News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by londons_explore on Monday May 04, 2020 @08:54AM (#23067388)
It should be noted that many modern systems are quite resistant to solar flares. Not by design, but mostly by chance.

Specifically, solar flares induce currents in long untwisted pair cables. If the cables have high impedance loads on the ends, high voltages will result, frying equipment.

The telegraph was an example of a high impedance long wire.

In modern equipment, long length high impedance lines are rare. Telephones are one, at around 900 ohms, although nearly all cables are twisted so barely affected. Power lines have an impedance below 1 ohm. Most Comms goes via fiber. Cable TV networks have a grounded shield so unaffected. Small household devices are small, and therefore don't have long lines to get big currents.

I'm sure a solar flare would break some stuff, but the vast majority of devices are more resistant than people expect.

The most vulnerable thing in today's world is probably actually disused phone lines, which are currently disconnected from anything else, so infinite DC impedance, yet very long, and could cause sparks and fires since they typically have paper insulation which is only good for 1000v or so.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by throwaway_pdp09 on Monday May 04, 2020 @09:14AM (#23067613)
I really do not buy this. Everything I've heard and read contradicts at least the "we'll be ok" view. Some very long untwisted thick wires are power cables.

On what evidential basis are you making this claim?

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/what-damage-co...

"An enormous solar storm could short out telecom satellites, radio communications, and power grids, leading to trillions of dollars in damages, experts say"

I asked an electrical engineer how well we're prepared for a large solar storm like the carrington event. She said 2 words: "we're not". What do you know that an expert working in this area doesn't?

More: https://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2014/2...

"

A similar storm [to the carrington event] could have a catastrophic effect. According to a study by the National Academy of Sciences, the total economic impact could exceed $2 trillion or 20 times greater than the costs of a Hurricane Katrina. Multi-ton transformers damaged by such a storm might take years to repair.

"In my view the July 2012 storm was in all respects at least as strong as the 1859 Carrington event," says Baker. "The only difference is, it missed."

"

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by sandworm101 on Monday May 04, 2020 @12:50PM (#23070351)
"An enormous solar storm could short out telecom satellites, radio communications, and power grids, leading to trillions of dollars in damages, experts say"

(1) Telecom sats are no longer essentially to much of anything. The vast majority of communcations happen over fiber lines, buried or laying deep under the ocean. GPS satalites may be affected, but the current crop are hardened and expected to survive.

(2) Radio communications certainly may be disrupted during the storm. Our cellphones might be offline for a week, so too local radio stations: a temporary inconveniance rather than end-of-days.

(3) Power grids may well be distrupted. Some transformers may blow. There are a handfull in the US that are of vital importance, but they could be replaced. A worst case senerio might see some large areas without GRID power for a period of weeks. But the power plants will still be there. Some sort of diminished local service would be restored.

Who will feel the effects: The military. Militaries still rely on telecomunications via satalite. They still rely on radio for long range communications.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by AnimalMuppet on Monday May 04, 2020 @02:19PM (#23071439)
We don't have all that many spare transformers sitting around, waiting to be used when one fails. And they aren't all that fast to build. If we lose a number of transformers, it may be a while before some of them are replaced.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by buran77 on Monday May 04, 2020 @03:58PM (#23072583)
You're handwaving a lot of serious effects of a powerful solar storm. The biggest issue by far is the power grid and depending on severity it can go from "we had a small spike that was easily absorbed by the network" to "the cables melted and set fire to everything around them".

The worst case scenario might be that your power grid is down and nobody can intervene because every intervention site is on fire. Big cities would be particularly affected since they don't do well for long without power.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by unethical_ban on Monday May 04, 2020 @04:03PM (#23072634)
> Our cellphones might be offline for a week, so too local radio stations: a temporary inconvenience rather than end-of-days.

All wireless communications, all maritime communication, being affected is much more than an inconvenience. The literal end of society and civilization? No. Potentially hundreds of thousands dead, billions of dollars in damages? Yes.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday May 04, 2020 @11:03PM (#23075993)
Your (2) ignores the dependency of civilian air traffic on working radios, AND GPS.

Your (3) ignores the TIME it takes to manufacture AND deliver/deploy grid-level/substation grade transformers.

There aren't many spares around, and it's not like you could buy them at the Home Depot/Lowes, etc.

Actually, if you're so inclined, you could gather that from various press releases of the involved parties, which i happened to come across because of idly watching various youtube videos of said heavy transports, which linked back to those. It's often a very complicated and slow multimodal operation, by ship, rail, and street, involving large detours to avoid bridges and other obstacles.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by throwaway_pdp09 on Monday May 04, 2020 @02:07PM (#23071298)
So experts are wrong and you're right. OK.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by ballenf on Monday May 04, 2020 @03:27PM (#23072248)
The reason I'm here is that there are often better informed experts here than in the cited articles. Maybe that's the case here or maybe not. Or maybe you're the best expert on the subject. I don't know, but I don't mind hearing the opposing view.

It's not like (I hope!) any government's public policy is being driven by HN comment threads.

> So experts are wrong and you're right. OK.

Yes, that position was already clear from their comment.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by throwaway_pdp09 on Monday May 04, 2020 @04:36PM (#23072960)
There are sometimes better informed experts here I suppose. But you didn't ask, you just made nonverified declarations which a little reading of the links posted here would have told you were wrong.

Didn't come across that you actually wanted to know the facts, but to assert that everything was fine, just fine.

That kind of thinking is what got us into the covid crisis we're slogging through at fantastic cost right now.

Of course that may not have been your intent but if not, what are you doing.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by spdustin on Monday May 04, 2020 @09:14AM (#23067619)
That isn’t actually true. Induced current will occur in nearly any conductor, and the biggest risk all over the world is in the loss of high voltage transformers.

This is absolutely, 100% a big problem. While these FOIA’d FEMA docs [0] are just one source, searching for “solar flare blackout” will net you all the sources you need. It’s the same as a nuclear EMP.

[0] (PDF): http://www.governmentattic.org/24docs/UnpubFEMAgeomagRpts_20...

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by Jeema101 on Monday May 04, 2020 @09:43AM (#23067933)
The North American Electric Reliability Corporation apparently doesn't agree with that assessment:

"NERC recognizes that other studies have indicated a severe GMD event would result in the failure of a large number of EHV transformers. The work of the GMD Task Force documented in this report does not support this result for reasons detailed in Chapter 5 (Power Transformers), and Chapter 8 (Power System Analysis). Instead, voltage instability is the far more likely result of a severe GMD storm, although older transformers of a certain design and transformers near the end of operation life could experience damage."

https://web.archive.org/web/20150908075507/https://www.frcc....

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by spdustin on Monday May 04, 2020 @03:07PM (#23071996)
Read this transcript [0] of remarks—given to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission—at a 2016 hearing on US power transmission reliability. These remarks directly contradict the relevance and, indeed, the reliability of the NERC study quoted.

[0] (pdf): https://www.resilientsocieties.org/uploads/5/4/0/0/54008795/...

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by SuoDuanDao on Monday May 04, 2020 @12:08PM (#23069711)
Well, I wasn't worried till I saw that. It reminds me of Trump saying there was no reason to worry about Coronavirus.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by throwaway_pdp09 on Monday May 04, 2020 @09:23AM (#23067724)
The stuff about blowing the transformers is exactly what I've heard too. If there are any EE who'd care to comment, I'd be curious to know if the level of power that starts flowing through HV cables could damage or destroy them. As I've not heard this I assume not (one bit of good news) but I'd like to know.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by geomagthrowaway on Monday May 04, 2020 @06:33PM (#23074159)
The problem is not directly with the wires, its the addition of the quasi-DC induced currents in an AC transformer. Even the addition of a small DC current can lead to unwanted harmonics or in extreme cases spot heating (this is what you think of when people say 'knocking out a transformer').

If you want a very in-depth review: https://doi.org/10.1002/2016SW001501

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by throwaway_pdp09 on Tuesday May 05, 2020 @03:57AM (#23077587)
Well over my head but printed it out and will read anyway. Thank you.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by Retric on Monday May 04, 2020 @09:39AM (#23067892)
Electrical cables are untwisted, but they are also designed to handle a lot of current so the overwhelming majority would be fine. Unfortunately, ultra long distance power transmission cables are the exception.

The long term damage from that is significantly less than assumed. Yes, making ultra efficient transformers designed to last decades is extremely time consuming, but building something less efficient in under a week is also possible. There would likely be various electrical issues until they where replaced, but that’s vastly better than societal collapse.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by spdustin on Monday May 04, 2020 @02:43PM (#23071716)
I do not believe the international supply chain is sufficient to replace any at-risk high-voltage transformers that are destroyed by an electromagnetic pulse. There is a considerable body of research around this topic.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by Retric on Monday May 04, 2020 @02:49PM (#23071791)
This is not a question of 1:1 replacement via the existing supply chain. This is using a 1920’s solution that gets us 80% of normal not the much better but more difficult 2020’s solution to the same problems.

Consider, a modern ship’s propeller is an marvel of modern engineering that would be extremely difficult to replace with something nearly as good. But, welding some plates to the drive shaft is vastly better than nothing in an emergency. Similarly, if the choice is a poor solution or no electrical grid, having some power makes a huge difference.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday May 04, 2020 @11:41PM (#23076253)
Look at this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_grid#/media/File:A_...

The purple lines there stand for the highest voltage level of the grid which usually runs at 380.000 to 400.000 Volts(with a few higher exceptions). These and their transformers are the most vulnerable to what we are talking about.

What do you hope to 'McGuyvering' there with maybe 110.000 Volts when the whole structure and anything connected to that is designed, specified, and built for at least three times the voltage?

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by Retric on Tuesday May 05, 2020 @07:13AM (#23078739)
This is what we are concerned with: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_grid#/media/File:Un... Not all of those lines are equally at risk, but for the sake of argument assume everything over 200KV is gone.

400kV is not directly stepped down to 33kV there are generally intermediaries at 132kV and or 66kV. So if you can send 132kV or even 66kV much of the equipment can be used.

Getting enough power to operate refrigeration and stop lights is a big deal. If you can only send 20% of normal power across those lines then that’s what you’re stuck with. In places such as Hawaii, local generation is close enough that your it’s no big deal, in others you may end up with rolling blackouts or charging 1+$/kWh.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by lowwave on Monday May 04, 2020 @11:02AM (#23068857)
Seems like the trillions bailout money ought to be spent on hardening these systems to prevent a solar flares or EMP type of events.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by geomagthrowaway on Monday May 04, 2020 @06:29PM (#23074117)
I think you have it the wrong way around. Geomagnetically induced currents (GICs) are more prevalent in high-voltage wires because they have low DC resistance. The longer a line, the larger the induced voltage. High-voltage lines can extend up to 1,000s of km, as they are most efficient. Then its basically V=IR. So low-resistance wires and long distances = larger GICs.

The danger is not from the cables burning out (extreme GIC events can lead to a couple of hundred Amps, which shouldn't be a problem for the cables), but the addition of the DC current in an operational transformer will push it into core saturation leading to nasty effects. Twisted/untwisted cables don't come into it.

Source: postdoc who models Carrington-scale events, and did my PhD on GICs in a regional power network.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by t_s_popik on Monday May 04, 2020 @07:17PM (#23074504)
It is clear to me that geomagthrowaway has some real technical expertise on solar storms and GIC.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by baq on Monday May 04, 2020 @10:54AM (#23068756)
if we had 16h to prepare, could high voltage transformers be saved by linemen racing to disconnect them and wrap in tinfoil or some other way?
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by AnimalMuppet on Monday May 04, 2020 @02:25PM (#23071487)
Disconnecting? Sure, reasonable idea. If the current doesn't get into the transformer, then it can't destroy the transformer.

But wrapping tinfoil? The kind of energies we're talking about would vaporize the tinfoil without breaking a sweat.

Disclaimer: I am not an EE.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by throwaway_pdp09 on Monday May 04, 2020 @12:01PM (#23069613)
Not an expert but re. your lovely image of wrapping them in foil, what I understand is that the long power lines pick up the huge surges and it's these that damage the transformers. So AFAIUI just disconnecting the transformers would protect them. But I repeat my disclaimer.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by spdustin on Monday May 04, 2020 @02:45PM (#23071747)
In fact, manual disconnects are included in the mitigation protocols proposed by researchers when providing guidance to the U.S. government on this topic.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by marcosdumay on Monday May 04, 2020 @01:33PM (#23070905)
I got the impression that the ground potential would change on such an event, that it's not only caused by induction on wires. Isn't it the case?

Differences in ground potential means that any cable that is grounded on more than one place now has a huge amount of current trying to run through it, on a large potential.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by rini17 on Monday May 04, 2020 @09:03AM (#23067496)
What about common mode induction - when the inducted current flows in the same direction in all strands of wire (regardless of twisting) with earth return path? This is what AFAIK causes the problems with power transformers and can happen on long metal pipes too.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by londons_explore on Monday May 04, 2020 @09:08AM (#23067555)
Common mode induction is an issue in any twisted pair system.

As long as the DC impedance to ground anywhere is <500 ohms, I wouldn't imagine enough voltage to build up to break down even a tiny signal transformer. In power systems, the connection between neutral and earth does that.

Long ethernet cables might be a concern, since the common mode DC impedance at the termination is normally infinite... Analogue audio equipment also frequently has infinite common mode impedance to prevent ground loops.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by spdustin on Monday May 04, 2020 @09:15AM (#23067639)
I really hope you take to heart the sources and links that people will respond with, and not just switch to defensive mode. This is a dangerous topic, and important to get right.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by dontbenebby on Monday May 04, 2020 @09:10AM (#23067580)
Thanks for this. I keep seeing FUD like such an event would wipe hard drives (which seems like a reach, but I'm not an electrical engineer).

What sorts of consumer electronics (if any) might be affected by a flare?

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by hyko on Monday May 04, 2020 @10:29AM (#23068476)
All of them, if there’s no power grid.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by dontbenebby on Monday May 04, 2020 @11:24AM (#23069121)
That doesn't answer my question AND isn't even accurate.

(Ex: I could charge my tablet with an Anker solar charger I have and as long as the electronics hold up have access to the videos/music indefinitely)

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by hyko on Monday May 04, 2020 @12:23PM (#23069952)
We’re talking no power grid for months or years. Most portable electronics would be technically fine, but unable to operate for any significant period of time because of the lack of power.

Your best bet might be to stash a solar panel some place shielded, and then use that to charge the batteries after the CME has passed.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by LargoLasskhyfv on Tuesday May 05, 2020 @12:00AM (#23076343)
As i understand it people mistake two different phenomena for the same. The geomagnetic storm induced by coronal mass ejection of our Sun is dangerous for the power grid because it could fry its transformers, because basically the long distance transmission lines work like an antenna, amplifying that. But it is a slow and weak thing, so anything disconnected at the time should be ok.

The fear about disconnected electronics becoming fried comes from the Nuclear Electromagnetic Pulse(NEMP). Which is a fast thing, inducing large spikes in a short amount of time, thereby frying transistors on-chip, if unshielded, even when disconnected.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by throwaway_pdp09 on Monday May 04, 2020 @11:50AM (#23069443)
If all of food/water/gas/electricity/fuel distribution is badly interrupted, there's the bigger picture.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by dontbenebby on Monday May 04, 2020 @12:58PM (#23070451)
You can grow or shoot food. I'm Appalachian, I know more than just how to code :)
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by londons_explore on Monday May 04, 2020 @10:40AM (#23068613)
> What sorts of consumer electronics (if any) might be affected by a flare?

* Old things (ie. pre 1990) - ie. before it was common to put protection diodes on every CMOS input.

* Analogue things designed to be very sensitive, particularly at longer wavelengths. FM/AM radio, ECG machines, microphone inputs...

* More modern things if a power cycle can't reset state.

Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by geomagthrowaway on Monday May 04, 2020 @06:43PM (#23074244)
This isn't true. Your electronics might be fried by a flare if they were in space, but the geomagnetic field changes due to a flare will not induce currents in any conductor shorter than several tens of kilometers. I think you are thinking of nuclear EMPs which could affect electronics?
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by simonebrunozzi on Monday May 04, 2020 @08:59AM (#23067452)
Thanks for explaining this in such simple terms. I am grateful. I wish I learned enough about electricity long time ago; and somehow I never get the resolution to do it today - despite, having an computer science background and curiosity for all things science, I suspect it shouldn't be particularly hard.
Re:Solar Storm of 1859 by prennert on Monday May 04, 2020 @03:45PM (#23072449)
Is this true for train overhead lines?