News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by MintelIE on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:42PM (#23579143)
Nobody would mind how they spent it if it was actually theirs to start with. When you give out free money it becomes everybody's business.
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by dang on Friday June 19, 2020 @09:22PM (#23580679)
Would you please stop taking HN threads further into ideological flamewar? You've been doing this a lot, and it's not what this site is for, because it leads to tedious and angry discussions which are the opposite of curiosity. And we've already had to ask you to stop.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by kergonath on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:57PM (#23579273)
I don’t know, the money I spend subsidises quite a few billionaires, bureaucrats, managers, and shareholders. Where do you think companies’ income comes from? It does not give me the right to put my nose in Tim Cook’s spending habits. That’s not even considering tax-funded bailouts, pork and vanity projects.

Also, we don’t “give” money to the poor. We buy social peace by preventing them to get desperate enough. Riots and revolutions is the alternative, which is much costlier.

Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by MattGaiser on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:59PM (#23579287)
Most people will happily scrutinize the spending habits of large corporations that get subsidies. That is a regular criticism on here.
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by kergonath on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:29PM (#23579491)
A corporation is not a person, though. It has no moral right to privacy, and no human rights.

Also, I haven’t counted posts or anything like that, but something along the lines of “that loophole is legal so how dare you criticise them exploiting it?” is quite common.

Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by MintelIE on Friday June 19, 2020 @07:01PM (#23579741)
Of course you have the right to poke your nose wherever you like and complain about whatever you like as well.

I also don't care for the idea that bribing the indigent and poor is what I'm doing. Glad to know that people are decoupling from the idea that welfare helps upward mobility.

Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by kergonath on Saturday June 20, 2020 @03:03AM (#23582331)
My right to be a nuisance stops when it infringes on their right not to be bothered by idiots, though. This can be rightfully seen as harassment.

Helping people who are in a difficult situation is also the right thing to do from a moral point of view. But I am under no illusion that our governments act on morals alone.

I don’t think welfare necessarily helps with upward mobility. On the other hand, it definitely is useful to prevent downward mobility, for example if someone has an accident and can’t do their job anymore, or their employer goes out of business.

Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by sweetheart on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:52PM (#23579223)
This is just begging the question: why does it become everyone’s business? Once you give someone something, it’s theirs (in the most simplistic sense). If there are social welfare programs that are doling out cash to low income families, we shouldn’t care how that money is spent, but whether or not the money alleviates the issues we are trying to eliminate. How and what that money is spent on is irrelevant as long as the problems are dealt with. Fortunately, we don’t need to know what the money is spent on to measure whether or not the program is working.
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by jonfw on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:58PM (#23579281)
The concern isn't what poor people are doing with their money- the concern is what are the people receiving tax dollars doing with their money.

> Fortunately, we don’t need to know what the money is spent on to measure whether or not the program is working.

I could not disagree more- we absolutely do not have adequate measure of how these programs are working. You are trying to solve a problem upstream of a million factors- we aren't anywhere near measuring outcomes of single decisions.

Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by dole on Friday June 19, 2020 @08:21PM (#23580326)
The United States loses $90B in tax revenue annually from corporations offshoring their profits in shelters and havens.

Which would we be more profitable monitoring and enforcing: who we’re paying out to, or who’s supposed to be paying us?

Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by jonfw on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @12:58PM (#23616694)
Also worth mentioning- the government spends 2.3 trillion on healthcare and welfare, 90 billion is not a lot of money in this context.
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by jonfw on Friday June 19, 2020 @08:36PM (#23580413)
Did you forget the topic of the discussion?
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by ByteJockey on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:11PM (#23579358)
> This is just begging the question: why does it become everyone’s business?

Generally speaking, this assistance doesn't come as a big lump sum payment, they're usually structured as ongoing payments (or other benefits with a cash value).

Because of the nature of this structure, money must be continually appropriated. The appropriation of resources by the government is something that, at least in democracies, the populace expects to have some input on.

Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by pickdenis on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:55PM (#23579249)
Is there an implicit contract between the benefactors of social programs and the beneficiary that requires the latter to use the aid to at least try to pull themselves out of poverty? I definitely lean towards the "yes" side. Maybe it's because I've been privileged, but it makes sense.
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by Skunkleton on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:49PM (#23579197)
Its useful to know _in general_ how this "free money" is spent. Its less useful to know on an individual basis. There are lots of "free" services that we all use, and very little individual scrutiny is placed on these things. Eg. Roads, airports.
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by JaimeThompson on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:43PM (#23579152)
SpaceX gets lots of money from governments as incentives to expand their production facilities so should all their spending be subject to such scrutiny as well?
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by WalterBright on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:51PM (#23579216)
If SpaceX gets a contract to provide X in exchange for $Y from the government, and delivers on their contract, the government has no further business scrutinizing SpaceX's spending.

If the government gives SpaceX money with no strings attached, just a vague "expand production facilities", then the government would be right to be upset if SpaceX spent it on keggers.

Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by xupybd on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:50PM (#23579211)
Far more so. Government corporate welfare is a terrible idea. Yes the government can and should contract to private businesses but at that point they are the customer and there should be huge amounts of scrutiny on how the money is spent. This should also apply to infrastructure if the government is spending too much on a contract but keeps using that business that is clear and present corruption.
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by zo1 on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:50PM (#23579208)
Maybe they just shouldn't be given free money from government without anything in return.
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by brown on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:46PM (#23579172)
Yes?
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by daenz on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:45PM (#23579170)
Yes.
[dead]
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by spaginal on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:02PM (#23579305)
These kinds of comments are a strong signal that we haven't matured enough to actually target the real cause of waste, fraud, and abuse yet, because people are still stuck in R vs. D.

Both corporations have been looting the American taxpayer, and the best we can ever come up with is partisan hackery.

This will never get resolved.

Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by titzer on Friday June 19, 2020 @07:19PM (#23579870)
Two people enter the room, one with muddy shoes and the other covered head to toe with mud. The one with mud all over them yells "I'm not dirty! You're dirty!" and then proceeds to defecate on the rug, smear it on the walls, and then grabs a beer from your fridge and crash on the couch. By the time you get around to confronting them, they look at you incredulously and say, "See, look what a disaster this place is! That other guy has got mud on his shoes!"

Technically you're right, they're both part of the problem.

Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by titzer on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:55PM (#23579250)
Great, then tax breaks for big corporations, subsidies for the fossil fuel industry and the military industrial complex are gonna get a closer look then? Sweet.
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by ByteJockey on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:17PM (#23579399)
That sounds like a great idea, those are causing all sorts of market inefficiencies.
Re:Why are we so quick to scrutinise how low-income families... by trentnix on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:58PM (#23579278)
It's a deal.