Japanese people also have an etiquette of wearing a mask when ill to avoid spreading disease.
Both of these habits are widespread in Asia because of this.
If the fashion industry gets on board to make them look nice and production ramps up to make them widespread and affordable, we may actually see mass societal change around this.
You may want to fact-check that statement more. Here is a list of mask research that could help: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1HLrm0pqBN_5bdyysOeoOBX4p...
[1] Limit how your files are shared https://support.google.com/docs/answer/2494893
I did. Most of the data is on medical workers, pitting N95 against surgical masks. We already know that even N95 masks, which are unlikely to have good sealing over a longer period of time, are not very effective in protecting against viruses. Obviously, there is no data on medical workers wearing no masks.
There is almost no data on the general population wearing masks (or not), and the data that exists doesn't seem to provide a strong argument either. Please correct me if I overlooked something.
Here's some quotes that don't exactly inspire confidence:
"Improvised homemade face masks may be used to help protect those who could potentially, for example, be at occupational riskfrom close or frequent contact with symptomatic patients. However, these masks would provide the wearers little protection from microorganisms from others persons who are infected with respiratory disease"
from "Testing the Efficacy of Homemade Masks"
"Home made masks, and to a lesser degree surgical masks, are unlikely to confer much protection against transmission of small particles like droplet nuclei, but as the reproduction number of influenza may not be very high [14] a small reduction in transmissibility of the virus may be sufficient for reducing the reproduction number to a value smaller than 1 and thus extinguishing the epidemic."
from "Professional and Home-Made Face Masks Reduce Exposure to Respiratory Infections among the General Population"
"Neither face mask use and hand hygiene nor face mask use alone was associated with a significant reduction in the rate of ILI cumulatively"
from "Mask use, hand hygiene, and seasonal influenza-like illness among young adults: a randomized intervention trial."
"Moisture retention, reuse of cloth masks and poor filtration may result in increased risk of infection."
from "A cluster randomised trial of cloth masks compared with medical masks in healthcare workers"
And your point on masks not protecting incoming droplets is wrong. When people sneeze, droplets can go more than 5 feet. Masks reduce exposure to such droplets.
https://medium.com/@Cancerwarrior/covid-19-why-we-should-all...
Research is on going on how immunity responds to decreased exposure to viral loads.
And masks can remind people to not touch faces and remind others that we're in a pandemic.
I'm aware of that, nevertheless what I say is true. Wearing a mask raises suspicion of you being sick. The irrationality of that doesn't matter.
> When people sneeze, droplets can go more than 5 feet. Masks reduce exposure to such droplets.
You're still going get them in your eyes, you're still going to breathe them in, you're still going to get infected. Why aren't people recommending to wear glasses or better yet, goggles? Why not a whole ski outfit?
> https://medium.com/@Cancerwarrior/covid-19-why-we-should-all....
Literally nothing in there says any more than "won't harm at worst, may help at best". No science, whatsoever, just speculation.
Let me then speculate how it might actually harm: You're carrying around a net to catch all those aerosols around you, then you'll be breathing against it constantly. You bring it home, at which point it is essentially a bio-hazard of which you need to dispose of properly, which you won't, because you're an average person.
Do I have any evidence on that hypothetical risk? No, but neither does the other side that claims it doesn't do any harm.
> And masks can remind people to not touch faces...
Yes, I omitted that.
>... and remind others that we're in a pandemic.
...as if people needed to be reminded about that. Soon enough, they'll have heard enough about it and start ignoring it again.
What is your explanation for the graph on this page, which clearly shows that wearing a mask has massive effect on the spread of the disease?
I don't. I haven't been provided clear evidence, I have been given speculation. I can speculate as well.
As a general rule, is a mask going to protect you from infection? No. There is overwhelming evidence to support that. Even an N95 mask will not protect you. Your eyes are still exposed, you'll still be breathing in a sufficient amount of particles to get infected.
On the average, might it reduce your personal risk of infection at least a little bit, because of some droplets missing your mouth? Maybe, maybe not. We don't know that. It might increase your risk, for the reasons I have mentioned. This is not just me speculating, I have seen it in medical papers as well.
The idea that "you cannot protect yourself" simply isn't as popular, so people cling to the idea that cloth masks that everyone can make themselves will protect them. Fair enough, but then we should be recommending diving goggles as well. We should be recommending people to cover their clothes in plastic bags to dispose of later, because that too is "better than nothing".
> What is your explanation for the graph on this page, which clearly shows that wearing a mask has massive effect on the spread of the disease?
It doesn't show that, that's spurious reasoning. If that was valid reasoning, I might as well re-label those circles with "eating mostly rice" and "eating mostly wheat" and claim that "rice saves lives". Correlation does not imply causation, there's lots of other factors at play here.
Nevertheless, widespread wearing masks may well significantly reduce the spread of the disease to others, I said that myself. It just won't protect you.
> https://www.maskssavelives.org*"
Not that I have a dog in this fight but that site was debunked as not constituting actual proof and flagged off the front page by HN's readership: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22706216
I am open to the possibility that masks really work, but this particular link doesn't really show that for me.
Sure, there is a smalll minority of uneducated people that believe that. Most do not.
I don't think so. Rhino horn is just a stand-in for TCM that everyone is aware of. Most Chinese believe in TCM, even doctors, who tend to practice a mishmash of TCM and western medicine.
It's plausible that most Chinese men believe that Rhino horn could cure their impotence - if only they could afford it.
EDIT:
Face the facts, downvoters:
"We interviewed 15 TCM practitioners in Hong Kong, investigating their familiarity with rhino horn, prescription experiences, and perspectives toward its use and trade. All interviewees believe that rhino horn possesses medicinal properties, despite general unfamiliarity with its chemical composition or any active ingredient."
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/19400829187874...
Note that I never claimed that a majority of TCM adherents support poaching. That is not the case.
The study isn't designed to determine the percentage of TCM practitioners who believe in/use rhino horn.
It is a study of TCM practitioners who believe in/use rhino horn to determine how they use it.
That 15/15 survey participants believe in rhino horn is part of the study's design, not one of its conclusions.
I have no idea how many TCM practitioners or patients in China believe in the efficacy of rhino horn, and neither do you.
I do know, having occasionally visited Australian TCM practitioners (who trained in China) for acupuncture and related treatments, that none of them have any belief in animal-based remedies, endangered or otherwise.
It doesn't explicitly say that anywhere. If you want to interpret the introductory sentence like that, fair enough, it's ambiguous. I interpret it the other way around.
> I have no idea how many TCM practitioners or patients in China believe in the efficacy of rhino horn, and neither do you.
Enough to drive the rhino the brink of extinction and enough to make the CCP legalize its trade again.
Indeed, it's not so easy to find stats on this. The best I found:
"Gratwicke et al. (2008) surveyed 1880 residents in six Chinese cites to learn about demand for products made from wild tigers. Of the 43% of respondents who admitted to having consumed tiger products, 71% expressed a preference for wild over farm-sourced products"
"A survey of 800 educated, urban, traditional medicine users in Vietnam with an average monthly income of US$292 revealed that 59% (475) had either purchased or used rhino horn, or expressed an in-terest in doing so in the future (Hanley et al. 2016"
https://www.nabu.de/imperia/md/content/nabude/internationale...
Of course that's proxy data, but it doesn't seem to be just a tiny minority.
> I do know, having occasionally visited Australian TCM practitioners (who trained in China) for acupuncture and related treatments, that none of them have any belief in animal-based remedies, endangered or otherwise.
Of course, foreigners only get sold the "feel good" version of TCM. Chinese people obviously don't want to "appear bad" to foreign sensitivities. That's why, if you ask them, they will probably downplay it or outright lie to you.
There is nothing racist about referencing the fact that the Chinese, and not just some small minority of them, believe in and practice TCM - including the application of Rhino horn[1].
The statement I made is as logically (un)sound as the statement I am lampooning. The practices of a population don't imply knowledge or rationality.
[1] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/2018/10/wildlife-...
Maybe we're like this French doctor, and that this is still the reason why we don't wear masks in the west? A widespread practice in several East Asian countries - but what do they know?