News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by underdeserver on Thursday June 11, 2020 @11:41AM (#23489997)
I'm a random industry software engineer. :)

> In day-to-day, all researchers use these to stay informed on recent results. But how to guarantee that nobody hacks in and figures out how to change a few bytes in one paper that is 10years old?

Printed versions + digitally signed and timestamped PDFs. This is a solved problem in the world, at least up to the level that Springer can solve it.

> How to guarantee that these documents are available 75 years from now?

I trust MIT and Harvard to keep PDFs and printed versions available much more than I trust Elsevier or Springer to be around in 75 years.

> Many academics need publications in prestigious journals with "high impact factors" in order to get tenure because the upper-level tenure committees in older institutions use these metrics to evaluate cases. These people are not stupid: it is just hard to evaluate cases across a university when you are not an expert. Instead, you assume that certain journals represent "the highest quality work" and thus use the presence of those publications to judge researchers. This means that the top papers still end up in Elsevier/Springer journals.

I don't disagree. This is why the change and the first wave of papers will likely come from already-tenured professors, who still publish high impact papers.

> When I was a grad student at MIT, it was easy to read papers; if your IP was from MIT, every paper was 1 click away. I wonder how it is going to work now that Elsevier's catalog won't work this way...

Now imagine the same situation, except you don't need your IP to be from MIT.

Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by mywittyname on Thursday June 11, 2020 @01:05PM (#23490913)
Just pointing out that Elsevier is ancient in business terms, it's origins as a publisher goes back to the mid 16th century and the modern version of the company is from around the 19th century. I'd be surprised if the company isn't around when I die.

In addition to publishing, they (RELX) is one of the biggest companies you've never heard of. They provide information systems to governments all over the world and span multiple market segments. I guarantee you're in a dozen of their databases right now. And that your local, state, and federal taxes all funnel into their pockets in one form or another. Along with some of the money you pay for various insurances throughout the year. When you buy a house, rent an apartment, get a job, or basically have any major event in your life, they get paid.

Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by gwern on Thursday June 11, 2020 @02:08PM (#23491629)
> Just pointing out that Elsevier is ancient in business terms, it's origins as a publisher goes back to the mid 16th century and the modern version of the company is from around the 19th century.

The 16th century publisher has nothing whatsoever to do with the current one, which shamelessly pirated and stole everything to plagiarize the prestige (so its ideas of business ethics go right back to its founding). Apparently, it worked.

Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by njharman on Thursday June 11, 2020 @02:27PM (#23491817)
It's not so much as they aren't an established company it's that that their business model has been broken/bypassed by technology. They've been reduced to being a middle-man that obstructs value rather than providing it.

The only part of biz model left is "prestige" (very fickle), "customer lock in / inertia" (which is already going away re: OA), and lobbying government to prop up/expand their monopoly (ever extending/expanding copyrights, which is the one thing that doesn't seem they will ever lose on cause ever other bypassed dinosaur broke ass business model publisher spends tons on it).

Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by mywittyname on Thursday June 11, 2020 @04:57PM (#23493230)
I disagree. It seems like you only know Elsevier as a publisher of journals, but that's only about 1/3 of their overall business. They (RELX) provide a lot of useful services to companies and governments.

About half their revenue and profits come from Risk and Legal services, which are not things you hear about in the news. They offer services for police, airlines, legal firms, insurance companies, accounting firms Hell, they have an analytics tool for agricultural businesses. They also have enough money to throw around in these spaces to prevent any startups from getting large enough to be a threat.

Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by CRConrad on Thursday June 11, 2020 @08:09PM (#23494589)
1) So they can keep doing business in those other areas.

2) Large universities are not little startups to be easily intimidated.

Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by Gibbon1 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @03:20PM (#23492397)
Tends to be ignored but the process of extracting a profit has costs. Both internal costs and external costs. Sometimes the external costs imposed exceed the profit extracted by a large amount.
Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by slavik81 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @11:56PM (#23495865)
The life expectancy of long-lived companies is shorter than you might expect:

> Based on detailed survival analysis, we show that the mortality of publicly traded companies manifests an approximately constant hazard rate over long periods of observation. This regularity indicates that mortality rates are independent of a company's age.

https://doi.org/10.1098/rsif.2015.0120

Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by lazyjeff on Thursday June 11, 2020 @06:06PM (#23493781)
Everyone here is imagining all the technical ways to replace publishers. That's quite feasible as you and others point out. I think there is also real work needed to solve social (people) problems, for example:

- explain to the stakeholders by preparing various text and other media about how your format/venue/website is different and better, and convince them that this solves a real problem they should care about

- solicit requirements from universities, funding agencies, various governments, about archiving and metadata requirements. Consider security, accessibility, long-term preservation, financial model, etc.

- respond to the questions and pushback from numerous stakeholders about problems (real or not) about your proposed solution, debate them in a polite and professional way in semi-public forums, converge on a solution that's acceptable (or at least not overly repulsive) to the key stakeholders. Deal with any PR backlash, response from existing publishers, etc.

- inform authors, potential authors, readers, journalists, universities administrators, students, etc. that there is a new publishing format/venue/website and that it is well managed and has a plan to be around for a long time

- coordinate and schedule a team of people to work on this with you, to figure out policies (author plagiarism, recruiting editors if needed, dealing with potential lawsuits, bad actors, copyright and IP issues, etc.)

Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by TheKarateKid on Thursday June 11, 2020 @07:16PM (#23494227)
The same way Wikipedia and Reddit manage to provide quality platforms that provide tools to address these social issues, built for longevity, and have strong community moderation.
Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by lozaning on Thursday June 11, 2020 @12:15PM (#23490374)
I don't have to imagine it: https://scihub.wikicn.top/
Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by ikiris on Thursday June 11, 2020 @02:24PM (#23491783)
this site doesn't even load.
Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by Recursing on Thursday June 11, 2020 @02:35PM (#23491925)
Might want to change your DNS to 1.1.1.1 or 8.8.8.8
Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by alasdair_ on Friday June 12, 2020 @02:28AM (#23496607)
>this site doesn't even load.

Probably time to use an ISP that is less willing to mess with your Internet access, or at least use a VPN and a different DNS server.

Re:MIT Ends Elsevier Negotiations by NicoJuicy on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:39PM (#23495453)
Loads in Belgium ( no censorship )