No, this is not true. If it were, the star's mass would be zero.
What "gravitational potential energy is negative" means is that the mass of the star is less than the sum of the mass of all of its constituents. Or, to put it another way, if we make a star out of a highly diffuse cloud of atoms as you describe, the process will have to release energy (by emitting radiation into space that escapes the star system). But the energy left over is far from zero: the mass of the star is energy.
> It seems likely that the net energy of the universe may well be very close to zero.
This is a speculative hypothesis that is not the same as the usual concept of "gravitational potential energy" being negative. The fact that it is often framed in similar terminology is misleading.
All it means is that if we were to take all the constituent particles in a star and spread them out at 'infinity' from each other (effectively all across the universe), pushing them apart working against the gravity of the star holding it together, the energy required would be equal to the energy in those particles (from their mass, nuclear forces, etc).
The energy cost of disassembling a star equals the energy in the star, so the net energy of the star is zero. It's just a matter of doing the relevant calculations to see this, which was first done by Pascual Jordan in the 1940s.
I realise it's a ridiculously counter-intuitive result. Apparently when Einstein was told this, he stopped dead in his tracks while crossing a busy road.
This would require that all of the particles in the end state of the disassembly were massless (so all of the rest mass goes away in the disassembly process); but if they are massless, they can't also have zero kinetic energy (the only kind of energy a massless particle can have in the absence of gravity) or they don't exist at all. So I don't think the scenario you are implicitly relying on here is possible.
> It's just a matter of doing the relevant calculations to see this, which was first done by Pascual Jordan in the 1940s.
Do you have a reference? (And no, I don't mean the pop science references in the "Zero energy universe" Wikipedia article, I mean an actual reference to the published paper by Jordan where he makes the calculations you refer to. Or a more recent paper where someone else makes similar calculations.)
As for references, the Wikipedia article explains the publication history of the idea and has references to the relevant papers. Jordan didn’t publish as it was during the war, as I understand it he just discussed it in his correspondences but there has been work done on it since.
Then the energy remaining at the end of the process would not be zero. Rest mass is energy.
> Why do you think simply moving them would make them massless?
Because you said "the energy required would be equal to the energy in those particles (from their mass, nuclear forces, etc)"; you included "mass" in the energy that would be required to overcome gravity, and would therefore be gone at the end of the process.
I didn’t say it would be. The final energy would be in the rest mass of the particles, and that’s all the energy there would be, despite just having pumped an entire star masses worth of energy into it to counteract the gravitational energy of the star.
You’re reading what I wrote and then filtering that into something completely different. You’re not actually replying to what I’m saying, but some bizarre distorted misunderstanding of it. To illustrate...
> Because you said "the energy required would be equal to the energy in those particles (from their mass, nuclear forces, etc)"; you included "mass" in the energy that would be required to overcome gravity, and would therefore be gone at the end of the process.
I didn’t say anything about using the mass of the particles to move them about. That is utter nonsense. I just said that’s how much energy it would take. It’s a general point about the amount of energy in the system.
Sure you did:
"The energy cost of disassembling a star equals the energy in the star, so the net energy of the star is zero."
> The final energy would be in the rest mass of the particles
Which contradicts the previous statement of yours that I just quoted. Rest mass counts as energy, so the net energy of the star is not zero, it's the star's rest mass.
> despite just having pumped an entire star masses worth of energy into it to counteract the gravitational energy of the star.
No, you would not have to pump an entire star mass's worth of energy into the star to disassemble it. The numbers are easy to run for a typical star, say the Sun, if we assume it to be a spherical distribution of matter with uniform density (an idealization, but it's enough to get the order of magnitude of the energy involved). The gravitational binding energy of such a mass distribution is U = (3/5) G M^2 / R. The numbers for the Sun are:
G = 6.67e-11 M = 1.989e30 R = 6.957e8
This gives U = 2.28e41.
Compare this to the rest energy of the sun, which is M c^2; for c = 299792458 this gives 1.79e47. So the gravitational binding energy of the Sun, which is the amount of energy that would need to be added to the Sun to completely disassemble it, is roughly 1 millionth of the Sun's rest mass.
(Note, btw, that this energy is added to the Sun, so the total energy of the disassembled Sun is larger, by about 1 part per million, than the total energy of the Sun in its current bound state.)
Your calculation of the stars binding energy uses the classical formula, but for a star and the universe generally you need to use relativity. The calculations for this are in the paper linked from reference 5 in the Wikipedia page on the zero energy universe. It’s a free pdf download.
The idea referred to in that article and its references is the speculative hypothesis I mentioned earlier about the total energy of the universe. None of those references do a calculation such as you described, showing that "disassembly" of a gravitating body like a star ends up with zero energy left over.
For a smart guy, that's not very smart.
This article gives an example of how that would work: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_binding_energy#N....
First off, the gravitational energy is not a direct component in the stress-energy tensor that serves as a "source" for gravitational curvature. So it is formally incorrect to say that the gravitational potential energy is a source for gravity. However, the Einstein equations are not linear the way the Maxwell equations are, and you can maybe interpret these nonlinearities as a self-interaction of the gravitational field, causing gravity to be a source of gravity. But the analogy does not seem to be as easy as just saying "here is the gravitational potential energy and by E = mc² ..." [1]
Secondly, I cannot reiterate enough that general relativity does not in its usual formulations conserve energy. General relativity does not generally give you a good way over a non-infinitesimal part of spacetime to define a volume and sum up all of the energy in that volume, so it makes it very hard to define energy. And then when you try to define it in some obvious ways, you run into some weird paradoxes -- for example due to the expansion of space light from distant stars is redshifted when it arrives at us; one can either do a complicated argument from classical electromagnetic theory or a weaker but more straightforward argument from quantum theory (just track a collection of photons of definite number!) to conclude that this redshift must correspond to a loss of energy.
This broader idea that the entire universe has zero net "energy" for some definition of energy does exist in some sparse literature, notably Krauss's pop-sci book A Universe from Nothing, but generally those treatments have not made a very robust case for this[2] and I don't think if I asked professional cosmologists that they would regard it as an established fact of modern cosmology, moreso than maybe just a way of speculating that maybe the universe is closed or asymptotically flat or so. (Asymptotical flatness is one way to try to give yourself an "out" so that you can again define mass, either by the ADM or Bondi methods[3].)
Finally, there is indeed a correlation given by thermodynamics and stellar evolution that due to the virial theorem, "the total internal energy of the star is simply −(1/2) of its gravitational binding energy." [4]
[1] Baez says a lot of this more eloquently at http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Relativity/GR/energy_g...
[2] e.g. https://arxiv.org/abs/1405.6091 as critical of that particular book, some further history at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-energy_universe . Note that the wikipedia article's claim has a very nice formulation of "could a quantum fluctuation create a star given that it apparently has no net energy?" and like I would view the lack of experimental evidence for this as perhaps experimental disconfirmation, but perhaps there is a more detailed calculation which confirms it as rare or some other excuse that means that you can't do it with a star but only a whole universe.
[3] This topic is adequately mentioned at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_in_general_relativity .
[4] PDF warning, https://websites.pmc.ucsc.edu/~glatz/astr_112/lectures/notes...
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_pressure Radiation pressure - Wikipedia
But the second law of thermodynamics really doesn’t. I should note the radiation pressure does not have much to do with gravity, either, unless the only thing you’re focusing on is whether a star is going to collapse.
Light pressure is a thing. And gravity certainly pulls. And pulling seems the opposite of pushing.
> It’s not even intelligibly refutable.
So, your calling your refutation unintelligent? I don't think that's what you meant.
Rapid fire of some refutations.
The gravitional force is a negative, it destroys separation and distance. Light and the other forces create separation and distance.
In your black hole example, the light has a momentum, and that doesn't vanish if a black hole forms, the black hole will continue moving.
Rapid fire of some refutations.
That was my point. You're looking for some wonderful unifying human beauty. I can make the same arguments.
>In your black hole example, the light has a momentum, and that doesn't vanish if a black hole forms, the black hole will continue moving.
My mistake, it's a bit more complicated, what if you pointed two lasers at each other and created a pulse from each of such magnitude the when the light pulses pass by each other the Schwarzschild radius is passed? The blackhole is formed from the photons and nothing can escape the interior of the blackhole. Too much EM radiation can destroy separation and distance.
Also: https://www.quora.com/Since-photons-are-always-moving-would-...
The photons had a gravitational field before the black hole. Their gravitational field is merely summed. Their total gravity is still conserved.
Nothing has really changed. The fate of the universe is still going to be a balancing act..
On the contrary, I get the impression that Alan took scientific discoveries and matched those onto his philosophical stances.
He objected to the personal beliefs of the stereotypical scientist, and put forward an argument that the science works even if you stop viewing the universe as a purely materialistic mechanism. Which is not to say it then automatically possesses meaning, an intelligent designer or purpose.
That takes a bit of getting used to. If you consider the universe after the Big Bang, it consisted of extremely thinly dispersed clouds of hydrogen and helium atoms. Over billions of years these collapsed into galaxies and stars. During the process of that collapse these atoms accelerated towards each other, impacted and heated up considerably due to the release of kinetic energy. This kinetic energy has to come from somewhere, so we consider that the energy of the gravitational field of a star or planet is negative energy. It's an energy deficit.
As an side, it is estimated that if you add up the energy in star, including the matter it's composed of, and deduct the negative energy of it's gravitational field they cancel out. It seems likely that the net energy of the universe may well be very close to zero.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-energy_universe