News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by gpm on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @06:11PM (#23025077)
This argument is akin to saying "sure, he murders people by night, but he's a fire fighter by day so it's ok".

The kids being addicted to nicotine weren't even collateral damage. They were being explicitly targeted. Doing good doesn't excuse doing evil.

Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by asdff on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @07:27PM (#23025804)
Where is the evidence that kids were explicitely targeted? Kids can't buy these unless some adult consumer or a shop clerk is breaking the law. Flavored vodkas aren't treated with similar scorn, but you know 14 year old kids are getting faced off of blueberry smirnoff and not rye whiskey.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by sandworm101 on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @07:42PM (#23025922)
>>The Food and Drug Administration on Monday came out swinging at e-cigarette giant Juul over a variety of its unproven safety claims and startling marketing practices—most notably saying without evidence that its products are safer than smoking traditional cigarettes and giving presentations directly to kids in schools—in at least one alleged case, without teachers present or parental consent.

https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/09/juul-gave-presentati...

The were speaking directly to students inside schools. Kids. They were telling them that their products were safe. You don't see toy companies doing that.

Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by Apocryphon on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @07:54PM (#23026010)
That's cartoonishly exploitative. Juul should be fined for this predatory marketing.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by titzer on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @08:04PM (#23026081)
They should face jail time.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by Apocryphon on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @08:08PM (#23026110)
Even better. Prosecute 'em.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by goldcd on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @08:13PM (#23026141)
Vaping is far safer than smoking - and there are countless studies and piles of evidence that prove this.

As evidence - https://www.gov.uk/government/news/e-cigarettes-around-95-le...

Now, I'm not saying it's safe. I'm not saying Juul didn't market unethically - just "vaping is better than smoking"

And if you can accept this overwhelmingly clear evidence - the cynic in you might ponder why there's an outrage over vaping, whilst cigarettes are still happily sold/taxed/lobbied.

Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by gpm on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @08:33PM (#23026261)
Nothing you said in any way replies to the person you responded to. You are arguing against a straw man.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by bradgessler on Thursday April 30, 2020 @01:39AM (#23027770)
Anecdotally my 3 year old saw a picture of a Juul in an ad and thought it was a juice box.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by eurticket on Thursday April 30, 2020 @12:26AM (#23027442)
The addiction to nicotine is nothing to scoff at, but they were taking a page out of the big tobacco brands' play book. The same people that go after Juul and disregard regular tobacco brands is something, seeing how they are just doing what big tobacco has always done. There are a lot of people angry over those kids being targeted by Juul, but fail to see big tobacco next door, causing as much, if not more damage due to the nature of their product. Both should fail, but I would rather have an ecosystem of Ecigs(for adults) vs the waste and carnage that big tobacco has done for decades.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by musicale on Thursday April 30, 2020 @03:58AM (#23028550)
> they were taking a page out of the big tobacco brands' play book

Indeed. Note Altria's large investment in Juul.

However, much of Juul's innovation was figuring out how to evade tobacco laws and regulations such as bans on advertising and flavored tobacco products (e.g. by claiming to not be a tobacco product) and how to escape much of the stigma associated with tobacco (e.g. by making something that looked more like an Apple product and less like a cigarette.)

Evading legislation and industry regulation is a powerful business strategy while it lasts - consider Airbnb (avoided hotel tax), Uber/Lyft (avoided taxi medallion limits), Paypal (avoided bank regulation) and cable companies (avoided telecom regulation while providing phone service.)

Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by catalogia on Thursday April 30, 2020 @11:25AM (#23031883)
Juul is big tobacco.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by nickysielicki on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @06:17PM (#23025140)
I'd say it's more akin to, "He flipped the switch to divert the train from running over 3 people, although the other track still had it running over one person."
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by munk-a on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @06:18PM (#23025153)
As an alternative - vaping flipped the switch to divert the train from three to a single person - Juul flipped the switch later down the line to make sure it still hit three people anyways.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by nickysielicki on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @06:24PM (#23025226)
I don't follow -- how did they cause more harm to existing smokers? Are you saying that a Juul is more dangerous (or even equally as dangerous) as smoking -- or that there's evidence that nicotine in and of itself is harmful? I don't think either has evidence to suggest it's true.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by munk-a on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @06:44PM (#23025442)
Oh sorry - they continued the trend of lowered harm to existing smokers, but they also developed a lot of new customers.

I work in a company with a lot of coops and just in the past three years a lot of the folks we've hired on have a nicotine addiction - there are more people in their twenties that vape or smoke than people in their thirties or forties.

Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by catalogia on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @06:23PM (#23025214)
No, it's not really akin to that. This isn't a trolley experiment with only two tracks; they could have chosen to not market their product to children.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by nickysielicki on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @06:27PM (#23025269)
They targeted them at young adults -- it turns out that kids in high school typically emulate college kids. Who knew? Go to any college bar and you'll see kids -- naive children -- smoking outside. A lot of those kids use Juuls instead now.

If targeting that demographic inherently means that highschoolers will look at them and think they're cool, does that mean nobody should ever target that demographic? Harm reduction only applies to the 30+ crowd?

edit: I also don't think that it's really fair to say that they advertised towards children. The worst they did was push some colorful and fruity flavors. I guess only children like sweet things, and once you turn 18 you can no longer like mangoes?

Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by gamblor956 on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @06:36PM (#23025371)
No, Juul openly and deliberately advertised to children. It used to run ad campaigns featuring high-school age models vaping, and as recently as last year paid hundreds of high-school age "influencers" to peddle their products.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by btown on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @06:38PM (#23025386)
Article re: the above: https://www.businessinsider.com/juul-congress-e-cigs-target-... . There's nothing accidental about this.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by nickysielicki on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @06:44PM (#23025441)
Just to be clear -- when you say high-school age, you really mean 18 year olds, right? And coincidentally, that's also college aged, right?

What's the argument here? That they should have casted 40 year olds for their marketing campaign? Or that they should have casted someone in their 20s instead of an 18 year old? The former is ridiculous and the latter doesn't make a difference. Natalia Dyer is 25 years old and plays an 18 year old in Stranger Things.

Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by munk-a on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @06:49PM (#23025486)
Just to clarify - regardless of whether they cast someone 18 or 17 - they were intent on casting young adults in advertising - this wasn't an effort on their part to make sure 40 year olds are aware of a way to safely quite smoking, it was a deliberate effort to hook new consumers since... even within the range stretching up to 20-23, those potential customers will be conversions from non-smokers in all likelihood.
Re:Juul is reportedly laying off 800 to 950 employees by catalogia on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @06:29PM (#23025297)
It shouldn't be legal to market tobacco products at all. Juul knowingly and deliberately marketing to kids is further proof of that, as if any more were needed.

> They targeted them at young adults

This is literally the same bullshit the same industry was spewing when they were advertising their cigarettes with cartoon characters (e.g. the cartoon camel.)