News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by swagonomixxx on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:59PM (#23093436)
This is pretty epic. VS Code has proven itself to be one of the best (if not the best) and feature-complete editor out there. It's basically an IDE of a ton of languages at this point, and it's completely free. Integrating it with GH is a no-brainer move from Microsoft's standpoint, to increase market share even further with more seamless integration.

If they're able to do setup for Python, Go, Ruby, and JavaScript projects, I suspect that'll be > 50% of all professional work (both FOSS and private) done on GH.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by skrtskrt on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:14PM (#23093628)
While VS Code is definitely good in general, and first choice for languages like JavaScript, I find it really hard to compare it to JetBrains PyCharm and GoLand (understanding GoLand has no free version).

The debugging and refactoring experiences for Go and Python in VSCode feel slow, awkward to set up and configure and just generally tacked-on.

I have gotten the PyCharm professional and GoLand licensed through my employer but I will 100% be paying for them out of my own pocket if I ever lose that.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by enitihas on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:37PM (#23094684)
Yup, VSCode isn't comparable to IntelliJ or the rest at all for anything other than Typescript. IntelliJ offers a bunch of life saving refactorings. Want to extract a new method? Ctrl+Alt+M. The exact same shortcut works in every language, with almost the same semantics as much as possible. Intellij can do context aware autocompletion (Ctrl+Shift+Space).

I use vscode for lightweight file editing. But for any long term project, it doesn't offer anything over Jetbrains products.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by eloff on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:53PM (#23094156)
I pay for the full JetBrains subscription. While I still use vscode for typescript and rust, I use JetBrains for anything else. It's one of those no brainer purchases that pays for itself within a month.

Programmers create enormous value. If you can get even small single digit percentage improvements by leveraging better tooling, it pays for itself almost right away.

I estimate conservatively I produce $500,000 in value a year. If I can eke out a 1% improvement in productivity that's worth $5000 a year.

I think it's a big blind spot that developers don't invest enough in.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by fierarul on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:50PM (#23096739)
Many vendors do think like this when they start their offer with 'how much is your time worth'? Indeed, your tool might save me 1 hour but it's not necessarily worth the price.

On complex codebases though I mostly need the IDE just to navigate code. Anything released in the past decade knows how to index some classes, jump around and do 'find usage'.

I agree that tooling most definitely helps, starting with your office, your chair, your hardware and your software config. You could also get 1% out of sleeping more I think.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by eloff on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:34PM (#23097193)
Chair, desk, distraction free environment, fast computer, fast internet, multiple screens, consistently good sleep, diet, and exercise. Stable emotional environment (relationships). You could easily get better than 1% from each of those. I'm ruthless about optimizing these.

Software tools, keyboard shortcuts, libraries, frameworks and saas software are also good targets to optimize that often don't get enough attention.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by symplee on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @11:24PM (#23099361)
(Serious question) I'm curious to hear more about "ruthlessly optimizing" your emotional environment and relationships. That is not something heard everyday...

Or if you'd prefer not to personally summarize, are there any books, articles, videos, etc, you can recommend that expand on this overall life philosophy?

Re:GitHub Codespaces by eloff on Thursday May 07, 2020 @12:55AM (#23099860)
It's not the right word for that, but in general just be extremely picky about serious qualities in your partner. Ditch bad relationships and maybes quickly, because there is a high opportunity cost. Value peace in a relationship, and stay away from people who like to fight.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by palerdot on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:07PM (#23095008)
> I estimate conservatively I produce $500,000 in value a year

Do you actually earn this amount per year? Or, is this just a projection of what you think the value of code you write is?

Re:GitHub Codespaces by wry_discontent on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:05PM (#23096287)
You can never earn the amount of value you produce. Your employer can't survive if they hire you for that amount.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by prepend on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:49AM (#23101925)
Not sustainably, but they could if they underpay others. Or run a deficit.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by actuator on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:44PM (#23095435)
I think he was talking about the value he generates, so possibly something like revenue/profit per employee kind of thing. For example, FB and Google make more than $1M revenue per employee. You can go more granular and look at the impact of your team or yourself as well.

But can be his comp as well, these are not unheard[1] of numbers.

[1] https://levels.fyi

Re:GitHub Codespaces by eloff on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:46PM (#23095462)
Yes, I'm talking about value. My comp is less than that figure. There are some developers with total comp like that though.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by dan_quixote on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:34PM (#23093888)
I've found I love JetBrains IDEs when I'm operating as a one-language power-user. But the last few years I find myself needing to use 2-3 languages in the same day (several more if you include markup "languages"). VSCode has become my editor of choice for local dev and vim for remote dev/debug.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by sswezey on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:04PM (#23094298)
I use IntelliJ with the various language plugins for this reason. It allows me to use the same setup for all my languages. Granted, I do get the full license through my employer, but I think it's worth it even if my company didn't pay for it.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by swagonomixxx on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:19PM (#23094487)
This is exactly my current situation. In one day I can end up writing in up to 4 languages (Go, Python, C, C++) and having one editor, with one set of settings for editing, and all the customization available in a single settings.json file, is just too good to give up for language-specific IDE's, especially ones that require yearly subscriptions.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by perrylaj on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @09:22PM (#23098605)
I just use intellij for the same purpose. Today alone, I made changes in Kotlin, Typescript, Java, JS, Groovy, and Python. All in a single project, in Intellij. I do use and appreciate vscode, sometimes, but the experience is nowhere near as good as Intellij for me.

That said, being able to change/edit PRs in github with vscode will be awesome. Will negate the need to check out out a branch locally for a ton of cases.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by antaviana on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:48PM (#23108113)
Have you tried the Remote Development VS Code extensions from Microsoft? I find them quite neat.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by arodyginc on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:20PM (#23093703)
Even for C# VSCode is way less useful than VisualStudio, which also has a free version (though doesn't run on Linux)
Re:GitHub Codespaces by twodave on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:56PM (#23094197)
Honestly, unless I'm working on a Windows machine, I find JetBrains Rider to be the best option for C# specifically. This is especially true if you like having your tests easily accessible from your IDE.

That said, VSCode is still very nice for front-end pretty much universally, and it's also great for things like back-end Javascript/Typescript. I think Codespaces is really going to excel when it comes to things like NodeJS -> AWS Lambda. Make code changes, run "sls test", done.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by recursive on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:10PM (#23094370)
> This is especially true if you like having your tests easily accessible from your IDE.

I haven't used Rider, but I'm curious how it could be easier than the Visual Studio test explorer? It seems pretty convenient, and doesn't lack any obvious features I can think of.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by noworriesnate on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:32PM (#23095282)
Minor point: the Rider test explorer tells you why your tests aren't appearing. Visual Studio's test explorer will just say "You have no tests, try rebuilding your solution" even if you already rebuilt it.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by peteri on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:14PM (#23096390)
I assume in part this is because the Rider test explorer is based on the one in Resharper.

Some stuff it does better is things like running 64 bit and 32 bit tests at the same time, supporting both nUnit 2 & 3 without having to disable/enable the plugin. Mind you I spent some time with code in release mode trying to work why I couldn't debug a test last week.

To be fair I hate what Resharper does for Visual Studio performance and a lot of the really useful refactoring in box these days so I no longer use it.

I prefer to stick with Visual Studio but I know lots of folks who are happy with Rider. It's good for all of us when there is competition in paid for developer tools.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by WorldMaker on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @04:03PM (#23095635)
I feel with .NET Core migrations the wind is shifting, at least for web development where VSCode is starting to be preferable to Visual Studio. VSCode isn't likely to get the WinForms or XAML visual designers any time soon, so Desktop apps will likely stay a Visual Studio niche, but even then I've found myself increasingly working in VSCode up until the point I need to do a UI tweak even with Desktop apps.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by mythz on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @08:22PM (#23098172)
It's no contest, JetBrains Rider provides the best C# development experience on any platform, with smarts well beyond what VS is capable of.

While a commercial product, I've got 9 JetBrains products installed under the same toolbox subscription where it's by far the best value software suite I've ever paid for. Thanks to their Toolbox App you can update all products with a single click, just the productivity saved from not having to endure VS's multi-gigabyte updates & OS restarts pays for itself.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by Guillaume86 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:35PM (#23095326)
> Even for C#

Weird way to put it, C# is expected to work better in VisualStudio, it's the standard/officially supported .NET IDE. For everything else I prefer VS Code personally.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by AsyncAwait on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:43PM (#23095417)
JetBrains has Rider on Linux for C# and while not free, if you're already paying for other JetBrains IDE's, as many devs do, it's included. I just think there's still not much reason to do C# on Linux over say Kotlin if you want a huge ecosystem.

I'd consider it if they come out with a cross-platform GUI toolkit for .NET Core/

Re:GitHub Codespaces by holtalanm on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:28PM (#23094585)
While Visual Studio is powerful, I have ran into wierd behaviors within the IDE that just make it a chore to use. Personally, I've preferred C# on VSCode over Visual Studio so far.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by swagonomixxx on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:17PM (#23094468)
I've been using VS Code's Go and Python plugins for development for the last 2 years and I've never had any major issues. In fact, my experience continues to get better after every release.

With the Go language server kicking off, Go development in VS Code is literally a breeze. Every single thing I'd want to do (format code, imports, run tests, run a particular test, debug a test, breakpoints, on and on) has been integrated into the VS Code plugin and it works pretty much seamlessly. I haven't used Goland since it's early release in 2016 or so, so I might be missing out on something, but it doesn't feel like it.

I've never had a good experience with PyCharm. Again might be because I've using earlier releases and things have gotten better. But I'm at a point where I'm too comfortable with VS Code and have customized it to a point where I don't think it's worth it for me to switch to another editor, especially one that is tied to a particular language.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by petargyurov on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:36PM (#23094677)
I made the transition from PyCharm to VSCode a couple of days ago and... it's not been smooth. Virtualenv doesn't automatically activate when I first open the workspace, pylint doesn't work yet VSCode thinks it's working and debugging just doesn't seem to work full stop.

I need to get back to it and try to fix it because I do like VSCode as a whole.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by zomglings on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:01PM (#23096236)
One thing that helps me managing Python environments in VS Code: I start VSCode from the command line with my virtual environment activated ("code -n .").

With this, I rarely have issues with VSCode picking up my environment. Hope that is of some use to you.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by petargyurov on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:08AM (#23101129)
I will try it, thanks.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by kstrauser on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:21AM (#23099976)
Pro-tip for VSCode: if you have a .venv directory in the root of your project, VSCode will try to activate it when you open the project. A few other tools have adopted that convention, too, and now at my job so have we. Rather than sticking virtualenvs in some odd location, the venv for ~/projects/mystuff is ~/projects/mystuff/.venv, and now it almost always Just Works.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by petargyurov on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:07AM (#23101126)
Mine is in the root directory but it's called venv, without the preceeding dot. I'll dig around the settings to see if I can change what it looks for.

Strangely it works if I close the initial termnial it spawns and open a new one.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by heavenlyblue on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:20PM (#23093701)
The issue with PyCharm is that it’s actually quite hard to extend due to lack of proper documentation for their plugins.

I love it but I sometimes think of something that contains less features while is easier to develop for would be a better choice.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by exdsq on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:33PM (#23094637)
I think VSCode sets a really good level across all languages (even more esoteric ones like Idris) however it can't compete with IDEs essentially dedicated to a tech stack like PyCharm or Visual Studio.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by harikb on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:08PM (#23095024)
Just an anecdote from a sample size of one - I had a recent situation where I had to nagivate and edit a code base that was a mix of Go, C++, and JS. And I had a paid IntelliJ Ultimate license. Long story short, VSCode did the best/fastest go-to-defintion like navigation given the constraints. IntelliJ separating Clion to a separate install is rather unfortunate. I can edit Java and Go together, but not C++
Re:GitHub Codespaces by AsyncAwait on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:46PM (#23095465)
I think it's because CLion is a bit of a separate codebase, integrating with GDB and all that, rather than just a language plugin that's also sold as a separate IDE as is the case for other languages.

This is also why the Rust plugin only has proper debugging capabilities in CLion.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by Polylactic_acid on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:54PM (#23097376)
I used to use rubymine a few years ago and maybe I just wasn't using it right but I can do all the stuff in rubymine in vs code. The only thing I'm missing is being able to look through the code for gems.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by vlunkr on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:13PM (#23093614)
> if not the best

Them's fightin' words. But on a more serious note, I think 50% is a massive overestimation. We haven't seen pricing. Unless MS is willing to take a huge loss on this there's no way it will be free. We all know the resources required to run a modern web app in development mode. I can certainly see this being useful if you happen to be away from your dev machine, or if you just want to contribute to something without setting up the whole environment, but not as a full-time solution. Especially considering github is known to have outages. You'll really be SOL then.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by topkai22 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:59PM (#23094248)
There is preview pricing available for VS Code Spaces, which is almost the same thing. https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/pricing/details/visual-stu...

The estimated cost for a full time developer to use the system is $23.30/month or roughly $280 a year. That's quite competitive- my "portable" workstation costs north of $2k and has a 3 year life span, so the "yearly" cost is $666. The benefits of being able to get use cheaper dev terminals in the general case could pay for itself, even before you get to the benefits of having a common environment.

Also, you can self host for free. 50% is an over estimate (I've never seen 50% of developers agree to ANYTHING), but broad adoption looks highly likely.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by prepend on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:54AM (#23101966)
I use my workstation for lots more than typing into vscode. If that’s all I do, then I could just use a chromebook.

I think my $2k laptop uses its local storage for evaluating software, working with large data in memory, lots of other stuff.

So that’s not going away. This would be a cost on top of my hardware $666/year.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by topkai22 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @12:39PM (#23104954)
I'll admit I've got a particularly killer use case. My daily project has an enterprise system for its backend. Its obnoxiously complex software, so devs generally only run part of it locally and part of it off of shared infrastructure in Azure. Because we are distributed team, cross-country network latency really hurts application performance under "local" dev conditions.

Running in a codespace, the entire codebase runs in Azure. The application performs almost as fast while debugging as it does in production deployment. It's awesome for where we've been able to convert to it.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by crdrost on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:00PM (#23096838)
MS may indeed be willing to take a "huge loss" on this. It may dwarf the added revenue from other sources.

So like I don't know your particular context but I imagine MS's moves would seem surprising for developers, say, at startups. Whereas if you work at an IT adjoint to a mechanical contractor it might make more sense. What's at stake is that MS might be ramping up to some bigger announcement, "GitHub Cloud" or so, where you pay some fee for the cloud hosting and the sales pitch is, "imagine that you can fix a bug from a bug report in a non-crappy editor like VS Code, do a quick code review and push a button which will run your tests, canary deploy, then version it and push it live -- we take care of all that infra, you just pay for the Azure hosting." If you give half of that for free to everybody, you nominally "lose" but you increase the adoption rate of a separate revenue machine, which makes up for it.

A similar strategy was used by Microsoft to make their initial profits with Windows. There it was "you don't have to worry about the hardware specs -- we have already worked all of those out and all of them work with Windows." The key point in both is to say, "what are people seeking out, at the same time as they are seeking out my product?" and then to either give people a lot of freedom or a really easy option. You would rather take one pill that is carefully engineered to have the right omega-3 balance to stave off depression AND is a good probiotic AND has all of your daily vitamins, than to have to bother with a separate fish oil pill and probiotic and multivitamin. Focusing on product "complements" is often a really good strategy.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by JoyrexJ9 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:53PM (#23094157)
I don't think anyone would suggest this a full time replacement for your dev environment and IDE
Re:GitHub Codespaces by colordrops on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:09PM (#23093556)
Let's just hope they don't only maintain this online editor and deprecate the desktop install.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by saagarjha on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:12PM (#23093603)
That sounds quite unlikely.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by searchableguy on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:18PM (#23093684)
Doesn't to me (they might not deprecate it but they will simply stop putting resources into it at which point it turns into maintenance mode). As another posted pointed out the Facebook links, companies would love remote IDE tooling hosted on their premise so it can be an easy way to remove overhead on onboarding and tighten security more.

For monorepos, it might work pretty well.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by meysholdt on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:27PM (#23093800)
> would love remote IDE tooling hosted on their premise so

sounds exactly like what Gitpod self-hosted is for: https://www.gitpod.io/blog/gitpod-self-hosted-0.4.0/

Re:GitHub Codespaces by searchableguy on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:28PM (#23093816)
Yeah but does it come with github or azure enterprise package?

No.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by jankeromnes on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:54PM (#23094170)
This sounds like good feedback. What do you mean by "github or azure enterprise package"?

I think Gitpod Self-Hosted was successfully installed on GCP, AWS, and Azure, and we're working on documenting the process.

It also works with self-managed GitHub and GitLab installations (with Bitbucket coming soon).

Re:GitHub Codespaces by edaemon on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:30PM (#23093838)
Considering the desktop install is an Electron app I wouldn't think the two would diverge that much.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by colordrops on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:40PM (#23094707)
If they don't release the code for the cloud implementation, it could diverge.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:28PM (#23093811)
Free is a huge minus in my book. If I'm not the customer, then I'm the product. I'll happily keep paying for my JetBrains all-product license: https://www.jetbrains.com/all/
Re:GitHub Codespaces by meheleventyone on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:44PM (#23094027)
> If I'm not the customer, then I'm the product.

This is not necessarily always the case, for example the free thing might be a loss leader, exist to boost secondary or tertiary effects or otherwise exist for non-profit motivated reasons.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:13PM (#23094420)
Sure, it's a generalization, not an absolute. But for me there's not a big difference between "I'm the end product" and "I'm an intermediate product used to increase sales of the end product". Microsoft isn't a charity; they're an oligopoly pushing hard to keep their stock price up.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by meheleventyone on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:15PM (#23095096)
I think your characterization of being an "intermediate product" is also dubious since you aren't being sold in any reasonable sense ala the way you are with ad tech. And whilst MS are obviously in the business of making money that doesn't mean it's the only thing they'll do.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:33PM (#23095301)
If you'd like to argue that MS is giving this away just to be nice, instead of as a calculated move toward sustaining or increasing revenue, I'd be interested to see that. But for now let's assume they're doing what their shareholders expect: making money.

We can't know whether I'm an intermediate product without knowing their goals, which they're unlikely to be transparent about. But lets suppose one of their goals is usage and market share statistics that they use as proof to convince paying customers. In that case, my usage is very much an intermediate product.

Or let's imagine that one of their goals is restored market dominance in developer tools. To that end, they would like their competitors to receive less money, leading to their collapse. If they paid somebody else to give away developer tools for that purpose, I'd obviously be the product. That they're paying for that internally obscures it, but fundamentally doesn't change the exploitative nature of the relationship.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by meheleventyone on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:07PM (#23096905)
If all this is really what you believe rather than just being argumentative then how can you use any product. Usage and market share statistics are just as useful to JetBrains in that regard and you pay them for the privilege of being an “intermediate product”.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:42PM (#23097265)
Jetbrains shows no signs of wanting to be a monopoly player in development tools. I've been a customer a long time, and I think they've done a great job of balancing making money with doing solid work and serving their customers. Microsoft, on the other hand, has a long history of willful domination and exploitation, and they've specifically done that with free products to kneecap competitors.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by meheleventyone on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:01AM (#23100466)
Ahh, so we get to it. You just don’t like MS. I think that’s a valid reason not to use their products.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Thursday May 07, 2020 @10:53AM (#23103664)
No, I like competitive marketplaces, as they're one of the core engines of capitalism. I deeply dislike willful monopolies and oligopolies in general, because their goal is to break that engine in ways that harm consumers and often society. Microsoft themselves I can take or leave now that they've been mostly defanged.

I also really like having good developer tools. Many of them come out of community-driven open source. But some of them cost money. And for those, I very much want there to be a competitive marketplace, so there are strong incentives for all players to keep improving.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by swagonomixxx on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:20PM (#23094508)
> If I'm not the customer, then I'm the product.

I'm not sure what you mean by this, care to expand? Aren't you also the product for JetBrains, since you're one of the customers that's keeping them afloat?

Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:39PM (#23094698)
Sure. The foundation of commerce is sustained relationships where value is mutually exchanged. I give you a few bucks, you give me a cheeseburger. If fix somebody's problem with a computer, they give me cash. Product for payment; value for value.

When some commercial effort departs from that, it's good to be suspicious. The bills are getting paid somehow. E.g., look at network television from 1960-2000 or so. The viewers were not customers. The viewers were the product being sold to people who wanted to manipulate them. Advertisers were the customers, so the programs were generally about getting maximum influenceable wallet-connected eyeballs; quality was at best secondary.

In contrast, look at what's happened to TV since then. We're in a golden age. [1] Why? Many reasons, but a key one is that people are now paying for TV directly. To Netflix and Hulu and HBO and all the other paid streaming efforts, you're the customer, not the product being sold to somebody else. Now they have a strong incentive to make things that you don't just tolerate but love.

Microsoft in particular has a history of monopolistic behavior that has been harmful to the industry (e.g., [2], [3]). Are these developer tools awesome just because Microsoft is run by nice, generous people? I'd say instead they correctly recognize that if they want to regain some of their lost market power, they're going to have to compete with the existing tools, many of which are quite good. Why are they good? I'd say it's partly because smart people have built a strong business [4] making those tools. If Microsoft manages to eliminate the competition, they'll lose the incentive to build good stuff, just like they have in the past.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Age_of_Television_(2000...

[2] https://eev.ee/blog/2020/02/01/old-css-new-css/

[3] http://www.ecis.eu/documents/Finalversion_Consumerchoicepape...

[4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21796793

Re:GitHub Codespaces by lern_too_spel on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:15AM (#23100227)
> Many reasons, but a key one is that people are now paying for TV directly

This is an insignificant reason. People paid for cable TV and were soon shown ads. Even people who pay to see movies are shown ads before the movie and during movies via product placement. Hulu makes great shows but sells ads more highly targeted than any broadcast channels.

The biggest reason for the current golden age is that streaming services don't have to try to create the most broadly appealing content to fill the most valuable timeslots and can instead cater to each viewer's tastes directly. Breaking Bad was a great show before it got on Netflix, but it wasn't a hit until wide on-demand streaming availability helped it find its audience. Tiger King is the kind of hot garbage that would normally get an afternoon time slot on a second tier cable channel, but making it available on demand turned it into a megahit.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Thursday May 07, 2020 @12:12PM (#23104632)
The explosion in channels was definitely another factor. But being paid matters. HBO punched above its weight for years, for example. WHy? Because they had to.

I agree with you that oligopolies like big movie-theater chains will try to exploit that power by doing anti-consumer things like showing ads. But that's just more proof we should be suspicious of free products that may increase oligopoly power.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by swagonomixxx on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:00PM (#23096835)
Thanks for the detailed response.

I can definitely see where you're coming from. In fact, for VS Code, I believe they collect quite a bit of metrics on your usage of the product through telemetry, so it's definitely not "free" in the sense of "nothing given" - essentially, your programming and usage habits of the program are being sent to MS every second.

Re: the case of VS Code eliminating competition and MS losing the inventive to build good stuff, I think the core editor engine being open source gives me hope that this won't happen like in the olden days of MS. But of course, still a risk.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by eeZah7Ux on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @07:06PM (#23097484)
Facebook (and Cambridge Analytica) is another example.

> If Microsoft manages to eliminate the competition, they'll lose the incentive to build good stuff, just like they have in the past.

Typical strategy. You provide a good and cheap product until you reach a relative majority of a market and customer lock-in, then quietly slow down on the free improvements and start extracting money from the users.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by vlunkr on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:35PM (#23094668)
No the JetBrains IDE is the product. This phrase generally refers to things like Facebook or Google. They offer tons of free services in order to gather data about you and sell it to advertisers.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by swagonomixxx on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:01PM (#23096847)
Thanks. VS Code is actually no saint in this regard. MS collects metrics through VS Code's "telemetry" option (I think toggle-able to off, not sure) and this data has no doubt been used to improve VS Code and help MS build better product offerings and hence more rake in more revenue.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by paulcarroty on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:39AM (#23101536)
Re:GitHub Codespaces by brndn on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:36PM (#23093922)
> If I'm not the customer, then I'm the product.

This isn't always true, so it's best to look at it on a case by case basis. One wouldn't suggest that Typescript coders are a product of MS.

So far, they don't seem to be treating vscode users like the product. I think they're are building out great free tooling to entice users to use their other paid services like Azure.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by eyelidlessness on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @10:23PM (#23099000)
Github has made their pricing model and the motivations for it pretty clear. They subsidize their hosted service with enterprise self-hosted pricing to justify expanding their feature set. This has been true for a long time, well before the MS acquisition. The things that have changed are:

- Developments that were in place were released.

- The subsidization model made pricing structure changes possible.

None of this has to be a big conspiracy or a big change from Microsoft's acquisition. It's possible they just have a business model that's less nefarious than you're able or willing to understand.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @10:52PM (#23099174)
That's an adequate slam at the end there, but I'm more interested in your claim about "to justify expanding their feature set." How about you give me the elevator pitch on that. Because the obvious alternative explanation is that Github was doing what a lot of companies have done: use a loss-leader pricing scheme to establish market dominance, allowing them to charge more to customers for whom that dominance is a feature.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by tekkk on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:27PM (#23095232)
Well, you must then love Oracle. I mean, what you are saying is just silly. Of course the producers of FOSS want something in return, but sometimes it's not nefarious as you might imagine it to be.

It could be a strategical investment to create an ecosystem out of technology that you know the best and can influence its direction, to then sell customizations and develop services on top of it. Like MS is doing here. Or RedHat. Or Google with Kubernetes. Or Canonical with Ubuntu. And so on.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @08:19PM (#23098141)
It could be a lot of things. Would you like to argue that it is some specific thing that couldn't possibly lead to the sort of oligopoly or monopoly position that Microsoft has eagerly sought and maintained in the past? If so, which exact thing?
Re:GitHub Codespaces by tekkk on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:57AM (#23101328)
I'm arguing that the premise of non-free software and services being somehow better because there must be a catch is just ludicrous. So no, I don't want to argue "it is some specific thing".

I don't think MS is very charitable company and dislike many things about them, but sometimes a deal is just mutually beneficial. Better at times than with paid products.

And if Microsoft has something terrible planned, the community would just fork the project and go in a different direction.

Moreover I want to add that people, and companies, change. Just like a nation isn't the same it was 100 years ago, Microsoft too might have toned down its malicious practises. Just as a thought to you. We don't anymore blame Germans for being Nazis either.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Thursday May 07, 2020 @11:09AM (#23103857)
I'm not saying paid IDEs are necessarily better. But I am saying that in practice, commercial IDE vendors have been making superior products to the free-as-in-speech ones, and have been for 20 years at least.

You blow a lot of smoke here, with "sometimes" and "might". Sure, Microsoft could have been taken over by angels straight from heaven, and is now only intent on doing charitable works until the money runs out. Many things are possible. But possible doesn't mean true. If you'd like to argue something's true, by all means do it.

I think the only substance is "the community would just fork". One, there's no particular proof that a bunch of volunteers can make something like that. Two, that's an enormous effort. Look at how much work and time it took between MS using a free IE to kill Netscape and the emergence of Firefox. And that only worked because Mozilla found a revenue model that let it afford the large number of full-time engineers needed to produce a browser.

So if you're serious about your argument, why don't you explain exactly how "the community" will afford to do that fork. And why your imagined destruction of paid developer tool vendors like JetBrains and handing MS a monopoly in the market is ok as long as you're getting something free right now.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by topkai22 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:49PM (#23094105)
I doubt codespaces will be free- this is how VS Code starts seeing increased monetization. It'll be interesting to see if the self hosted codespace options are no-cost as well.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by lern_too_spel on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:11PM (#23094385)
Even if you're the customer, 99.9% of the time, you're also the product.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:17PM (#23094464)
Not in the sense which that is meant. The foundation of commerce is long-term, positive-sum relationships between people. The people at my corner grocery are looking out for the needs of me and my neighbors; we look out for them in return. That relationship is fundamentally different than the one between cow and meatpacker.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by lern_too_spel on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:47PM (#23094800)
Yes, you are the product in the sense that this is meant. The people at my grocery store track my purchases using my loyalty card, use that data to influence their ads, and sell that data to others.

Jetbrains might not do this, but if they can make money from this, they would be just as incentivized to do this as GitHub.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:36PM (#23095341)
Good thing my grocery store doesn't have a loyalty program or track purchases then. Maybe you should use a different one?

I agree the lets-exploit-the-customers behavior you're talking about is currently common, but it's far from universal. And regardless, in a value-for-money relationship one has power that just isn't there when one is purely being sold.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by lern_too_spel on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:53AM (#23100105)
Your grocery store probably charges slotting fees for shelf space, making you the product.

You have the same power when not paying because there are other providers whose free services you could use instead.

Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Thursday May 07, 2020 @11:11AM (#23103874)
My grocery store definitely does not charge slotting fees. Which is part of why I use them. They're a small, family-run market.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by recursive on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:12PM (#23094397)
Do you avoid public drinking fountains? (Covid-19 aside)
Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:22PM (#23094526)
Huh. Do you really not see any difference between a publicly funded accommodation and attempts to dominate a market by a company with a long history of abusing a monopoly?
Re:GitHub Codespaces by recursive on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @04:47PM (#23096106)
I do see some differences. I was attempting to use those differences to illustrate one of the ways that this maxim about consumers and products is overly broad.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by yarrel on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:01PM (#23096235)
It's interesting that this is the moment at which you chose to do that.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by wpietri on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:44PM (#23097284)
Exactly. All generalizations are broad. But nobody goes around objecting to generalizations every time they see one; they'd get nothing else done. So the pattern in which they do that is always informative.
Re:GitHub Codespaces by recursive on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @07:38PM (#23097797)
I aspire to contribute intrigue to the world.