https://m.youtube.com/premium?persist_app=1&app=m

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by CivBase on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:40PM (#23697522)
That is not a la cart. I want the option to subscribe to individual channels - ideally with multiple tiers.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by v7p1Qbt1im on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @03:04AM (#23698598)
They do that as well. It‘s called channel memberships. Though they are nowhere near Twitch yet in terms of funcionality.

https://creatoracademy.youtube.com/page/course/channel-membe...

You need to in the Partner program and have 30‘000 subs though (1000 for gaming content).

This is obviously very important for YouTube Gaming. They are (finally) getting into bundling one membership per month with YouTube Premium.

This is IMO the single most reason why Twitch is so successful. They should’ve copied Twitch Prime much earlier. The fact that kids can use their free sub a month from their parents Amazon Prime sub was a stroke of genius.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by CivBase on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:54AM (#23702028)
Interesting. I watch a lot of content through YouTube daily, but I have never seen this "Channel Memberships" thing. Thanks!

EDIT: Wow. I'm even subed to MKBHD, the example you use in your other comment, and I never noticed the "Join" button before. YouTube does a terrible job of advertising that! How am I even supposed to know what "Join" means? Thanks again for pointing that out!

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by asdfasgasdgasdg on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:26AM (#23697738)
In your parenthesis you said, "or ten dollars a month on YouTube premium." What did you mean by that? I thought you meant that a YouTube premium subscription for $10 a month would be acceptable but maybe you meant something else.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by CivBase on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:02AM (#23702131)
"YouTube Premium" is a subscription service that allows users to disable ads on the entire platform (plus a few other minor perks) for a flat monthly fee. I guess it's actually $12/month, not $10/month. That subscription fee supplements the platform and creators for the lost ad revenue.

I meant that they could continue to offer YouTube Premium as a way to disable ads on all channels and support premium subscriptions for individual channels as an alternative for users who might not be interested in buying YouTube Premium just to support one or two channels.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by asdfasgasdgasdg on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:10PM (#23703078)
> as a way to disable ads on all channels and support premium subscriptions for individual channels

Ah. In your comment you said "or," so I thought you meant "or." As in YouTube should offer this or that, not YouTube should offer this and that. But it seems like another poster has also brought up the relatively new channel membership feature.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by paxys on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:21PM (#23697422)
Isn't the exactly what YouTube Premium is (https://www.youtube.com/premium)?
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by CivBase on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:45PM (#23697545)
No. YouTube Premium is a subscription to the whole platform, not a channel. It does not allow me to subscribe to channels a la cart. If I only watch one or two channels regularly, my options are to A) buy YouTube Premium, B) watch with ads, C) watch with an ad blocker. I bet YouTube would see more than a few people switch from C to B if they supported per-channel subscriptions.

They could bring in even more revenue with subscription tiers that offer trivial rewards like comment flairs, special emojis, or early access to videos. Even if most of the extra revenue from higher tiers goes to the channel instead of the platform, it would still be extra revenue for practically no cost.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by paxys on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:36AM (#23698102)
YouTube also lets you subscribe to individual channels. Go to some of the popular ones and you'll see a price next to the subscribe button. Channels can choose to publish videos to subscribers only.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @02:52AM (#23698534)
Got link? I've literally never seen these. (Or maybe I'm just in a geo that doesn't support this?)
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by v7p1Qbt1im on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @03:09AM (#23698639)
MKBHD‘s channel supports it for example:

https://www.youtube.com/user/marquesbrownlee

You should see a blue „Join“ button next to the sub button.

It‘s called channel membership. You need to be in the partner program and have 30‘000 subscribers (1000 for gaming channels) to activate it.

https://creatoracademy.youtube.com/page/course/channel-membe...

Edit: depending on what your region is it might not be a thing yet. But if your region supports Premium, I‘m pretty sure memberships are supported as well.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by astura on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:05AM (#23700147)
https://youtube.com/user/ryukahr

There's a "join" button next to the "subscribe" button. You have to be logged in to see it.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by bonestamp2 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @02:09AM (#23698270)
Now they're doing the exact thing that drove everyone away from their cable company to them in the first place. It's clear misunderstanding of their customers. I'm sure most of the HN demographic would have no real trouble affording this 30% rate hike, but it's not about the actual money, it's about the principle.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by caymanjim on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:04AM (#23701424)
They're also no longer price-competitive with traditional cable TV, which many people rely on as their only source of wired Internet. When it costs $60/mo for Internet, and only another $40/mo to bundle cable TV, why would I spend $25 extra for YouTube TV instead? The unlimited DVR is nice, but most cable providers also offer some DVR functionality and tons of on-demand content. They also increasingly offer streaming to other devices. YouTube TV is only a marginally better experience in some ways, and worse in others, with a smaller channel selection. At $40, it was monetarily a wash; at $65, they need to offer something that cable isn't giving me, and at the moment they don't.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by bonestamp2 on Friday July 03, 2020 @06:05PM (#23728050)
Yes! I noticed the next time I launched the YouTube TV app they added a screen I've never seen before where it reminded me how much value they were providing (basically the DVR) and showed me a list of shows to add to my unlimited DVR.

I agree the "unlimited" DVR is nice but even then it's not truly unlimited and it doesn't give me the part of unlimited that I'm interested in. I don't need unlimited shows saved for a year, I want to save a few things until I get to them or the odd rare special thing I want to save forever.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by verandaguy on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:34PM (#23697497)
This sounds like cable TV packages with extra steps — and the precedent there is to still have ads even after gouging the cusotmer.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by 29athrowaway on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @09:59PM (#23696911)
Paying $65 to watch ads, no please.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by D2187645 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:08PM (#23696953)
10 dollars felt too much compared to free youtube, and now they want 65 for whatever they are selling.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by caymanjim on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:28PM (#23697100)
YouTube TV has nothing at all to do with YouTube proper. It's purely branding. TV is comparable to Sling or DirecTV or your local cable TV option.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by 29athrowaway on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:24PM (#23697068)
I pay for YouTube Red because I can skip through ads. It's worth it.

In YouTube TV you get to see unavoidable ads, unlike in TV where you can switch the channel while those ads are running.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by Volundr on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:32PM (#23697125)
I use YouTube TV and this comment confuses me. What exactly do you think is stopping you from changing channels?
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by caymanjim on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:41PM (#23697180)
Yeah, it works just like TV. There are no unskippable ads or interstitials. Also with unlimited DVR and time-shifting, I rarely watch live, and I can skip all the commercials (albeit manually).
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by thaumasiotes on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @03:07AM (#23698625)
> I pay for YouTube Red because I can skip through ads. It's worth it.

Hard to see how this could possibly be worth it, since you can also skip the ads for free.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by rbrtl on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @05:16AM (#23699501)
This isn't necessarily true. I don't have any behind the scenes knowledge, but I suspect that enough money or reputation can buy you unskippable ads. I've had several ads I have been unable to skip, running to as long as 15 seconds for the TV+ Tom Hanks movie from Apple. Almost every ad for a Google product has also been unskippable.

Could just be an extension of Google's anti-Apple UX design, but I would be rather surprised.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by tpm on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @08:06AM (#23700487)
This probably depends on the client you are using - using Youtube in browser with adblockers, I have never seen an ad on Youtube, much less an unskippable one. So I take this is what the parent comment meant by "you can also skip the ads for free".
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by 29athrowaway on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:46PM (#23708230)
Not all ads can be fully skipped, and skipping the ad takes at least a couple of seconds. You can also get multiple ads in a video.

I use YouTube for many purposes: music, learning, recreation, etc. and i'd rather pay like $10 a month than spend 1 hour a month watching ads.

For the record, I do not care at all about YouTube Red exclusive content.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by thaumasiotes on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:31PM (#23709346)
> Not all ads can be fully skipped, and skipping the ad takes at least a couple of seconds. You can also get multiple ads in a video.

You're not watching them right. All ads can be fully skipped, preemptively, at a time cost of zero. If you don't like the ads, just don't watch them. There's no reason to pay for YouTube Red.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by 29athrowaway on Thursday July 02, 2020 @03:38PM (#23717129)
Not watching them involves waiting a few seconds for the skip ad button to appear.

That time adds up to 30 to 60 min a month. Let's say 45 min a month in average. That means, saving 45 min of my spare time costs $12, the cost of YouTube Red.

45 min of my spare time is much more valuable than $12, so I just pay for it.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by thaumasiotes on Thursday July 02, 2020 @11:24PM (#23720764)
> Not watching them involves waiting a few seconds for the skip ad button to appear.

You're hallucinating. Just read the sidethread comment from tpm:

> I have never seen an ad on Youtube, much less an unskippable one.

Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by driverdan on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:08AM (#23701461)
What do you mean? YouTube Premium removes ads, there is no skipping through them.
Re:YouTube TV sharply increases monthly subscription to $64.99 by seansmccullough on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:11AM (#23697964)
Just cancelled. The value proposition of YouTube TV was great a few years ago, for $40 a month. They've added a bunch of channels I won't watch several times, and raised the price multiple times now. I wish they had a cheaper option, with the original channels.