News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by cowsandmilk on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:34PM (#22780832)
Classpass was founded in 2013. Wonderschool was founded in 2012. Can we stop calling companies that age a startup? Or at least stop using them as examples? I mean, the article then goes on to call Airbnb a "home rental start-up". It isn't a start-up, it is over a decade old and has over 10,000 employees.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by daenz on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:57PM (#22781006)
I worked for a self-proclaimed "startup" that was 10 years old. At some point, it's really just another word for "we don't have our shit together."
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by WJW on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:25PM (#22781222)
Hahaha so true. The one I rebranded itself as "scaleup" around its 10th birthday when "startup" became untenable.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by Jagat on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:44PM (#22780905)
People often (wrongly) refer to pre-IPO companies as startups.

Chick-fil-a, the chicken sandwich 40 year old startup.

Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by umanwizard on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:43PM (#22780898)
For better or worse, in colloquial American English, "startup" means a particular type of company, and is only weakly correlated with age.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by gamblor956 on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:14PM (#22781128)
To most of America, the term "startup" means a vaguely tech-ish company which doesn't know how to make a profit.

As a former techie, I strongly agree with that usage.

Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by dreamcompiler on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:33PM (#22781291)
And sometimes a de facto scam (WeWork) or full-on scam (Theranos) because the investors caught FOMO fever and couldn't be bothered with due diligence.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by bdcravens on Saturday April 04, 2020 @06:28PM (#22782057)
The company I work for has been profitable from day one. I think we'd be proud to say then that we were never a startup :-)
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by hogFeast on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:13PM (#22781119)
The reason AirBnb is a startup is because it makes no money. A company stops being a startup when you aren't relying on someone cutting you a check every month to keep it all going.

Most of these companies will now fold. The number of employees or, even, revenue is irrelevant.

Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by missedthecue on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:20PM (#22781176)
I still see Tesla commonly called a startup
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by hogFeast on Saturday April 04, 2020 @06:30PM (#22782066)
I would have been in that camp. But it is probably unfair.

I still think the company is a dumpster fire but the big investments that Musk is making are, in part, driven by actual revenue.

...now that isn't wholly true. Musk seems to be able to keep raising debt without hitting equity. Over and over, he just finds utter idiots to keep bailing him out. The deal with the Chinese govt was incredible. Eventually, this will run out of road but the bankruptcy will show that Telsa did create some value.

Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by tomashertus on Sunday April 05, 2020 @12:32AM (#22783746)
I really hope this recession will bust AirBnB. It would lower the rents all over the world...
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by naveen99 on Friday April 10, 2020 @04:24PM (#22836985)
recession is going to lower rents. airbnb is not even a rounding error.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by dehrmann on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:40PM (#22781347)
While I agree, I think the main thing they have in common is they're pre-IPO with intent to IPO, not just a privately owned company.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by manigandham on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:12PM (#22781118)
Indeed. Startup = entirely new business model. That's what venture capital is designed for.

Otherwise it's just a small business, until it becomes medium, big, public, etc.

Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by cjblomqvist on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:51PM (#22780954)
Completely agree. I find the terms startup and scaleup as useful. Both aim for the same thing, but are in very different phases (pre/post business model validation). Then of course, in reality it's not that clear whether you're one or the other....
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by KoftaBob on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:08PM (#22781085)
The term "start up" generally means any relatively young company (compared to companies that are multiple decades old) that's growing rapidly in revenue and/or valuation. The number of employees isn't as relevant.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by yellowapple on Saturday April 04, 2020 @05:05PM (#22781512)
And more precisely: any company that's young relative to incumbents / dominant competitors in the space (beyond a certain proportion, of course; a 99-year-old company is obviously not a startup even if compared to a 100-year-old competitor, but a 5-year-old company would be, IMO).

I personally think reliance on VC money is a more reliable indicator, though.

Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by gamblor956 on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:17PM (#22781149)
While PG tried to redefine the term "startup" to include "growing rapidly in revenue" or whatever, this redefinition never took hold outside of a very limited sphere centered in Silicon Valley.

Outside of the valley, startup means a company that doesn't know how to make money.

Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by _bxg1 on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:42PM (#22780887)
And yet we all know what they mean when they call those companies "startups". The term has drifted pretty far from its original meaning, but it does carry a new meaning even though it's almost completely different
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by TazeTSchnitzel on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:47PM (#22780926)
It means they're VC-backed webapps from San Francisco?
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by _bxg1 on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:49PM (#22780941)
Roughly. I would broaden the colloquial meaning to "new-wave tech companies". Ones from the past decade that aren't FAANG and maintain an agile culture (or at least purport to), and have a certain San Francisco sheen to them even if they aren't actually from there
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by maxerickson on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:51PM (#22780952)
I feel like you are now vigorously explaining that the other poster was right, that we should use some other name.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by _bxg1 on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:54PM (#22780973)
I'm not arguing one way or the other, I'm just observing that "startup" is an overloaded term in 2020, and maybe the new definition is a bit silly, but it's also really hard to get everyone in a society to change the vocabulary they've become accustomed to.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by renewiltord on Saturday April 04, 2020 @05:35PM (#22781728)
It's a bit like asking you to define just how many grains of rice there are in a heap. You may be unable to do so and yet know a heap when you see it.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by brain5ide on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:19PM (#22781172)
Because investing in a .com would be bonkers.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by rumanator on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:53PM (#22780962)
> And yet we all know what they mean when they call those companies "startups".

That isn't true at all. These companies were startups almost a decade ago, but since then they already matured and strayed very far from the classification. This is like calling a 40yo man a teenager just because he was one in the distant past.

Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by benatkin on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:43PM (#22780894)
Another thing that's more than half a decade old is your objection. The term "startup" has come to have a broad meaning. The meaning of words changes over time. Fortunately, new terms often come along to fill gaps. In this case there is the term early-stage startup.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by StavrosK on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:48PM (#22780930)
So "startup" now means "company" and "early-stage startup" means "startup". I look forward to having to call them "incipient early-stage startup".
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by yborg on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:53PM (#22780967)
I guess startup is generally understood now to mean a VC-backed company that doesn't make any money.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by digitaltrees on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:04PM (#22781058)
I think it’s more about the nature of growth potential. Hyper growth with a hockey stick is the measure.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by skissane on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:19PM (#22781173)
Often, a "startup" just means a private company that plans to go public but hasn't done so yet (as opposed to already public companies, and private companies that don't plan on going public)
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by Klinky on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:29PM (#22781254)
No, that sounds like a private company trying to sound trendy.

A startup has a small number of employees to start with and a 2 - 3 year window to go big, fizzle out, or pivot into a small - medium sized business. You're not a "startup" forever, nor does eventually marketing yourself as one, actually make you one.

Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by jedberg on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:31PM (#22781271)
I don't think so, because a whole lot of startups plan to get bought, not go public.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by travisjungroth on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:06PM (#22781074)
Airbnb claims to make money.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by digitaltrees on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:03PM (#22781053)
Start up has come to mean a company attempting hyper growth as opposed to a traditional business like a mechanic or brewery.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by jbay808 on Saturday April 04, 2020 @07:38PM (#22782415)
But what about companies that achieved that hyper growth (Google, Airbnb, etc). Are they still startups? How would you view this dialogue?

"I'm working at a startup".

"Oh? Where?"

"Google."

Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by chipotle_coyote on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:20PM (#22781177)
I mean, sure, but the fact that the objection is old doesn't mean it's wrong. While I wouldn't say there's a clear cutoff point in terms of time or employees between "startup" and "not a startup," there's got to be some point at which we say "company X was a startup, but really isn't one now." Google was a startup, but we wouldn't call it one now any more than we'd call Apple a startup, right? How about Facebook? They're younger, they pushed that whole "move fast and break things" schtick. But with a billion users and worldwide offices and an actual corporate campus, I'm gonna say "no, not anymore," aren't you?

So I think it's fair to ask whether Airbnb, a profitable company with 12,000 employees and annual revenues of $3B+ for the last few years, can really be called a "startup" now. They were a startup. But now? Eh...

Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by Klinky on Saturday April 04, 2020 @03:57PM (#22780997)
This just sounds like marketing spin. It's hip to be a "startup" because that conjures up the idea that the company possesses certain advantages over larger organizations, even if it doesn't anymore.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by onetimemanytime on Saturday April 04, 2020 @05:17PM (#22781584)
>>Another thing that's almost a decade old is your objection. The term "startup" has come to have a broad meaning. The meaning of words changes over time.

They use the word "startup" when it serves their interests. Yet, we don't call 10 year olds babies. Too bad

Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by jimbokun on Saturday April 04, 2020 @10:16PM (#22783207)
Companies are called start ups by people old enough to clearly remember when they really were just a start up, and haven't internalized just how long ago that really was.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by manigandham on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:12PM (#22781111)
The definition is now so broad as to become meaningless.
Re:Startups are pummeled in the ‘great unwinding’ by rumanator on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:24PM (#22781205)
The definition hasn't changed. There's a lot of misuse and abuse for marketing purposes.