1. Old, hugely successful company needs to find new growth areas.
2. Company acquires company in high growth area (sometimes innovative, sometimes not)
3. Taking from the MBA playbook that higher investment equals more growth, acquired company is given aggressive targets but also a huge budget to meet them.
4. Company goes on a massive, usually relatively untargeted hiring spree, things become a major shitshow, acquired leadership team is eventually canned.
Instead of finding some realistic product targets and then setting a budget around what resources will be needed to attain those goals, the budget is allocated based solely on desired revenue and somehow hiring all these people without a clear plan will make that happen.
I'm genuinely curious, has this ever worked?
- bought and turned into success
- bought and integrated into the larger business
- bought and closed after running into the ground
- bought and then later spun off due to inability to create a successful business or integrate.
Not just for Google, but across IT as a whole.
AT&T's mistakes were made by people who were more technical than MBA, but it's a consistent trope that "Google bought Company A" and then Company B brings their salespeople to muster the next morning to inform them what's going to happen at Company A, and the next sales retreat is fistbumps all around.
I wonder if we could put a break on mergers and acquisitions, not for the sake of communities, workers, and competition, but just for the poor stockholders!
my recollection is that it's closer to half. m&a deals tend to be executive vanity projects as often as sound strategy.
Because in an ideal world you expect M&A to provide synergy, but it is often where 1+1 = 1.5 or less, and at best successes are 1+1 = 2. What people should be aiming for is 1+1 = 2.5 or more.
And recent Intel ( Post Andy Grove or Post Patrick Gelsinger ) has a track record of both poor strategic decision, acquisition and execution.
Note: That is M&A with respect to diversification.
it's a fascinating component of how companies are often overvalued in m&a activity.
Youtube -> Google
Twitch -> Amazon
Instagram -> FB
WhatsApp -> FB
FriendFeed -> FB
LinkedIn -> Microsoft
Ring -> Amazon
Paypal -> Ebay (Well they didn't destroy it)
Flipkart -> Walmart
Github -> Microsoft
Moat -> Oracle
EMC -> Dell
Beats -> Apple
Nest -> Google (Debatable?)
Qualtraics -> SAP
Macromedia -> Adobe
Mulesoft -> Salesforce
Tableau -> Salesforce
Skype -> Microsoft
Redhat -> IBM
Kaggle -> Google
Metaweb -> Google
Probably others - these are just the ones I can think of off the top of my head.
I don't know about every item in your list, but I do know at least in some of those cases that the acquired company was largely left alone. They were perhaps given some integration goals, but the parent company specifically "left them alone" to not kill the secret sauce that made them successful in the first place.
Pay attention kids. There are times when a company is investing in the future. Do exactly that. Buy equipment that will be useful down the road because it won't last.
One place I worked had some awesome custom test stands for the product we were developing. I wondered how they ever came to be since money seemed tight and we actually had some layoffs. Development had been going on since years before I got there and they hadn't landed a customer yet. We rebooted the design for the 3rd time and did finally win. The business became very significant to the company. Sure, they let a small team keep trying but we never could have made it without that initial investment in equipment/infrastructure. Spend the money when it's available, but try to make it count.
Mobileye: Paid $17B for it.
Altera: Paid $17B for it. At the time, Altera had a net profit of $0.5B. With something like $2B in assets, this will take 30 years to break even. How much growth are they expecting to offset that?
McAfee: Paid $8B for it, sold it for later. I'd love to see if they ever made back the amount they paid for it.
Nervana: They recently announced they're dropping the HW they produced. Time will tell if they can adapt the Nervana SW stack to the other ML company Intel just bought.
Infineon: Would love to see the numbers on whether they made a net profit on it. They may actually have with the sale to Apple.
WindRiver: Same question.
Yes, big companies should do some big bets. But bets are to make a net profit in the long run, with several failures along the way. With the amount Intel Capital has dumped in buying companies, and adding in the costs involved while holding them (employee salaries, capital expenses, etc), has Intel made money or lost money?
>Infineon: Would love to see the numbers on whether they made a net profit on it. They may actually have with the sale to Apple.
Likely not. Intel paid $1.4B for Infineon, invested billions into it every year, could not catch up to Qualcomm. Finally got the Apple contract by reducing price. And when they did it took out many of their 14nm capacity that could have been better used for something else. The $20 per pieces also did not really cover their R&D as stated in the court case against Qualcomm. In the end Apple got most of their R&D for $1B, and had to force to sign a license with Qualcomm or faced with the possibility of Intel shutting down their Modem business and they are left with no modem for iPhone.
Which equals to usually three pieces of redundant silicon with high availability failover, functional safety on each, high computer power needs and hard real time requirements (translating to further companion acceleration silicon).
Intel would love that to be Intel instead of some arm, riscv, Nvidia, whathaveyou...
The global vehicle production is in the order of 100mio vehicles per year, and drive ai is a growth market.
Is invest the same if I were Intel.
Do you mean the person or the company? If you mean the person, this is going to pretty weird.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McAfee#Acquisition_by_Intel_an...
at first they thought it would sell quad-core processors, but discriminating consumers learned that third-party antivirus makes your machine slow, unstable, hot and runs down the battery. Thus it damaged Intel's brand.
I don't get the anti-virus market at all. Granted all AV products are probably horrible and I haven't used a third party AV on a personal machine ever since about 2009-ish [0] but back in college I distinctly remember the consumer AV stuff was so much taxing on performance compared to "enterprise" stuff. I don't think there was ever a technical reason for this, was there? So, why?
Now I do remember subversion checkouts or anything file intensive was pretty bad (and it still is if you don't have a decent SSD) but my impression is that the enterprise av was better than consumer? Am I misremembering this?
[0] I think I switched to Microsoft Security Essentials or some variant of it if I recall correctly.
But like anything new, gets fat marketing budget, then after that grace period runs out, they are expected to be self sufficient and yielding a return.
Then even if everything goes well, those expectations and returns will also grow and eventually things change.
But initially, the honeymoon period is always fun, bit like first year at university, then things start to get real, real fast.
Fortunately for my team, Intel completely shitting the bed on 10nm meant that all these problems were barely noticed - who can blame you if the silicon isn't there.
The thing is, that when you pay a premium, overinvest and under-deliver you end up with no choice in the exec team - and you end up 'cutting you losses' and doing a McAfee.