News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @08:28AM (#23550544)
It's a good feature from an individual perspective. It's not a good feature if you don't like cultural bubbles forming. Democrats will block Republican ads, Republicans will block Democrat ads - will that lead to a better world when Republicans can't reach Democrat voters or vice versa?

I find this focus (attack?) on political advertising on social media platforms by traditional media companies to be self-serving and hypocritical. The craziest political ads have been run on local TV and newspapers for decades [1] and everyone just accepted it as part of a normal political discourse ... but now there is a concentrated effort to prevent or "fact check" political ads on Facebook and Twitter. Why? I'm sure it has nothing to do with billions spent on political ads (revenue that will go to traditional media outlets if it can't be spent on social media), nor anything to do with the pro-Democratic party bias in almost all traditional media.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LcjEe9guEIA

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:47AM (#23552789)
> Republicans will block Democrat ads - will that lead to a better world when Republicans can't reach Democrat voters or vice versa?

The piece indicates that there will be an option off political ads entirely, not to block political ads by partisan affiliation. (The latter is both more complex to even superficially inplement and would be rather ineffective because SuperPAC ads are formally unaffiliated with either parties or candidates.)

Also FYI: The adjective for “Associated with the Democratic Party” is “Democratic”, just like the adjective in the party name. “Democrat” is the noun form.

EDIT: I'm going to quote and respond to a dead reply, because it makes a common point which deserves a response rather than downvoting to oblivion:

> Yes, but Republicans consistently use the term 'Democrat' instead of 'Democratic' because they don't want to imply that Democrats have a connection to the concept of Democracy.

> It's a shibboleth; folks who instinctively say "Democrat" are reliably far-right.

While this is correct as to the origin and the tactical employment of the usage, it is not a reliable indicator because lots of people who aren't far-right or Republican partisans are exposed to media in which far-right (or at least solidly Republican partisan) voices which embody this tactic are common and don't realize that is what it is, and adopt the pattern from that source.

The ones who persist after correction are doing it intentionally and tactically, though.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by AbrahamParangi on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @01:45PM (#23554333)
I don't think it's always a shibboleth, many people use Democrat as the demonym adjective form because of the obvious confusion otherwise. Seen it both ways.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by js2 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @02:06PM (#23554606)
Whenever it's not obvious from context during spoken language, the traditional way of being clear is to say "small-d democratic ...". It's always clear from capitalization in written form.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by rlt on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @02:56PM (#23555260)
> Yes, but Republicans consistently use the term 'Democrat' instead of 'Democratic' because they don't want to imply that Democrats have a connection to the concept of Democracy

If true that's petty, but on the other hand, is the Democratic party actually any more "democratic" than the Republican party? (current president's authoritarian tendencies notwithstanding)

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by Der_Einzige on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @05:37PM (#23557074)
Which one of them likes the electoral college?
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by minkzilla on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:11PM (#23559420)
Depends on the year
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by thrwawy0601858 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @04:06PM (#23556082)
They aren't, and the people suggesting this (i.e. the people defending their party branding in this very thread) are lying to you.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by amznthrwaway on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:16PM (#23553126)
Yes, but Republicans consistently use the term 'Democrat' instead of 'Democratic' because they don't want to imply that Democrats have a connection to the concept of Democracy.

It's a shibboleth; folks who instinctively say "Democrat" are reliably far-right.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by lliamander on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @02:15PM (#23554711)
I'm not saying you are making things up, but that makes no sense to me. I don't think any Republicans I know are aware of that tactic, use that tactic, or would even think it's effective.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dhosek on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @02:27PM (#23554883)
Start paying closer attention. You'll see it all the time from Republican officials and conservative media personalities.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @02:51PM (#23555187)
There's an well-sourced Wikipedia article covering the of “Democrat” as an adjective in place of “Democratic”, including its history and Republicans citing their justification for it: https://en.m. wikipedia.org/wiki/Democrat_Party_(epithet)
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by ardy42 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @03:28PM (#23555646)
Your link is broken, so here it is with some quotes:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democrat_Party_(epithet):

> The term Democrat Party is an epithet for the Democratic Party of the United States,[2][3][4] used disparagingly by the party's opponents.[5] United Press International reported in August 1984 that the term had been employed "in recent years by some right-wing Republicans" because the party name implied that the Democrats were "the only true adherents of democracy."[6]...

> [Conservative] Political commentator William Safire wrote in 1993 that the Democrat of Democrat Party "does conveniently rhyme with autocrat, plutocrat, and worst of all, bureaucrat".[9]...

> Journalist Ruth Marcus stated that Republicans likely only continue to employ the term because Democrats dislike it,[2] and Hertzberg calls use of the term "a minor irritation" and also "the partisan equivalent of flashing a gang sign".[10]

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by lliamander on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @04:11PM (#23556133)
That is just so...weak. I acknowledge the historical origins, but is anyone really bothered by this? "Democrat" is obviously a demonym for those in the Democratic Party, so shortening it to the "Democrat Party" (i.e. the party of the "Democrats") seems perfectly reasonable. I mean, it does lend itself to silly orthographic puns like "DemocRAT" etc., but by itself doesn't really seem particularly offensive.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by mywittyname on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @04:45PM (#23556512)
Adopting a disparaging name for a group of people that you don't like is a means of dehumanizing them.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by lliamander on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @07:00PM (#23557835)
True, I just find it odd that this is seen as (or was ever intended to be) disparaging, rather than a mere grammatical variation.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:25PM (#23558812)
Heck, before it was adopted as the name of the party, Democratic was also a disparaging epithet conjured by the faction’s opponents (though not one involving torturing grammar, because that's not how Federalists rolled.)
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by lliamander on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:33PM (#23559549)
To be fair, Democracy had (up until that point) a rather tumultuous history.

And even in the modern day, it is often the case that self-styled "Democratic" institutions are measurably worse than their counterparts. For example, compare the "People's Democratic Republic of Korea" to South Korea, or the "Democratic Republic of Congo" to the mere "Republic of Congo".

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by TheKarateKid on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @08:21PM (#23558432)
It’s because “democratic” is only an adjective while “republican” can also be a noun. Does it make sense to say “The democratics oppose this legislation?” No.

Before you all downvote this, check Webster dictionary if you don’t believe me.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Thursday June 18, 2020 @07:46AM (#23562141)
>but Republicans consistently use the term 'Democrat' instead of 'Democratic' because they don't want to imply that Democrats have a connection to the concept of Democracy.

I've never heard that. I thought it was a synonym like 'GOP'. The question is, who cares?

>It's a shibboleth; folks who instinctively say "Democrat" are reliably far-right.

Sure.

Did you make a throwaway account just to put this out? You have nothing else to contribute, correct?

[dead]
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by learc83 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @04:23PM (#23556281)
If the title "The Democratic Party" is consciously manipulative branding what is "The Republican Party" or "The Grand Old Party".
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by Talanes on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @07:35PM (#23558114)
You say "branding" as if the names of BOTH parties don't stretch back to the early days of our democracy. If you object to a party including "Democratic" in their name, complain to Thomas Jefferson.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dragonwriter on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:51AM (#23561139)
> You say "branding" as if the names of BOTH parties don't stretch back to the early days of our democracy

Unless you are referring to the fact that it borrowed the unused half of the Democratic-Republican Party’s name after the Democratic Party had stopped using it, the Republican Party and its name only stretches back to the early days of the Republic by a very generous interpretation of “early”.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by Talanes on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:01PM (#23576390)
Why would I not be referring to that? It's literally where the name comes from. Are you trying to argue that it was separate group and therefore different? Because the original Democratic-Republicans are all dead regardless.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by mehrdadn on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @04:22PM (#23556260)
Did you make a throwaway just to post these?
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by freehunter on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @06:03PM (#23557324)
Which is absolutely against the HN guidelines:

>HN is a community—users should have an identity that others can relate to.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by cwhiz on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:18AM (#23550993)
You can target Facebook ads with surgical precision to manipulate people exactly the way you want. This is exactly what Cambridge Analytica did.

You cannot target people with such precision in traditional advertising.

I don’t think it’s unfair to say social media advertising and data collection is the biggest risk to democracy that we have ever faced.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by throwawaygh on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:27AM (#23551094)
The targeted precision really is what's different. Your candidate can be N different single-issue candidates in a way that's just not possible without precise targeting.

The "echo chambers" explanation, in particular, seems wrong. Echo chambers always existed.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:41PM (#23553451)
> Your candidate can be N different single-issue candidates in a way that's just not possible without precise targeting.

Before near real-time national news media coverage and the ubiquity of portable recording devices and online media to distribute the recordings, that was normally the case, but the segmentation was geographic and by addressing selected audiences in closed events. Many political gaffes and scandals of the last couple of decades have been candidates getting caught with unexpected exposure of addresses to either specific geographical markets or closed-group events that were less palatable to general audiences. It won't be too long before political groups maintain social media personas with a variety of constructed backgrounds to capture and expose to wider audiences to which the message would be repugnant those ads that the other side targets narrowly.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by naravara on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:06AM (#23552301)
>The "echo chambers" explanation, in particular, seems wrong. Echo chambers always existed.

Echo chambers always did, but I think the bubble-forming dynamic we have now is a bit different. It's not that I have my own views echoed back to me by the communities I'm in all the time, it's that so much of my exposure to opposing views is often coming from some of the dumbest and most unhinged people on Earth. It's the filtering for nutcases more than echoing back confirming views that seems to be the issue.

It's really easy to believe that certain perspectives are only held by insane people if the only people you see speaking for them happen to be insane. And even if they're not crazy, normal people aren't really going to be interested in communicating nuance or understanding if they're hastily firing off a missive during a toilet break.

There's a lot of reasons for this, but I think one of the big ones is that our intellectual institutions have given themselves over to internet troll logic, including many prestigious Op-Ed pages. In the past you might have encountered plenty of nuts, but you could also see similar enough versions of their ideas being advanced by people who could construct an argument that didn't rest entirely on motivated reasoning, and include enough nuance so as to not be monstrous. But at this point, many professional opinion havers aren't any better or more cogent than a regular Twitter troll. It's mostly just Frankfurtian bullshit all the way down.

Drezner actually has some really good ideas about the replacement of "public intellectuals" with "thought leaders" that touches on this dynamic. https://newrepublic.com/article/143004/rise-thought-leader-h...

>The rich have, Drezner writes, empowered a new kind of thinker—the “thought leader”—at the expense of the much-fretted-over “public intellectual.” Whereas public intellectuals like Noam Chomsky or Martha Nussbaum are skeptical and analytical, thought leaders like Thomas Friedman and Sheryl Sandberg “develop their own singular lens to explain the world, and then proselytize that worldview to anyone within earshot.” While public intellectuals traffic in complexity and criticism, thought leaders burst with the evangelist’s desire to “change the world.” Many readers, Drezner observes, prefer the “big ideas” of the latter to the complexity of the former. In a marketplace of ideas awash in plutocrat cash, it has become “increasingly profitable for thought leaders to hawk their wares to both billionaires and a broader public,” to become “superstars with their own brands, sharing a space previously reserved for moguls, celebrities, and athletes.”

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by pjc50 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:39AM (#23552707)
> I think one of the big ones is that our intellectual institutions have given themselves over to internet troll logic, including many prestigious Op-Ed pages

Yes, absolutely. The prevalence of stupid "both sides" reasoning calls into being the contrarians and gives them a platform - in order to have someone say the world is round, you have to find a flat earth pundit as well and put them opposite each other so the public can enjoy the fight.

The kind of people who find themselves cited in mass shooter manifestoes. At least the Unabomber wrote his own deranged manifesto; these days people assemble them piecemeal from everyday racism and conspiracism.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by naravara on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:13PM (#23553087)
>At least the Unabomber wrote his own deranged manifesto

To be fair he was given an elite education and was, by many accounts, an actual genius and math prodigy. Most people don't clear that bar.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by kortilla on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:07PM (#23553001)
Can you come up with a better example? I don’t think flat earthers have been given any air time at all.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by pjc50 on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:21AM (#23560970)
Frequently cited by mass shooters: Melanie Phillips

Climate change denial correspondent for Times, Telegraph, Spectator: James Delingpole

Wrong about everything on purpose: Brendan O'Neill (and the rest of the ex-Living Marxism gang who pivoted from Marxism to Libertarianism without ever passing through sanity)

All over television until he had served his purpose and then invisible: Nigel Farage

And of course, reprimanded as a journo for lying about Europe too often; paid more for a weekly column than as a Minister: Boris Johnson

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @03:58PM (#23556004)
Echo chambers always existed, but now the gain is higher. Your comment reaches more people faster on Twitter, or Reddit, or Facebook than it would face-to-face.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by adventured on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:40AM (#23551238)
> The "echo chambers" explanation, in particular, seems wrong. Echo chambers always existed.

The echo chambers haven't gotten worse at all. They've become easier to observe in action and quantify, because social media is leaving a giant digital trail that everyone can observe (whereas previously the average person didn't leave much of a partisan trail/record for observation or study or reporting). The perception that the echo chambers have gotten worse is merely the horror of seeing the already existing echo chambers in action so vividly now that everything is recorded and everyone has a bullhorn.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by kuzimoto on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:20AM (#23551708)
I think there is a case to be made that it has gotten worse. For example, before social media a lot of social interaction happened in public areas with a more diverse group of people.

With social media you can pick and choose who you interact with, and what content you consume. To make things worse, companies use algorithms that are more likely to show you things you like and already agree with to increase engagement in their platform.

Additionally from my perspective, it seems society is reverting back to a sort of tribalism, where people identify with a specific group and are more and more unwilling to find common ground with one another or to even have respect for differing viewpoints. Things are only seen as black and white, and anyone that doesn't agree is wrong, and must be silenced.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dx87 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:28AM (#23552575)
I've had older coworkers say the same thing. They said that when your social circle was usually your coworkers and neighbors, you had to make an effort to get along, and if you had any sort of extreme viewpoints, you had to remember that there were real life consequences to everything you said. Now you can hide your extreme viewpoints from people you interract with, and probably find groups online who share the same viewpoints and only interact with them, getting the false opinion that an extreme viewpoint is normal and socially acceptable.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by throwawaygh on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:18PM (#23553162)
> They said that when your social circle was usually your coworkers and neighbors, you had to make an effort to get along

People still have neighbors and coworkers.

> Now you can hide your extreme viewpoints from people you interract with, and probably find groups online who share the same viewpoints and only interact with them, getting the false opinion that an extreme viewpoint is normal and socially acceptable.

The choice to isolate yourself in a like-minded bubble was always available.

On the right: most church communities in small midwestern/southern towns will make social media bubbles look like veritable cornucopias of diversity. Or if you have to live in a larger metro, you can very easily find pockets of people who all attend the same church, work for the same few employers, live in the same zip-code, etc. At my first employer (small finance company in the rural midwest) I joined a church because it was the only way to fit in. I think it's fair to say that the majority of the private K12 schools in the USA and the majority of the home-schooling community are explicitly about isolating your family from the out-group.

On the left: same thing. Live in the city, in particular neighborhoods within the city, send your kids to the right montessori, attend a liberal mainline church (or no church), etc.

I don't think there are more people isolating themselves in bubbles. It's just way easier and far less painful to moan about social media than to point out that a huge fraction of our built world and social infrastructure has the effect of forming various types of bubbles.

Social bubbles make it hard to maintain a huge coalition, because disagreeing with any one part of the hive mind can make life in the bubble unbearable even if you are happy with 90% of the other stuff (e.g., if you're socially and fiscally conservative except that you're openly gay, then the rural midwest church is probably a bubble you'll leave). Precise targeted and personalized advertising doesn't have that attribute.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by naravara on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:13AM (#23552387)
> it seems society is reverting back to a sort of tribalism

"Reverting" implies it ever left. Is it not possible that our media system, in the past, just enforced uniformity to effectively create one tribe of people who consumed it and excluded everyone else? As the environment gets more diverse, then the existing tribalism, and the conflicts it engenders, just become more evident.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:15AM (#23552405)
One way it may have gotten worse is the perception that it’s not there. If I’m hanging out with friends and we all agree, it’s obvious we’re just a small group. When all the top votes posts on reddit or twitter agree with my leanings, it’s much easier to think that random tens of millions of internet users must be more representative. With some of the upvote dynamics, it probably won’t even be representative of their own whole userbase. It’s so easy to forget that if like 51% of users have a view which they comment and upvote, downvoting the rest, then all the top comments might end up agreeing and you’ll never see the views of the 49% unless you scroll a mile down. (Then you get another headline that causes maybe 2% change their minds or not click through and the 51:49 flips to 49:51 and looks like the whole community flipped around and is totally hypocritical.)
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:17PM (#23553136)
Crackpot movements used to require you have personal contact with the core members or have access to a newsletter. Now, impressionable people can just find them on FB, Reddit, or *chan.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by vharuck on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:12AM (#23552375)
In my opinion, surgically precise targeting was not the problem with Cambridge Analytica. The problems were:

1. Disregard for privacy, by scraping data from people who had not agreed to their terms. And, honestly, from most of the people who "agreed" to their terms.

2. Doubling down on the idea "a candidate should get votes", instead of "a voter should choose the best candidate." It's the classic problem of a measure (vote count) becoming less useful. This has always been the case in politics, but we should discourage it. Not sell it as a service.

I also remember hearing one of their goals was suppressing turnout among voters who likely supported the opponent, but I'm having trouble finding a good source. Even if Cambridge Analytica didn't focus on this, it's another case of the measure ruining its own intent. Voter suppression by official acts is often illegal, but it's not much better when done through legal messaging.

As powerful as Facebook is in the world of American communication, it can't solve those problems. Reducing political ads can help, but we're far from being able to wipe our hands and think we've accomplished much.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by JMTQp8lwXL on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:39AM (#23552710)
Surgical ads allow you to greatly reduce ad spend. If you know people who like A, B, C and are easily convinced of your worldview via data scrapping, and X, Y, Z are not, you can rile up a relatively small group of voters to shape the election outcome in battleground states.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by Reedx on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @01:41PM (#23554279)
I would say that social media generally is the biggest threat.

However, I find it hard to believe that ads are even remotely the real problem (though they're part of it). They're not nearly as effective at influencing people as friends/journalists/etc and the methods social media uses to reward and elevate angry, tribal content. An endless stream of confirmation bias and strawmen, mostly from other users. Ads are a small part of that river, more likely to be ignored/blocked and more likely to be understood as fiction vs other content. They do have an effect of course, but it seems to be greatly overstated.

Also remember the unprecedented $500M ad experiment Bloomberg ran to little effect. Would $50B even have done the trick? I would bet not.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by bhupy on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:42AM (#23551248)
I think you might want to brush up on more recent news, because by now Cambridge Analytica’s data has been shown to have been mostly useless at meaningful targeting. Even the New York Times reported that Cambridge Analytica’s impact on the election of Donald Trump as president was overrated.

https://stratechery.com/2018/the-facebook-brand/

From the article:

“But a dozen Republican consultants and former Trump campaign aides, along with current and former Cambridge employees, say the company’s ability to exploit personality profiles — “our secret sauce,” Mr. Nix once called it — is exaggerated. Cambridge executives now concede that the company never used psychographics in the Trump campaign. The technology — prominently featured in the firm’s sales materials and in media reports that cast Cambridge as a master of the dark campaign arts — remains unproved, according to former employees and Republicans familiar with the firm’s work.”

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by MacsHeadroom on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:22AM (#23551729)
I'm not contesting the conclusion.

But traditional media is incentivized to be biased against social media. So "even the NY Times" isn't particularly compelling. (Not to mention NYT is squarely center right, politically. "Left" of the GOP but not left in any meaningful sense.)

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by belorn on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:03AM (#23552260)
http://wilkins.law.harvard.edu/projects/2017-08_mediacloud/G...

Partisanship, Propaganda, and Disinformation: Online Media and the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election

NYT sits pretty much center left, but feel free to point towards a more comprehensive study.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:14PM (#23553096)
> NYT sits pretty much center left, but feel free to point towards a more comprehensive study.

It's sits center-left in that study because the study centers around the center of US media coverage, not any principled definition of political center; the NY Times viewpoint is, and has long been, neoliberal corporate capitalist, which is a center-right position (the same center-right position which was held by the dominant factions of both US political parties in the neoliberal consensus of the early 1990s, though the Republican Party has since shifted further Right, and the center-left faction has been gaining ground in the Democratic Party in the last several years.)

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Thursday June 18, 2020 @09:26AM (#23562872)
>It's sits center-left in that study because the study centers around the center of US media coverage, not any principled definition of political center; the NY Times viewpoint is, and has long been, neoliberal corporate capitalist

Your contention is that the center is really defined by the progressive/Marxist/"democratic socialist" minority? In that case, I guess anything to the right of that minority (i.e. everything) would be see as right-wing. Unfortunately, that's not the actual center. A better descriptor for those groups is 'far left'.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by kortilla on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:10PM (#23553047)
> But traditional media is incentivized to be biased against social media. So "even the NY Times" isn't particularly compelling

That makes the NYTimes admitting that it wasn’t that big of a deal more compelling, not less.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by bhupy on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:40AM (#23551980)
Lots to unpack here.

1. That the traditional media is incentivized to be biased against social media, and "even the NYTimes" came to a conclusion that advances a social media friendly narrative is exactly the point. If we are talking about the historical biases of the NYTimes, their reporting has consistently had a bent critical of the Citizens United decision (pertaining to paid political speech) and in this particular case, overstating the impact of Cambridge Analytica. That the NYTimes would then go on to conclude that CA's impact on the 2016 election was overrated is absolutely worthy of special remark.

2. Calling NYT "squarely center right and not left in any meaningful sense" is pretty odd. The left-right spectrum is created within the polity in question. It's of no use to an American to classify the American political spectrum from the locus of European politics, because Europeans have no say in American politics. It literally doesn't matter that Joe Biden is "to the right of" Corbyn, because the two will never run against each other in a political election, and British voters have no say in American elections. So while you're technically correct that, on a global scale, the NYT is "center right", that fact is not meaningful at all to their readers, the vast majority of whom are American voters participating in the American political spectrum.

3. Even if one were to concede your premise that it's somehow valuable to classify American politics through another political entity's spectrum of discourse, the left-right spectrum is an extremely lossy way of encoding both social and economic views. On social issues, I think you'd have a pretty difficult time arguing that the NYT is "squarely center right". The issues of election integrity, paid speech, and campaign finance are decidedly social in nature.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by naravara on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:21AM (#23552489)
> Even if one were to concede your premise that it's somehow valuable to classify American politics through another political entity's spectrum of discourse, the left-right spectrum is an extremely lossy way of encoding both social and economic views.

Even breaking views down as "social" and "economic" encodes a lot of biases. In reality political views seem to align more based on a matrix of dimensions like "openness to novel experiences" or "preference for structure/stability." The system we use often surprises people with how often the Individualist Lefties (of the hippie variety) and Far Right align on both social and economic policy. It turns out their main differences are just about things like sexual mores and recreational drug use, but the general orientation on most other dynamics is the same. They just end up on different ends of the spectrum because of how factional alliances manifest in our political system.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:19PM (#23553172)
> the left-right spectrum is an extremely lossy way of encoding both social and economic views.

It's not really in the US, where it's been studied and the main dimensions of political variability were a strong economic left-right axis and a weaker racial policy axis (Arend Lijphart, Patterns of Democracy), and since that study it's pretty clear that divisions on the race axis have aligned more tightly with those on the economic axis, making the US political spectrum even closer to a unidimensional one.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Thursday June 18, 2020 @09:23AM (#23562848)
>NYT is squarely center right, politically.

Just because you are far-left, doesn't mean institutions to the right of you are actually 'right-wing' or 'center-right'. NYT is in no way a 'center-right' publication.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by arethuza on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:54AM (#23552844)
The other thing that is notable about that kind of precise targetting is that nobody other than the recipients and the advertiser know these ads exist and what their contents were.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by kalleboo on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:37AM (#23552677)
I wonder what the result would be if they disabled any kind of targeting for political ads (or massively limited it, to targeting per-state).
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by johnpaulkiser on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @01:37PM (#23554232)
Democracy is inherently broken if you think people can be controlled in this way.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by svachalek on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @02:35PM (#23554992)
The US election system is a much narrower target than "democracy". It's possible to get big results by tipping over a small minority of people.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by cloverich on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @03:23PM (#23555598)
Do you inherently disagree that targeted information tuned for uptake via automated, ML driven feedback, is incapable of affecting a persons behavior? If so, do you disagree that information in general is capable of influencing people?
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by cpmsmith on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @01:45PM (#23554342)
A lot of money is spent based on the assumption that they can—it's not a great situation even if the assumption were wrong. The worst form of government, except for the others.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by avalys on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:45AM (#23552767)
Because voters are too stupid to tell fact from fiction, and need their betters to protect them from misinformation and make sure they are only exposed to approved viewpoints?
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dave5104 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:50AM (#23552816)
> Because voters are too stupid to tell fact from fiction

Education on critical thinking skills is a problem in the US, in my opinion. I don't think that needs to lead to 1984-esque "approved viewpoints", though.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by avalys on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:54AM (#23552853)
If that’s true, I’d say that’s the biggest underlying risk to democracy, not targeted advertising.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by cwhiz on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @01:40PM (#23554274)
Every single person is susceptible to manipulation. If you have enough data points you can manipulate someone. This has absolutely nothing to do with intelligence or “smarts.”

I would argue that there is actually an inverse relationship between how susceptible you are to manipulation and how susceptible you think you are.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:24AM (#23551065)
>This is exactly what Cambridge Analytica did

The impact of Cambridge Analytica is so overstated that it crosses into hyperbole. They were a bunch of clowns with minimal impact that got magnified to a status of super-villain because you could use them to club Trump over the head with. And let's not lose sight of the big picture, namely before Trump accidentally won (yes, accidentally and barely), the Trump campaign was seen (correctly) as a total disorganized disaster and one of the biggest clown-shows in modern political campaigns ... and yet they were at the same time these nefarious puppet masters using modern high-tech technology to manipulate voters and ultimately skew the election.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by cloverich on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @03:28PM (#23555647)
They aren't the only ones doing it. I get what you are saying, but is your (more general) argument that CA was bad, or that precise, hidden information targeting based on a persons characteristics cannot be used in nefarious ways? Because if you aren't arguing the latter, I don't think its worth calling OP out on CA specifically.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Thursday June 18, 2020 @09:18AM (#23562788)
> but is your (more general) argument that CA was bad, or that precise, hidden information targeting based on a persons characteristics cannot be used in nefarious ways?

The only argument I made was that the impact of CA was overblown for political reasons. I don't have a well-formed opinion on targetted political messaging, except maybe that it is a reality and we should just get used to it - perhaps having some regulations may make sense (the way lobbyists are regulated) so that the entire industry doesn't go underground.

>Because if you aren't arguing the latter, I don't think its worth calling OP out on CA specifically.

OP was making a political point - that CA was uniquely bad or an example of the problems of the industry because they were tied to Trump's joke of a campaign. If you actually read what they did, they were clearly clowns and shysters - as in, they siphoned consulting money from the campaign by promising the moon, and couldn't actually deliver. Ironically, their promises were taken at face value after Trump's election.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by retortio on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:03AM (#23551497)
Exactly. Not just that, when the Obama used social media targeted advertising to its advantage it was fawned over in the media.

Cambridge Analytica was targeted purely because they were on the wrong political side, it's as simple as that. Does anyone really think they would have gotten any attention if they were working for Hillary?

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by edmundsauto on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @02:26PM (#23554859)
Yes, I think they would have been screamed about from every Republican supporting media outlet there is. And I think they were targeted because of the underhanded way they went about collecting data, and for violating FB ToS.

But the real reason that I think they were targeted? I think they leaned into it as a submarine PR coverage tactic. "We're so effective that it's a national scandal" was a great marketing tactic in the (hopefully bygone) era when amorality had no consequences.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by tlrobinson on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:44AM (#23551276)
> Democrats will block Republican ads, Republicans will block Democrat ads

I could be wrong, but it sounds like you can just turn off all political ads, not those from specific parties.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by michaelmior on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:23AM (#23552516)
Interestingly, it seems like if you have solidly made up your mind, you should block your own party's ads to save the unnecessary ad spend. Similarly, you should not block the other party's ads to cause them to waste ad dollars.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by catalogia on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:37PM (#23553389)
That assumes the annoyance you suffer would be worth the money they lose. I sincerely doubt that would be the case, unless you have an exceptionally high tolerance for annoyance.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by giarc on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:02AM (#23552245)
Not to mention you already could accomplish this by blocking ads from those specific parties... just like you could block ads from a company.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:13PM (#23553084)
But that turns into a ridiculous game of whack-a-mole, because there are always new PACs that can pop up. That is a huge difference from a one-and-done checkbox somewhere that lets me block all political adds, regardless of what new parties and organizations are created in the future.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by Balgair on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:12AM (#23552370)
I think this highlights another issue with this: How many people even know that they can do this, something already implemented?

Of the people that use FB, some percent won't even know that they can block ads from anyone, let alone political ones. Taking only the political ads into account, you then bifurcate the population into those that turn them off, and those that don't know to in the first place.

We've been dealing (poorly) with these filter bubbles already, adding in more filtering may not be the solution here.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dan-robertson on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @08:46AM (#23550711)
One difference is that there’s less transparency with digital ads. They can be targeted at much smaller groups of people so you may see quite different ads from your neighbour. It seems much harder to talk to other people about the ads as you are less likely to be seeing the same things, and it seems much harder for their to be a public debate when one side may not even know the arguments being made by the other
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by blueatlas on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @08:41AM (#23550668)
You are saying this as if those ads state facts and stick to the issues. Politics in the US is a mess. Party politics makes absolutely no sense to me. My trust in what they have to say, particularly on social media, is nil. Those ads will be turned off.

I have never have, nor never will, vote along party lines. I am, proudly, unaffiliated.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by wffurr on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:14AM (#23550949)
If you want to be effective and create change, you need to engage with party politics and push one (or both?) parties in a particular direction.

Voting in party primaries and advocating for change within parties, given the state of affairs in US politics, is a better bet for effective change than maintaining a stance of moral purity.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by chii on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:20AM (#23551012)
This is absolutely the right stance to take. Nothing will change if you don't do it, and choosing to ignore politics is not going to lead to better politics. You'd just leave the bad actors all the room to act!
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by Spivak on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:56AM (#23551398)
You're right but I think it's a mistake to assume that politics should be everyone's "thing." Everyone should vote but not everyone needs to be in the weeds of the political process unless it's something they're passionate about.

And when it comes to the "civic duty" level of participation there's honestly not much that to do. You'll know pretty quick whether you're part of the red, blue, or grey tribe so you can just vote by color and then look up what the local ballot initiatives are and vote on the ones that you have an informed opinion on. With this strategy you're the political equivalent of an index fund investor but you're role is still important since modern politics is a game of taking territory.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by catalogia on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:03AM (#23552259)
Why should everybody vote? I live in a solidly blue state where the electoral college votes are a forgone conclusion. I'd just be adding another thimble-full of water to an ocean. I suppose voting would give me the sticker, but I'm not really a sticker collector. I could move to a swing-state, but I like living where I live, and not everybody can move to a swing-state anyway.

Granted there is local politics, which I occasionally vote in, but more often than not I am not sufficiently informed in local politics to make an informed decision. If I don't feel I can make an informed decision, why should I vote? My input, if anything, would only add more noise to the process. That doesn't seem productive. I think, when aware of my own ignorance, abstaining from the voting process is the responsible choice.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by boomlinde on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:47PM (#23553529)
Personally I think that if you are wholly ignorant about the potential outcomes, you should refrain from voting. You have to be "in the weeds" at least to the extent that you can make an informed decision for a vote to be constructive.

The will to vote should follow naturally from an understanding of the democratic process and its fundamental implications on society, and the availability of information that can serve as the basis of informed opinions on the subjects of policies. This needs to be promoted for a democratic society to function, and the idea that you must vote regardless needs to die. You should vote, but IMO only as a consequence of giving a damn.

As far as colored tribes go, consider the policies they agree on and evaluate whether they benefit society or not. Reducing political opinion to a matter of "tribes" creates all sorts of room for corruption and socially destructive changes that benefit the ruling class more than its constituents.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by Spivak on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @04:12PM (#23556153)
Sure, but there's really no harm voting if you really are completely ignorant -- you and the people like you will just be noise in the final tally. But most people aren't completely ignorant, and the return on going deeper in the political process isn't that great if all you're trying to do is decide how to fill out your ballot.

Largely speaking pretty much everyone sponsored by a major party is plenty qualified on paper, and candidates tow the party line so close that you don't really need to know all that much to make a decision. Don't get me wrong, it sucks that parties have such a stranglehold on people that people who I'm sure have plenty of complex nuanced opinions are reduced to a color but my distaste for that doesn't change the reality of how they will vote.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by boomlinde on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @05:06PM (#23556758)
> Sure, but there's really no harm voting if you really are completely ignorant -- you and the people like you will just be noise in the final tally.

First of all, I don't think that forms a very good argument for the idea that "everyone should vote".

Second, that's the best case scenario. The worst case scenario is that you are completely ignorant but harbor misconceptions that make you susceptible to useless or destructive populism, which creates an incentive for opportunist politicians to base their outward facing platforms on that, allowing them to not so clearly and visibly create real opportunities only for themselves.

> But most people aren't completely ignorant, and the return on going deeper in the political process isn't that great if all you're trying to do is decide how to fill out your ballot.

The problem of how to fill out your ballot is not removed from its consequences. If all you want to do is put a name on a ballot, again, please refrain from voting. If you are at all concerned with what your choice entails other than having filled out the ballot, I sincerely believe that you owe it to yourself and everyone else to be informed and to inform.

The idea that politics isn't for everyone (but that voting somehow is) scares me. That politics might not being your "thing" is only true of hermits that have effectively removed themselves from society. For everyone else, it is your thing. What might not be your thing is caring about it, which I think is sad for the same reason someone not caring about their health is.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by brownbat on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:21AM (#23552492)
> Voting in party primaries and advocating for change within parties, given the state of affairs in US politics, is a better bet for effective change than maintaining a stance of moral purity.

I don't see why this would necessarily be true. Unaligned votes decide elections, while deeply partisan groups can generally be assumed safe and disregarded. Turnout boosting is a thing, but not generally through policy concessions. Turnout operations are much more about rallying people who already agree with you.

I might be wrong, but my strong hunch is that if you have an hour to spend, volunteering at a party call center is going to pale in comparison to just writing a carefully worded letter to your representative on a specific issue you care about.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @08:47AM (#23550718)
>Politics in the US is a mess.

Why would you want it any other way? Democracy is messy.

>You are saying this as if those ads state facts and stick to the issues

I'm not saying that at all, but I will say this, political discourse is never about facts and policy. Same with activism. Do you think activists stick to facts and data to prove their case? Almost never. Do you think any housing activists that push 'rent control' as a partial solution to homelessness, care that 'rent control' as a policy has been objectively an abject failure and doesn't actually solve the issue at hand? Politics are emotion-driven and things like 'emotional trust' will outweigh any policy or fact-based discussion.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by ses1984 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @08:50AM (#23550744)
>Why would you want it any other way? Democracy is messy.

Sounds an awful lot like giving up to me.

>Do you think activists stick to facts and data to prove their case? Almost never.

There's a difference between "appeal to emotion" and spewing outright lies.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:05AM (#23550857)
>Sounds an awful lot like giving up to me

No! The opposite in fact! When Democracy is messy it means there's a lot of 'bumping' and 'turn' (to use some metaphors), unlike the sterile utopia that some push for, where everything is clean and specified and everyone follows a neat pattern (to use more metaphors). For example, I love how messy caucuses are, people are yelling and clamouring, convincing each other to join the other side, negotiating and trading (TALKING to each other), making mistakes, etc. Democratic chaos! Beautiful! But they are going away to just regular, boring voting because this chaos makes many people uncomfortable and it FEELS better to have a top-down, clean, organized, designed approach.

This reminds me of Jane Jacobs [1], an urban activist that criticized the then modern notions of urban renewal which called for creating neat, sterile, single-purpose zoned areas. To her, a city should be 'messy' with active mixed-use neighbourhoods encouraging this 'bumping' and 'mixing'. She's right! And I see this idea of urban planning analogous to the democratic process.

There is a side-benefit to this chaotic Democracy - it's harder to be gamed, by Russians or political consultants or political parties.

>There's a difference between "appeal to emotion" and spewing outright lies.

The other side feels the same about your side.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jane_Jacobs

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by ncallaway on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:42AM (#23551247)
> But they are going away to just regular, boring voting because this chaos makes many people uncomfortable and it FEELS better to have a top-down, clean, organized, designed approach.

I am strongly opposed to caucuses, but not for the reasons mentioned. I'm actually fine with the disorder, the chaos, the shouting.

What I'm not okay with is the time commitment required. It seriously disenfranchises those who cannot afford to take an entire evening in order to vote.

It creates a significant discrepancy between those who are privileged enough not to see the time commitment as a significant burden, and those who do.

(Not to say regular voting is perfect. Look at the recent elections in GA for a counter-example, where voters had to wait in line for hours)

Anyway, none of this is really relevant to your main thesis, but I did want to run down the tangent and present the case for why I think caucuses are bad that doesn't focus on disorder.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:54AM (#23551374)
>What I'm not okay with is the time commitment required.

I understand your position but this is way overstated. Anything worth doing is going to cost you time and effort and streamlining it will make it lose some important intrinsic property of it.

Approximately 50% of American households carry credit card debt. Do you know why? Because if you truly want something, you'll find a way to get it even if it means financing it will cost you 3x-5x more than just saving up for it. I do not believe that the vast majority of people who care about caucuses would not find a way to attend a caucus.

>It creates a significant discrepancy between those who are privileged enough

I will never buy into this flawed notion of 'privilege' that misinforms more than it explains. Everyone is busy, especially when it comes to things they barely care about. If someone cares about caucuses and primaries they will get engaged and find a way to attend. Evangelicals that care about their faith will find a way to tithe 10% of their income, go to Church EVERY Sunday (not just once every 4 years), and get involved in Church activities. Practicing Orthodox Jews have very onerous stipulations on what they can and cannot do in their daily life, but they care about their faith and therefore they find a way to do those things - regardless of their income and wealth and privilege.

Going to a caucus once every 2 or 4 years on a Saturday isn't a reasonable barrier for those that care. Worrying about those that don't care enough to make time isn't improving things. Your time would be better spent advocating to those people to CARE enough to attend, not destroying the beautiful chaos in order to HOPE it attracts those people into coming out.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by ncallaway on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:51AM (#23552119)
Do you find getting an ID to be a significant burden? Probably not.

There exist people for whom this is a real barrier.

Do you have a job that allows you to take a day off work if you need to? Probably.

There exist people for whom this is a real barrier.

Do you have a job that doesn't require you to work on weekends? Probably.

There exist people for whom this is a real barrier.

It's hard to ask someone to just CARE more, if caring more means they might be fired from the job that puts food on their table.

I'm sorry I used your trigger-word "privilege". I do want this to be a safe space for everyone to participate, so next time I'll avoid that word. For my previous post, you can substitute the word "economically able" instead of the word "privileged", and the meaning should remain mostly the same.

I actually don't mind the additional barrier that caucuses create that deter the people that don't care that much. If two people are equally able to attend a caucus, and the activation energy of the caucus filters out the one that doesn't care that much, that seems good to me.

But I really very much do mind the additional barrier that caucuses create for the people that are not able to attend them due to their circumstances. If two people care equally, but one doesn't attend because they would lose their job or need to earn enough money for dinner—then I have a massive problem.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by talentedcoin on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:41AM (#23552717)
So, OP points out that maybe a commitment of one night every few years isn’t so unreasonable, and your response is to berate them for their privilege?

What alternative do you suggest?

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by komali2 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:51AM (#23552821)
Mail in voting and thousands of in person voting booths across the state.

Berate is a strong word to describe what I read imo. I think it was more a suggestion to put one's self in another's shoes.

If you believe for example that a caucus is not too high a burden of voting for anyone in America because credit card debt exists, I personally guarantee to you that this is due either to a lack of experience in the struggle some Americans face, or to a lack of imagination.

If you actually wanna know, it's easy - check out "Evicted" from your local library.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Thursday June 18, 2020 @08:07AM (#23562274)
>Mail in voting and thousands of in person voting booths across the state.

I dread the dystopia when you sent your party affiliation on your phone and you never even have to think about pesky things like engagement, and people, and politicians, and elections as your phone will be automatically be polled at election time for your vote.

This is a democratic dystopia.

To me, this is democracy: https://youtu.be/FRtp-ooeC3Q?t=139 - yelling, cheering, jeering, people in a common space, interacting with their neighbours, fired up!

> I personally guarantee to you that this is due either to a lack of experience in the struggle some Americans face, or to a lack of imagination.

Personally guarantee eh? I can personally guarantee you don't know what you're talking about. I noticed a tendency of a certain class of people, typically who grew up in an affluent household, who are deeply uncomfortable with making any statement that doesn't infantilize people of modest means or modest upbringing. Frequently they will also lecture others who are familiar with growing up poor, or in an immigrant ghetto in an immigrant household, as somehow ... not understanding what non-affluence looks like, perhaps because they themselves don't understand it and they lack the imagination to (as you put it).

I understand what growing up as a foreign-born immigrant in working-class immigrant household looks like, and it doesn't change my conclusion. If people, regardless of income, care about caucus they will make time. In fact, they will be happy to. Sacrificing a little for something you care about is a spiritual experience.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by komali2 on Thursday June 18, 2020 @11:19AM (#23563872)
> If people, regardless of income, care about caucus they will make time.

This is essentially the "people are poor because they don't care enough to be rich" argument which yes is a valid target of derision.

Spending a day at a caucus could mean more than "sacrificing a little." I do claim you're lacking imagination here - why haven't you considered the case of the single mom who is one missed shift away from missing rent - and by the way, if she misses a shift she just gets fired anyway? Oops, evicted and no income. Job hunting while homeless.

The choice between "participating in democracy" and "having shelter" isn't an actual choice.

Also, I disagree entirely with your premise that a caucus is what a democracy looks like. No consideration for mute or deaf constituents. No consideration for introverts. "But if they cared enough." Sure. And if people didn't do crime, there'd be no crime. The reality is those people just wouldn't be represented by a vote. We can sit on the sidelines and make pointless statements about the ethical inferiority of people that don't want to spend 8 hours screaming at eachother to get their vote registered, or, we can acknowledge reality and build our systems around it.

A good democracy is a mail in ballot at home, guaranteed access to a free and open internet, with weeks of time before it needs to be dropped in a nearby mail box, so I can sit at my desk after work with tea while I thoroughly research before I vote.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Thursday June 18, 2020 @12:16PM (#23564549)
>This is essentially the "people are poor because they don't care enough to be rich" argument which yes is a valid target of derision.

No it's not. Don't strawman.

> I do claim you're lacking imagination here - why haven't you considered the case of the single mom who is one missed shift away from missing rent - and by the way, if she misses a shift she just gets fired anyway?

This is a good example of why it's so frustrating to debate this. You're engaging in creative writing and storytelling. You don't know any single mom who couldn't caucus because she was afraid to be fired. You just made her up to buttress your point. Are there working single moms at caucuses - you bet there are. Caucus are also organized and run by caring activists who are sensitive to constituent's needs - do you think they don't attempt to be as accessible as they can? Is that a major issue that affects a significant portion of would-be attendees? You don't know, you just assume it is.

>Job hunting while homeless. The choice between "participating in democracy" and "having shelter" isn't an actual choice.

No kidding it isn't an actual choice, because you just made it up and put it us a false choice. Homelessness is not dominated by people looking for work and unable to find any (and for some reason not having access to various social programs) and therefore being prevented from attending a caucus meeting. Chronic, long-term homelessness is almost solely a result of drug addiction and/or mental illness.

>The reality is those people just wouldn't be represented by a vote.

More making things up. You don't know that. You have a stereotype of working people and you're using your imagination to think of all the ways your caricatures of working people may be shut out democracy. But you don't actually know if this in fact a real problem or just something you think is a real problem. And why wouldn't they be represented well by their neighbours if some specific individual had personal commitments that prevented them from attending?

I get why you're asking me to use my imagination - because you have no other connection to the people you purport to fight for.

>A good democracy is a mail in ballot at home, guaranteed access to a free and open internet, with weeks of time before it needs to be dropped in a nearby mail box, so I can sit at my desk after work with tea while I thoroughly research before I vote.

Says who?

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by komali2 on Thursday June 18, 2020 @12:53PM (#23565007)
> You don't know any single mom who couldn't caucus because she was afraid to be fired

I actually do - my own mom, when I was growing up. I'm talking about my experience.

But hey, don't believe me, here's a journalist that went ahead and got a couple families on the record that are in exactly the situation I just described: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/25852784-evicted

> More making things up. You don't know that.

I do know that. That's the reality we live in. Make it easier to vote from home and more people vote: https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/letting-people-vote-a...

The state of American family finance is far more dire than you seem to be aware: https://www.marketwatch.com/story/half-of-americans-are-just...

> Says who?

Says me, with as much earnestness as you say with your desire for a caucus. Except my method, the evidence shows, franchises more Americans. That doesn't necessarily invalidate your argument by the way, you can say you prefer a caucus even though it would disenfranchise some Americans. I don't know if that exactly describes a democracy though.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by talentedcoin on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @01:01PM (#23553762)
OK, sorry, maybe I was confused -- we're talking caucuses weren't we? I definitely agree with that for voting at large, but I always thought the whole point of a caucus was the messy political "fun" of it all. (Disclaimer, I am not American.)

Anyways thanks for the reply, I am familiar with that book and these arguments. I just don't understand why they should apply to a caucus, which is once every few years, and mostly for more politically-involved folks by definition already.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by komali2 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @01:08PM (#23553843)
If it were up to me, every American would have the time and financial stability (as well as the accessibility resources necessary) to participate in a caucus.

Until we can achieve that kind of safety net, though, I think it's important that ALL forms of engaging with democracy are available to ALL Americans. The political parties get away with far too much shenanigans imo.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Thursday June 18, 2020 @09:52AM (#23563095)
>If it were up to me, every American would have the time and financial stability

"Time" and "financial stability" is not an absolute measure, but is relative to your level of 'care' about the issue. I don't have 'time' to visit someone I don't care about. I make time to visit someone I do. Someone of modest means who has to work many hours a week and raise kids, won't have time (or 'financial ability') to attend a political rally if they don't really care a lot about it. They WILL make the effort if they did. If they don't care about your political cause, but you go ahead and remove all the perceived barriers, they still won't care, and they will prioritize other things they care about over your political rally or caucus.

That's what you're missing here. You're under the impression that the reason why many people don't attend caucuses is that they aren't able to - that's not reality. As a counter-example, many many many people who have all the free time in the world and all the money in the world, also don't attend caucuses. Why is that?

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by komali2 on Thursday June 18, 2020 @11:20AM (#23563887)
> As a counter-example, many many many people who have all the free time in the world and all the money in the world, also don't attend caucuses. Why is that?

That the choice exists for others doesn't automatically mean it exists for all.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Thursday June 18, 2020 @12:24PM (#23564651)
It should imply to you that there are reasons other than barriers that come out of your imagination that is preventing people from caucusing ... like they don't want to. They aren't interested.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by komali2 on Thursday June 18, 2020 @12:54PM (#23565033)
Sure, I bet there are lots of people that aren't interested! Me, for example, and I'm rich as sin. I'd rather pick up trash on the side of the road with that time - and I do have ample free time.

Doesn't change the fact that there are still Americans that don't have that freedom. Though I wish we all did!

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by biscottigelato on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:36AM (#23552674)
Well, nothing is black or white. It's always a trade-off. Destroy the intrinsic property of the system to trade for broader access. Is it worth it?

It makes me think of the Bitcoin scaling debate. Destroy the ease of running nodes for the ease of trading at low fees. Is it worth it?

In this case, I don't think the suggestion is for people to 'care' more. At the same time we also have to recognize that we can't accommodate for everyone's situation without destroying the fundamentals of the system itself. It's a balancing act. Where the line should be drawn is probably very subjective.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by ncallaway on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:24PM (#23553244)
> It's always a trade-off

I agree with that. I personally find the trade-off to be unacceptable.

However, I can totally understand people that think the trade-off is worthwhile. I disagree, but very much understand and think a debate is merited.

I strongly disagree with anyone who denies that the trade-off exists.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Thursday June 18, 2020 @09:59AM (#23563157)
>I strongly disagree with anyone who denies that the trade-off exists.

Well of course the trade-off exists. I never said it doesn't take effort to go out and caucus. It does. Having said that, there are many people with the time and means to attend a caucus (as you would define it), still don't attend a political caucus. Why is that? I'll tell you: because they don't care about caucusing and therefore the trade-off for them (as minuscule as it is) is too big.

So you aren't making any profound argument. What you're missing is the other side of the equation - it isn't just about the relative effort to do something, but more importantly the level of care that people have for that something. That is if people don't care about attending a political rally, they won't attend a political rally even if you remove every barrier you perceive there to be. We see it in elections all the time. For all the talk about structural barriers to voting, black turn out was a record high for Obama because black communities really cared about voting for Obama. Black turnout was not as high for Hillary, because she didn't have the same level of support from the black population.

When people care about something, they will find a way to engage.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by ncallaway on Thursday June 18, 2020 @11:26AM (#23563965)
> Having said that, there are many people with the time and means to attend a caucus (as you would define it), still don't attend a political caucus. Why is that? I'll tell you: because they don't care about caucusing and therefore the trade-off for them (as minuscule as it is) is too big.

I'm going to copy and paste something I wrote earlier, because this response still doesn't address my actual concern:

I actually don't mind the additional barrier that caucuses create that deter the people that don't care that much. If two people are equally able to attend a caucus, and the activation energy of the caucus filters out the one that doesn't care that much, that seems good to me.

But I really very much do mind the additional barrier that caucuses create for the people that are not able to attend them due to their circumstances. If two people care equally, but one doesn't attend because they would lose their job or need to earn enough money for dinner—then I have a massive problem.

---

To reiterate my point: I am genuinely unconcerned even slightly about those you address in this post. My concern is still entirely unaddressed, except for being dismissed as not a problem or shifted to the alternate concern about people who can attend but choose not to.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Thursday June 18, 2020 @12:21PM (#23564620)
>If two people care equally, but one doesn't attend because they would lose their job or need to earn enough money for dinner—then I have a massive problem.

Urgh. This is the same creative writing exercise that another poster here is engaging in. I'll tell you the same thing, I told him. You don't know that person. You don't know if that person exists. You don't know if that is actually a problem that affects even a tiny minority of would-be attendees. What you're doing is creating a caricature of working people and engaging in an imagination exercise of seeing how your caricatures would respond in hypothetical situations that don't actually exist ... because maybe you have no other connection to those working people? I don't know.

I don't know how to argue that. You created a scenario that doesn't exist. The best I can do is just say that you did that.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by ncallaway on Thursday June 18, 2020 @12:47PM (#23564941)
Me:

> I strongly disagree with anyone who denies that the trade-off exists.

You:

> I don't know how to argue that. You created a scenario that doesn't exist.

I don't think I just made this problem up.

https://www.kunr.org/post/what-rights-do-employees-have-cauc...

Anyway, I'm not going to debate whether such a person exists. If you think there exists no such person, we're not going to productively carry the conversation forward.

If you think there exists such people, but it's a small enough set that the merits of a caucus outweigh the disenfranchisement of that set, we can discuss that.

But if your argument is that flat out no such person exists, then we can stop discussing it.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Thursday June 18, 2020 @04:02PM (#23567299)
>Anyway, I'm not going to debate whether such a person exists.

Of course, because you made up that person. You made up the problem. Can you quantify how many people are being prevented for caucusing because they can't take a day off? What are we talking about here, apart from imaginary situations?

>If you think there exists such people, but it's a small enough set that the merits of a caucus outweigh the disenfranchisement of that set, we can discuss that.

That is the argument. It's a big country with hundreds of millions of people. Lots of things are happening all the time. I'm sure a person broke their leg and couldn't caucus, or they found out they were pregnant and were distraught, or their mother recently died, or they couldn't take a day off work, or they don't care enough. So what?! There's an election every 2 years. There are local, state, and federal elections. If you miss one caucus because of life, it's not the end of the world, life happens. Go to the next one. Besides, it's a representative democracy, a single voter isn't dictating policy. Your neighbours and like-minded voters will be pushing for policies you care about. In Democracy, it takes a long time for people to be converted to a new position, so it takes years of grassroots organizing to enact change because every person has their own ideas.

Jesus Christ, you're making it seem like it's China where nobody is able to vote. Or as if it is a crime against humanity if a life event prevents some individual from participating at some political event - to the extent where we need to reform the entire system that worked well for hundreds of years. And by the way, life will happen no matter which way you redesign voting and democracy.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by MacsHeadroom on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:29AM (#23551832)
Chaos is way easier to game if your goal is to accentuate chaos to an extreme.

It's a mistake to think all competitors want a competitor they can trick into helping them. What if they just want to see their competition crumble?

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:41AM (#23551994)
The implicit and critical part of this 'chaos' is decentralization and localism. When every caucus is run differently and by local organization, that's not easier to game. The only way to game that kind of system is to centralize and standardize the process ... which is exactly what is happening.

> What if they just want to see their competition crumble?

Who cares! Every person will have different motives for doing what they are doing. That's expected. Welcome to Democracy.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by kortilla on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:31PM (#23553317)
Russian troll farms drove nice wedges across the US on all kinds of issues (by boosting the extreme viewpoints) and it worked wonderfully despite there being no central/standardized process.

Caucuses are impacted by that just as much as any other process.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Thursday June 18, 2020 @08:54AM (#23562611)
>Russian troll farms drove nice wedges across the US on all kinds of issues

Small potatoes and inconsequential. Americans don't need any outside help to drive wedges between, they are already at each other's throats.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by ses1984 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:19PM (#23553174)
As long as "democracy is messy" isn't used as an excuse to avoid reform, I don't care what you call it.

>The other side feels the same about your side.

"both sides are the same" NO.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by stronglikedan on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:55AM (#23551393)
> There's a difference between "appeal to emotion" and spewing outright lies.

The only difference is that spewing outright lies is a large subset of appealing to emotion when it comes to activism, which is itself a large subset of politics.

> Sounds an awful lot like giving up to me.

Democracy is compromise, and compromise at the level of government is messy. It's not giving up, it's jut not giving in to one idea without considering and weighing all opinions.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by giarc on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:01AM (#23552235)
When you see a bad ad on TV, you might talk about it with your spouse or kids. When you see a bad ad on Facebook, you argue with 1000 strangers.

I deactivated my Facebook account 6 months ago or so for precisely that reason. I was in a "community group" for my neighbourhood and every little thing would descend into an argument you would never have if you were talking in person. For example, a person complained that his neighbour was shoveling the snow from his sidewalk onto the road instead of his yard. Huge 40 person argument began. People act different online.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by newacct583 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:20AM (#23551020)
> Democrats will block Republican ads, Republicans will block Democrat ads - will that lead to a better world when Republicans can't reach Democrat voters or vice versa?

The article doesn't say they'll allow partisan choice about what to block. Just that they'll give you a bubble disallowing "political" ads. I think the big quibble is how they define "political", but the scenario you're imagining doesn't exist.

And FWIW: maybe all those ads in the Atlantic video you posted are "crazy". Very few of them (none that I saw) are lies. It's routine for a median Facebook user to be faced with screenfulls of misinformation. Zuckerberg was challenged about this directly, and stated that it wasn't his job to act as a gatekeeper.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by bad_user on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:57AM (#23551416)
Whether it's a good feature for your or not, that's your opinion and choice.

Personally I find Facebook to be unusable and I'm close to deleting my account. I couldn't care less about information bubbles, I basically started unfollowing all acquaintances that frequently post political articles.

I'm really sick of it and given Facebook's feed is screwed anyway, I would like the option of completely filtering out posts on certain topics, such as politics. Alas Facebook doesn't even give the option of censoring words from that stupid timeline.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by piva00 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @08:35AM (#23550614)
It can be one motive but it's not the only one. Can be the driver for a lot of actors attacking social media but we can't deny that social media has enabled a lot of new techniques for reaching an audience in a much easier and rapid platform than ever before. Those techniques have been twisted into the range of untruthfulness that we couldn't have seen before in the old media because moderation was much more strict (and papers depended on some kind of respectability).

The closest we had to this in the past were tabloids but people could more easily categorise those than the thousands of "Truth News Online"-esque articles peddled on social media. It's an extreme torrent of an old issue, we scaled it up.

Very few campaigns ran on extreme blatant lies and warped reality as we have seen the past few years...

So yes, money might be a shady motive behind this hunt but there is also quite a lot of damage that we haven't yet found a way to deal with. And it's causing very real problems, in real life, right now.

Not that these problems were caused directly by social media but they are adding fuel to the fire and it only seems to be increasing now when having checks on them becomes another divisive subject and added as another single-issue partisan bullshit.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by macspoofing on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @08:41AM (#23550676)
> Those techniques have been twisted into the range of untruthfulness that we couldn't have seen before in the old media because moderation was much more strict (and papers depended on some kind of respectability).

That's not even remotely true. The Atlantic put together snippets of political ads over decades [1]. It's pretty crazy stuff. The local stuff, just from personal memory, was even crazier, frequently asserting the equivalent of the opposition being murderers.

>Very few campaigns ran on extreme blatant lies and warped reality as we have seen the past few years...

The problem is that even that perspective is your personal bias which you're using to justify censorship. The other side is bad and lying and therefore they wrong so they shouldn't be allowed to speak.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LcjEe9guEIA

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by AlexMax on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:05AM (#23550851)
> The problem is that even that perspective is your personal bias which you're using to justify censorship

To clarify, are you asserting that hiding political advertisements - either by not allowing them like Twitter or by giving people an option to opt-out like Facebook - is censorship?

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by hairofadog on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:08PM (#23553026)
> the pro-Democratic party bias in almost all traditional media

I often see this presented as a given, but it doesn't ring true to me. Is there some evidence or research I'm missing showing that traditional media is biased toward the Democratic party?

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by _-david-_ on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @02:45PM (#23555111)
I think what people tend to mean is national media not necessarily local news sources.

ABC, CBS, NBC, CNN, and MSNBC tend to favor the Democratic Party. While Fox News tends to favor the Republican Party.

Some of the largest newspapers NYTimes, LA Times, Washington Post, etc tend to favor the Democratic Party. There are a few that tend to support the Republican Party.

When you look at the endorsements by newspapers and magazines you will see that it is overwhelmingly supporting the Democratic Party [0].

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspaper_endorsements_in_the_...

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dfxm12 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:34PM (#23553344)
Quite the opposite, when you consider how the Sinclair Broadcast group is the largest owner of local broadcast stations, where most people get their news, and force their affiliates to run certain conservative segments.

Then, consider how owners of 3 of the top 4 most circulated newspapers in the US are conservative: Frank Gannett and News Corp (which owns 2!).

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by lliamander on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @02:21PM (#23554796)
I forget where the statistics are from, but as I recall a significant majority of all journalists are left of center.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by baby on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @07:52PM (#23558236)
IMO political ads should be banned from all platforms, as a law. It is insane that candidates who have more money and funding will in turn have more reach. This is antidemocratic.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @08:54AM (#23550772)
The problem isn't the cultural bubbles; the problem is that there are apparently only two bubbles, which quickly boils down to "you're with us or you're against us". This is not a technological problem or a filter bubble problem, but a core issue with how US politics is currently organized.

With sweeping political reform, you can have dozens of parties active, each representing a much more fine-grained selection of the US population.

That way, one can be extreme-right and vote for the KKK party instead of the current Republicans which may be too mild for their liking; they'll be represented in the government (and outed for being a racist) and feel like their vote counts, but their influence will be marginalized.

There'll be a room for a Democrats-like party headed by Clinton and/or Biden, and another one more liberal / socialist headed by Sanders. It gives more space for more nuanced policies, and it gives more room for different opinions (whereas the current one is with us or against us, and if you're not cool enough your candidacy has no chance).

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by rsynnott on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:12AM (#23550925)
The current US electoral system makes this practically impossible. You'd need widespread adoption of PR or similar. A FPTP system, like nearly all US states use, essentially ensures that there will only be two viable parties (there are occasional cases where such systems lead to a 2.5 party system for historical reasons, as with the UK's Liberal Democrats, descendants of the defunct Liberal Party, one of the previous two parties).
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by cheschire on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:07AM (#23550878)
The US would require multiple votes as well to really succeed at this. For example in Germany a person has 2 votes, and that enables them to perhaps use one vote to support a moderate-left party like SPD who they want to be a strong opposition party, but then at the same time vote for a far-right party like AfD.

Maybe the voter's issue is the power of CDU? Maybe they're just anti-establishment? Maybe they're just voting on specific issues?

Who knows, but it's way better than only being able to put your stamp on one party, and gives a little more negotiating power to the smaller parties when forming coalitions.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by Hitton on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:38AM (#23551215)
>It's not a good feature if you don't like cultural bubbles forming.

I agree with that, but I don't think that advertising will meaningfully impact that. From what I gather political advertising isn't used to change opinions of opposition, it's precisely targeted. It's used to help sway undecided and make your own vote base actually register for voting and vote. People from groups with differing opinions already haven't been seeing the advertisement.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by harikb on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:00PM (#23552929)
Targeted advertising literally made propaganda 10 times cheaper. This means I can spare a few bucks and target whatever sh*t I want at whoever I like. I don't need to a big business with a big budget. Most orgs who have an agenda can easily throw a few thousand dollars to push a narrative. Not all of them can afford a TV ad at Prime time (at least TV ad on a network anyone is watching).
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by skybrian on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:11AM (#23552363)
How many Facebook ads even target people in the opposite party? I have only seen fundraising ads for Democrats. The ads seem to be reinforcing cultural bubbles.

It seems like targeting people committed to the other side wouldn't be a good use of campaign funds? With low voter participation rates, there is a lot more to be gained from increasing turnout for your own side.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dfxm12 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:58AM (#23552893)
In 2016, I saw ads for both D's and R's running for president and senate.

The primary elections aren't totally over yet. I'll bet come November you have a different experience.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by danShumway on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:20AM (#23551017)
I am mildly skeptical that disabling advertising will have the effect you worry about.

Anecdotally, I am more likely to be charitable and curious about someone else's views if I'm not surrounded by a lot of appeals to emotion or party loyalty. Watching Republican/Democrat ads doesn't make me more sympathetic to either party, often it's the opposite. Get rid of all of the ads comparing Nancy Pelosi to the devil, and I'll be more likely to engage with the actual issues being discussed. Modern political advertising seems specifically designed to push me into more tribal attitudes.

I won't comment on banning things, but blocking political ads on a personal level may be healthy for at least some people. It's not exactly hard to find political arguments if you search for them. And if you do search for them, you're more likely to engage with people who actually know what they're talking about, instead of conspiracy theorists on Facebook.

It's the same attitude of, 'if you want to learn Javascript, there are better ways you can spend your time than reading random rants online about the death of the web.' If you want to learn conservatism/liberalism/socialism, there are better sources than a Facebook ad.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by TLightful on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:54AM (#23552854)
>>It's not a good feature if you don't like cultural bubbles forming.

I think you'll find the horse has bolted on that.

You'll not catch me dead on Facebook, ever. But the feature to turn off political ads sounds great.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by minikites on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:15PM (#23553107)
>will that lead to a better world when Republicans can't reach Democrat voters or vice versa?

We've lived in this world since 2016, if not earlier. The question is how to proceed from here.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by sangnoir on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:57PM (#23553705)
> will that lead to a better world when Republicans can't reach Democrat voters or vice versa?

That entirely depends on whether you think voter suppression ads are fair-play or not

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dhosek on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @02:32PM (#23554948)
I have never seen a Republican or conservative political ad on Facebook. This hypothetical bubble already exists.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by Justsignedup on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:39AM (#23551965)
The problem is if you turn off all ads, you won't see any alternative points. I don't need Biden ads because I already will vote for Biden, so I turn off political ads. That's it I'm back in my bubble.

This is a cop-out for actually having to verify/review political ads.

Zuckerburg is really really good at the art of seeming like he is progressive but is empirically horrible for society.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by catalogia on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:49PM (#23553564)
> The problem is if you turn off all ads, you won't see any alternative points.

That's ridiculous, it's not as though Facebook ads are the only source of political information in America. Even on facebook specifically that's not true; everybody's Facebook wall will still be packed to the brim with their friends, family and neighbors still talking about politics. We're talking about politics right now, despite there not being any paid promotional material present in this thread.

Advertisers simply do not fill the vital social role you seem to attribute to them.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dfxm12 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:14PM (#23553100)
Zuckerburg is really really good at the art of seeming like he is progressive but is empirically horrible for society.

Is he good at the art of seeming progressive?

He's hosted fundraisers for Chris Christie, his lobbying group FWD.us had created a GOP-led spin off called "Americans for a Conservative Direction" that supported the keystone XL pipeline, and the decidedly non-progressive politicians Lindsey Graham and Marco Rubio.

So when I hear people say stuff like "Facebook has a liberal bias" or that Zuckerberg himself is progressive, I'm genuinely puzzled.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by biscottigelato on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:43AM (#23552737)
Having of all people FB to be your arbiter of truth of what is a fact based political ad vs a non-fact based political ad sounds like a dystopian nightmare.

What we perceive as fact is actually something derived from a lot of open discourse based on a lot of evidence. Removing open discourse based on whether the discourse is fact based is circular reasoning and a chicken & egg problem. It's not fact check, it just becomes outright censorship.

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by throawy1234 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:35AM (#23551910)
I was in the social media team of one of the Democratic presidential candidates. I agree with you.

It's my belief that if you want to give a chance to lesser known candidates who are not backed by millionaires and powerful insiders, Facebook was the last option available.

I believe Facebook was one of the last services available to make our democracy more democratic.

I think this move by Facebook will make it so much harder for smaller candidates to have a chance now.

I know there is this perception that without Facebook ads Trump would have not won. I don't believe that at all.

I think Trump won first because of NBC and then because of CNN, ABC, etc. than because of any Facebook ads. Allow me to explain:

A - It was NBC that gave Trump years of national TV exposure and created this myth of this business mogul and business guru with his TV show the Apprentice. So people believed "Make America Great Again" was possible.

B - Trump got about $5billion in free media [0]. Because Trump and all his statements captured so much interests.

C - In 2016 election, about 8.5 million people who voted for Obama in 2012 voted for Trump and about 2.5 million of 2012 Romney voters voted for Hillary [1].

These 8.5 million 2012 Obama voters may or may not have been Fox viewers and as likely watched CNN, NBC, ABC, CBS, local news (which are all affiliated).

Did you know the Democratic party will cancel working with you as an agency or entity if you work with any candidates that challenge any incumbents? [2]. Basically if you are a professional or entity doing email campaigns or other work and if you work for any non-incumbent you're basically gone and blacklisted. Are we okay with this? Facebook made it so easy for much smaller candidates with little resources to challenge the incumbents. Now this path is gone.

BTW, in the past 4 years or so Republicans have invested and built this enormousness voter database with email, sms and phone number targeting. I've seen screenshots of it. There are other entity who have built something similar at the DNC or will offer one to the Democrats at the right price. There is so much data out there outside of Facebook to target you.

If a candidate has the budget and all the resources he/she/they don't need facebook to get that kind of targeting.

I had the opportunity to evaluate various vendors and their pitches. What's available now out there outside of facebook is rather scary. Any candidate with large budget can target the audience they want it's the smaller ones who will be eliminated by this change.

Lastly, Trump won because of the message. Trump actually ran economically on the left of Hillary and socially on her right.

The kind of stuff like union jobs/workers protection, which used to be the platform of Democrats is what Trump ran on. Everyone talked about the wall, and racism. But many Americans who have been gradually marginalized and seeing every product that used to be made in USA was now coming from China and blaming their jobs lost to Mexico because of NAFTA wanted to hear Trump's message. I know for us in the Bay Area or in NY, this doesn't matter, but I believe it's because we are out of touch with the rest of the country. This is why I had predicted Trump win during GOP primary and his national win. I spoke with random people in various parts of the country. Once they felt comfortable with you, they had a positive view of Trump and how he would somehow come and rescue them. He fooled them, but the message resonated and Trump got $5 billion in free media coverage. That's why he won, because of the places like NBC, CNN, FOX, etc.

You can talk about the small narrow of victory by which Trump won places like Michigan and if Facebook wasn't there he would have not won. I'm not sure about that at all. I think this facebook narrative distracts from the bigger picture, which Trump won on the message that years ago was part of the Democratic platform and he got his message across for free using the mainstream media.

[0] https://www.thestreet.com/politics/donald-trump-rode-5-billi...

[1] http://centerforpolitics.org/crystalball/articles/just-how-m...

[2] https://theintercept.com/2019/03/22/house-democratic-leaders...

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by dfxm12 on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @12:52PM (#23553610)
The kind of stuff like union jobs/workers protection, which used to be the platform of Democrats is what Trump ran on.

Interesting to see what happens in the upcoming election since he failed to deliver worker protection (but found plenty of time to let pro-corporate judges get more power).

Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by Dumblydorr on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:06AM (#23550872)
I don't think you can equate FB and traditional media and then honestly ponder why people are upset. Traditional media ads weren't paid for in rubles by Putin's agents. Traditional ads weren't being approved by the most dangerous CEO in modern times. Traditional media didn't lead to the most terrible president in history. Clearly we are in a different world than the strawman traditional media, FB is a whole new monstrosity.
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by bhupy on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:18AM (#23550983)
Question: how many rubles were used to pay for US political ads in the 2016 election?
Re:Facebook to let users turn off political adverts by lisper on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @11:31AM (#23552612)
It's "Democratic" not "Democrat". Democratic ads. Democratic voters. Democratic party. "Democrat" is a noun. It is used by Republicans as an adjective with the intent to be belittling and pejorative. It's like calling a black man "boy". Don't do it.