We basically locked people in their homes. Shut down every imaginable business except those deemed "essential". Closed all retail and restaurants.
What would you expect to happen?
This isn't just about big business. Small businesses notoriously operate on very thin margins. Though that's not necessarily because of debt, but because what it takes to run a business today takes a considerable amount of overhead.
I know that the idea of saving money seems cliche, like some obsolete thing your grandpa might say, but we're going to have to wake up to the fact that if we want to finance everything with debt then we're going to be penalized every 10 years when there's an adjustment or a catastrophe that forces one.
The catch 22 there is that using less debt also means less growth, and we've all gotten used to unprecedented amounts of growth.
With the amount we pay in taxes, the ability to save is sharply limited.
Compared with, say, contributing to the construction of a resilient, humane society in a variety of ways (including paying taxes) and being ready to deal with semi-random catastrophes quite well.
Oh, also: the amount we pay in taxes, as a percentage of personal and corporate income, as well as GDP, is at a (near) historical and cross-country-comparative low.
Now, it's true that the commercial (retail) real estate "sector" has created a more flexible and dynamic space for retail to operate in. Sign leases for just a year in case the idea doesn't work out etc. etc.
But it has also meant (1) a more encouraging environment for retail ideas that are even more likely to fail than the average (2) when business drops (e.g. covid-19), there's still the rent to pay.
It is true that in the past, the retail store owner-operator probably didn't own the premises outright, so there's still the mortgage payment when business drops. But that was (then) an arrangement with a bank (often local) who were going to be much more likely to see the mutual benefit of finding a way to not reposess the building.
This is just another small contributing factor to the overall fragility.
When times are good, corporations are essentially making monthly payments to a bunch of local landlords (or banks) for the service of housing their employees.
I do find it a little strange that we didn't try to stick landlords and lenders with more of the bill. It'd be easier for corporations to keep employees staffed if they could reduce their salaries because their rent / mortgage payments were lower.
We really aren't. Between government pension plans, unemployment insurance, and all the welfare programs, I would challenge whether this is a real expectation at this point.
My mention on Wikipedia as a Liberal candidate.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calgary-Bow#2015_general_elect...
I support welfare programs, it is just that the existence of them makes personal saving less paramount.
One might think you'd engage in some self-reflection...? Have you no decency, Senator?
I think I'll pass on using your blacklist, thanks.
Second, you're actively trying to derail someone's career based on a 174 character comment that was far from being considered "vile conservatism". I too disagree with his viewpoint, but damn you're taking this wayyyyyyyy too far.
I recommend you engage in open discourse and dialog instead of looking for an enemy? And when I say "open", I mean willing to also change your own opinion.
If the stimulus bill had gone directly to that, then this might have made a lot more sense.
Forget UBI, the trillion dollars in PPP, if it was put into people's checking accounts as a reverse payroll tax might have had a very different (& aligned with consumerist values) economic result.
As in, take the "employee as a cost" out of the employer's books & turn every extra employee just extra hands to work at your business, just paid for by the negative taxes (this punishes the under-the-table payment tax dodges directly).
The fact that they gave PPP, without actually putting money into a paycheck absolutely sucked if your goal was to stop the money from slowing down in the economy.
A dollar I spend turns into many more dollars spent, than a dollar I saved.
But if I know I'm out on the street once that number drops to 0, I won't spend right now, even if it is a necessary purchase.
Yeah, we've moved beyond subsistence. In fact, we've moved so far beyond subsistence that we can put the entire economy on hold for months and no one is in even remote danger of starving.
https://www.hamiltonproject.org/blog/the_covid_19_crisis_has...
It's largely because people—especially the poorest people—have been laid off to protect businesses' balance sheets, and have received a meager attempt at counterbalancing that from the government.
There is absolutely no reason any human needs to starve in the modern world. If we as a society prioritized people's lives and welfare over businesses' profitability—and expressed those priorities consistently through our voting decisions—we could eliminate hunger in America without any kind of serious (or even noticeable) hardship to the rest of us.
like do you actually believe this? just because none of your friends are starving doesn't mean there aren't people that are
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/04/22/covid-19-...
https://www.npr.org/2019/09/10/759512938/u-s-census-bureau-r...
38 million.
12% of households don't reliably eat
https://www.feedingamerica.org/about-us/press-room/new-data
people are getting evicted en masse soon
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/27/us/coronavirus-evictions-...
do you really think "no one" is going starve to death in the US in the coming months? or even that many people aren't?
I mean...we just faced a complete black swan event where people all had to lock themselves in their homes, and so far we seem to have avoided catastrophe (at least by many expert predictions).
The US is extremely well positioned to avoid many of the negative effects that most countries are going to be seeing.
We are the opposite of fragile, at least compared to other human economies.
https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2020-0...
https://zoom.us/rec/play/uZV8drj9-z83SIDH5QSDAvcoW9XoKK2shHI...
The others are Peter Zeihan, and an essay in Foreign Affairs. These are not politicians.
Also, JP Morgan doesn't really count for expert. That's not because they don't know what they are doing but because their incentives are not aligned, they have a stock to defend.
There won't be a "V-shaped" recovery. That's just what the administration is hoping for because they understand it will have a massive impact in November.
The best analogy I've heard is that we just had a huge earthquake, and now everyone is waiting for the tsunami of a catastrophic economic crash.
I'll turn it back around to you: by what measure? Spiking nearly 40m jobless claims isn't weathering the storm. Spiking nearly 40m jobless claims, while continuing to see 2m+ every report, seems to be the opposite of weathering the storm.
I mean, the gist is: The American economy is incredibly resilient, and it is showing during this. Yes it's true that jobless claims are increasing, but the expectation is that they will peak next week. While we won't be an overall growth year, the expectation is to close out the year at levels comparable to those in 2010.
In addition to that, the US is just incredibly resilient when compared to the rest of the world. The world still trades using our dollars, they still want to buy our bonds, they still want to invest in our companies. All of this stuff ends up benefiting the US job seeker, and the American family because it means that there are jobs, stability, and the ability to pass monetary policy that protects them in times of crisis.
If you want specific details, there is hours of content that I linked that will explain explicitly why. \\
Who wouldn't when they can't fail?
> All of this stuff ends up benefiting the US job seeker, and the American family
Since the last downturn, roughly half of the jobs created have been approximately gig-economy. An expansion of the precariat isn't helping me, it's not helping my parents, and it's not helping a lot of other Americans. It's actively immiserating people. But, hey, the number went up, so we must be resilient.
> because it means that there are jobs
Unless you're part of the 12% and growing portion of the country that are out of work today, and the 42% of jobs that won't return after.
> stability
Unless you're part of the gig economy workforce or you live in a right-to-work state. So, you know, everyone.
> and the ability to pass monetary policy that protects them in times of crisis.
Nothing protects me like a small business loan that I wouldn't ever qualify for and virtual money printers running full speed.
This is such a deeply ideological take, so i guess it seems in-line with linking to foreignpolicy, but the gist of it is: the American economy is resilient because it has been resilient in the past and we can make this claim by removing the current historical context of the moment.
Yes, exactly.
>Since the last downturn, roughly half of the jobs created have been approximately gig-economy.
Can you source this?
>This is such a deeply ideological take, so i guess it seems in-line with linking to foreignpolicy
What's wrong with foreign policy?
The physical buildings and roads are still there. The people who use them are not, which makes it in practice not in place.
/fiddle with CSS
Seriously? There are dozens or hundreds of amazing books on alternative economics. I wouldn't be the best to make the case, and certainly not the first. Do you actually want some recommendations (most of my own canonical ones are a bit old) ?
This is market capitalism unrestrained. Any measures in place to account for "black swan" events get optimized out of existence in the name of short-term efficiency. And why shouldn't they when the government has shown that they will bail out companies over and over?
We also have so little in the way of economic self-reliance anymore, at almost any scale. Certainly not individual or familial (which might not be a good goal anyway), but also not at neighborhood, community, city, state and to some extent even national scales.
The flip side of cheap money is inflation, and it's been building up in the economy since the 2007 crisis. The inflation has been hidden by stagnant wages and falling commodity prices from globalization, so it's led to "top heavy" inflation -- the value of a dollar has been shrinking as the supply of dollars has increased, but that extra supply of dollars has been almost exclusively concentrated in equity markets. Prices of goods have remained in check because the vast majority of people simply don't have access to most of the new money. See also all the US companies sitting on hundreds of billions in cash, stock buybacks, and corporate debt.
I believe the US has 2 economies: one denominated in dollars, the other denominated in millions of dollars. It wasn't seen as "inflation" because most of the inflation indicators used by the federal reserve target the consumer economy. I think we're about to have a really bad decade as all this starts to unwind. The housing market is the first place this will hit (and we're seeing it already); capital will start to flow into REITs buying up residential properties and we'll see prices stay high even or even rise in an economy when they shouldn't be. All but the wealthiest individuals will be priced out of the market (this is already the case in many cities). That means more renters, higher rents, and zoning laws that prevent new housing starts.
The two economies will start to bleed together in the margins between the millionaire economy and the individual economy -- with disastrous results for the people of the country.
And yet the economy is staggering and it's likely to get worse. Why? Because people have stopped doing things
We've built an entire economy around people doing things they don't really need to do. In and of itself, that's not so bad, but we've also built an economy with so little resilience, so much fragility, so little spare capacity that the mere fact of people stopping doing a bunch of stuff has the potential to cause complete economic disaster for, what 15-20M Americans?
This is utter insanity. It's like claiming that the only vehicle you need is an F1 race car because of course that's all you need: lean, fast, stripped down, powerful and ultimately focused on increasingly one thing. Meanwhile, it's totally obvious to anyone with a pair of eyes that it's a completely unsuitable design for anything except racing on a specially built course, and that the smallest thing is capable of destroying it.
We've built this insane economic system despite the blinding obviousness of calamities like pandemics, wars, storms, unrest, climate change and so on. The "system" will continue to function (very probably), but at what cost and to how many?