News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by BenoitEssiambre on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:13PM (#22721699)
Isn't that just like 2x seasonal flu death numbers? This seems like a very conservative estimate.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by dannykwells on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:20PM (#22721789)
This is conservative, but also, this is happening in a very short time frame, AND is taking into account all of the social distancing AND is happening at the same time as flu.

Without the distancing measures we have in place we would be looking at millions of deaths.

Once this is over, it will be very tempting to say, "Look it was only as bad as flu, we shouldn't have trashed the economy just for that..." but that of course is not fair reasoning. We only will have 200k deaths because of the distancing.

Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by mirekrusin on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:48PM (#22722063)
But social distancing can make at most order of magnitude difference (generous, semi-arbitrary) - which is still way too small change, it just spreads a lot of deaths in time, doesn't stop all of them, right?
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by manicdee on Sunday March 29, 2020 @08:27PM (#22724071)
Spreading out cases over time means what might have been a death in a crowded, overworked hospital is a recovery in a moderately challenged hospital where the concerns are fresh face masks rather than available hands.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by mirekrusin on Monday March 30, 2020 @12:04AM (#22725127)
I know and I don't argue that. I gave 10x less deaths for that, which is generous - but that still means deaths counted in millions.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by edoo on Sunday March 29, 2020 @04:04PM (#22722206)
Wrong. Flattening the curve merely delays infections and does not prevent them. It doesn't seem to work well either. It has been good for a 0.5 R-0 drop which points to other primary vectors instead of aerosols. Also it turns out if you need a ventilator you have a 95% death rate, so if the hospitals get overwhelmed the overall death toll won't be too different. If the death toll is anywhere near 100k total we trashed the economy over a bad flu. It would take 6+ months of isolation to beat the virus with quarantine measures, more than long enough to cause a wave of economic related deaths way higher than the virus. People have to get back to work.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by dannykwells on Sunday March 29, 2020 @05:33PM (#22722964)
No, you are wrong by confusing number of cases with deaths. Flattening the curve reduces the max number of cases, which reduces hospital overload, which in tun saves lives. Without any intervention we were/are looking at 1M+ deaths:

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/13/opinion/coron...

That's a lot of people to condemn to death. Do you have statistics to cite for "Economic related deaths" that you quote?

Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by edoo on Monday March 30, 2020 @09:46AM (#22727940)
1M+ deaths is impossible based on .gov's own numbers. Estmated 100-200k dead. The only way a hospital can help is with ventilators. Everyone else gets the exact same treatment at home or not. If we have a 90% death rate on ventilators than in an absolute worse case 'system overwhelmed' scenario there are 10% more deaths. The idea of millions is laughable, but to be expected from political opinion pieces.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by bb88 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:20PM (#22721784)
CDC estimates that 24k - 62k die every year from the flu.

Fauci estimated 100k - 200k will die from covid-19.

So that would be 2-8x on the extremes. But 2x would be the low end estimate assuming a bad flu season and a low end number for the death rate on covid-19.

Hospitals are optimized for typical illness, not for pandemics. And the death rate has been calculated based upon cases that get adequate health care -- an assumption that goes away when the hospitals have to choose who lives and who dies.

Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by rumanator on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:24PM (#22721822)
> an assumption that goes away when the hospitals have to choose who lives and who dies.

I feel this sort of statement misrepresents the true problem and portrays deaths from lack of medical care as just a capricious choice made by cruel doctors and nurses. This portrsial is neither fair or truthful.

If you have 10 patients requiring a respirator and only a single respirator to spare, figuring out who is a priority or has a better chance of making it alive is not the same as deciding someone should die.

Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by bb88 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @04:04PM (#22722203)
Someone had mentioned recently that one of HN's biggest problems was overly pedantic responses get better upvotes rather than actual content. This has a caused HN to devolve into a fact correctness engine rather than a content engine. To be fair, this is something I've done in that past too.

Yes, I did use a rhetorical phrase to make a point, but one that's pretty prevalent in modern culture and especially when it comes to triage. Perhaps google phrases like "Doctors forced to play God", etc. Ironically, the first hit that comes up is this: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8163641/NHS-doctor-...

I really recommend that you go watch episodes of MASH from the 1980's. Particularly the episodes where the doctors have to triage cases that might be savable if they weren't in a field hospital. If the US president says we're in a war, we should all refresh ourselves up on what meatball surgery is during an actual war.

Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by threatofrain on Sunday March 29, 2020 @04:13PM (#22722278)
The objection is that the phrasing of a doctor playing God is extremely culturally potent in America, and far less on whether you are technically correct on the intersection of God and medicine.

And in public speech it's the public that determines meaning and not the speaker with their intentions. What the speaker gets to do is make predictions about how it will be received.

Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by notacoward on Sunday March 29, 2020 @09:54PM (#22724523)
> in public speech it's the public that determines meaning and not the speaker

False dichotomy. It's a shared responsibility. Nothing gives the reader or responder the right to project their own biases or guesses of intention onto someone else's words and argue as though they'd been in the original. Please stop doing that.

Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by bb88 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @04:17PM (#22722316)
And this is exactly the pedantry I was talking about. You're arguing about the "way" I mead the point. Not about the argument itself.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by threatofrain on Sunday March 29, 2020 @04:23PM (#22722362)
As a public speaker engaged in public speech, you are responsible for getting the results you want. It would be silly for JK Rowling to blame people for not correctly interpreting her novels.

You are absolutely reaping your own fruits, but you are blaming others for your displeasing harvest.

Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by bb88 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @04:41PM (#22722518)
Wow, all I did was use a phrase from popular culture, and now I feel I'm being speech shamed.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by threatofrain on Sunday March 29, 2020 @05:15PM (#22722817)
Sure, it's language used to discuss doctors in the context of abortion, euthanasia, and medical research relating to genetics. I wonder why people might focus on doctor playing God. Could some people actually be religious?
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by sykick on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:31PM (#22721887)
I think no sufficiently intelligent person thinks that hospitals deciding who lives/dies will be done capriciously or by cruel doctors. But on the other hand there were large numbers of fools in the U.S. who thought the ACA would create death panels. So maybe for the U.S. your point is valid.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by rumanator on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:07PM (#22723215)
> think no sufficiently intelligent person thinks that hospitals deciding who lives/dies will be done capriciously or by cruel doctors.

The death panel political talking point suggests otherwise.

Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by lolc on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:44PM (#22722025)
To me the statement "have to choose who lives and who dies" doesn't carry the meaning that the decision will be taken in a capricious way. In the end it's a horrible responsibility to decide somebody doesn't get a chance to live so that somebody else gets that chance. But that's the situation.

How would you write that, then?

Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by Kye on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:31PM (#22721890)
It's reasonable to assume bb88 understands the nature of triage and was referring to that in a non-judgmental way.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by BenoitEssiambre on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:29PM (#22721864)
I suppose that is true, if the crisis is impeccably managed from this point onward, we might only see 100k to 200k deaths. On the other hand, if it is not, it wouldn't surprise me to see this level of deaths just in NY state.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by analog31 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:16PM (#22721730)
True, but flu is spread out over the whole year, and 100k deaths is only 10 million cases, possibly a severe underestimate. We'll be at a million reported cases in a week, or 10 million not long after that.

Edit: Corrected as per below. Thanks!

Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by herman_toothrot on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:20PM (#22721791)
I'm not sure I understand you statement re: "100,000 deaths is only 1,000,000 cases". That seems an awfully high percentage compared to the recorded numbers so far.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by jude- on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:16PM (#22721728)
If hospitals get overrun, the total number of deaths that result from this pandemic is bound to be higher.
Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by melling on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:20PM (#22721793)
Half of America is hiding inside taking extra precautions. He’s probably giving us one of the better outcomes. He also said 100,000 to 200,000

If we took more precautions with the flu, the number would be less too. And if people got the flu shot

Re:Fauci: US can expect more than 100k Covid-19 deaths, mill... by Kye on Sunday March 29, 2020 @03:16PM (#22721729)
It's not like the flu tagged covid-19 in. Both are going to cause a lot of deaths at the same time.