News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by jasonmcalacanis on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @12:47AM (#2278601)
1. We're working with the folks impacted to place them at whatever company they would like to join. I'm personally reaching out to folks who might want these fine people. They will all wind up on their feet and be great additions to the vibrant startup scene in Los Angeles.

2. Mahalo is doing amazing videos with experts, but our (text) articles were created by passionate writers who are not necessarily experts. Google want's experts, so we're doubling down and getting experts to help build curriculums and lesson plans for our videos. I'm 100% certain that will solve the problem.

3. You can think of us as a free version of Lynda.com for everything. Or a version of Kahn Academy for everything.

Imagine tens of thousands of these type of pages and videos being made a year: http://www.mahalo.com/learn-adobe-photoshop-adjustments-pane...

We're going to teach folks every major piece of software, every recipe of note, how to change their oil and how to play any song on guitar or piano. http://www.youtube.com/howtoplayguitar2

Video is the future, and we're going to be the largest creator of educational videos this year.

It sucks that we got hit so hard, but we will come back stronger. The 95 members of the team that are still with us are more committed than ever to the mission.

Yes, it really sucked to get off stage after 47 amazing LAUNCH companies had such amazing launches on stage. I got told on my way to the after party. We struggled over these decisions all weekend with the leadership team.

At the end of the day entrepreneurship is about kicking ass and getting your ass kicked. I've been through this many times, but I would be lying if I said it didn't impact me. It does.

This is the first time I had such a big high followed by such a low, low.

OK, time to change a diaper and give a bottle. No rest for the weary.

Back to work.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by rimantas on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:34AM (#2278780)

  > Video is the future, and we're going to be the largest
  > creator of educational videos this year.
Oh no. I cannot wait for the video be the past. It may be the best way to teach some things (mainly involving physical activities or physical manipulation of some sort), but for programming topics it most often just waste of time and bandwidth. Why would I want to spend a minute watching someone to type a line of code with all mistypes and corrections, when I can glance it in a second? Why would I want to fiddle with video controls to get replay of particular section when I can reread it much faster whenever I want?

Seriously, I am starting to see this tendency to do anything in video as some sort of DRM scheme for content sites. I recently unsubscribed from thinkvitamin.com because they started to push everything to video (with annoying intro at the start of each video).

I did check your guitar lessons… Sorry guys, but with "amazing videos" you have you will never ever beat this guy: http://justinguitar.com/ (check out his beginners course or intermediate method; http://www.youtube.com/user/JustinSandercoe ) — take a look if just to see how expert teaching looks like.

I will chose the best over the largest every time.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by JonnieCache on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @06:07AM (#2279169)
>Why would I want to spend a minute watching someone to type a line of code with all mistypes and corrections, when I can glance it in a second?

A lot of people do want this. A good screencast shows not only the code, but the thought process that goes into writing the code.

People have different cognitive styles and learn in very different ways. I thought this was common knowledge by now.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by DrJokepu on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @07:06AM (#2279265)
Yes I don't doubt that, but for example, I am not one of those people and I don't think I'm alone. Just give me written instructions, please.

I guess that's probably the same reason why I was always incredibly bored during lectures at university and preferred learning from books instead.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by alexfarran on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @08:46AM (#2279496)
It's common knowledge, but its essentially a myth.

http://www.changemag.org/Archives/Back%20Issues/September-Oc...

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by JonnieCache on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @09:46AM (#2279691)
While the specific claims made by this article are true, they do not change the fact that most educated, especially self educated people have experienced situations where they have repeatedly gained much more knowledge much faster from one particular type of learning experience than they have from others, and that there is widely differing opinion on which type is best.

Now, while this obviously does not vindicate the claims of the people who assert that learning styles must be embodied in the neurology of the learner, it does show that something is going on, and it would be to the benefit of both learners and teachers to find out more about it.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by rimantas on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @06:55AM (#2279248)
A good writeup can do this too. I think some like video because of the pacing — you just have time for the information so sink in.
Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by stevefarnworth on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @07:06AM (#2279266)
Everyone learns in different ways, there are lots of people who are "viewers", who learn by watching others do something and there are also those who learn by reading about a topic. Both are perfectly acceptable forms of learning, and the drop in bandwidth and hosting costs is enabling those who teach/learn in that way to come to the fore.

I for one wouldn't know anything about Rails without Ryan Bates' Railscasts series or Patrick Lenz's Simply Rails book. Quality videos watching Ryan work through the code, and show notes with the code written is great for some things, and a book is great for others.

As for Jason, sorry to hear about being forced into such a hard decision - I like the direction Mahalo is taking and wish you all the success.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by trotsky on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @08:59AM (#2279536)
Every time I'm searching for an answer to something and I hit a video without a transcript, I bounce.
Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by uptown on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @10:27AM (#2279830)
SpeakerText seems to be a solution to address that problem. I know Matt is a user here. I'm sure he can speak to how it could solve that problem better than I can.

http://www.speakertext.com/

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by danssig on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:48AM (#2279014)
I disagree. For me, I would like to see a world where you could press a button and get a transcript of any video for the times when I don't have the time to dedicate but I would also like the video for those times that I do.

The problem with just reading programming things is you're seeing the final product. If you watch the video there is a better chance that you'll see how the person got to that point.

The thing that always annoyed me about Haskell tutorials, for example, was people would put in all this beautiful code but I couldn't ever make it run. In a video they would probably ran it themselves and I would have been able to see the import statements they were using but not putting in the tutorial (this isn't a problem with Haskell literate programming afaik).

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by Splines on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @12:31PM (#2280310)
You're right - the only times I've used video tutorials is when performing actions in space (video game guides for hidden objects, where pictures aren't enough, and home repair guides where showing how something works in real-time is paramount).

Trying to teach somebody something like programming over video is taking the lazy way out. In my university days some large first-year classes were delivered by video - I never took any, but I'd wager that student transcripts of the talks would have been worth real money.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by staunch on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @01:21AM (#2278659)
You like brutal honesty and you put yourself out there, so I think it's fair to ask you. Why don't you leave your role at Mahalo and do what you're the absolute best at? (TWiST, LAUNCH Conf, TC competitor)? Plenty of people can do a video eHow, but almost no one else could rival TC.

It seems like a pride/ego/money thing from the outside. Is it something else?

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by jasonmcalacanis on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @01:52AM (#2278708)
Well, I really believe in the mission to build a site that helps people learn anything... and I believed in human-powered search before that (and still do to be honest).

I've got the education bug, and I want to take the promise we all see in things like Lynda.com and Kahn Academy and scale it into a brand as big as Google or Wikipedia.

LAUNCH, Angel investing and This Week in Startups are all fun, but they are not as challenging as MAHALO.

Also, keep in mind that Mahalo is a top 200/300 site with millions in revenue even with this hit. It's the most successful thing I've done.... despite the hits we've taken.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by marcamillion on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:04AM (#2278922)
Jason...some constructive feedback:

Perhaps you shouldn't try to be 'everything to everybody'. I might not be your demographic, but whenever I think of learning I never think of Mahalo.

I would say choose one vertical that you can conquer - from an education play - and conquer it. Then branch out horizontally.

You can't beat Lynda.com, Khan Academy and every other learning site at the same time. Take it one vertical at a time and come up with a unique value proposition.

Lynda.com was the first mainstream internet video portal to make programming/technical tutorial videos and charge for them.

People don't go to Khan for the quality of the videos (i.e. fancy production and cameras), it is because he has an interesting way of explaining complex topics - and he focuses on the content (not himself).

Those are not very easy to beat, because they have already achieved Product/Market fit.

Unfortunately, you guys are still struggling to find yours.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by clojurerocks on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @06:59AM (#2279254)
Jason, you might consider doing a non profit with a more narrow focused education project rather then a for profit catch all product. Im personally involved with 2 projects that are being directed at kids and teens and are using game mechanics to try to get them excited about learning.

There is a DESPARATE need within this market for passionate knowledgeable and skilled people who are willing to invest their time energy and certainly money to help build these projects and get the word out. Personally knowing that the work that im doing will help kids and teens and maybe even young adults get excited about learning is more exciting then the idea of having everybody use my product and then being able to sell it and make alot of money. Ok almost as exciting. :-).

So please consider it. Thank you.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by tertius on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @12:57PM (#2280441)
I think he's busy.
Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by ComputerGuru on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:08AM (#2278734)
For someone so obsessed with education sites......

s/Kahn/Khan from both your posts.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by georgemcbay on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @01:38PM (#2280614)
I wasn't going to say anything... but I find the straight-up 4th grade grammatical issues (eg. "Google want's") to be far more annoying than the proper name misspellings.
Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by silverbax88 on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @09:44AM (#2279679)
Point taken about it being the most successful, but is it profitable? It would seem like the conferences could be bigger and more profitable immediately if you focused entirely on that and expanded on it.

Plus, you've already carved out a massive amount of market share and goodwill with the conferences related products.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by shareme on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @08:00AM (#2279382)
Jason I think the stats, pre-pivot, pivot, and after pivot bear this out that Wales may be right that a profit site cannot be execute properly..

I even saw the stats pattern when the Quantcast stats were not hidden..and I had to look up how to do stats again just to analyze it..as I had not touched stats math in years..

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by tertius on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @01:48AM (#2278702)
It's his company. I guess he wants to keep it going himself.
Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by sofakeekafos on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @01:38AM (#2278684)
>more committed than ever to the mission.

Oh my God, I think I just threw up a little in my mouth. What mission would that be? Spamming the web with contrived content related to high-value keywords, for the money?

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by aaronwall on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:04AM (#2278727)
Hehehe ... with a close second perhaps being "using deceptive public relations non-sense to get ink any way possible"

Good things happen to good people.

The opposite is also true.

Congrats Jason! :D

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by moultano on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:15AM (#2278745)
Jesus guys, take it elsewhere.
Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by sofakeekafos on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:35AM (#2278782)
He's being lionized on HN for making money, while he's polluting the written heritage of the human race. Not a chance I will take it elsewhere. He needs to be called out, to his face, as does anybody who thinks he deserves HN's respect.
Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by moultano on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:40AM (#2278796)
Mostly I see people expressing sympathy for a guy who had a really bad day (and a newsworthy one.) And if you think mahalo is polluting the written history of the human race, then boy do I ever have some spam to show you. Mahalo may not be the best, but it certainly isn't the worst.
Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by praptak on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:04AM (#2278924)
"And if you think mahalo is polluting the written history of the human race, then boy do I ever have some spam to show you."

GP's point: X are spammers and get undeserved respect on HN. Your response: there are worse spammers. Do the spammers also get undeserved respect?

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by ericd on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:07AM (#2278835)
Borderline stuff may actually be worse than blatant crap, because the borderline stuff is harder to classify as crap.
Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by tristanperry on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:50AM (#2279017)
Borderline stuff might be useful to some extent, to a minority of people. Blatant crap is - well - blatant crap with no use to anyone.

I accept your point about it being harder to classify, but I don't see how the SE's job being harder can equate to slightly useful content being worse than outright spam.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by aaronwall on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @12:52PM (#2280418)
How many of those sites had the sustained level of traffic that Mahalo had for years?

Also note that Mahalo enjoyed that level of traffic based on auto-generating pages through shagging third party content (without requesting permission and without any way to opt out of getting your content scraped, since they were pulling in the scrapes from Google's search API & you couldn't block Mahalo doing that without blocking GoogleBot).

In the past when Matt Cutts wrote of such MFA scraper sites he described them as "shoot on sight" http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/im-on-webmasterradiofm/#commen...

"In the chat room, I said hello to teeceo, but I know the stuff that he was doing and it’s shoot-on-sight. I think anyone who is blackhat knows (or should know) that I’m happy to talk to anyone, but that we’ll still take action on the spam we find."

And yet you have sympathy for Jason? Shows how powerful his public relations skills are! :D

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by pier0 on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @08:04PM (#2282231)
I honestly couldn't care less what happened to Mahalo and I pretty much agreed with all your points when you first revealed their ways of creating tens of thousands of useless pages, but nevertheless I also have simpathy for Jason.

I think not many people on HN realize (or probably are willing to admit) that This Week In Startups is the most interesting resource to learn from real experiences of fellow entrepreneurs, developers, etc. Mixergy is another interesting one, but the format of TWIST provides its viewers lots of insights and info that you simply can't get anywhere else on the web.

So not all Jason does is evil.

Just my two cents.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by mhp on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @08:31AM (#2279451)
How is posting on an anonymous internet forum with an account you just created hours ago telling him 'to his face'?
Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by andrewvc on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:10AM (#2278939)
Jason, we're currently looking to add a third engineer here at VOKLE in Santa Monica, the work's mostly Ruby / Rails, and we've been looking for someone experienced in that area, but given the quality of the Mahalo engineers I have met, I'm sure they'd have no problem getting up to speed.

I can be emailed at [email protected] for details.

Re:A Week After Google Changes Algo, Mahalo Fires 10% of Staff by oneplusone on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @10:31AM (#2279843)
I took a look at that page you linked as an example of quality content, and I just don't see it. The video was incredible superficial and a better medium would have been screenshots that identified all the UI controls and their function since that is all the video did.

Khan Academy has quality content which are dense with information. Your video wasted four minutes and told me nothing I couldn't find out by playing around with Photoshop.