News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by bluedino on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:08PM (#23328314)
Fragile?

We basically locked people in their homes. Shut down every imaginable business except those deemed "essential". Closed all retail and restaurants.

What would you expect to happen?

Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by ravenstine on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:17PM (#23328442)
Fragile, because corporations that have millions or billions in cash flow don't have the kind of savings to keep people staffed and make debt payments. No, we little people are supposed to "save for a rainy day" and flood the stock market with our 401ks while big business gets to grow grow grow, make little to nothing in profit, and bolster stock prices with corporate debt.

This isn't just about big business. Small businesses notoriously operate on very thin margins. Though that's not necessarily because of debt, but because what it takes to run a business today takes a considerable amount of overhead.

I know that the idea of saving money seems cliche, like some obsolete thing your grandpa might say, but we're going to have to wake up to the fact that if we want to finance everything with debt then we're going to be penalized every 10 years when there's an adjustment or a catastrophe that forces one.

The catch 22 there is that using less debt also means less growth, and we've all gotten used to unprecedented amounts of growth.

Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by dantheman on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:35PM (#23328742)
I'd blame the tax code; it makes no sense for corporations to save money. They should aim for zero every year either by investing in growth or paying it out.

With the amount we pay in taxes, the ability to save is sharply limited.

Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @04:10PM (#23329284)
This attitude is another component in why the economy is so fragile. "It makes no sense for corporations to save money" ... as long as you think that "paying the least amount of taxes possible" is a sensible goal for a corporation.

Compared with, say, contributing to the construction of a resilient, humane society in a variety of ways (including paying taxes) and being ready to deal with semi-random catastrophes quite well.

Oh, also: the amount we pay in taxes, as a percentage of personal and corporate income, as well as GDP, is at a (near) historical and cross-country-comparative low.

Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by Antecedent on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @04:11PM (#23329289)
Doesn’t the personal tax code pretty strongly incentivize saving for individuals? 401ks and IRAs have preferential tax treatment.
Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:52PM (#23329006)
One thing I've reflected on a little bit recently ... I don't want to take a TV show as an accurate account of historical reality, but given that "Deadwood" did have quite a bit of research behind it ... when two characters in that story wanted to open a hardware store, they had to buy the land and build the store. How many people who open a retail store these days even thinking about owning the property?

Now, it's true that the commercial (retail) real estate "sector" has created a more flexible and dynamic space for retail to operate in. Sign leases for just a year in case the idea doesn't work out etc. etc.

But it has also meant (1) a more encouraging environment for retail ideas that are even more likely to fail than the average (2) when business drops (e.g. covid-19), there's still the rent to pay.

It is true that in the past, the retail store owner-operator probably didn't own the premises outright, so there's still the mortgage payment when business drops. But that was (then) an arrangement with a bank (often local) who were going to be much more likely to see the mutual benefit of finding a way to not reposess the building.

This is just another small contributing factor to the overall fragility.

Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by apta on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @04:42PM (#23329680)
The fact that the modern day economy is based on usury (aka interest) seems not to be brought up by either the left or right, even though eliminating it would provide huge value for everyone (except the few at the top). It's a form of slavery, but it does the job for those at the top of the hierarchy, so it remains the way it is. That, coupled with a backward and extremely intrusive tax system which also benefits the same group of people, and you see why there's vested interest in keeping the status quo. This combination forms the basis for the fragility of the present day economic system.
Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by neutronicus on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:51PM (#23328998)
> don't have the kind of savings to keep people staffed

When times are good, corporations are essentially making monthly payments to a bunch of local landlords (or banks) for the service of housing their employees.

I do find it a little strange that we didn't try to stick landlords and lenders with more of the bill. It'd be easier for corporations to keep employees staffed if they could reduce their salaries because their rent / mortgage payments were lower.

Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by MattGaiser on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:30PM (#23328649)
> No, we little people are supposed to "save for a rainy day"

We really aren't. Between government pension plans, unemployment insurance, and all the welfare programs, I would challenge whether this is a real expectation at this point.

[dead]
Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by dang on Saturday May 30, 2020 @04:14AM (#23359428)
You have a long history of treating other people viciously on HN, but for some reason we gave you many more second chances than we usually do. This is beyond the pale and I've banned this account.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by MattGaiser on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:44PM (#23328894)
I'm a Liberal and not only a Liberal, but a Canadian Liberal, which is more to the left than American Democrats.

My mention on Wikipedia as a Liberal candidate.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calgary-Bow#2015_general_elect...

I support welfare programs, it is just that the existence of them makes personal saving less paramount.

[dead]
Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by alenanand on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @11:29PM (#23333079)
This is hilarious. You pop into a thread out of nowhere to advertise your Evil Conservative blacklist, and literally the first person you accuse has a Wikipedia cite showing that you're completely wrong.

One might think you'd engage in some self-reflection...? Have you no decency, Senator?

I think I'll pass on using your blacklist, thanks.

Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by ravenstine on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:43PM (#23328872)
It's pretty despicable to show up in a thread where we are having an honest discussion, tag people as conservative(I think you mean "heretic"), and offer your blacklist to employers. Heck off.
[dead]
Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by my_usernam3 on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @04:04PM (#23329202)
For one, you're expecting others to be held accountable while also hiding behind a throwaway account. Thats hypocritical.

Second, you're actively trying to derail someone's career based on a 174 character comment that was far from being considered "vile conservatism". I too disagree with his viewpoint, but damn you're taking this wayyyyyyyy too far.

I recommend you engage in open discourse and dialog instead of looking for an enemy? And when I say "open", I mean willing to also change your own opinion.

Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by flatline on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:26PM (#23328590)
Except all retail and restaurants have not closed. I live in a state that has had one of the most aggressive and successful responses to the virus, and people are still out and about in nice weather. The big box stores and groceries were open the whole time. Most restaurants have been open for take-out only, the whole time or most of the time. Smaller retailers are now allowed to re-open. People have been ordering a ton of stuff from online retailers. Commerce has slowed, and if everything somehow went back to normal next week we'd see the effects of just this initial slowdown for years to come. We are a service-based economy that depends on continual consumer growth that will never come back the way it was. The deep systemic impacts of all this have not really started yet.
Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by keithnoizu on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:13PM (#23328389)
Buying starbucks, etc. People who work at one cafe spending money at another cafe, etc. is the economic version of busy work. It doesn't really impact the countries ability to produce food and goods. Yet with out it the economy grinds to malaise that may last for years. That is pretty fragile.
Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by ianleeclark on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:30PM (#23328658)
Well, it would seem that if we close down all the non-essential businesses, and the economy immediately hemmorhages 10s of millions of jobs, that most of what we're doing isn't essential. In some bizarre twist of fate, an enviable hegemonic position has been squandered: where Americans could have cemented their dominance by doing likely anything else, we instead de-industrialized ourselves into a service-based economy specializing in shuffling the same 300$ around between 300 million people while nose-diving off a cliff the second the invisible hand comes knocking.
Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by czbond on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:15PM (#23328415)
You both have valid points; I think OP is talking about the U.S. economy being built on consumerism, materialism, and need to spend for growth. Growth requires the citizen base to continually spend more.
Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by gopalv on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:26PM (#23328584)
> Growth requires the citizen base to continually spend more.

If the stimulus bill had gone directly to that, then this might have made a lot more sense.

Forget UBI, the trillion dollars in PPP, if it was put into people's checking accounts as a reverse payroll tax might have had a very different (& aligned with consumerist values) economic result.

As in, take the "employee as a cost" out of the employer's books & turn every extra employee just extra hands to work at your business, just paid for by the negative taxes (this punishes the under-the-table payment tax dodges directly).

The fact that they gave PPP, without actually putting money into a paycheck absolutely sucked if your goal was to stop the money from slowing down in the economy.

A dollar I spend turns into many more dollars spent, than a dollar I saved.

But if I know I'm out on the street once that number drops to 0, I won't spend right now, even if it is a necessary purchase.

Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by spamizbad on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:39PM (#23328821)
What state requires you to stay in your home?
Re:Salaries Get Chopped for Many Americans Who Manage to Kee... by jondubois on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @04:44PM (#23329722)
I think that it's definitely fragile in the sense that there are a lot of people going through hardship at the moment. When so many people need to rely on friends and relatives to survive, it means that capitalism has already broken down. The system has already failed. Now we just have to wait and see the results of this weird socialist system that we just created.