News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by DangerousPie on Friday May 22, 2020 @06:24AM (#23270500)
It's ridiculous how Siri is still this shitty. I have an 11 Pro and even on such an expensive phone I can't really trust it to do anything more advanced than set timers. Every few months I try to do something else and just get annoyed at how bad it is.

Before lockdown I even had it disabled entirely because it would get activated randomly from time to time, even if nobody in the vicinity said anything remotely close to "Hey Siri".

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by pjc50 on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:08AM (#23270781)
The problem is not just that it is wrong, nor that it doesn't have enough personal information, but that it lacks proper personalisation and the ability to learn.

You can't reply with "no Siri, not that London" and have it remember. It doesn't learn your voice among the people who normally use your Siri in your household.

"Artificial intelligence" is always going to make mistakes, as do real humans. Humans can perform unsupervised learning - in fact it's one of the key skills that employers like to select on! Until AI can learn in context it's going to be very limited.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by neor on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:26AM (#23270901)
Siri indeed never learns.

I've had to disable "Hey Siri" because my daughters name is pronounced vaguely similar to Siri. Worst thing is, Siri transcribes what it hears, and it transcribes my daughters name. So it doesn't hear wrong; it just activates on a different name than Siri.

I've tried telling Siri to shut up; but it never learns not to activate when I call out my daughters name.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by aasasd on Friday May 22, 2020 @08:02AM (#23271176)
That might be because the activation words are recognized by a separate chip (so it's low-power and works offline). Whereas the rest of the conversation is with the software service.

At least that's what I heard about how iirc Alexa works.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by hrktb on Friday May 22, 2020 @09:08AM (#23271605)
Activation words are fuzzy by design.

Siri is easy enough so we never looked much into it, but “OK Google” for instance looked like a real PITA, so we did some research before buying an assistant.

It appears a ton of people just intentionally say “Ok GooGoo”, “Ok Boogle” etc., whatever is easier for them to pronounce and it works perfectly fine.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by anewdirection on Friday May 22, 2020 @10:30AM (#23272480)
When those designs strip your privacy, 'fuzzy by design' is cery much a bug to the user, and only a feature to the company mining the data.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by hrktb on Friday May 22, 2020 @12:50PM (#23274129)
I may be biased as I helped a voice recognition internal project in a previous life.

It’s a genuinely hard problem to solve, and I am willing to give the benefit of the doubt to Apple for instance when they have humans reviewing samples. There may be other motivations, there’s ton of people in any of these companies, any given feature must be seen from a different angle depending on the department looking at it.

But I think a lot of what we see as privacy violating is primarily an effect of the flaws and all the hacks needed to make the feature work at all (when it works).

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by mdemare on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:51AM (#23271093)
It activated when I greeted my cat. My cat is called "Timmie"
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by thrwn_frthr_awy on Friday May 22, 2020 @11:02AM (#23272831)
Siri is not artificial intelligence-it is speech-to-text + a poor search experience with one result.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by chappar on Friday May 22, 2020 @06:44AM (#23270636)
I had never used an Apple product before the company which I joined recently gave me a MacBook Pro. I am really surprised how bad the product quality is. The calendar notification is very random. Sometimes it fires, sometimes it does not. I have missed couple of meetings because notification popped after the meeting was over. Similarly the keyboard shortcut is random. Sometimes it opens the app, sometimes it does not. The laptop also gets very hot if you are not sitting in A/C. Not sure if it is this specific laptop or it is a general issue
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by eknkc on Friday May 22, 2020 @06:56AM (#23270709)
Yeah it is the norm these days. I’ve been using macs for 15 years and they bave been fantastic until the very last iteration (after 2016, 17).

My latest MacBook (16") is so unstable that it is actually funny at this point.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by osrec on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:21AM (#23270864)
So do people just buy these to look cool? I tried using a Macbook many times, but often got frustrated and went back to my good old Linux laptop for development. Doesn't look quite as slick, but certainly gets the job done.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by eknkc on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:34AM (#23270979)
No, I don't think so. There are multiple aspects.

I develop on this thing. It is running a great Unix os. I can't stand desktop Linux. The hardware quality was the best with a wide margin before the latest gen. Battery life is also great. I like them for development work when they are stable.

A lot of people are also really invested into the ecosystem. My entire photo collection is on iCloud. I use an iPhone. I can copy paste between my computer and phone. My Apple watch unlocks the computer when I'm near... List goes on.

But now I feel like Apple is a fantastic phone company that also happens to make some computers. They have been degrading pretty bad.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by noirbot on Friday May 22, 2020 @10:51AM (#23272724)
It's also that Windows/Linux has many of these issues as well. It's not as if Windows 10 notifications are clear and intuitive. When I go to my desktop after a day of work, Windows will slowly replay every single slack message and email I got all day, one at a time, for almost an hour, as single notifications.

I think it's less that OS X is bad now, but more that it's finally degraded to a level of annoyance that people just have gotten enured to with Windows. It's not to say that that's a good thing, but at this point, I have known bugs and annoyances with all of the computers I work with, no matter the platform.

Some of it is also that Apple has a "real" integrated ecosystem. To what you say, you can easily move things between iOS and OS X. If you're watching stuff on your Mac, you can throw it to an Apple TV or your Airpods. Windows doesn't have a version of that that "just works". The closest you get is opting into Google's ecosystem and going Chromecast/Android, but I'd rather not trust Google with even more of my info.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by parliament32 on Friday May 22, 2020 @12:46PM (#23274076)
Honestly I'd dare to say most of Apple's market right now is purely from vendor lock-in. Both their hardware and software are getting worse, but not bad enough for people to switch their entire digital lives to a different ecosystem.. not yet, anyway.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by karatestomp on Friday May 22, 2020 @11:19AM (#23273046)
My first Mac was an employer-provided MBP in... oh, 2011 or so. Before that I'd used DOS, Windows (3.1 and up, including NT4 and 2K) and Linux (Mandrake, Debian, Gentoo, Ubuntu, roughly in that order with a little Redhat and Fedora here and there). I'd seen some early OSX server edition thing, but not really used it, and I'd used pre-OSX Macs at school (hated them, "it's more stable and faster than Winblowz" my ass). Some exposure to Solaris, too. Used BeOS (loved it) and QNX on home machines for various purposes, as well.

The MBP was the first laptop I'd used that 1) had a trackpad good enough that I didn't feel like I needed to carry a mouse around to use it for more than 10min at a time, and 2) had battery life good enough that I didn't feel like I needed to take my power supply with me if I'd be away from my desk for more than an hour. It had every port I was likely to need for most tasks. In short, it was the first time I'd used a laptop that was actually usefully portable as a self-contained device. They kinda ruined that appeal by going all-USB-C and The Great Endongling, but that's another story.

It was also very stable, and over time I came to really appreciate the built-in software. Preview's amazing (seriously, never would have thought a preview app would make a whole computing platform "sticky" for me, but here we are, it's that good), Safari's the only browser that seems to really care about power use, terminal's light and has very low input latency, it comes with a decent video editor, an office suite I prefer over anything I've used on Linux, and so on. In short it's full of good-enough productivity software that's also light enough on resources that I don't hesitate to open them, and often forget they're still open in the background.

These days I like having a base OS that's decent, includes the GUI and basic productivity tools, and that's distinctly separate from my user-managed packages (homebrew) rather than having them all mixed up together (yes, I could achieve this on Linux, if it had a core, consolidated GUI/windowing system so various apps weren't targeting totally different windowing toolkits, but it doesn't, so separating a capable and complete GUI "base OS" from the rest of one's packages gets tricky). There are quite a few little nice-to-haves littered around the settings and UI. Most of the software is generally better polished UX wise than Linux or Windows, and that doesn't just mean it's pretty—it performs well and, most importantly, consistently. There are problems and exceptions to "well and consistently" but there are so many more issues on competing platforms that even if it's gotten worse, it's still much nicer to use.

Given the premium on hardware (that's come and gone—at times there almost wasn't one if you actually compared apples to apples [haha], but right now it's large) I'd rather use Linux (or, well, probably a BSD, but that'd mean even more fiddling most likely) but the only times that's seemed to function genuinely well and stably compared to its competition was when I either kept tight control over every aspect of the system (time-consuming, meant figuring out how to do any new thing I needed to do that other systems might do automatically, which wasn't always a great use of time to put it mildly) or in the early days of Ubuntu (talking pre-Pulse Audio, so quite a while ago) which was really sensible, light, and polished for a time.

I do still run Windows only for gaming, and Linux on servers or in GUI-equipped VMs for certain purposes.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by mattmanser on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:28AM (#23270915)
It's not just Apple, I've got a Mi phone, sometimes reminders pop up hours after they happened. They've mucked around with the default android lockscreen to save power and I think this is causing the problem.

The devices are so complicated now that they cant do their most basic functions right.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by leonroy on Friday May 22, 2020 @06:55AM (#23270705)
> The calendar notification is very random. Sometimes it fires, sometimes it does not. I have missed couple of meetings because notification popped after the meeting was over.

I see something similar and assumed this happens because Mail / Calendar are relying on ics attachments (not sure what the behaviour is with the Gmail integration). I believe this means that if Mail is closed you don’t get Calendar updates until you open both and refresh.

Either way I find I have to refresh Mail and Calendar a lot to keep them in sync.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by acdha on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:21AM (#23270867)
Heating is either a hardware issue or something like a broken program running continuously - on a normal setup that doesn’t happen.

Calendar / Todos depends on the backend. If you’re using Exchange, check the settings to confirm that it’s not set to poll every hour or something like that.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by roland35 on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:30AM (#23270934)
I had this problem too. Maybe try charging it on the other side. It sounds crazy but it's true:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22957573

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by jotm on Friday May 22, 2020 @06:49AM (#23270666)
It's ridiculous how poor in functionality all of them are... The best they can do is, what? Creating schedule entries, for me. All I ask Google is the weather, time, some search when I'm lazy and translate (the voice translate app itself is great btw). Feeling like a total corporate bitch saying "Hey Google" every time, too :D

This is supposed to be a personal assistant. And I have a whole list of what it could do for me, personally. But it doesn't.

I've been trying to figure out how to hook Google's speech recognition and voice into other apps, since they're great and it's 99% of what I need, hands-free control and feedback. Maybe they should make that easy, preferably offline and let other people create their own personal assistant modules or something.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by TeMPOraL on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:14AM (#23270830)
> Maybe they should make that easy, preferably offline and let other people create their own personal assistant modules or something.

Like they would ever do that. Then you would no longer be their "corporate bitch".

Seriously, the one thing that stands between home assistants and being useful is opening the software up and letting it be used by regular OSS devs. Alas, every one of the four big providers (Apple, Google, MS and Amazon) treat them as their moat; they want control over the ecosystem. It's the same in many other places in the industry - we're technologically way behind where we could be, because everyone wants to be the platform and commoditize everyone else, which necessitates having total control.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by jotm on Friday May 22, 2020 @10:09AM (#23272209)
I'm fairly sure they could still control and monetize such a product. Kind of like Android.

Maybe there's already something like that in the works, with all the talk and investment in AI, we should be seeing some real world results...

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by fauigerzigerk on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:13AM (#23270822)
I agree, some things are just astonishingly bad given the immense effort and resources that are being put into machine learning.

Microsoft OneDrive tags my photos. It's mostly useless. For instance, I have some pictures of squirrels on the tree outside my window. Squirrels can really do the most amazing things on trees, but they are small compared to the tree.

Microsoft with all its AI muscle will invariably tag those images as something like #Outdoor #Grass #Plant #Tree.

It's the same problem with all of those benchmark beating AIs. They have no clue what's special about the picture and what just happens to be in them as well.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by bnt on Friday May 22, 2020 @06:27AM (#23270523)
I’ve had Siri disabled for years. Even the basic “call home” works every 3rd time. I try it for a few minutes with every new iOS update only to see it’s still the same dumbster fire.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by mxcrossb on Friday May 22, 2020 @06:33AM (#23270568)
When I lived in the United States I frequently used Siri while driving to setup the gps or change what music I was listening to. But indeed, ever since moving to a country with a nice public transportation system, I’ve had it disabled. There just isn’t a compelling use case.

Meanwhile, my iPhone has gotten much smarter about adding meetings to my calendar, or guessing the person who is calling me. These seem like the real use cases for AI going forward.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by toyg on Friday May 22, 2020 @06:47AM (#23270661)
TBH, Google Assistant is not that much better. In the last few months it has become absurdly racist against my Italian accent, replying to me in Italian after I ask stuff in English - and getting the question wrong anyway.

But yes, Siri is the worst.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by swebs on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:20AM (#23270862)
Are you sure it's due to your accent? That seems like a difficult feature to even implement. I know Google loves to play language shenanigans based on your current IP address.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by nicbou on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:37AM (#23271000)
Mine will sometimes parse English, sometimes German. Sometimes it will understand English, and answer in German. It's a total crapshoot.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by toyg on Friday May 22, 2020 @09:30AM (#23271812)
I live in England.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by r1ch on Friday May 22, 2020 @11:59AM (#23273464)
Google Assistant failed on me recently trying to set a timer. It correctly understood my "set timer for three-and-a-half minutes" request, says it's setting a timer for 3am instead and proceeds to actually set a timer for 30 seconds. How is there that much disconnect between the stages of the query?!

Screenshot: https://twitter.com/R1CH_TL/status/1252232170237640706/photo...

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Friday May 22, 2020 @10:22AM (#23272356)
You consider that racist?
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by ewindal on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:07AM (#23270777)
There’s nothing worse than being forced to use a language you didn’t explicitly request.

Well, maybe some things are worse.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by swebs on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:21AM (#23270871)
Probably at least number 3 behind the Holocaust and Internet Explorer.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by empath75 on Friday May 22, 2020 @06:55AM (#23270699)
It even sucks at setting timers. I asked to set a timer for 50 minutes and it clearly said 50 minutes on the screen and then “corrected” it to 15 minutes.

For a while, it randomly decided that “call my wife” meant to “call my mom.” It clearly said call my wife on the screen and then switched to “mom”.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by jonplackett on Friday May 22, 2020 @09:12AM (#23271640)
You have to know the Siri hacks.

Set a timer for fifty-one minutes or fourty-nine minutes.

Even siri can hear that

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by huffmsa on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:28AM (#23270918)
Ask it to set a timer for 5/6ths of an hour.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by Gatsky on Friday May 22, 2020 @08:08AM (#23271222)
It isn’t really ridiculous. The number of people that buy an iphone because of Siri could share a pizza.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by DangerousPie on Friday May 22, 2020 @09:48AM (#23272017)
It may not be the main selling point but it's certainly a factor for many people. And the fact that Siri is so bad makes the whole phone feel less high-quality.

And maybe I'm the exception here, but I have refrained from buying an Apple Homepod specifically because of how bad Siri is. If it was on the same level as Google Assistant I would have bought one by now.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by saagarjha on Friday May 22, 2020 @04:54PM (#23276885)
Back when Siri was new and I was much younger this was something I really wanted…
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by csomar on Friday May 22, 2020 @08:06AM (#23271210)
Yesterday I was washing the car while listening to Music with the air pods. I mistakenly clicked them and it launched Siri which for some reason it called a number on my phone through Facetime.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by fiblye on Friday May 22, 2020 @10:28AM (#23272446)
I always immediately disable siri because something similar happened the very first week I got my first iPhone. It seems to want to call the one person you haven't talked to in years.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by csomar on Friday May 22, 2020 @10:32AM (#23272504)
Ha. Same thing for me. Made me rush to the phone as I heard the number it wanted to call.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by whywhywhywhy on Friday May 22, 2020 @08:12AM (#23271248)
I'm convinced it's actually gotten worse with the 11, I recently went from an iPhone 7 where Siri only really activated randomly a handful of times a year and could set timers (Only thing I ever use it for) with a shout across a room over the sound of an oven and fan.

Now it randomly activates multiple times a week and really struggles to even pick up me talking to it right next to it.

Convinced they've switched to a less capable microphone system because assistants were all the rage in the 7 era but now I think people have realized it's not really that important.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by jonplackett on Friday May 22, 2020 @09:10AM (#23271622)
Like others have said - it's Apple's privacy policy, they don't know enough about you and can't use the recordings to train.

I think Apple should have been more honest about it in their privacy messaging -

"Hey guys, pretty please can we listen to your Siri recordings? We know it's not the privacy style you're used to from Apple, but if you want Siri to ever not be a piece of crap, this is really the only way."

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by michelb on Friday May 22, 2020 @10:19AM (#23272334)
I don't buy that anymore. There's a multitude of ways to improve Siri while respecting privacy. Apple doesn't have to go the Google way to improve.

Apple knows a ton about me, they have realtime access to my email, calendar, contacts etc. If they have guarded access, then I would accept a toggle. A lot of Siri processing happens locally on the device nowadays, which could be why the Watch, Mac, iPhone and Homepod all can give wildly different results.

Also, Apple could train it themselves, they possibly do, except we haven't gotten an update yet. A large portion of my personal training data could be stored in iCloud, I mean my passwords, mail, documents and my photos are there, right? The analysis of my voice data is sent to Apple anyway.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by pndy on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:41AM (#23271027)
I think that up until the real AI appears that can mimic human personality and expand it, understand variety of languages, virtual assistants will remain what they are: virtual assistants capable of executing basic commands provided by a human (preferably in English). This technology isn't bad per se - in particular cases is helpful (blind people) but it's still far for what we dream about.

My Nokia 1320 with Windows Phone 8.1 come with a very basic VA that was capable of understand Polish but only if I drop all grammar and talk like a robot. The "call mum" is "zadzwoń do mamy" in its proper form, but I had to do "zadzwoń do mama" which sounds unnatural; not mention that stuff is also being read without proper Polish grammar; "calling mum" is synthesized as "dzwonię do mama", not "dzwonię do mamy". The grammar complexity is a problem for VA technology and probably that's why neither Siri nor Cortana supports Polish or other Slavic languages, not mention dozen of other languages.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by racl101 on Friday May 22, 2020 @10:16AM (#23272287)
Siri is utterly useless. Like, I just don't. The only capacity in which I use it is to tell it to open an app on the phone, or set the timer.

Siri is like that nice employe who was hired by way of nepotism, and she's attractive, but she sucks at most things, but the organization won't fire her because of aforementioned nepotism in the organization and the only reason you put up with her is cause she's attractive and she, at the very least, makes coffee and makes photocopies just good enough, but you can't trust her with more advanced tasks.

What's worse is that the organization also won't hire her more talented and equally attractive contemporary Google Assistant because of aforementioned nepotism. The boss thinks there's only room for one assistant.

lol.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by michaelbrooks on Friday May 22, 2020 @06:34AM (#23270573)
I mostly use Siri to play Spotify, but most of the time she won't listen to me through my car's microphone. If she isn't working then I need to pull my phone out of my pocket and place it somewhere the phone can clearly hear me.

Every once in a while she will decide to listen through my car, but it's very rare. I don't have Apple Car Play so not sure if that's a factor.

Google has been far better and more consistent listening through my car even if it didn't get my query correct all the time, at least I could correct it without pulling my phone out.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by wazoox on Friday May 22, 2020 @08:10AM (#23271231)
I almost never use the "google assistant". However it has an habit of firing up while I'm driving listening to podcasts : "I didn't understand your command" (generally, at a annoyingly loud level, with that). I didn't ask you anything, you stupid. You've just misunderstood a sound coming out of the phone itself, where nobody said anything remotely related to "hey google" or "OK google". Puhlease.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by viewer5 on Friday May 22, 2020 @08:48AM (#23271454)
I turn off as many settings for Assistant as I can, and disallow the Microphone permission to the "Google" app. That should help you out.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by parliament32 on Friday May 22, 2020 @12:44PM (#23274039)
Same deal for me but with Google. I had to turn it off because it kept activating itself, despite voice training it to apparently just my voice. I'd be driving in the car by myself, playing music (via BT, from Google Play, on the same phone!) and it would randomly pause my music and give me an assistant prompt (after, I assume, hearing something in the song that it was playing itself that sounded like OK Google). It was absolutely infuriating and would come up a few times a week.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by dunham on Friday May 22, 2020 @11:11AM (#23272941)
Still? Siri has actually gotten worse.

In the last year or so it's gone from correctly handling "add red salsa to the shopping list" to consistently adding two items "red" and "salsa". (It also fails on "buttermilk" and others.)

And around the time this started happening, Siri went from acting after a short pause to saying "just a sec" after a short pause.

Perhaps it's time to file a feature request to Apple to allow us to plug in alternative digital assistants in place of Siri.

Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by justinph on Friday May 22, 2020 @11:21AM (#23273064)
"Timers"? You mean: the timer. You can still only set one timer. Yet another deficiency. Its like the people who work on iOS don't ever cook multiple things at once.
Re:Siri, What Time Is It in London? by rhinoceraptor on Friday May 22, 2020 @09:59AM (#23272115)
I get the accidental invocations about once a day, because my dog is named Maisie and apparently that's just close enough to "Hey Siri".