News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel to buy smart urban transit startup Moovit for $1B f... by renewiltord on Sunday May 03, 2020 @02:45PM (#23060988)
I think Google did it with YouTube if you want a B2C example but this has happened many times in the B2B world successfully.
Re:Intel to buy smart urban transit startup Moovit for $1B f... by dmitriid on Sunday May 03, 2020 @03:52PM (#23061375)
Survivor bias and all that. I wonder what the ratio is between

- bought and turned into success

- bought and integrated into the larger business

- bought and closed after running into the ground

- bought and then later spun off due to inability to create a successful business or integrate.

Not just for Google, but across IT as a whole.

Re:Intel to buy smart urban transit startup Moovit for $1B f... by PaulHoule on Sunday May 03, 2020 @04:04PM (#23061460)
The number I have heard (from maybe 15 years ago) is that "2/3 of corporate mergers meet their goals." That was across a range of industries. Tech in 2020 might be different, there is a certain kind of mindlessness around acquisitions that happens around technology sectors. For instance, AOL bought Time Warner, regretted it, AT&T bought Time Warner, now the vulture funds like Elliot Capital Management are circling and they will have the CEOs head.

AT&T's mistakes were made by people who were more technical than MBA, but it's a consistent trope that "Google bought Company A" and then Company B brings their salespeople to muster the next morning to inform them what's going to happen at Company A, and the next sales retreat is fistbumps all around.

I wonder if we could put a break on mergers and acquisitions, not for the sake of communities, workers, and competition, but just for the poor stockholders!

Re:Intel to buy smart urban transit startup Moovit for $1B f... by clairity on Sunday May 03, 2020 @04:40PM (#23061687)
> "The number I have heard (from maybe 15 years ago) is that '2/3 of corporate mergers meet their goals.'"

my recollection is that it's closer to half. m&a deals tend to be executive vanity projects as often as sound strategy.

Re:Intel to buy smart urban transit startup Moovit for $1B f... by calvinmorrison on Sunday May 03, 2020 @07:06PM (#23062634)
Again it depends. Look at Church & Dwight, more known as the Arm & Hammer company. Their strategy of expanding all over the grocery store cleaning isle seems to have worked as they have a whole team of brands and brands at different price premiums. They have bought smaller cpg companies successfully
Re:Intel to buy smart urban transit startup Moovit for $1B f... by clairity on Monday May 04, 2020 @10:12AM (#23068277)
yes, certainly there are successes, but it's good to realize that that's only about half of attempts. if you're an involved shareholder, it's eminently reasonable to be skeptical of executive strategies that feature m&a centrally.
Re:Intel to buy smart urban transit startup Moovit for $1B f... by ksec on Monday May 04, 2020 @02:12PM (#23071356)
And even with the half rate "successes" ( Success in terms that is actually defined by the executive themselves ), most of them were done with a miraculously talented team that normally has little to do with the executives.

Because in an ideal world you expect M&A to provide synergy, but it is often where 1+1 = 1.5 or less, and at best successes are 1+1 = 2. What people should be aiming for is 1+1 = 2.5 or more.

And recent Intel ( Post Andy Grove or Post Patrick Gelsinger ) has a track record of both poor strategic decision, acquisition and execution.

Note: That is M&A with respect to diversification.

Re:Intel to buy smart urban transit startup Moovit for $1B f... by clairity on Tuesday May 05, 2020 @12:49PM (#23082021)
yes, i refrained from using the word "synergy" because most people don't differentiate the common pejorative understanding and it's M&A usage.

it's a fascinating component of how companies are often overvalued in m&a activity.

Re:Intel to buy smart urban transit startup Moovit for $1B f... by joejerryronnie on Sunday May 03, 2020 @03:12PM (#23061140)
Perhaps when the acquisition target is a smaller but fairly mature company who is being asked to scale existing processes. I think this is much more difficult for a startup when you’re essentially asking them to scale both their output and shrink their time to maturity by orders of magnitude.
Re:Intel to buy smart urban transit startup Moovit for $1B f... by renewiltord on Sunday May 03, 2020 @03:44PM (#23061331)
Yeah, the cases where I've personally seen it work were when the company had product market fit but was money constrained for how much it could grow.