News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by fasteddie31003 on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:20PM (#22871591)
I personally think we need a county-by-county approach. There is a high variation of the infection at local levels. All the news is currently about how bad New York is and it's true but we're not all New York. http://www.countycovid19.com/
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by ajross on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:25PM (#22871650)
It's true that regions are different, but I don't see how that translates. Can you be specific? How would a plan for Queens County, NY differ from one for Waukesha WI, except in trivial stuff like dates?

Some outbreaks are smaller, but you'll note that they all leveled off at roughly the same time and on the same schedule. That's because we locked down on "New York's schedule"[1]. If we didn't, these places which seem to have "handled" the outbreak would look like New York.

The plans should absolutely be regional in that the lockdown rules should be based on infection rate thresholds, etc... But to do that they all need exactly the same per-capita testing resources. It's the same plan.

[1] Really that's not true. We locked down on Seattle's schedule, because they moved first on most things. Seattle had by far the biggest early outbreak, but peaked earlier, peaked lower, and is now one of the better managed areas in the country. Cuomo gets all the attention but it's really Jay Inslee who saved us all.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by timr on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:42PM (#22871846)
Different regions have dramatically different population densities, and don't necessarily need shelter-in-place rules. In NYC, shelter-in-place is probably the only feasible way to reduce social interactions when case-count is exploding, but in Boise, where people mostly live in detached housing and drive cars and cases are measured in the hundreds, it might be sufficient to eliminate large gatherings and shut down restaurants. It's not just a matter of thresholds.

For all the various politicians are talking about "following the science", there's very little actual science backing up these measures. We're pretty much making it up as we go, and you would be hard-pressed to find "scientific" justifications for most of what we're currently doing.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by ajross on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:48PM (#22871903)
> don't necessarily need shelter-in-place rules

Is there a cite for that? Because that's not the way the data looks.

Everywhere was growing with roughly the same exponent before lockdown. The numbers were bigger in NY because it grew longer pre-detection, but there's no reason to believe that everywhere else was any different. Really this disease's growth constant looks shockingly consistent almost everywhere in the world.

> It's unclear to me why we're making these policies at a federal level.

We... aren't. Literally every existing lockdown regime is being enforced at the state level or lower. For the Boise example you mention, the relevant regulation is a stay in place order from Gov. Little in late March.

Edit to show the point better: Go here (easily the best visualization site, FWIW), scroll to the bottom where you can see a log chart of per-capita infection rates normalized to a single "start time" metric, and compare the Idaho chart with the New York one.

https://91-divoc.com/pages/covid-visualization/

They are almost exactly the same chart, modulo a vertical offset and a kink in NY data in the second week (which consensus says is the testing backlog finally catching up).

If Idaho's detached housing and automobile dependence was reducing its rate of infection spread, it should be visible in the slope of this line. And it clearly isn't.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by timr on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @06:59PM (#22872504)
"Everywhere was growing with roughly the same exponent before lockdown."

No, they weren't. You're just asserting that this is true. There's effectively no way to know what the doubling rate was in a place like Boise before the national lockdown, because the numbers were in the low single digits:

https://covid-19.direct/metro/Boise?tab=glance

But even ignoring that...the site you're linking to shows a wide range of slopes on the per-state graph. You just think they look the same, because the log Y-axis compresses dramatic differences in scale, particularly near the origin. New York, NJ, Michigan and Louisiana are well above the diagonal line, while states like Wyoming, Montana, Vermont, Maine etc. are all well below it.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by ajross on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:13PM (#22872597)
Idaho on 20 March was at 23 confirmed cases (above the "low single digits" metric you picked, but you can pick other points too and get the same result). On 31 March it hit 515.

That's a doubling period of less than three days. It was spreading every bit as fast as New York was. It looks like exactly the same chart with a different constant factor. Yet you insist that these identical results are somehow due to different underlying behavior? Why? Where's the research showing that?

Because the pretty obvious hypothesis is that the disease was spreading the same way because it's the same disease and doesn't care about whether you live in Boise.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:07PM (#22872565)
One of the things we urgently need to figure out is how to prevent bad data visualization from leading to bad conclusions. Statistical malpractice isn't just a meme phrase anymore.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by orangecat on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @11:36PM (#22874248)
Edit to show the point better: Go here (easily the best visualization site, FWIW), scroll to the bottom where you can see a log chart of per-capita infection rates normalized to a single "start time" metric, and compare the Idaho chart with the New York one.

Number of cases is largely a proxy for how many tests are being done (https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/coronavirus-case-counts...). Looking at deaths is more accurate, and that shows Idaho (and all other states) well below New York.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by ajross on Wednesday April 15, 2020 @08:42AM (#22877014)
But growing with the same exponent! The point was that Idaho doesn't need special mitigation rules, because unmitigated Idaho is somewhere around 2 weeks "behind" New York. Even here people seem not to get that point. The outbreaks are smaller outside the international cities because they were later, not because they're inherently better controlled.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by timr on Thursday April 16, 2020 @11:44AM (#22890561)
They are not growing with the same exponent. You keep repeating this, even though the evidence you cite clearly shows that it's not true.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by ajross on Thursday April 16, 2020 @01:17PM (#22891494)
I literally gave you numbers elsewhere in this thread. Argue there and cite your own, please. You seem to be the one arguing without evidence.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by timr on Friday April 17, 2020 @01:20PM (#22900961)
I used the graph you gave me. You aren't reading it correctly.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:23PM (#22872659)
All right, here's a different example. Loving County, TX, is roughly 50 or 100 people. It has roughly the area of Los Angeles County. "Don't leave your house" is a bit more ridiculous when the next humans are 20 miles away. Sure, maybe don't go visit them... but stay at home? Why?
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by ajross on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @08:28PM (#22873095)
OK. That seems like sort of a strawman, but fine. I'm OK with very rural areas having a "Stay home, OR at least 20 miles from the nearest people" rule. Is Loving Texas really chafing under the existing shelter order? I mean, surely that's the way it's being enforced currently, no?
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @10:02PM (#22873697)
Out there? I doubt it's being enforced at all. How would you?
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @06:49PM (#22872428)
Multiple states don't have shelter-in-place rules, but still remain very different from NY. (They still have some rules, of course; I agree it seems silly to claim that it was safe to do nothing.)
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by munk-a on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:00PM (#22872515)
Those states are in for a surprise like Florida was - they may get lucky and just have a very low rate of spread into their state - but if they have a lot of community transmission the disease will spread very quickly and the lack of a reasonable response will be obviously stupid in retrospect once again.

Shelter-in-place is a good general rule - we can roll it back when we've got infrastructure to vaccinate people.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:04PM (#22872542)
Florida isn't doing great, but it's not doing as bad as New York either.

I'm not sure what you're referring to about vaccination. As California's roadmap lays out, we'll need to roll back shelter-in-place long before vaccines are available and find less costly ways to mitigate the virus.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by bcrosby95 on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:36PM (#22871768)
Jay Inslee and the Seattle Flu Study. Without the flu study going against medical guidelines (along with the guidance of the CDC to adhere to those guidelines) and testing some of their samples for COVID-19 (which isn't what they were collected for), Washington's timeline would have been pushed much further back.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by 333c on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:40PM (#22871816)
Don't forget Newsom, who issued the first state-wide shelter in place order. That has been invaluable in keeping California safe(r).
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by djrogers on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @06:23PM (#22872222)
> except in trivial stuff like dates?

Dates are not trivial when people's very livelihoods are at stake.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by ajross on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @06:28PM (#22872257)
You know what I meant. You can write the same plan for different regions with parameters. There's no inherent regional interest that requires every county government in the US staff its own disease control department.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by joe_the_user on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:42PM (#22871843)
I live in Nevada County, which apparently has a very low infection rate (34 cases, none in the last week) but if you open this county, what prevents folks from other countries from flooding in and bringing more infection? This county was previous a tourist mecca so it would be especially inviting. But any county that was open would be an appealing destination for the closed counties.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by thaumaturgy on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:48PM (#22871906)
Nevada County is a particularly good example here of one of the failings of a county-by-county approach because Sierra Nevada Memorial Hospital there isn't really equipped to deal with a large number of critical care patients, and neither are many other rural counties. It would take far fewer cases to incapacitate Nevada County's health care infrastructure than Placer County or others to the west.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by swsieber on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @11:10PM (#22874094)
> because Sierra Nevada Memorial Hospital there isn't really equipped to deal with a large number of critical care patients

That makes me think its sterling example of why we need a county-by-county. Don't just base it on infection levels though, as you pointed out. Include hospital support, ppe levels, interconnectedness, etc.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by jshevek on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:17PM (#22872623)
I see this as an argument for a county-by-county approach in which the specific circumstances of the county are taken into account.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by joe_the_user on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @11:34PM (#22874237)
Why?

I don't see why any "deemed safe" county wouldn't be overrun by visitors from unsafe counties, making the county unsafe again. Maybe you could find a county so remote it wouldn't matter but whether those extremely isolated places are opened up now or not probably doesn't matter either way. I doubt they're much effected by this situation regardless.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by jshevek on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @11:55PM (#22874341)
I don't understand your argument. Are you thinking that there will be two kinds kinds of counties at each point in time, those "deemed safe" and those "deemed unsafe"? If so, that would explain my confusion. I imagine that each county would be advised to implement one of a small number of strategies, in consideration of the peculiarities of that county, its economy, its normal levels of travel, its immediate neighbors, and the effect they are likely to have on their state (and even the nation) as a whole.

Are you thinking of the people who would be willing to drive far distances simply to, for example, go out to eat? I would assume that this analysis would be included. Close proximity to a large population that's on lockdown is, in my opinion, a reason to keep the lockdown in a county, even if that county doesn't yet have many cases. But the next county over might or might not open up. Sure, people near the border from the second county will just go into that third county, and that's fine - as long as there aren't too many people coming from the first county.

Politicians and pundits simplify and say stupid things, when taken literally, but when it really comes down to it no one is really suggesting that the state of affairs within a county be the sole determining factor for the degree and form of economic activity which will be permitted. We have to look at the larger region. But once we look at the larger region, it will probably make perfect sense to completely lift the shutdown in some counties (esp. in Alaska, Montana, Wyoming, etc) while keeping a strong shutdown in other places.

Edit: I assume that we will also be looking at individual industries independently. Can the companies in a certain industry in a certain region reliably commit to following strong anti-COVID practices? If so, we might let them open up, while other industries are not allowed to. We don't have the time to create certification bodies or licensing departments to handle these specifics, so politicians will just have to make the best decisions they can.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by rconti on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @08:35PM (#22873135)
When I turn on the news at night, I don't see the information for the county I intend to visit once it's deemed safe(er) to travel. I see the information for where I live.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by gnicholas on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @10:12PM (#22873743)
If you’re going to travel to another county, you could check the website for that county to see their rules.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by jshevek on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @10:53PM (#22873990)
Yes, we already have to do this at the state level, at the moment. It's in the best interest of a region's government (whether county or state) to make sure the rest of the country is aware of their rules, so they don't have people showing up with incompatible expectations.

I don't imagine there will a increased multiplicity of confusing rulesets beyond what we have now, either. Many counties will simply adhere to some standard recommendation from their state, and the rest will copy one of a small number of recommended levels along a spectrum of openness.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by xienze on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:33PM (#22872741)
Agree completely, it seems like everyone wants to treat every municipality as NYC, just scaled down. I’d like to see county-by-county assessment, with added common sense restrictions like elderly and sick people self-quarantining, which I think at this point people are familiar and somewhat comfortable with.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by dickjocke on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:33PM (#22871743)
In the live address they said that most implementations will be left to the county and local govts. The state isn't giving any specific guidance on masks, for example, leaving that to specific locales.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by hilbertseries on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @06:19PM (#22872183)
LA county now requires anyone entering an essential business to wear a mask.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by ravenstine on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @08:38PM (#22873160)
Pretty sure that's just the City of Los Angeles, not the county. I haven't been to any grocery stores outside DTLA that required masks. (though 7-11 did)
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by petsormeat on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @06:47PM (#22872409)
As is Sonoma County, today.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by clairity on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @08:02PM (#22872939)
this is probably a little overly cautious relative to the actual reduction in risk (you'd have to be especially unlucky to get infected just from regular breathing in a grocery store), but not terribly unreasonable, particularly for those with co-morbidities.

but i routinely see people with masks and gloves on while walking outside. not shopping, or going to shop, just walking. it's so odd, and frankly, wasteful.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by impendia on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @08:22PM (#22873060)
> frankly, wasteful.

I think I disagree.

It seems that face masks are quite effective in reducing the spread of illness. For example, look at the numbers in South Korea, Japan, etc. (where mask-wearing is common) compared to ours. Masks don't need to do 100% of the job -- rather, we would hope that in combination with moderate social distancing, better hygiene, improved testing, etc. we could reduce the rate of transmission. If each infected person spreads the illness to an average of only 0.9 others, then it won't do much more damage.

Now, from an economic angle, the US government just passed a $2 trillion stimulus package, which works out to about $6,000 per American. There are calls to spend much more money. Suppose we spend 5% of this on face masks, so $300 per American.

Currently, face masks can be bought at $20 for a box of 50 on Amazon. That gets 750 face masks to every American, at a cost that is cheap relative to the other costs of Covid-19.

And this is ignoring economies of scale. If the government decided to distribute free face masks in every school, every restaurant, in every theater, etc., then it could produce them at much cheaper than 40 cents each.

All in all, it seems like a potentially good investment.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by clairity on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @09:42PM (#22873597)
99% of the reduction in transmission comes from physical distancing alone while inside of closed spaces with strangers. hygiene is likely negligible outside of a very few high interaction zones inside those enclosed spaces. testing only improves targeting who to distance (isolate).

it's a virus that rides on tiny masses of water to hopefully jump into the nasopharyngeal cavity of the next host. if it doesn't make it to those warm and juicy brachiae, it exponentially decays to the elements in hours. relative to air, those virus-laden water masses are heavy. most fall at your feet. some fly a few feet. very few make it many feet.

then imagine your chances of making a full-court basket (94 feet, 9.4" diameter ball in 18" hoop) and then divide those odds by the several orders of magnitude smaller that viruses are relative to us.

wearing masks (or gloves) outside makes no sense. you might as well walk around with your own lightning rod too then.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by tlb on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @11:22PM (#22874157)
Substantial research contradicts your claims. See https://www.masks4all.co for links.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by clairity on Wednesday April 15, 2020 @12:19AM (#22874459)
that site serves to reduce anxiety rather than transmission risk. none of the graphs and pull quotes, presumably the strongest arguments they could find, address the added risk reduction of masks above other prevention measures like distancing, and especially not concerning outdoor, non-group settings for the general public.

emergency personnel, medical professionals, and essential business workers should wear masks because they are at elevated, face-to-face risk.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by impendia on Wednesday April 15, 2020 @09:10AM (#22877253)
> 99% of the reduction in transmission comes from physical distancing alone while inside of closed spaces with strangers.

This is an extremely strong statement. Although it might be plausibly true, my impression is that the transmission of the disease isn't well enough understood to make such assertions with confidence.

Can you cite a reference for your claim?

I think it is agreed that physical distancing alone while inside of closed spaces with strangers is an extremely good idea. Wearing masks is, potentially, also an extremely good idea.

Shouldn't we adopt any and all measures that have the potential (not certainty; potential is enough) to substantially cut down on Covid-19 transmission, and whose economic and other costs are comparatively modest? Even if we later determine that only one of these measures was really necessary, I doubt that we'll regret our efforts.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by perl4ever on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @09:43PM (#22873606)
"For example, look at the numbers in South Korea, Japan, etc. (where mask-wearing is common) compared to ours."

There seems to be a huge difference in the trajectory of cases in Japan, vs South Korea, so I don't know what you think you're saying, if you group them together. In South Korea, cases went up and then apparently flattened out almost completely. In Japan, the graph I saw has been lower than in other places but is, almost uniquely, not flattening so far, even in the way that Italy or the US has.

So it makes no sense to me to combine them and say "look, that is the example". If one is the example, the other most likely isn't.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by Talanes on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @08:38PM (#22873158)
Can't defend the gloves though.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by tlb on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @11:17PM (#22874132)
I wear masks in public, even though I have no comorbidities, because of all the people I might subsequently spread it to if I got it. Remember that asymptomatic transmission for several days is common.

Putting on a mask takes a few seconds, so compared to all the suffering it might prevent, even at 0.01% probability, it's well worth it.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by clairity on Wednesday April 15, 2020 @12:10AM (#22874409)
no one is arguing that you disregard others, especially those who have comorbidities, only that a mask adds negligible risk reduction outside, above and beyond the natural physical distancing of strolling down the sidewalk.

risks differ with context.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by tlb on Wednesday April 15, 2020 @12:06PM (#22879387)
Do you have evidence that risk reduction outside is very small? I haven't seen any, and I think it would be nearly impossible to collect such evidence.

A plausible rule of thumb seems to be: if you could smell someone's cigarette smoke, you could inhale their viruses. I certainly smell smoke from smokers I pass on the street.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by clairity on Wednesday April 15, 2020 @02:48PM (#22881482)
there are no studies done, because, as you note, it would be difficult and costly, and it's a simpler (and more easily followable) message to tell people to wear masks all the time.

but here's some additional intuition:

1. it's true that virus particles are roughly the same size as smoke particles, but infected people exhale virus "pucks" that are agglomerations of multiple viruses and water, leading them to fall while smoke floats (giving us the 3-6 foot rule, per prior coronavirus studies).

2. a single virus particle in the air without water could float around but is overwhelmingly likely to fall apart quickly. the air doesn't provide the countervailing forces to keep it together, and the bombardment of energies from all around also pull it apart.

3. the fact that a homemade mask allows smoke right through but filters out some portion of the virus pucks (as per your prior link) is evidence in itself of the differential affinities of smoke and virus pucks.

but let's face it, most people wearing masks (outside) do it because they think it's protecting them from the filthy other people. however, if you're sick, all you're doing is concentrating the virus pucks in one place right in front of a face we'll each touch 30 times an hour. no lay person consistently observes the contamination rules that hospital personnel do, especially when infection rates are <0.1% and failure to do so has no obvious downsides. masks could in fact be more dangerous because of a false sense of security.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by toddh on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:26PM (#22871664)
Problem is the travel between counties, at least in CA. There's a lot of travel that could cause reinfection.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by bb2018 on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:34PM (#22871758)
I'm not too sure reinfection is as important mathematically as some think when you realize the goal will be to operate below a threshold of cases, not eliminate covid entirely.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by jandrese on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:42PM (#22871833)
The problem is that Covid-19 spreads extremely fast in unprepared populations. It only takes one unaware person to infect hundreds. Check out what happened in South Korea where they had the problem contained until one woman decided to go to church.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @06:38PM (#22872351)
The woman went to a very large church, with over 1,000 people in the room. Such large gatherings won't be allowed for a while.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by macintux on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @09:56PM (#22873672)
A few religious leaders seem intent on making those large gatherings happen, regardless of prevailing medical and legal advice.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by jandrese on Wednesday April 15, 2020 @02:40PM (#22881375)
Churches are usually exempt from the shelter in place rules. Thankfully most are still observing the rules, but it's not because the government is forcing them to.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by joe_the_user on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:55PM (#22871984)
Reinfection is only unimportant if you don't have a large number of people who are going act to reinfect. If you do have a large number of infections, then of course refection is going to matter. And we do have a large number of cases in the most affected counties.

Basically, just like you don't want to overwhelm hospitals, you don't want to overwhelm your contact tracing infrastructure

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by toddh on Wednesday April 15, 2020 @12:19AM (#22874458)
It just takes one super spreader to reinfect a population, especially without herd immunity or vaccinations.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by nradov on Wednesday April 15, 2020 @01:02AM (#22874690)
Which is exactly why we need to aim for herd immunity as fast as possible, but not too fast to overwhelm the healthcare system.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by adelHBN on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:55PM (#22871993)
Thanks for sharing the link. But how do you enforce stay-at-home policies or any rigorous public health policies, in populated counties that border each other, such as San Francisco and San Mateo counties, or LA and Orang counties.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by jshevek on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:21PM (#22872647)
I think you are asking specifically about the enforcement issues that derive from neighboring populated counties with different policies? Neighboring counties can and should coordinate to address this, possibly choosing to enforce the same policies even if they have different infection rates, as they did for the initial lockdown in the bay area. This doesn't prevent us from using a county-by-county approach in other areas.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @06:53PM (#22872454)
The county health officials would presumably coordinate with each other, as San Francisco and San Mateo are already doing.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by adelHBN on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @10:33PM (#22873872)
But to your point, San Mateo is not closing off 280 and 101 to stop S.F. traffic. And the Governor has issued a stay-at-home policy to the San Francisco Bay Area, not just one or two cities. So that's why I think area-wide policies work better than county-by-county policies. We could have San Diego area ban and policy, L.A./OC/San Bernardino, Santa Barbara/Ventura/San Louis Obispo... you get the picture.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by cmrx64 on Wednesday April 15, 2020 @06:09AM (#22876116)
It was not the _Governor_ who issued those orders in the bay area, it was the local county health officers acting under the authority granted them by the state legislature. This wasn’t some top-down fiat. I am grateful that my local officials have decided to act in solidarity in this instance, but it wasn’t a structurally certain outcome.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @11:32PM (#22874226)
Yeah, that makes sense to me. (And presumably the Bay Area is going to keep moving in lockstep as it has been.) It'd just be silly if Tuolumne County had to stay sheltering in place because of conditions in the LA area or something.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by runawaybottle on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:41PM (#22871827)
In all sincerity, New York wasn’t Wuhan either. If I were any any other state, I’d absolutely limit travel from NY and screen them.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by joe_the_user on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:48PM (#22871896)
Really? New York current has quite a few times the casualties of all of China (10834 vs 3341) with a small population than Wuhan and the casualties haven't stopped there. New York by itself has one of the high casualty levels in the world by any measure.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by djrogers on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @06:22PM (#22872212)
Any comparison using the officially reported death toll in Wuhan at face value is of no value whatsoever.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by munk-a on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @06:57PM (#22872485)
It has value - it should just be treated very skeptically.

And, honestly, the US numbers are highly inaccurate as well due to a simply lack of an ability to test (instead of a lack of will to publish the real numbers).

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by mlindner on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:15PM (#22872615)
The casualty numbers are quite accurate. The US records every cause of death.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by gizmo686 on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:53PM (#22872875)
The US cannot record data it doesn't have. Covid is only the cause of death if the deceased had Covid; and we cannot know that unless we can test them. In aggragate, we can sidestep this issue by looking at excess death, but that is non-trivial (particuarly because the behavioural changes mean that we would expect other causes of death to differ in unknown ways). At the end of this, I would expect to get fairly accurate estimates for how many died to Covid, but while we are in the middle of it, the numbers are very murky.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by csdreamer7 on Wednesday April 15, 2020 @12:12AM (#22874420)
Indeed, if you look at CDC's cause of death numbers you will see they only list till 2017.

https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/leading-causes-of-death.htm

https://www.cdc.gov/healthequity/lcod/

At least that is what I could find. I was curious to see if I could find some month to month chart on all deaths for March, February, and January. I could not find one.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by raphlinus on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:49PM (#22872852)
https://twitter.com/MarkLevineNYC/status/1250170016504430595

@MarkLevineNYC BREAKING: NYC publishes, for first time, data on fatalities that includes "probable" cases (those without a confirmed test result).

It has pushed the death toll in NYC up by 57%.

Was 6,589 before this adjustment. Now stands at 10,367. This is a painful but necessary accounting.

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by macintux on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @09:59PM (#22873685)
That is categorically false. They’re not testing every dead person for the virus, and most people die from one of its side effects, like pneumonia.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by dsl on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @06:40PM (#22872366)
Have you been on site in Wuhan? Collected any data? Where can we get a copy?
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:20PM (#22872641)
No, we don't have solid data on Wuhan. Neither does anyone else outside of China (or so we strongly suspect). The question isn't whether someone has better data than you. The point is that you don't have believable data for Wuhan.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by webninja on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @06:20PM (#22872192)
New York started their business closures and stay at home orders 2 weeks after Seattle and California closed down. That’s why they ended up with so many more cases and deaths than the former two.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by vkou on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @09:06PM (#22873363)
New York on lockdown is also busier then Seattle on a regular day.

Have you seen any of the photos of the packed subway trains, a week and a half into the lockdown? Seattle doesn't see that sort of thing even in rush hour.

Likewise, if you live in a highrise in New York, you're going to be taking the elevator to go get groceries. Usually with other people...

Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by lhopki01 on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @05:50PM (#22871922)
Higher reported casualty rate.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by mlindner on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @07:15PM (#22872612)
The key thing is "reported" casualties. It's well known that actual casualties in China were MUCH higher than actually reported.
Re:California’s Roadmap to Modify the Stay-at-Home Order [pdf] by runawaybottle on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @09:04PM (#22873350)
I suppose I worded it wrong. What I meant was, you might not be New York now, but you could be.

New York didn’t think they’d top Wuhan.