News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by Mengkudulangsat on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @03:44AM (#22943191)
Cut flower export sounds like climate travesty; they are not essential, they are fragile (requiring energy-intensive cold chain logistics and air-freight) and after all that effort... they have a shelf-life of a week.

If there is an industry that should be strictly localized, it's this one.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by floatrock on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:28PM (#22947327)
> [Image of Kenyan woman picking roses in a Kenyan greenhouse]

> The work is grueling, with long shifts in steamy greenhouses, and laborers earn as little as $70 a month, but it’s a steady paycheck in a country where those can be hard to come by.

By comparison, that monthly wage of $70 is less than a day of minimum wage in the US. That's why it's more efficient to make a global energy-intensive cold chain logistics and air-freight network.

(That and the price of carbon pollution isn't priced into the supply chain)

That's the scale of globalization.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by schemathings on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:15AM (#22946424)
The US saw it as a good alternative to the cocaine trade .. "To offer incentives for alternative crops, the US under the administration of President George HW Bush passed the Andean Trade Preference Act in 1991, which dropped duties on agricultural products like flowers for Colombia, Ecuador, Peru and Bolivia."

So there's that.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by easytiger on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:57AM (#22943556)
> they are not essential

Welcome to civilisation. We do things than aren't survival focused.

[dead]
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by easytiger on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @06:27AM (#22944094)
Are you quite serious?
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @09:04AM (#22945083)
Your comment here is far more uncivil and aggressive than the one you're replying to.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by Scapeghost on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:45AM (#22946088)
easytiger has multiple comments here attacking the same parent(s):

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=easytiger

You may need to enable your "showdead" option to see some of them. I'm not sure how I've said anything more uncivil and aggressive than calling people "incels", lingo that is more suited for Reddit and 4chan than HN.

I'm just baffled at how some people get so angry at someone for saying maybe we shouldn't be killing something.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by easytiger on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:59AM (#22946239)
That's not what they said and I was not aware I was replying to the same person, if indeed I was.

People going around and reductively deciding to morally posit that people who like flowers are morally repugnant should be assuredly told their opinion doesn't matter.

They called displaying cut flowers a

> bizarre and grotesque custom

And then went on to compare it with human slavery.

If you don't think that's ridiculous on a whole number of levels (some of which levels speak to the psychology of the person), you need to take a long hard look at yourself.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by verytrivial on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @08:09AM (#22944666)
I would phrase it as "mispriced" as has much of the consumption that has occured for the last couple of hundred years. Seems the atmosphere is starting to call in the line of credit.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by ihaveajob on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @08:29AM (#22944809)
They also propagate pests. The olive industry in Italy is being decimated and the flower trade is suspected to be at the root.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by anoraca on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @09:34AM (#22945351)
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by ihaveajob on Thursday April 23, 2020 @08:33AM (#22955233)
Thank you. This is quite worrisome to me personally, as my family lives on the south of Spain and a good deal of our livelihood is from olive farming. It feels like being tied to the railroad and watching a train barrel down toward you from the distance.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by op03 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:39AM (#22943466)
I don't agree about not essential. If we go there, sooner or later, someone will show up and say Music is not essential, and why can't everyone dress like Zuck etc.

But I do agree about local. I mean who doesn't want to walk by something like this everyday - https://scontent-yyz1-1.cdninstagram.com/v/t50.2886-16/93565...

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by Mengkudulangsat on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @05:57AM (#22943929)
I have no qualms about cut flowers per se.

In my country garlands for hindu ceremonies are big business. I guess that is as essential as it gets for cut flowers. However, these largely depend on local suppliers.

The exporting surely is not essential.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by lm28469 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @05:44AM (#22943832)
> someone will show up and say Music is not essential

Depends on your definition of essential, I'd argue 100% of the world population would survive just fine without music or flowers. Food is essential, water is essential, medicine is essential, shelter is essential. Some tulips imported for 2000km away aren't. I mean, do we really have to debate this ?

If we go there, sooner or later, someone will show up and say Ketchup is essential.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by gherkinnn on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @07:56AM (#22944592)
If you’re only concerned about the lowest layer of Maslov’s pyramid, then you might be right.

Few things are “essential”. But that’s hardly the point.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by londons_explore on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @08:10AM (#22944676)
Are all those people really essential, or could we perhaps do with fewer people too?
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:09AM (#22946359)
100% of the world population would survive just fine without music or flowers

No they wouldn't, they'd get depressed and eventually become either withdrawn or violent. I'm not arguing for a wasteful and environmentally destructive flower trade, but against your notion that mere maintenance of the biological organism is sufficient. Universals like music and flowers serve an important role in social cohesion.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by brain5ide on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @09:52AM (#22945521)
Can I decide what is essential to me and you decide what is essential to you? And then if there are not enough of me, maybe I have to pay more? And maybe if there are not enough of you, you pay more for those that provide those essentialities? Hm... This reminds me of something.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by adrianN on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:07AM (#22945682)
If only there wasn't such a thing as externalized costs...
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by elwell on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @07:57AM (#22944594)
The word "essential" by itself is ambiguous. GP didn't posit "Music is essential to survive."

Anyways, is love essential?

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by mns on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:31AM (#22945952)
Up until someone decides that food is also not essential for the majority of the population and we will just need to drink some sort of universal soy and lentil based smoothie. :)
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by kumarvvr on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @09:06AM (#22945098)
To be fair, even though it rings of a dystopian oppressive society, there might be a day where, due to impact of climate change, a lot of pleasures that we take for granted will be ultra regulated.

I just hope society gradually moves to a state where everything but the most essential of essential stuff is produced and consumed.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by sojournerc on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @09:49AM (#22945502)
I think the problem is who gets to determine what is essential. One man's essential activity is another man's superfluous activity.

Music is a great example. Sure we could do without it, but life is for the living. Experiences are not essential to the physical functions of life but without them life would quickly become depressing, at which point, what are we protecting?

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @03:50AM (#22943220)
The argument I regularly hear is that there would be more energy spent heating local greenhouses than flying the flowers.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by throwaway_pdp09 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:38AM (#22943457)
I am not an expert but I doubt it. Double poly tunnels are can keep in a decent amount of heat during the day, and at night most plants can take a decent dose of cold provided it's not frost. However I'm not an expert.

But is spending irreplaceable fossil fuel energy on what are basically short-lived ornaments rational? I'd say no.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by furyg3 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:03AM (#22943285)
It’s possible to run a greenhouse with green energy. It’s not possible to do that with jet airplanes.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by pampa on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:22AM (#22943363)
Or maybe we could reexamine the need for cut flowers out of season?
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by elwell on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @08:01AM (#22944616)
> not possible to do that with jet airplanes

How's about a jet airplane that runs on cut flower waste? taps head

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by smackay on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:49AM (#22943513)
It's likely the place where that energy is expended is not being taken into account. Injecting water vapour and combustion products from burning jet fuel high in the sky is probably a lot more harmful than just the amount of energy is being consumed.

The skies in summer here are criss-crossed with dispersed contrails. It might help a little with global warming by increasing the reflectance of the atmosphere but it's sure ugly.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by adrianN on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:08AM (#22945694)
If energy was sufficiently expensive, we would just build greenhouses like so: https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2015/12/reinventing-the-gree...
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by netsharc on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:37AM (#22946012)
It seems employing Western Europeans to plant and pick flowers in Western Europe would mean expensive flowers, and they've apparently calculated it's cheaper to let Kenyans plant, pick, ship the flowers to big Boeings, for pilots to burn fuel flying the Boeings to the Netherlands, and for the flowers to be distributed around W. Europe (and apparently USA) that way.

It' the same with people screaming why their country doesn't have their own PPE manufacturers; because in non-crisis times, the hospitals would buy from the lowest bidder, and those would be manufacturers with cheap developing country labor..

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by eythian on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:13AM (#22946400)
Well, I assume the article isn't covering the whole story (because otherwise it'd be a long story detracting from the point, so fair enough.) The Netherlands has a lot of greenhouses. I have no idea what the ratio of flowers to vegetables in them is though.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by kumarvvr on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @09:07AM (#22945109)
Would it not be possible to build efficient greenhouses and save costs on heating systems?

Surely solar power could help.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by vwcx on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:17PM (#22952240)
Source?
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by koheripbal on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @08:22AM (#22944755)
While I don't disagree, this applies to a massive portion of all consumer goods and speaks to commercialism, in general.

It is why the Fed specifically segregates "durable goods" in inflation, GDP, and price indexes.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by kumarvvr on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @09:03AM (#22945064)
Yup. Humans collectively are responsible for a lot of unnecessary greenhouse gases just because they want to have a pretty wedding or a party.

I can understand the argument about money, economy, livelihood, etc., but IMHO some things ought to be regulated to avoid situations where a bunch of roses carry a non trivial amount of carbon footprint.

Wouldn't it be possible to use locally grown flowers?

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by notechback on Thursday April 23, 2020 @02:13AM (#22953282)
Completely agree. At the same time this wouldn't be the focus of my ire, look at the risk impact of July and beef production - a nightmare and arguably also not essential as we have cheaper, more resource efficient and more nutritious options.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by aaron695 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @05:20AM (#22943665)
A carrot you eat and turn to literal shit.

Flowers like you say lasts a week for multiple people. Also unlike kitschy stuff you buy and just sits there forgotten, you appreciate them, you have to somewhat care for them, they add value to life.

To say they are "they are not essential" is saying life itself is not essential, just eat powder and sit in a room if this is the case.

I feel like what you are saying is you don't like flowers so no one else should.

And I really think it's callous for us to forget the "More than 150,000 people now toil on Kenyan flower farms, many of them women." These are the poorest of the poor, to take away what little they have is pretty thoughtless.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by TeMPOraL on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @05:51AM (#22943891)
> A carrot you eat and turn to literal shit.

It sustains their life and thus serves an important purpose.

> Also unlike kitschy stuff you buy and just sits there forgotten, you appreciate them, you have to somewhat care for them, they add value to life.

Kitschy stuff is another ecological disaster, separately from cut flowers. People who appreciate flowers generally buy potted ones and care for them; cut plants are meant as gifts or decorations, and they get thrown away immediately (think of all the decorative flowers on social events) or after they wither (ain't nobody has time to care for the gift roses in the vase, or even notice them).

> I feel like what you are saying is you don't like flowers so no one else should.

I think GP is saying something else. They're taking a systems-level view. Flowers are cool, but we've created a system in which huge amount of energy is used to manufacture and ship around what amounts to reified mating signals, that could be manufactured and shipped locally instead. Now it would be fine in the era of free energy and matter replicators, but we're still in the era of scarcity and looming climate change. So it's fair to ask questions about unnecessary waste in the system.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by strgcmc on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @09:18AM (#22945210)
Surely folks on HN understand that, if it was economically feasible to compete on this, then locally sourced flower start-ups would've already become a thing?

Yes shipping and storage seem wasteful, but there are economies of scale involved when centralizing production to areas with the right climate, with desirable soil qualities, with expertise in planting such flowers, etc.

To help local flower growers win out, we would need to increase the cost of shipping/storage/etc. (maybe because we think they are not properly pricing in externalities?). Then we're back in the realm of tariffs and protectionism, which is its own can of worms; personally, I think we can complicate our understanding of free trade, and reasonably choose to impose artificial costs/penalties when it comes to climate protection or environmental goals (as opposed to, propping up certain industries just because they're better at lobbying).

Consider that, it is cheaper/more-efficient for fisherman/crabmen in Alaska or the PNW to send their catch to China for processing (filleting, canning, etc.), before shipping it back to the US for retail. I always found that to be fascinating, that supply chains are such that, it's more economical to outsource the processing of seafood, than for the fisherman to dump their catch to a local processing facility that then sends it out for retail.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:28AM (#22946573)
Economic efficiency and waste are not the same thing, unless you really are pricing in all the externalities. Also, while the concept of comparative advantage is elegant and powerful, excess fealty to it creates monocultures, much as too much sugar brings on diabetes.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:42AM (#22946743)
And I really think it's callous for us to forget the "More than 150,000 people now toil on Kenyan flower farms, many of them women." These are the poorest of the poor, to take away what little they have is pretty thoughtless.

I'm willing to bet that given the choice many of them would rather not engage in such toil, and the reason they're poor is because wages are kept so low that they have little opportunity to save enough to make such choices.

Nobody buys flowers because they are trying to better the lives of agricultural laborers. I always find myself doubting the sincerity of such appeals, which only seem to arise in discussions of externalities. Many years ago I worked at an industrial floristry company for about a year, doing the manual work of handling the flowers as they came in from abroad and putting them in storage or preparing them for sale. I liked the work OK but I didn't get up every day thinking 'thank heavens so many people love the flowers we sell.' The pay wasn't that great and when I found a better job I took it.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by robocat on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @05:46AM (#22943848)
> they are not essential

If we only live for the essentials, what do we live for?

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by floatrock on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:20PM (#22947229)
If we continue to live beyond our means, what's the point? It's like rats fighting for scraps onboard a sinking ship... sure, I'll fight for the bigger tastier crumb, but the ship's still going down. If it's not us that will drown, it's the next generation.

Alternative framing: rather than thinking of it as "subsisting on the minimum essentials", how do you build a legacy that will continue to outlive you in perpetuity?

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by kumarvvr on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @09:09AM (#22945126)
That would be true if our carbon footprint is minimal, but that is not the case.

Until society self adjusts, to minimize the total carbon emissions per capita to a sustainable level, we might have to do with only essentials.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by sojournerc on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @09:54AM (#22945548)
Who determines what the essentials are?
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by adrianN on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:09AM (#22945703)
You price in the pollution and let the market decide.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by bostik on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:25AM (#22943379)
I don't even understand the whole cut flower thing. It's morbid.

You cultivate something that is living and beautiful. Then you kill it, and bring the corpse inside, to essentially observe the once-living thing's decay.

(And don't get me started on giving cut flowers as gifts. If your host is an animal lover, you don't pick up roadkill on your way over, either.)

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by kinkrtyavimoodh on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:32AM (#22943424)
Merely using words with shock value isn't going to help your case. Yes when you sneeze often in spring it's because of plant bukkake in your nose and when you eat saffron you are munching on plant dicks. What's your point?
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by bostik on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @07:27AM (#22944415)
I have learned that vivid imagery, when used sparingly, helps to drive the point through.

For the record: I have never liked cut flowers as a concept, and even find flower vase the second most useless household item that one can own. But as to your snark, I actually DO refer to the high-pollen times as plant-orgy season. Not all the time, but often enough.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by lifeisstillgood on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:37AM (#22943456)
Great, that saffron scented curry I was looking forward to after the lockdown just got scratched off my list.

:-)

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by lsb on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @05:00AM (#22943571)
I'm pretty sure that's a great new botanical OnlyFans
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by Razengan on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @05:00AM (#22943568)
Hiding the facts of something with sugar-coated words isn’t going to help your case. Yes most bizarre and grotesque customs continue as long as agree upon them without questioning their value. It was also perfectly fine to own people as property and throw virgins into volcanoes, once. What’s your point?
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by crispyporkbites on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @05:09AM (#22943602)
When has it ever been fine to throw virgins into volcanoes? And slavery has always been opposed by huge numbers of people, theses things have never been considered "fine" or comparable to having flowers in a vase.
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by Balero on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @08:01AM (#22944615)
Whilst I agree with your general point, some of what you said isn't quite right.

Human sacrifice has a long history. Though it was, as far as I'm aware, a rare and drastic thing to do. For example there were a few instances in classical Roman history when human slaves were sacrificed. This was done in very dire situations, think pandemic or important battle, and often in earlier Roman periods. It was also actually quite common in Aztec and Mayan, though in differing degrees. They didn't however use volcanoes

Also in these classical times human slavery was much more wide spread and accepted. It was a very different situation to modern and colonial slavery. Some examples of it being wide spread being helots in ancient Greece, and the slave economy of Rome. The influx of slaves in the gallic wars lead to the political upheaval that let Cesar come to power, with "cheap" labor taking work from Roman citizens.

To summarize, having flowers in a vase is completely normal, and likening it to slavery or human sacrifice is dumb. Also history is interesting!

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by Razengan on Friday April 24, 2020 @03:45AM (#22965615)
> having flowers in a vase is completely normal

Why?

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by easytiger on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @05:11AM (#22943615)
Are you genuinely calling flowers a

> bizarre and grotesque custom

And comparing it to slavery?

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:25AM (#22946533)
Flowers are nature's billboards to promote pollination. I let a lot of trees and plants run wild around my home, partly because I enjoy looking at bees. Plants flower and then let the flowers die as soon as they've served their purpose; and the competition between plants for space and sunlight is also aggressive. If you let nature take its course, you have to get used to seeing lots of death as different plants kill each other off and run into the limits of their environment. Also, a lot of the real action is happening underground, where most of the nutrients are - sunlight and CO2 are only part of the equation, and for some plants being trimmed back is no more of a big deal than getting a haircut.

I get your point, but it's also a reflection of your own psychological state. People mostly like flowers to bring some nature into their home; they could also cultivate houseplants, but that's a lot more work and if you try cultivating multiple plants together they are likely to either kill each other or attract bugs. The transience of flowers isn't inherently morbid, for the same reason you can be vegetarian but still wear woolen clothes.

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by staz on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:42AM (#22943476)
Re:The crash of the global flower trade by Scapeghost on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @06:26AM (#22944088)
> If your host is an animal lover, you don't pick up roadkill on your way over, either.

It all comes down to the "plants don't have feelings/aren't really alive" bias we have.

Some people will go to great contorted lengths to justify the destruction of something, using words like tradition, aesthetics or honor and justice (like for war) or just "the way it has always been", and if you try to call them out on it, they'll get angry at you for trying to stop them from destroying something (as seen in the other comments here) :)

Re:The crash of the global flower trade by thinkingemote on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @05:37AM (#22943791)
It's an attractive.view as it's easy to understand but ultimately simple view of the world which ignores a range of human experience. Similar to the case for not eating meat, or not going to war. Both of which are noble and good but are more complex deeper down.