News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by enneff on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @06:23PM (#22817845)
MS Office isn't "banned" from employees' computers at Google. If you need it (and some do) you must request it specifically, because it costs Google a nontrivial amount of money for every user. Same thing with any piece of commercial software: for example, I have Adobe Photoshop on my Google laptop, and I had to request it because it costs Google a few hundred bucks, and most people don't need it at all.

Before Google Docs existed, many employees used MS Office, and when Docs was being rolled out Googlers were incentivized to switch to Docs by being offered kudos, swag, etc (ie, the carrot, not the stick).

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by rossjudson on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @07:46PM (#22818405)
I haven't once thought, "Gee, I really wish I could use Microsoft Word". I have thought, "there's a capability I wish I had in Docs" a few times.

I did most of my doc writing in LyX before Google, though.

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by enneff on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @09:36PM (#22819037)
I imagine most people who want MS Office over Google Docs probably want it for Excel, which IIUC as several powerful features not present in Google's Sheets.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by philliphaydon on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @10:50PM (#22819348)
The only thing Google Docs has over MS is the collaboration.

Word in the browser is a billion times better for formatting than Google Docs. I loath using google docs. But when it comes to Collab, Google docs wins hands down.

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by shbooms on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @11:07PM (#22819417)
> The only thing Google Docs has over MS is the collaboration.

As someone who has had to build relatively complex tools in both Sheets and Excel, I would have to say Sheets has done a much more impressive job with their builtin formulas/functions than Excel.

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by wwn_se on Thursday April 09, 2020 @03:13AM (#22820462)
Also JS vs VB, im not a big fan of JS but only a madman prefers VB.

The JS in Sheets also run in the cloud. Really nice for scheduled things or things that talk to an api or similar. But being able to run stuff locally is nice to.

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by philliphaydon on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @11:29PM (#22819505)
I can't comment on that because I rarely use Sheets or Excel. I think my usage of Sheets is `=SUM...` :D
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by enneff on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @11:50PM (#22819602)
Then I'm not sure why you're replying to my comment about Excel. :-)
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by philliphaydon on Thursday April 09, 2020 @01:04AM (#22819927)
Because even between Excel / Sheets, formatting is still much easier in Excel. But formulas I cannot comment on as I just don't use that.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by kerng on Thursday April 09, 2020 @12:55AM (#22819894)
Entire GSuites is a productivity and doc formatting disaster. From docs, sheets to mail all very inconsistent and formatting of content and information is terrible compared to Office. Glad I'm back at a company that uses O365.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by panarky on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @06:51PM (#22818062)
> because it costs Google a nontrivial amount of money

It's not just the money it's also additional security vulns to defend.

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by jiggawatts on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @06:32PM (#22817911)
> because it costs Google a nontrivial amount of money for every user.

Google is the fourth biggest public company in the world as measured by market cap.

A Microsoft 365 "E3" license is $20/user/month. They can afford it.

This restriction is entirely about eating your own dogfood.

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by enneff on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @06:42PM (#22817994)
Yes, we can afford it, and that's why if you want MS Office you click a button on a web page and get it immediately. But why would we throw away money by having it installed by default?
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by soup10 on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @06:54PM (#22818082)
Can you guys stop astroturfing here. Nobody is dumb enough to believe that Google is saving money by not using office.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by arcticfox on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @07:14PM (#22818220)
> Nobody is dumb enough to believe that Google is saving money by not using office.

Maybe I'm dumb, why wouldn't they be saving money by not paying for Office? Obviously they could buy it for every employee, including the majority that don't need it, but why? They could also just light money on fire (but why?)?

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by soup10 on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @07:45PM (#22818401)
Office is business productivity software. You don't buy it for every employee, you negotiate a license for the number of seats in use. It has way more features than google docs and is standard everywhere. It's like saying you could save money by having programmers write code on pencil and paper. You saved the money on the computer but you have a net loss because you lost the power and efficiency of real time editing, compiling and debugging. These corporate guys just drink the internal koolaid/spin from hr or whatever and come here repeating nonsense as if its fact and it annoys me. It's dogfooding with some minor privacy/security concerns since microsoft is competitor, we get it, just call it what it is and move on.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by briandear on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @08:22PM (#22818626)
> It has way more features than google docs and is standard everywhere

I work for another FAANG and we don’t use MS Word. It certainly isn’t “standard” for us. It’s not standard for two of the three FAANG companies, so “everywhere” is inaccurate. Being popular isn’t the same thing as standard. Pages is a far more usable for the vast majority of use cases. Most people aren’t creating extremely complicated word processing documents in their day-to-day. Word is a bloated mess. Keynote is far easier and more elegant than PowerPoint. Excel however certainly shines for big spreadsheet work, but for most spreadsheet work Numbers and the google spreadsheet are perfectly fine.

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by scroy on Thursday April 09, 2020 @02:30PM (#22825686)
> two of the three FAANG companies

three?

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by soup10 on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @09:00PM (#22818843)
This isn't about the merits of excel over sheets, it's about employees coming on the board and lying to promote their company. Google makes 1.61 million in revenue per employee. Honestly it's only going to get worse, because if you see the videos of the company meetings, Sundar was always the super loyalist that would say anything to protect Google or run interference for senior leadership. And now that he's CEO they will start aping him.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by enneff on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @09:57PM (#22819120)
I may work for Google but I am often critical of them. I have no reason to lie in this instance, and anyone you talk to who works for Google will corroborate what I'm saying. Not everything is a conspiracy.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by joshuamorton on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @09:11PM (#22818909)
Your reasoning is based on the belief that Google is sacrificing productivity by not giving all employees office. GP is directly contradicting that line of thought, which makes the rest of it fall apart.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by soup10 on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @09:33PM (#22819024)
there is two narratives, which do you think is more likely:

1. Google is dogfooding it's own products to improve them and make them competitive and stop potential data/privacy/security leaks by using external software.

2. Google is trying to save 20 bucks

There is nothing wrong with Google docs or sheets and I have used them both. But sooner or later you make enough documents or work with enough spreadsheets you're going to want or need some feature that office has.

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by enneff on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @10:12PM (#22819192)
Why should it be an either/or thing? Both are valid reasons for Google to prefer its employees use Docs. However the fact that you can choose to use MS Office without any special permissions somewhat undermines your reasoning in point 1.

Google may be a rich company but it's also a very frugal company in many ways, particularly wrt technology (they pioneered the "huge amounts of redundant cheap hardware" approach to DC construction, for example). When Googlers were being coaxed into switching to Docs from MS Office, the financial benefits were front and centre to that pitch.

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by zackaman on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @10:17PM (#22819216)
Those two things aren't mutually exclusive.

1. Yes, Google probably prefers for people to use its own products both for usability and security reasons.

2. Google also wants to save money. However, if someone wants a license for a Microsoft product, they can get one.

Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by lallysingh on Thursday April 09, 2020 @10:20AM (#22822759)
They directly build and sell a competitor.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by thomaslord on Thursday April 09, 2020 @09:55AM (#22822555)
Google is a large company so they have lots of money, yes. Google also has lots of employees, so paying a per-employee price for anything gets expensive. I can't find a Google headcount vs Alphabet, but at the end of 2019 Alphabet had 118,899 employees. $20/month for each of those employees would cost $2,377,980 a month or $28,535,760/year assuming no annual-payment discounts. Google could absolutely absorb that easily if they purchased Office for every employee by default, or if only 25% of the company gets around to requesting it they can save $21 million a year simply by not buying software nobody asked for or intended to use.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by mrits on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @06:42PM (#22817992)
"Google is the fourth biggest public company" -- That's exactly why they wouldn't want 365 company wide
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by mehrdada on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @07:10PM (#22818181)
I'd seriously doubt more than a few of people at Google would want to use 365 at work. I for one never felt the need when I was there nor afterwards and the entire company is fully utilizing Google Docs which is a better product as far as sharing and search is concerned. It's not like people at Google constantly email .docx files to each other, lol. Nevertheless, you can request it (in an AppStore like fashion, not some overburdened process) if you really need MSOffice, but Zoom binary being banned seems to be a completely different matter though, as pointed out in other posts.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by lonelappde on Thursday April 09, 2020 @12:55AM (#22819892)
Docs is good at sharing and searching, but bad at editing. Anything over a few pages brings a workstation to its knees.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by mehrdada on Thursday April 09, 2020 @04:20AM (#22820710)
For workplace collaboration, sharing is the highlight, not formatting (unless you're designing for paper-based publication). I have to say the few times I encountered the browser-based Word 356, it felt like total shit. Cannot imagine anyone really using it if they have the desktop app installed. Seems like a checkmark product and the real users end up using the full app version. I've even heard this from friends at Microsoft.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by coffeeling on Monday April 20, 2020 @04:20PM (#22928064)
From what I've tried the desktop apps themselves do cloud-driven collab just fine, so I don't really see a reason to use a browser app when native's available. May just be me seeing things, but the native-to-native sync seems faster than with the web apps. Sadly that means sharing is a bit less convenient than just click link to open.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by m1sta_ on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @06:36PM (#22817948)
They have 103,000 employees. It adds up.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by tartuffe78 on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @06:39PM (#22817973)
That's only $24 million per year /s
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by byteshock on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @06:50PM (#22818057)
Just because Google has a lot of money doesn’t mean they’ll go wasting it on software licenses. 24 million might not even come close to what they make per year, but they still have to be considerate on what they spend their money on.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by Operyl on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @07:01PM (#22818121)
Just because I don’t know if you’re aware, the parent comment has a “/s” which means they’re saying it sarcastically. They agree with you most likely.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by xyzzyz on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @06:40PM (#22817977)
$20/user/month is tens of millions of dollars every year for Google. Sure, they can afford it, but I'm quite sure they have better things to spend money on.
Re:Google bans Zoom from employees' computers by Spooky23 on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @06:38PM (#22817965)
It’s an exception, it’s not about ability to afford.