Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by huhtenberg on Sunday May 10, 2020 @07:10AM
(#23131734)
The crucial part is missing in the Readme - how it works.
Nothing else matters until this bit is explained.
From the looks of it, it's just a proxy that forwards search requests to Google. Unless these happen to go out via Tor or similar anonymizer tech, that's hardly a "privacy-respective alternative to Google search".
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by tyingq on Sunday May 10, 2020 @08:12AM
(#23132037)
It does appear to strip cookies, and either some or all of Google's JS, depending the config. So, Google wouldn't see your client IP, any cookies, etc. Perhaps not fully private, but they do seem to provide better privacy.
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by rovr138 on Sunday May 10, 2020 @01:14PM
(#23134233)
> So, Google wouldn’t see your client IP
Yes they would. You can’t sent them a request without giving them your IP.
- If you’re self hosting it on your device, they have that device’s current public IP
- If you’re self hosting at a server you have, you’re giving them that (and will be easier to track).
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by justaj on Sunday May 10, 2020 @10:54AM
(#23133068)
If that's the case, then why not just use googler [0] since it only appears to send IP address, user-agent (which is set to Google Chrome) and search term to Google [1]
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by vinushkah on Sunday May 10, 2020 @07:17AM
(#23131780)
Since I found out that private.sh was owned by PrivateInternetAccess, I've been hesitant to use it given their recent acquisition by Kape Technologies.
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by livre on Sunday May 10, 2020 @08:46AM
(#23132188)
You can never be sure that the code you see is the same as the code that powers that website. If you trust the code the best you can do is run your own server.
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by rasengan on Sunday May 10, 2020 @09:11AM
(#23132326)
If you click View Source you can see that queries are absolutely encrypted. Running your own server just changes your IP but it’s still “yours.”
Finally, you shouldn’t “trust” code and run it. You absolutely need to read and understand first and finally, determine if running yourself actually brings benefit.
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by livre on Sunday May 10, 2020 @05:40PM
(#23136484)
You can't trust code you don't understand, if you do that don't call it trust, call it faith. Your query has to get decrypted somewhere or else the server wouldn't be able to proxy the request to Google unless it is E2E encrypted but then it is no different than just using a VPN or a socks5 proxy. If that's the case better just use Tor or a VPN and have privacy everywhere instead of just on your search page.
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by moepstar on Sunday May 10, 2020 @05:35AM
(#23131387)
Just to add some perspective - i'm using DDG exclusively because i'm really wary sending G any kind of traffic at all, since that will be tracked anyways.
Same goes for facebook - as long as you're logged in, you're sending them beacons for every site you visit that has a Like-button somewhere :S
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by lozf on Sunday May 10, 2020 @07:34AM
(#23131852)
> Same goes for facebook - as long as you're logged in...
Even if you're not logged in, AIUI they're still logging the IP's that load those like buttons, and anything else they can glean to match to "shadow profiles", which presumably they try to match with known profiles via cookies etc. if/when you log in later.
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by the_pwner224 on Sunday May 10, 2020 @08:31AM
(#23132109)
This happens even if you're not logged in.
You can go to the ublock origin settings and from the 'filter liste' section enable the social blocking ones. Those will disable the fb/twtr/etc. buttons completely. Or, as someone else mentioned, Privacy Badger should help without completelty disabling them.
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by brnt on Sunday May 10, 2020 @05:51AM
(#23131442)
Lately I've been using searx, which I found out depends in quality greatly on the instance used. Searx.space has a list of instances you can use, and you should try another if one doesn't perform well for you.
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by p49k on Sunday May 10, 2020 @09:11AM
(#23132324)
As someone who mostly uses HN on mobile, I occasionally accidentally flag things, and then they disappear from my feed making it impossible to correct my mistake, and there is no way (that I know of) to see a history of what I flagged. I wonder how many people accidentally flagging could trigger the notice.
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by t0astbread on Sunday May 10, 2020 @09:50AM
(#23132554)
Yeah, I see. I still think it's a bit harsh, especially since it kinda depends on how you interpret it here (i.e. what is "Google search"? The frontend or the backend? etc.) and it was made in good faith after all.
This reminds me of a passage in the "Waterfox joins System1" blog post[1] where the maintainer of Waterfox goes into how they've recieved harrassment because some people felt Waterfox wasn't up to their standards in terms of privacy.
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by detaro on Sunday May 10, 2020 @10:26AM
(#23132813)
It's not a binary. There's a threshold of flags after which it is shown and a higher one after which it gets killed, scaled by other activity on the submission (and possibly some other internal factors, the details aren't really documented).
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by badrabbit on Sunday May 10, 2020 @07:09AM
(#23131733)
Perhaps a common protocol to query index search items would help with all this. New search engines pop up but how can they realistically stand a chance unless they depend om bing or google at least in the back end,even if they can they simply can't out spend or out hire google
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by baxtr on Sunday May 10, 2020 @06:15AM
(#23131538)
I have been using the Russian search engine yandex.ru lately. You will get different results. It reminds me of the google of previous times with less "SEO optimized" content on-top.
Re:Show HN: Self-hosted, ad-free, privacy-respecting alterna...
by t0astbread on Sunday May 10, 2020 @08:50AM
(#23132221)
And how much energy it'd take if everyone did that...
Addendum: Maybe something like what package managers are doing would be feasible? Download an index that's as compact as possible and search locally. Does that exist already?
Nothing else matters until this bit is explained.
From the looks of it, it's just a proxy that forwards search requests to Google. Unless these happen to go out via Tor or similar anonymizer tech, that's hardly a "privacy-respective alternative to Google search".
Yes they would. You can’t sent them a request without giving them your IP.
- If you’re self hosting it on your device, they have that device’s current public IP - If you’re self hosting at a server you have, you’re giving them that (and will be easier to track).
I suspect you know what I meant. They can't see the IP of your browser. Rather, they see a Heroku, DO, whatever IP.
That’s why I pointed out the 2 cases.
Edit: Forgot to add, also supports proxies.
0: https://github.com/jarun/googler
1: https://old.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/gayf4i/googler_v41_i...
Gigablast itself is an open source crawler, index, and query engine. It is a bit of a quirky one-man project, but also kind of good.
Don’t trust, verify :)
Finally, you shouldn’t “trust” code and run it. You absolutely need to read and understand first and finally, determine if running yourself actually brings benefit.
Same goes for facebook - as long as you're logged in, you're sending them beacons for every site you visit that has a Like-button somewhere :S
Even if you're not logged in, AIUI they're still logging the IP's that load those like buttons, and anything else they can glean to match to "shadow profiles", which presumably they try to match with known profiles via cookies etc. if/when you log in later.
You can go to the ublock origin settings and from the 'filter liste' section enable the social blocking ones. Those will disable the fb/twtr/etc. buttons completely. Or, as someone else mentioned, Privacy Badger should help without completelty disabling them.
Doesn't facebook run in its own container by default?
.. before I read it's actually a frontend/proxy to google, not a separate thing. This is fine, but the seems a bit misleading to me.
Minor nitpicking re: title, I don’t view it as an alternative to google search, since it still relies on google search results.
That said, I like the effort and it makes sense. It just shouldn't be called an alternative.
Edit: Never mind I missed the upper project description.
This reminds me of a passage in the "Waterfox joins System1" blog post[1] where the maintainer of Waterfox goes into how they've recieved harrassment because some people felt Waterfox wasn't up to their standards in terms of privacy.
[1] https://www.waterfox.net/blog/waterfox-has-joined-system1/
If that were the case, admins would simply change the title.
I suspect the reason is that it's a tool that is designed to violate a specific site's TOS, which I think this tool does.
Addendum: Maybe something like what package managers are doing would be feasible? Download an index that's as compact as possible and search locally. Does that exist already?