News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by Loughla on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:40AM (#22946042)
This might not add that much to the conversation, but the only thing I can think to say here is;

Of course.

The large institutions are more savvy, have staff they can devote to finding this money, and have more connections to the banks.

The small businesses who actually need this money are run by the owner, and may have an accountant, but certainly don't have someone who can jump through the arbitrary hoops put in place by banks.

Also,

>More than 300,000 customers [. . .] applied for loans through the Paycheck Protection Program[. . .]. About 18,000 were funded, for a 6% success rate.

Are you fucking kidding with this? I feel actually insulted by this number.

And finally:

>The bank is among four lenders now facing accusations in a lawsuit that they prioritized the biggest loans in order to earn higher fees.

Of course. I am upset at myself for hoping anyone in this process would act like a decent human being. I don't know what to do with the anger I'm feeling. Any thoughts on where this energy should go?

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by k3oni on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:55AM (#22946171)
Came here to say this but you put it better. It's laughable that with all the changes that went in and voting on that bill they left the loophole open for big players to get access to this funding which was directed at small businesses/mom-and-pops shops. But business and shitty politics as usual.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by jlmorton on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:11AM (#22946376)
To be clear, this was not a loophole, it was a carve out. They specifically and intentionally excepted restaurants and hotels from the affiliation rule. It wasn't a drafting error, it was a clear and purposeful choice.

Personally, I don't have any huge problem with that, I think it makes sense to protect workers at both Ruth's Chris Steak House and a local family-run steak shop, and we should fund the program at the levels necessary to do that.

But I keep hearing the word loophole, including from Congress members. It is not that. This was by design, and it wasn't buried in some dense text. It was an unambiguous exemption in a two page rule. [1]

[1] It may not be perfectly clear to the average reader, but it certainly was clear for the rulemakers at Treasury.

"Waiver. The affiliation rules described above are waived for (1) any business concern with not more than 500 employees that, as of the date on which the loan is disbursed, is assigned a North American Industry Classification System code beginning with 72;"

Businesses with an industry classification code beginning with 72 include all restaurants and hotels.

https://www.sba.gov/document/support--affiliation-rules-payc...

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by crispyambulance on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:21PM (#22947241)
A loophole is a loophole whether it's expressed in obfuscated language or not.

There's a reason why the administration fired Glenn Fine on 4/7 who was the inspector that was supposed to oversee the 2T rescue plan. The administration and their cronies are doing a classical "shock doctrine" move to even further concentrate wealth while the opportunity is hot.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by jlmorton on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:41PM (#22947457)
I get your point, but loophole has a specific meaning that implies taking advantage of an ambiguity, unexpected complexity, or oversight in drafting to reach an unintended result. This was not unintentional, and I think that's important to say.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by JeremyNT on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:36PM (#22949921)
The difference between "loophole" and "carveout" here is basically intent.

Occam's razor suggests that, of course, members of a corrupt and self-interested Federal government would intend for their allies at megacorps to have a safe landing, and they would prioritize their wellbeing over others. They look after the people who pay their bills, of course.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by _curious_ on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:37PM (#22947413)
"The administration and their cronies are doing a classical "shock doctrine" move to even further concentrate wealth while the opportunity is hot." Agreed; buckle up folks if there's another four years to come :/
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by abnry on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:22PM (#22947255)
What most people don't understand about hotels, chain restaurants, or any business that runs on the franchise model is that the majority of such outlets are run by small businesses.

McDonalds isn't a burger and fries company, it is a real estate company. This is because they buy the properties each restaurant is located on and rent them out to small business owners who front the capital and run the operation (with stipulations). You may think there are flaws in this setup (which you could argue, though the exchange is a tested business model and logistics network in exchange for franchise fees) but the point is that small business owners are HEAVILY involved in these chain businesses.

It's the same with something like Dunkin Donuts. Here in MA, the profits from the coffee you buy at one location will go into the pockets of one small business owner while down the street it will go into another.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by jlmorton on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:45PM (#22947511)
Note that the rule separately exempts franchise models.

This is a bit different than that. This exempts restaurants and hotels that are all owned by a single entity, as long as the individual restaurant, or hotel is a subsidiary with fewer than 500 employees.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by abnry on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:05PM (#22947749)
Thank you for that information, I didn't know that.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by dd36 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:39AM (#22946712)
I think it’s because many (most?) people would prefer Ruth’s Chris failing over their local mom and pop. I think I’m in that boat and I like Ruth’s Chris, except the one in SF - was not impressed.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by crispyambulance on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:26PM (#22947304)
The thing about large restaurant chains is that they can easily borrow money, their scale is such that their banks will lend them money regardless of the pandemic (even if that's simply because they've previously borrowed).

Ruth's Chris isn't in nearly as much danger of going out of business as, say, a 1000 or so single-location restaurants that didn't get the time of day from JP Morgan when they called.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by dd36 on Thursday April 23, 2020 @02:13PM (#22959039)
Right. I agree.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by arkanciscan on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:15PM (#22947158)
I can put a stick of butter on a New York Strip at home for less than $100. Who needs Ruth's Chris.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by tedunangst on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:19PM (#22947217)
Who needs any restaurant?
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by RHSeeger on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:13PM (#22949688)
There's a lot of things we don't _need_ that we still enjoy. In fact, the vast majority of things fall into that category.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by _curious_ on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:38PM (#22947427)
Fair point...certainly seems to be more supply than demand even before CV19
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by js2 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:04PM (#22947027)
It was reported at the time before the bill was signed:

> Many of these special-interest provisions would be impossible for a casual reader of the legislation to identify. For example, on Page 15 of the bill, there is a section with the title “Business Concerns With More Than 1 Physical Location.” It says this change in federal law will apply to companies that fit “a North American Industry Classification System code beginning with 72” — a reference that turns out to mean the hotel and restaurant industry.

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/25/us/politics/virus-finepri...

Edit: This NYT article is the only one I've found in a cursory search that mentions it.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by IG_Semmelweiss on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:01PM (#22946993)
You are correct in your assertion. However your conclusion is wrong.

First, the waiver got in due to major lobbying by corporations with cash.

Second, it is not correct to state that is is appropriate for larger employers to take PPP. Here is why: although at first glance it would make sense to support workers via PPP, the sad reality is that these workers have already been laid off. As such, PPP will turn into a loan. A cheap loan at that, which is basically a cheaper source of capital funds that any public co has.

Public co.s can tap the capital market or existing banking relationships to survive.

Small biz cannot tap capital markets and banks are not extending credit at this time.

For larger orgs, cheap PPP subsidized loans are literally taking precedence over life and death funds for small biz.

So institutional investors, PEs, and banks are being bailed out, while mom and pops and their staff are getting destroyed.

Laeger orgs already laid off staff. Mom and pops were hoping for PPP.... to keep staff.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by Exmoor on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:11AM (#22946382)
Not really shocking, actually. The total turnaround time on the bailout bill was, what, a week and a half? Writing laws is complicated. I doubt anyone would be shocked if a large company cobbled together a hugely fairly complicated piece of software in two weeks and it turned out to have some major bugs. Writing a law like this is a bit like that, except with the additional downside that you can't really do any testing before release and you have people being paid to leverage the program for their own interests.

I actually heard and interesting interview [0] with one of the people in charge of the 2008 bailouts. He said the lessons learned were essentially don't worry about being too aggressive and don't worry about spending time trying to engineer a law that will target exactly who you feel like you should target. The most important thing is speed.

[0]: https://www.npr.org/transcripts/818583204

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by Leherenn on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:17PM (#22947183)
In line with your comment, I would say the biggest issue here is not that some companies that probably shouldn't have received the funds did. It's that a lot that should have didn't.

Of course though, given limited resources the 2 are correlated.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by salawat on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:47PM (#22948209)
I actually think you need to flip that around a bit.

Instead of >the biggest issue here is not that some companies that probably shouldn't have received the funds did. It's that a lot that should have didn't. Try >the biggest issue here is that some companies that probably shouldn't have attempted to receive the funds did; causing a lot that should have to not.

There was a clear prioritization screw up in this whole boondoggle.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by goatherders on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:12AM (#22946384)
I think it's laughable that the American public (of which I am a part) expected anything but this result. OF COURSE the little guy was going to get screwed. OF COURSE politicians were going to overlook loopholes that would allow the money to go to more established businesses. OF COURSE the machinations of the whole thing were going to be a campfire thrown into a dumpster fire packed in bonfire.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by Eridrus on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:05AM (#22946310)
Honestly, this was foreseen by everybody writing commentary. All the coverage of the paycheck protection program mentioned that the loan terms were extremely generous, and the money was not enough to cover everyone who was eligible, so it was going to run out really quickly.

The only answers here are political: to hold legislators to account for passing laws knowing they have not provided adequate funding and basically running a government-sponsored lottery.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by elliekelly on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:15PM (#22947856)
What the program needed was for applicants to demonstrate they had exhausted other lines of credit available or at least had been turned down for a loan since their state implemented business closures. The same way unemployment checks are contingent on making some effort to find gainful employment these forgivable “loans” should only be given to those who (1) truly need assistance and (2) have made a good-faith effort not to need assistance.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by BFatts on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:32AM (#22946638)
I heard estimates it was near $2T to fund it properly.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by zapita on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:44AM (#22946077)
> Any thoughts on where this energy should go?

Voting, and making sure everyone you know votes too.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by 317070 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:56AM (#22946197)
I mean, if there ever was a point where you take a step back and ask yourself "will voting actually solve this" this surely must be it? How on earth would voting actually solve something like this?

I'm not advocating for "not voting", I'm advocating for not letting yourself getting paralyzed by the idea that you are represented already anyway. You are only represented in the most superficial of ways. Start acting instead. Make JP Morgan feel your anger. Make people see your anger to JP Morgan.

You don't have to keep taking the hits. Acting helps psychologically and emotionally and on the best of days even might change things.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by michaelt on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:08PM (#22947067)
> How on earth would voting actually solve something like this?

The solution is not voting directly, although voting is part of the solution.

The solution is to form and fund a political action body, equivalent to the NRA or MADD or NAACP; define its remit broadly enough to cover all important aspects of the problem but narrowly enough it can draw members from across the political spectrum and won't be impossible to satisfy; recruit lots and lots of members; hire some competent lobbyists; issue candidate endorsements at every election and THEN vote.

Opposing corruption isn't only a Silicon Valley concern, but it's always struck me that the Silicon Valley community could have a lot of political power if there was a collective will to grasp it: SV regularly gambles tens of millions of dollars on uncertain returns, and the median SV worker has much more disposable income than the median NRA member.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by test1235 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:09AM (#22946351)
What are you suggesting, specifically?
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:16AM (#22946432)
I'd assume not supporting JPMC as a customer (as well as the businesses that use JPMC for commercial and investment banking services), perhaps protests next. Are we in an era when JPMC senior leadership would be doxxed online? I would be surprised if we weren't.

Lots of actions available besides the political process where you can still remain firmly on the right side of the law but cause discomfort to the other party. Don't break the law.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by 317070 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:33PM (#22947379)
Possible actions:

- If you had a JP Morgan account. Cancel it.

- Evaluate if they did something illegal, organise a group and go to court over it.

- If you live close to a JP Morgan office, go there and do something. Try to not attract police, as they have more important things to do, but as a rule, the people that work there should have an unusual day. Something as simple as distributing leaflets can for example be really effective to get the office productivity down, especially when maintained.

- Push politicians (maybe on a local level) to apply pressure where they can.

Overall: Don't be nice and agreeable. Be MOAR: mad, organised, angry and relentless.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by munk-a on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:43PM (#22947488)
Additionally, Jamie Dimon is on the short list for a Biden cabinet position[1] - reach out to his campaign and express that given the action he's undertaken he is absolutely unsuitable to advocate for the American people.

1. https://www.axios.com/joe-biden-cabinet-vice-president-picks...

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by zapita on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:40AM (#22946716)
> How on earth would voting actually solve something like this?

By removing from power the corrupt officials who colluded with JPM and other large corporations to steal stimulus money from small businesses?

JPM benefited from corruption of the political process. Corruption is enabled by minority rule. Minority rule is enabled by citizen apathy, like when people start saying that “voting isn’t acting!”.

By voting en masse, we as citizens get to 1) hold corrupt officials accountable, and 2) strengthen the democratic process by making it more representative, and therefore less vulnerable to corruption in the future.

As a side note: in my experience, people who say things like “voting is not acting, you need to do more!” are not reliable voters, and not reliable activists either. On the other hand, the most proactive voters tend to already know what else they can do. Electoral activism leads to broader activism.

TLDR: start by taking voting seriously.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by mumblemumble on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:16PM (#22947168)
> By removing from power the corrupt officials who colluded with JPM and other large corporations to steal stimulus money from small businesses?

Bluntly, I think that this is a polyannaish idea. The best pop culture representation of how US politics works is the Simpsons one where Kang and Kodos ran for President. The choice presented to the American public is rarely a choice between a corrupt politician and a non-corrupt one. It's much more typically typically down to deciding which corrupt, power-hungry individual spews the platitudes, half-truths and lies that you think sound the nicest.

Yes, we should still vote. But voting is not a panacea. The real province of democracy is grassroots organizing. It's probably never enough, but the US Constitution and 200 years of supreme court decisions around it have (tacitly, if not explicitly) made it so that that's the only piece of real political leverage available to those of us who don't have enough money to purchase actual political influence.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by zimpenfish on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:45PM (#22952376)
> is rarely a choice between a corrupt politician and a non-corrupt one

2008? 2012? Can't say that I've heard (m)any corruption allegations against Obama.

2016? I mean, I don't think a single charge of corruption or malfeasance ever turned out to be true for Hillary Clinton, has it?

Unless you mean "corrupt" in the sense of "non-pure" and, yeah, 99.9$ people who have enough money to be politicians are distinctly "non-pure". Now if you want to get the money out of politics, it'll need consistent Democrat gains at every level down to local council for the next 20 years to move SCOTUS left and undo all the dark money idiocies of the Roberts' court.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by 317070 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:59AM (#22946960)
> As a side note: in my experience, people who say things like “voting is not acting, you need to do more!” are not reliable voters, and not reliable activists either.

Well, sorry if I take the above personally, but here is another datapoint. I almost literally said the above in the post you quoted. I have voted in every election I legally could do so. I have run as a candidate in a number of elections. I have even organised groups to running for elections. I did broader activism and have organised a number of activist lawsuits. After a run in with the police I had to tune things down a bit for my family.

> Electoral activism leads to broader activism.

It does both, really. It is a rung on the ladder, a lot of activists start there. But it can also have the effect of soaking up a lot energy from existing activists, with very little real consequences. There is a balance. Political activism, civil activism and judicial activism also have a space and can have a better trade-off between energy invested and concrete consequences.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by rblatz on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:51AM (#22946861)
If you don’t like chocolate ice cream, and you are given the choice between two different flavors of chocolate ice cream, picking the other chocolate flavor isn’t a solution.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by Bud on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:43PM (#22947497)
Ignoring the obvious and glaring differences between our two political parties isn't constructive or illuminating.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by RHSeeger on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:25PM (#22949795)
Neither is ignoring the similarities (corruption, greed, etc).
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by thefounder on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:16AM (#22946437)
Is JP Morgan to blame that the guy you voted for gave it some money to spend on its biggest customers? You fail to see that JP Morgan is just the middle man.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by ardy42 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:27AM (#22946560)
> Is JP Morgan to blame that the guy you voted for gave it some money to spend on its biggest customers? You fail to see that JP Morgan is just the middle man.

Yeah. We blame people and organizations all the time for things that they were legally permitted to do but were selfish, short-sighted, or stupid.

Frankly, JP Morgan should try to be more like Shake Shack (not that Shake Shack was perfect, but at least they recognized and corrected their error: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/20/business/shake-shack-retu...)

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by ken on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:13AM (#22946404)
Which ballot is for JP Morgan loan officers?

Or do you mean voting in my non-battleground state for US president (D for the past 30 years), or perhaps senator (D for the past 20 years)? What effect, exactly, are we hoping for?

‘Voting for financial policy change‘ is like ‘participating in a moment of silence for those we’ve lost to the pandemic‘. The act is something a reasonable person should do because they are a member of society but it is not a solution to that particular problem.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by zapita on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:46AM (#22946798)
Are you certain that none of your mayor, governor, senators, representatives, state senate, state representatives, local democratic council members etc. have accepted JPM’s money? Perhaps you can research that point, and act accordingly. In “all blue” seats you can do this in primary elections.

You can also donate your time and money to battleground campaigns elsewhere in the US if you are a citizen.

There are also plenty of ways to get more people to vote, including in battleground states.

If you care, there are plenty of things you can do.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by jdironman on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:49AM (#22946117)
Voting doesn't do sh.. if the system is inherently broken.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by donarb on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:21AM (#22946492)
The system is broken because people don't vote. There are plenty of votes out there to override the powerful, but people who give up and say it's hopeless are part of the problem.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by erentz on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:59AM (#22946969)
There are two parties and they both represent the interests of the large corporations that fund them. The media are all large corporations that benefit from this system, and get funding from those same large corporations in ad revenue. The over 45 demographic only watches that media and so only hears what that media wants them to hear so are extremely low information voters. The PACs and committees of the respective parties are insanely powerful and run by people who are mostly grifters there to get their paycheck. They don’t care about policy. And if you step out of line too far against them they’ll throw millions against you in a primary to get rid of you.

The system is broken because at the moment in most districts you just can’t compete against who has the money.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by ralston3 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:57PM (#22947636)
+1 here
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by alpha_squared on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:05PM (#22947039)
While you're not wrong, there are plenty of inactive voters, I sincerely doubt they'd vote in any way that isn't already highly consistent with how votes are already allotted. Say there are 40% of inactive voters (the number is much higher in the US) and you get them all to vote somehow. I'm willing to bet those votes don't dramatically shift election outcomes in any significant way (beyond ~1%). Sure, that'd help in close races, but not much else.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by hi_im_miles on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:39PM (#22948115)
I don't buy this. Even if everyone voted, you'd still end up with policies that continue to advantage whichever voting blocs have the largest influence. The system is broken because it's a zero-sum game; privileging those who are represented by the system at the expense of those who aren't is a feature of democracy, not a bug.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by HorizonXP on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:50AM (#22946138)
It also doesn't help those businesses today. Voting won't happen in time to effect the emergency measures needed today.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by spaceprison on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @08:33PM (#22951664)
At some point I feel like we moved from 'deregulation and open markets' to a federal plutocrat enshrinment and oligarch protection program.

This behavior will not change because of a single election for a handful of seats 6 months away.

There was talk of a constitutional convention back in 2016 and I think it's time to think about how regular folks can recapture the direction of the nation.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by _curious_ on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:43PM (#22947495)
I think we're past that point...don't get me wrong, it can help and is part of the answer but very clear it is not the solution. It's naive in this day and age to rely on such an archaic method and expect permanent or fundamental change.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:57AM (#22946205)
Who do we vote for? The only standout here is Rep Thomas Massie who tried to force a recorded vote by requiring people to return to the capital. He was dragged by both sides and the president. Google his name and look how the media treated him.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by hcknwscommenter on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:12AM (#22946390)
Massie's stunt was an obvious and dangerous troll. You want all of Congress to come down with COVID? What nonsense is that. Massie was rightfully pilloried. THe obvious answer is to vote for the party that actually believes in sound government. The one that is not constantly dismantling important institutions. I have a lot of issues with the Democratic party positions on a number of matters, but they would not have been so entirely inept at every step of the way as team trump and his corrupt cronies. I mean, what the heck is Mnuchin even doing? Kudlow? THese are the people in the executive branch who should be working day and night to craft the regulations as Congress passes the law. The law states the rule, the regulations state how those rules will be implemented. That is how it is supposed to work. This administration is completely incapable of anything requiring competence. These crooks need to get voted out. They are literally killing us and destroying lives and careers.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by pythonaut_16 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:29AM (#22946584)
These bailout bills have been passed with broad bipartisan support, of which you will never see who voted for or against the bill because it was only a voice vote.

So how is voting for either party going to help a problem that both parties equally passed?

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by ardy42 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:43AM (#22946756)
> These bailout bills have been passed with broad bipartisan support...

> So how is voting for either party going to help a problem that both parties equally passed?

I think that's misunderstanding politics. Broad bipartisan support doesn't mean both parties were happy with each and every provision, it means that they found the overall compromise acceptable enough to vote for (given the circumstances).

For instance: IIRC, the Democrats actually wanted to add a permanent, general paid sick-leave benefit to one of these relief bills, but after Republican objections they compromised and settled for a temporary COVID-specific benefit to achieve "broad bipartisan support" for the overall bill. That doesn't mean they changed their position, and if more people had voted for Democrats in the last election, the outcome would have been different.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:22PM (#22947257)
> it means that they found the overall compromise acceptable enough to vote for (given the circumstances).

For every $1 going to a good cause, our politicians add $2 of pork in order to find a “compromise”

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by ardy42 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:37PM (#22947418)
> For every $1 going to a good cause, our politicians add $2 of pork in order to find a “compromise”

That's pretty obviously false unless you consider only 0.17% to 0.6% of federal government spending to be "going to a good cause." [1] [2]

[1] https://www.factcheck.org/2007/12/pork-barrel-spending/: "In 2005, CAGW identified 13,997 projects costing $27.3 billion that met its definition of pork spending; as in 2006, that was about 1.1 percent of total spending."

[2] https://www.cagw.org/reporting/pig-book: "The cost of earmarks in FY 2019 is $15.3 billion..." https://www.thebalance.com/fy-2019-federal-budget-summary-of...: "The budget office estimates the federal government will spend $4.536 trillion in FY 2019." That works out to 0.337% of the federal budget.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by will4274 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:11PM (#22947114)
I think that's misunderstanding politics. The Democrats actually wanted to talk about adding a permanent, general laid sick leave benefit, but blame Republicans for it being unfeasible. This result gives the Democrats the best of both worlds - they earn more votes in November but don't actually have to figure out how to pay for such policies.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by ardy42 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:27PM (#22947318)
I disagree. While what you say is technically true, but I'm not so cynical to think the Democrats would have backed off on a permanent paid sick leave benefit in this situation if they'd been in a more powerful position. I think it's a policy they actually want, and the pandemic makes the need clear enough to neutralize most conservative-inspired unease with it in the minds of centrists and swing voters.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by will4274 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:50PM (#22947562)
The proof is that they only advocate these things when they can't pass them. When the Democrats control Congress, it suddenly isn't a priority again.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by hcknwscommenter on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @09:58PM (#22952144)
The Dems haven't had a veto proof majority in House and Senate since the the 111th (2009 to 2011) and before that the 95th ( 1977 to 1979). I'm not going to go into the 95th too much because it was a very long time ago. Our country is very different. Obama spent basically all his political capital getting ObamaCare Dodd-Frank and CFPB passed. All of which were MASSIVE steps to dramatically increase access to health care and for the first time in decades bend the cost curve, dramatically reign in the banks, and give consumers actual protection from predatory big business. So, I don't really understand what you are talking about.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by erentz on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:03PM (#22947019)
I don’t know why you’re downvoted. I am a solid social democratic left person. But whatever his motivations, the fact is Massie was the only one that wanted to force a record of the vote. Good on him.

For those that claim it was dangerous, take that up with Nancy Pelosi the speaker who has refused calls to allow remote voting and video conferences so congress can work. She has refused this because she doesn’t want committees to do anything and she doesn’t want votes recorded. It makes a mockery of any suggestions of oversight. Your beef really is with her not Massie.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by jjmorrison on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:15PM (#22947854)
> I am upset at myself for hoping anyone in this process would act like a decent human being.

I hear you that you were hoping these big institutions would do what was best for people and the country in a time like this and they didn't deliver on that.

If helpful, this is how I thought of it. If the fees are higher on bigger loans, and the company's goal is to make money, this was the right decision for them. These banks are as successful as they are because they are the best at optimizing for the goals the system we've created has set. Maybe in a special case like this, they could've chosen to go against this incentive. But that would probably be worse in the long term. The real problem at hand is that the incentives we've set aren't the ones that we want anymore. We know it needs to be fixed, but it's really hard because our economy is this tightly coupled web. No one really knows what will happen if we start changing incentives. So we've decided not to change much yet. In a way, if banks had gone against their incentives in this moment of acute need, it really would've been a lie. A red herring that might make us delay changing the incentives even longer.

I guess the way I'm holding this is without righteousness. There's no single individuals in these banks that are the evil ones to blame. We've just created a system of incentives that ensures whoever is making certain decisions will keep making the ones that are made. It doesn't matter who, they'll always be made. It's like darwinism. So let's really spend time thinking about what change we want to make that would reward people for making the choices we want to see.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by ralston3 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:00AM (#22946260)
I agree with your general sentiment. But at some point you have to start looking at this type of thing as a feature, not a bug. I read all of this terrible news and I think "Wow, things seem to be going as planned for the small few that have been given (i.e., are ordained with) the ability to plan things"
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by Zelphyr on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:05AM (#22946312)
Explain to me how our government failing the people at a massive scale is a feature, not a bug.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by ralston3 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:48AM (#22946823)
Devil's advocate (again, I agree with you but just for the sake of hearing you out) -- What makes you think the govt is suppose to support the people at massive scale? Last time I checked most (or at least the great majority of those that dominate and survive) organized governments were put together for the purposes of serving a few elite.

;)

again, I agree with you

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by ForHackernews on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:16AM (#22946433)
Since when are small business owners "the people"? As of 2012, only 21.5% of small businesses even employed anyone; 73.5% of them were sole proprietorships.[0] Most Americans don't work for these companies.

I'm a little bit playing devil's advocate, but why is it a given that "small business owners" are a special class that the government should take extra pains bailing out?

[0] https://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/FAQ_Sept_2012.pdf

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by cultus on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:48AM (#22946814)
It's a feature for the people whom the government serves.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by xenospn on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:11PM (#22947823)
This is by design. The entire program was built and designed to benefit them, and I would not be surprised if it turned out that they were instrumental in writing the legislation and were given details ahead of time, so they could get a leg up on the "competition".
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by clairity on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:05AM (#22946317)
move to a small bank/credit union and tell everyone you know to do the same. BofA, jpmorgan chase, wells fargo, goldman, etc. are plutocratic rent-seekers at best.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by dustingetz on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:40PM (#22947448)
"Sufficiently Powerful Optimization Of Any Known Target Destroys All Value"

https://thezvi.wordpress.com/2019/12/31/does-big-business-ha...

Once recognized as emergent phenomenon we can stop getting emotional about it and learn to build more resilient systems that scale to the next level

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by akira2501 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:28PM (#22948023)
> The large institutions are more savvy, have staff they can devote to finding this money, and have more connections to the banks.

Except, when they aren't. Wells Fargo got completely eclipsed by a much smaller regional bank. Per the LA Times:

"Small businesses that rushed in vain to tap $349 billion in emergency U.S. loans to survive the coronavirus crisis are facing a harsh reality: Some of the nation’s top banks lagged behind relatively tiny rivals in handling applications.

As banking giants tried to automate the process, hundreds of employees at Texas lender Cullen/Frost Bankers Inc. volunteered to fill out forms manually, working late into the night in homes to set up $3 billion in loans. That contrasts with Wells Fargo & Co., which arranged only about $120 million by the time the program was depleted this week, according to people briefed on its progress."

From: https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2020-04-18/small-busi...

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by Loughla on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:35PM (#22948079)
I meant large businesses, not large banks. Large businesses are more apt to have folks dedicated to working through that kind of red-tape.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by sharadov on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:19AM (#22946469)
Planet Money has an excellent podcast on this https://www.npr.org/2020/04/10/832149266/episode-990-the-big...
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by malandrew on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:00PM (#22946980)
> jump through the arbitrary hoops put in place by banks.

To be fair, in most industries, arbitrary hoops are the result of government regulation. Yes, they might have been implemented by staff at the banks, but oftentimes at the behest of regulators.

In every business I've worked on, every single friction point I've seen us add has been due to regulations, often in patchwork form since they would differ from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. The product managers then are tasked with trying to mitigate the added friction.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by seph-reed on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:57AM (#22946938)
> Any thoughts on where this energy should go?

Join the pact:

I solemnly swear to stand by those who fight corruption. Should they go too far, I will not fail to recognize the heroism in their intent. As they are expunged from social consciousness, I will not forget. I will not let their sacrifices be completely in vain.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by jannes on Thursday April 23, 2020 @07:46AM (#22954942)
What do you mean with going "too far"? Sounds a bit scary.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by _curious_ on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:31PM (#22947357)
"Any thoughts on where this energy should go?"

Good question. What are you working on? Can you channel your negativity into a positive starting today - however small?

Bigger picture/longer term: can you re-calibrate your time, energy, and emotions into a 'be the change' model?

It can be done deliberately!

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by erentz on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:11PM (#22947107)
To all those who are simply saying voting is the answer, no that’s too simplistic and ignores the root of the problem. When the real difference between both parties is down to nothing and they’re both representing the monied and corporate interests, and when their immense power (funded by those interests) prevents alternatives you don’t really have anyone you can vote for who represents you, instead of the money. That’s the core of our issue in this country.

If you don’t understand this just look deeper at the bailout and how they voted for it when they could’ve changed it. It contains all kinds of loot for those interests and things that are easy to say no to. It was drafted by the Republicans who control the Senate and the Democrats who control the house could’ve stripped out the controversial parts like the Mnuchin slush fund and passed the uncontroversial parts like the paycheck protection program. They could’ve stripped out the $170 billion real estate tax break. Etc. and passed those in the house that they control. Then forced the Republicans to go on the record as refusing to pass paycheck protection unless they get a slush fund and billionaire tax break. That’s politics. But they didn’t because the powers in the Democrat party wanted those things too. Which is also why they didn’t do an on the record vote for it.

Another simple recent example is to look at the funding in the Democrat primary. Over $1 billion was spent in a panic against a social democrat who wants people to have health care. It’s an incredible figure. That wasn’t money from people that was money from the extremely wealthy and corporate interests.

The solutions are:

1. Abolish the senate. It’s wholly undemocratic. This is the hardest but in time it may be whittled down to more of a ceremonial function like in most other countries that have two chambers. Meanwhile implement instant run off voting for Senators.

2. Implement STV with multi member districts for the House so that we have more proportional representation and voting for other outsider candidates becomes feasible.

3. Increase the size of the house to 650 members to improve representation.

4. Solve the money in politics problem. Perhaps public financing of elections is right. Perhaps tighter controls of campaign financing are possible and other anti corruption measures to prevent lobbyists passing money to officials.

5. Instant run off for election of the president.

Two organizations that you may find good places to start are:

https://www.fairvote.org/

https://represent.us/

PS: I will also add you do need to let your feelings be known to your representative. Call your local representative to express it. More people should do this because it can have an impact and tells them that people are watching. (We all like to complain about our representatives but how many of us ever express our issues to them?)

And at some point later there may be more protests and demonstrations after what has happened. Be prepared to join them. Big change has always required this.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by danaris on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @02:04PM (#22948398)
And the way to get any and all of this done starts with...

Voting.

Can't vote for the people who will support these agendas? Vote for the ones who are closer to them. Vote for the ones who are closer to supporting wide enfranchisement, transparency, and access. Vote for the ones who are more interested in good governance than good kickbacks.

It will take time. It will probably take more time than either you or I have. But it's much, much more likely to actually result in achieving the goals you want than any strategy that says "We need to change how our government works! Don't bother to vote, though, that never changed anything!"

I mean, it's still not impossible that revolution will happen, I suppose. We haven't seen the end of the pandemic and whatever changes come out of it, so a lot more is still up in the air than usual. But it's extremely unlikely that the outcome of a revolution would look like what you're suggesting (mainly because while I can certainly see the logic behind all your proposals, aside from #4, they're not particularly widely talked about, and it takes time to spread ideas like that).

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by BFatts on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:30AM (#22946607)
I'm glad that there are better controls in the extension being made to provide for mom&pop shops over big companies.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by stevens32 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:25AM (#22946537)
The energy should probably go towards voting and trying to get others to vote as well
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by bsanr2 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @06:41PM (#22951004)
If you're the kind of person I think you are, then it's going to take all of the energy you can muster to convince yourself to vote for leftists/American democratic socialists in the next election. But I promise you, those are the only people who are going to help you in this situation. Not necessarily because they'll get what they want, or because their ideas are good, but because the threat of them coming into power will force banks et al. to reassess just how much they want to push it.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by mochomocha on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:20AM (#22946482)
> I don't know what to do with the anger I'm feeling. Any thoughts on where this energy should go?

I'd personally direct it towards the realization that the US in these difficult times looks more like a plutocracy than a healthy society (I live here). Socialism for the rich, "capitalism" for everyone else. Thinking of creative ways to convince your fellow citizens that this is nowhere near "the best" a society can offer to its constituents would be a good use of extra anger / energy.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by avgDev on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:08AM (#22946345)
What makes me really angry is the way Trump/Mnuchin talked about this issue. This is not about politics. When I listened to them talk about how they want the big businesses to give the money back I laughed out loud.

I mean have we not learned anything from the past? Does the administration NOT know that if there are no strict rules and oversight the bigger players have more resources to secure these loans. What a complete failure this program has been.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by MR4D on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:13AM (#22946402)
Congress wrote the rules on this behemoth of legislation, not the President.

Second, Shake Shack actually gave back their $10 million. Whether that was due to Trump or just bad press, I haven't looked to see, but it can't hurt.

Finally, if there is one thing that Trump is good at, it is using the podium as a bully pullpit. So yeah, I want him calling out companies to give money back. Even if he's only 1/2 successful, it's a lot better than not doing at all.

Am I frustrated like you? Sure, but legislation like this is always messy. Always.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by stevenbedrick on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:39AM (#22946707)
Congress wrote the bill, yes, but in this case did so in very close coordination with the Treasury, specifically the Secretary, who presumably had a lot of input on the specifics. So it’s definitely not just on Congress, here... plenty of blame to go around.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by MR4D on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:43AM (#22946766)
Agreed, but that’s only so the administration gets to check its list of stuff. Congress never delivers just that.

But I agree that there is plenty of blame.

I still think it was amazing that a relief act got passed so quickly that at least worked somewhat given the disparity in politics these days.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by dannyw on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:58AM (#22946219)
Do you think we can change these outcomes within our current for of capitalism? If not, maybe it's time to think about alternatives. Maybe you think things would be better in a more socialist world, or maybe you think worlds would be better in a world with less government intervention. Maybe something else.

The point though is: we need to advocate for a systems change.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by inerte on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:47AM (#22946806)
Run for elections or get a job in government.

There are 90 thousand government agencies. Local, city, county, state, etc... There are people out there who wants you to think they are all like the DMV or dysfunctional like the Senate and Congress.

Or worse, that the private sector somehow is where the challenge is. Maybe where you can get richer, but look at the department of agriculture or any other major government institution. $150b in budget and 100k employees. You find me a private company with similar size and a mission to feed 380M people.

The US needs a renaissance of the importance and virtue of public service. Our best minds are selling ads or consulting to shave off 0.001% of sub-prime derivatives in nanoseconds.

The government is us, and it’s huge and slow and careful and conservative and complex. But it needs us inside to change.

PS: I got inspired by words from Anand Giridharadas, so bonus points if you recognized any from his interviews.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by aclsid on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:41PM (#22947468)
This, the only way to prevent stuff like this from happening is to actually decouple the system from business interests. These kind of incidents repeat themselves over and over because it is based on a flawed logic where if you help businesses it will have a trickle down effect that ends up helping productive people. Same thing that happened when GM got a whole bunch of money and then they were using their private jets and collecting the nice CEO bonuses.

Governments by their very nature, and democratic ones especially, are supposed to be about charging taxes and redistributing that wealth for the better good. There is this big concept about having a powerful middle class which in turns make the extremely poor or the extremely rich a problem for the system to deal with.

The SBA could have helped all of those businesses directly through a coordinated effort with the IRS. Through the IRS they will know who is effectively a small business doing real work recently. How hard is it to just phone or email people asking for their bank account and fund the small business directly? If 6% of funding was all that was available at least a public raffle would have been a fairer system.

But even this stuff doesn't solve the question of what do you do with people that are out of a job, have a disability, mental issues or in general people that are unable to work like the elderly. Do you just let them die out of starvation out in the streets?

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by IAmEveryone on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:43PM (#22948152)
The idea was that banks had the experience, resources, and (most importantly) existing relationships with the recipients of these loans.

The loan conditions and availability is tied to the magnitude of loss the business is experiencing, Then, the business' ability to repay must also be appraised. That's the bread-and-butter business for banks. The IRS has been gutted over the last decades, and I doubt they have the manpower and information needed.

The major problem was that banks didn't really have any incentives to do this work: to make them care about accuracy, you want them to share in any potential losses. But the potential for losses obviously scares them away. You need some fee structure, and there might only be a narrow sweet spot where everyone's interests align.

The second possible improvement would seem to be tighter rules on the sort of business that should preferentially receive help. Small retail and service businesses would seem to be both popular and possibly most effective in terms of jobs/money. At the other end of the spectrum, a single-proprietor business owning and running a dozen apartment buildings with maybe one or two clerical workers should just go bust––the owner loses out but the buildings aren't going to go away,

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by hi_im_miles on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:08PM (#22947785)
> Governments by their very nature, and democratic ones especially, are supposed to be about charging taxes and redistributing that wealth for the better good.

The idea that democracies allocate resources efficiently (as in, "for the greater good") is one that I do not agree with. If a democratic majority conclude that harsh restrictions on immigration is beneficial for them (as they suppress the bargaining power over wages/benefits of those who immigrated illegally anyway), then maintaining these restrictions would be democracy as intended. However, you'd still end up with a significant underclass and thus an inefficient outcome.

I think even a cursory analysis of the state would lead you conclude that governments don't efficiently allocate resources in any meaningful sense, but they do allocate resources very well from those who are disadvantaged by its policy to those who are privileged by it, democratic or not.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by Supermancho on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:39PM (#22948113)
> However, you'd still end up with a significant underclass and thus an inefficient outcome.

Forget immigration, the USA had slavery, which too, went away due to the natural forces of the democracy (and liberty of man). I subscribe to the notion that The US Constitution always had eventual emancipation of the slaves in mind, during the drafting (typical political can kicking).

Over time, the choices that affect an underclass are more lenient, as the underclasses vote in their own interest. Short term, there can always be less efficient redistribution outcomes, which does not contradict the mid term effect.

The long term effect is that Democracies are subject to the tyranny of the majority or the pareto curve via coordinated propaganda toward an extensive uneducated/politically-ineffectual population. The USA is no different, but is still very young.

> I think even a cursory analysis of the state would lead you conclude that governments don't efficiently allocate resources in any meaningful sens

A cursory analysis shows that US Govt entitlements are the largest part of the US Budget year over year, since Social Security was introduced (at least). What you mean by efficient is a sticking point, but the majority of the budget goes to supporting the people. That seems to fit.

https://www.nationalpriorities.org/budget-basics/federal-bud...

https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-budget/policy-basics-w...

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by hi_im_miles on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @02:26PM (#22948637)
> Over time, the choices that affect an underclass are more lenient, as the underclasses vote in their own interest. Short term, there can always be less efficient redistribution outcomes, which does not contradict the mid term effect.

This argument doesn't check out for me. There is no guarantee the underclass wins any of the votes they make. The leniency we see towards the "lower classes" is a result of actual struggle by the underclass themselves, in ways typically unrelated to electoralism. If they're not a majority then there's no guarantee "voting in their self-interest" results in any favorable outcomes for them.

In order for democracy to work in this manner, every interest must be evenly distributed, and every overlapping group of interests must also be evenly distributed. This just isn't demonstrated in reality.

> via coordinated propaganda toward an extensive uneducated/politically-ineffectual population

I greatly dislike this idea that propaganda is what makes people vote the way they do. A much simpler explanation is that people have overlapping and contradictory interests that change over time, and their vote reflects this interest. A xenophobic voter may recognize immigration as a net gain for "the economy", but still be willing to take that hit to not live among those of other cultures.

> A cursory analysis shows that US Govt entitlements are the largest part of the US Budget year over year, since Social Security was introduced (at least). What you mean by efficient is a sticking point, but the majority of the budget goes to supporting the people. That seems to fit.

Even if the government spent 100% of its budget "supporting people", this support can still be:

1. Tilted towards more influential voting blocs. 2. Highly discriminatory and exclusionary (thinking of blocs like undocumented immigrants here). 3. Ultimately a raw deal, because we're still supporting a parasitic capitalist class and only getting back cents on the dollar compared to what they make off of us.

The situation you're describing here is one in which the government breaks our legs, then hands us crutches as compensation (which conveniently happen to be manufactured by the corporation lucky enough to get the contract).

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by kelvin0 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:57PM (#22947632)
Not to sound too cynic, but unless you have a powerful lobby on your side you won't get much done in government (US, CAN).

Moving higher up in the government to have any position of power means that you necessarily 'played' the game and most likely are restrained by the powerful interests who help you along the way.

Aside from any type of revolution or catastrophe (none I which I personally advocate), I can't see how you can make deep and lasting changes in the current system of entrenched interests.

This is my opinion from observation. I am not an expert.

Quite willing to read opposing views.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by Balgair on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:41PM (#22947466)
Well said, thank you!

It is much easier than you think. Uncontested races are about half of all elections [0]. Just near me a city election had only 19 people vote in it (covid played a big role though). In front of me right now there is a mail ballot for a local election with half the races being uncontested. Look up what your local elections are like here:

https://www.google.com/search?ei=DnGgXrfZJNa5tQbtpKy4DA&q=ru...

For instance in SF here is the page on how to run for office: https://sfethics.org/compliance/campaigns/candidates/running...

This takes about a lunch break to get through. Please consider it, democracy only works if you do.

[0] https://www.governing.com/topics/elections/gov-uncontested-l... Per the article, there is a LOT of variation here.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by Talanes on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:10PM (#22947816)
I agree with your general point, but San Francisco politics is the worst example. The local political scene is huge and all very connected together, and you have a billion options for every seat because people are trying to play the game and just run for any office. We had a dude running for Community College Board last cycle who had never attended any sort of public school.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by Balgair on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @02:59PM (#22948969)
True! I've seen first hand the 'issues' with something as small as the a single street's dev. board. Such 'struggle' is even more of a reason to get involved and not shy away. The problems are unlikely to get better without your involvement.

I mostly used SF as an example to whet the appetite, as many HNers seem to reside in the Bay Area.

I encourage anyone to look up their local races and consider throwing their hat into the ring.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by Talanes on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @03:48PM (#22949459)
I would also encourage anyone in the Bay outside of San Francisco to look into your town and county politics too. San Francisco draws a lot of attention in the areas scene, but the outlaying areas are often more suited to quick change. Those actually in the city, get familiar with your local supervisor. Some of them are very accessible, if yours isn't vote them out.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by LeifCarrotson on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:23PM (#22947270)
That's inspiring, for sure, and I know from personal experience that there are good people trying to do good in some local government agencies. Some of our best minds are doing good in small ways in the private sector, as well.

But there are systemic issues that you need to consider to make fulfilling, effective change. The problem is that without good regulation, might will make right and cheaters will prosper.

Elections are decided by a combination of appealing to people by telling them you'll do what they want, by advertising money to get the message out that you're the candidate who matches their interests, and by getting people who will vote for you into the polling place. Recent elections have proven that a candidate who's dishonest, who outspends on advertising, and who manipulates the voting population through voter suppression or gerrymandering can win over an idealistic candidate who's unwilling to engage in those tactics.

Those effects don't come into play so much at the local level, but without addressing that 'elephant in the room' a grassroots effort to change government from the bottom up will spend a lot of energy but hit a ceiling on its effectiveness.

I see no point in trying to grow grass when I know there's a lawnmower effect that will chop it down.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by phkahler on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:36PM (#22947402)
Without an elephant gun one really has to grow grass. Maybe figure out how to make fertilizer so it grows like a weed everywhere. Doing nothing is really the only option guaranteed to have no effect.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by thoway987987 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:48PM (#22948223)
Criticisms of bureaucracies are valid in that decisions by groups are difficult. The more consensus required the slower the process.

Isn't this just the human manifestation of the CAP theorem? Bureaucracy is a democratically managed database.

Anyways. All that to say, it seems valid to work on the system and within. You list local, city, county etc, and to the detriment of the system those are global write locks.

> The government is us, and it’s huge and slow and careful and conservative and complex. But it needs us inside to change.

I'd like you to consider the government is slow and huge not because of any bad will or conspiracy, but it exists that way due to technical limitations of human organization and achieving consensus.

Our government is Encyclopedia Britannica and we're expecting Wikipedia levels of quality and availability. The underlying organizational structure simply cannot support our expectations. I believe a more participatory form of democracy would be for us not to vote for editors, but a protocol that allows agreeable edits to be socially accepted and contentious edits to be ignored.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by chosenbreed37 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:04PM (#22947028)
> Or worse, that the private sector somehow is where the challenge is. Maybe where you can get richer, but look at the department of agriculture or any other major government institution. $150b in budget and 100k employees. You find me a private company with similar size and a mission to feed 380M people.

I'm off on a tangent here...but is it really the responsibility of the department of agriculture to feed 380 million people? What did people do before the creation of the department of agriculture? :-)

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by save_ferris on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:16PM (#22947164)
> but is it really the responsibility of the department of agriculture to feed 380 million people?

Given that the primary goal of farming is to feed people, why not? USDA was created by President Lincoln and was critical to ensuring food distribution throughout the Great Depression. Which agency is better equipped to handle this responsibility than Ag?

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by zentiggr on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:15PM (#22947159)
They listened to the tribal leaders, or their god-king, or their feudal lord, or whomever else held the reins in whichever time period. Until corporations came in and turned money and shareholders into the misguided controllers.

Maybe the Department of Agriculture is at least an attempt to help farmers in a less selfish way.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by joslin01 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:17PM (#22947884)
You can read their actual 2018-2022 strategy here: https://www.usda.gov/sites/default/files/documents/usda-stra...
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by bdavis__ on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:14PM (#22947140)
i don't think they feed that may people directly. they do manage via regulation and research, how the US farmers grow the food that 380 Million people consume. ag dept was created in 1862.
Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by w3mmpp on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:01PM (#22947687)
> The US needs a renaissance of the importance and virtue of public service.

Go check in countries with large public services and let me know what virtues they display...

Spoiler: you're gonna be disappointed.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by inerte on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @06:22PM (#22950845)
Who said anything about big government, or increasing its size? Specially it being more virtuous

If anything, I have advocated for a culture where the smartest people want to join the public service and help others instead of becoming a product manager for a button on a corner of a stupid app that doesn’t care at all what anyone of us do there as long as we interact with ads.

If you’re going to try to be a smart ass, I also have some spoilers for you, drop the attack mode and get better at text comprehension.

Re:JPMorgan’s small business loans instead went to its bigge... by w3mmpp on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:20PM (#22952250)
I'm gonna reference what you said again:

> The US needs a renaissance of the importance and virtue of public service.

"importance and virtue of public service".

Unless you consider there is such a thing as public service without government, and that your "virtue" here, used along "renaissance" and "importance" doesn't suggest it needs to be more virtuous, I'd argue it's you who needs to be better at explanation.

Now, on a more important note, if your vision of the private sector is reduced to people working on online ads, I suggest you look beyond the software industry and consider smart people working in very important industries, in research, energy, medicine, finance, millions of people making our lives possible in ways than no public servant will ever be able to even just dream about.

So if anything imo, we don't need more public servants, aren't there enough people telling us how to live our lives? If renaissance we need, is on the importance and virtue of a good day's work as a way to better ourselves and society.