Governments by their very nature, and democratic ones especially, are supposed to be about charging taxes and redistributing that wealth for the better good. There is this big concept about having a powerful middle class which in turns make the extremely poor or the extremely rich a problem for the system to deal with.
The SBA could have helped all of those businesses directly through a coordinated effort with the IRS. Through the IRS they will know who is effectively a small business doing real work recently. How hard is it to just phone or email people asking for their bank account and fund the small business directly? If 6% of funding was all that was available at least a public raffle would have been a fairer system.
But even this stuff doesn't solve the question of what do you do with people that are out of a job, have a disability, mental issues or in general people that are unable to work like the elderly. Do you just let them die out of starvation out in the streets?
The loan conditions and availability is tied to the magnitude of loss the business is experiencing, Then, the business' ability to repay must also be appraised. That's the bread-and-butter business for banks. The IRS has been gutted over the last decades, and I doubt they have the manpower and information needed.
The major problem was that banks didn't really have any incentives to do this work: to make them care about accuracy, you want them to share in any potential losses. But the potential for losses obviously scares them away. You need some fee structure, and there might only be a narrow sweet spot where everyone's interests align.
The second possible improvement would seem to be tighter rules on the sort of business that should preferentially receive help. Small retail and service businesses would seem to be both popular and possibly most effective in terms of jobs/money. At the other end of the spectrum, a single-proprietor business owning and running a dozen apartment buildings with maybe one or two clerical workers should just go bust––the owner loses out but the buildings aren't going to go away,
The idea that democracies allocate resources efficiently (as in, "for the greater good") is one that I do not agree with. If a democratic majority conclude that harsh restrictions on immigration is beneficial for them (as they suppress the bargaining power over wages/benefits of those who immigrated illegally anyway), then maintaining these restrictions would be democracy as intended. However, you'd still end up with a significant underclass and thus an inefficient outcome.
I think even a cursory analysis of the state would lead you conclude that governments don't efficiently allocate resources in any meaningful sense, but they do allocate resources very well from those who are disadvantaged by its policy to those who are privileged by it, democratic or not.
Forget immigration, the USA had slavery, which too, went away due to the natural forces of the democracy (and liberty of man). I subscribe to the notion that The US Constitution always had eventual emancipation of the slaves in mind, during the drafting (typical political can kicking).
Over time, the choices that affect an underclass are more lenient, as the underclasses vote in their own interest. Short term, there can always be less efficient redistribution outcomes, which does not contradict the mid term effect.
The long term effect is that Democracies are subject to the tyranny of the majority or the pareto curve via coordinated propaganda toward an extensive uneducated/politically-ineffectual population. The USA is no different, but is still very young.
> I think even a cursory analysis of the state would lead you conclude that governments don't efficiently allocate resources in any meaningful sens
A cursory analysis shows that US Govt entitlements are the largest part of the US Budget year over year, since Social Security was introduced (at least). What you mean by efficient is a sticking point, but the majority of the budget goes to supporting the people. That seems to fit.
https://www.nationalpriorities.org/budget-basics/federal-bud...
https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-budget/policy-basics-w...
This argument doesn't check out for me. There is no guarantee the underclass wins any of the votes they make. The leniency we see towards the "lower classes" is a result of actual struggle by the underclass themselves, in ways typically unrelated to electoralism. If they're not a majority then there's no guarantee "voting in their self-interest" results in any favorable outcomes for them.
In order for democracy to work in this manner, every interest must be evenly distributed, and every overlapping group of interests must also be evenly distributed. This just isn't demonstrated in reality.
> via coordinated propaganda toward an extensive uneducated/politically-ineffectual population
I greatly dislike this idea that propaganda is what makes people vote the way they do. A much simpler explanation is that people have overlapping and contradictory interests that change over time, and their vote reflects this interest. A xenophobic voter may recognize immigration as a net gain for "the economy", but still be willing to take that hit to not live among those of other cultures.
> A cursory analysis shows that US Govt entitlements are the largest part of the US Budget year over year, since Social Security was introduced (at least). What you mean by efficient is a sticking point, but the majority of the budget goes to supporting the people. That seems to fit.
Even if the government spent 100% of its budget "supporting people", this support can still be:
1. Tilted towards more influential voting blocs. 2. Highly discriminatory and exclusionary (thinking of blocs like undocumented immigrants here). 3. Ultimately a raw deal, because we're still supporting a parasitic capitalist class and only getting back cents on the dollar compared to what they make off of us.
The situation you're describing here is one in which the government breaks our legs, then hands us crutches as compensation (which conveniently happen to be manufactured by the corporation lucky enough to get the contract).
Moving higher up in the government to have any position of power means that you necessarily 'played' the game and most likely are restrained by the powerful interests who help you along the way.
Aside from any type of revolution or catastrophe (none I which I personally advocate), I can't see how you can make deep and lasting changes in the current system of entrenched interests.
This is my opinion from observation. I am not an expert.
Quite willing to read opposing views.
It is much easier than you think. Uncontested races are about half of all elections [0]. Just near me a city election had only 19 people vote in it (covid played a big role though). In front of me right now there is a mail ballot for a local election with half the races being uncontested. Look up what your local elections are like here:
https://www.google.com/search?ei=DnGgXrfZJNa5tQbtpKy4DA&q=ru...
For instance in SF here is the page on how to run for office: https://sfethics.org/compliance/campaigns/candidates/running...
This takes about a lunch break to get through. Please consider it, democracy only works if you do.
[0] https://www.governing.com/topics/elections/gov-uncontested-l... Per the article, there is a LOT of variation here.
I mostly used SF as an example to whet the appetite, as many HNers seem to reside in the Bay Area.
I encourage anyone to look up their local races and consider throwing their hat into the ring.
But there are systemic issues that you need to consider to make fulfilling, effective change. The problem is that without good regulation, might will make right and cheaters will prosper.
Elections are decided by a combination of appealing to people by telling them you'll do what they want, by advertising money to get the message out that you're the candidate who matches their interests, and by getting people who will vote for you into the polling place. Recent elections have proven that a candidate who's dishonest, who outspends on advertising, and who manipulates the voting population through voter suppression or gerrymandering can win over an idealistic candidate who's unwilling to engage in those tactics.
Those effects don't come into play so much at the local level, but without addressing that 'elephant in the room' a grassroots effort to change government from the bottom up will spend a lot of energy but hit a ceiling on its effectiveness.
I see no point in trying to grow grass when I know there's a lawnmower effect that will chop it down.
Isn't this just the human manifestation of the CAP theorem? Bureaucracy is a democratically managed database.
Anyways. All that to say, it seems valid to work on the system and within. You list local, city, county etc, and to the detriment of the system those are global write locks.
> The government is us, and it’s huge and slow and careful and conservative and complex. But it needs us inside to change.
I'd like you to consider the government is slow and huge not because of any bad will or conspiracy, but it exists that way due to technical limitations of human organization and achieving consensus.
Our government is Encyclopedia Britannica and we're expecting Wikipedia levels of quality and availability. The underlying organizational structure simply cannot support our expectations. I believe a more participatory form of democracy would be for us not to vote for editors, but a protocol that allows agreeable edits to be socially accepted and contentious edits to be ignored.
I'm off on a tangent here...but is it really the responsibility of the department of agriculture to feed 380 million people? What did people do before the creation of the department of agriculture? :-)
Given that the primary goal of farming is to feed people, why not? USDA was created by President Lincoln and was critical to ensuring food distribution throughout the Great Depression. Which agency is better equipped to handle this responsibility than Ag?
Maybe the Department of Agriculture is at least an attempt to help farmers in a less selfish way.
Go check in countries with large public services and let me know what virtues they display...
Spoiler: you're gonna be disappointed.
If anything, I have advocated for a culture where the smartest people want to join the public service and help others instead of becoming a product manager for a button on a corner of a stupid app that doesn’t care at all what anyone of us do there as long as we interact with ads.
If you’re going to try to be a smart ass, I also have some spoilers for you, drop the attack mode and get better at text comprehension.
> The US needs a renaissance of the importance and virtue of public service.
"importance and virtue of public service".
Unless you consider there is such a thing as public service without government, and that your "virtue" here, used along "renaissance" and "importance" doesn't suggest it needs to be more virtuous, I'd argue it's you who needs to be better at explanation.
Now, on a more important note, if your vision of the private sector is reduced to people working on online ads, I suggest you look beyond the software industry and consider smart people working in very important industries, in research, energy, medicine, finance, millions of people making our lives possible in ways than no public servant will ever be able to even just dream about.
So if anything imo, we don't need more public servants, aren't there enough people telling us how to live our lives? If renaissance we need, is on the importance and virtue of a good day's work as a way to better ourselves and society.
There are 90 thousand government agencies. Local, city, county, state, etc... There are people out there who wants you to think they are all like the DMV or dysfunctional like the Senate and Congress.
Or worse, that the private sector somehow is where the challenge is. Maybe where you can get richer, but look at the department of agriculture or any other major government institution. $150b in budget and 100k employees. You find me a private company with similar size and a mission to feed 380M people.
The US needs a renaissance of the importance and virtue of public service. Our best minds are selling ads or consulting to shave off 0.001% of sub-prime derivatives in nanoseconds.
The government is us, and it’s huge and slow and careful and conservative and complex. But it needs us inside to change.
PS: I got inspired by words from Anand Giridharadas, so bonus points if you recognized any from his interviews.