News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by gunshai on Friday March 20, 2020 @10:26AM (#22637732)
I've been telling my friends for years, if you can successfully sell Vodka in today's market you can probably market any product.

While there are "differences", they all basically have to be the same by law and you probably can't reliably identify a difference in a double blinded application.

"(1) “Vodka” is neutral spirits so distilled, or so treated after distillation with charcoal or other materials, as to be without distinctive character, aroma, taste, or color." https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/27/5.22

The differences are defined by a sliding scale of three elements, the "heads,hearts, and tails".

https://www.diffordsguide.com/encyclopedia/198/bws/distillat...

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by tw04 on Friday March 20, 2020 @10:39AM (#22637855)
I'm sorry but if you can take a shot of Karkov vodka and a shot of Stoli and not tell the difference there is something very broken with your taste buds - regardless of what the law says. That's ignoring the headache you're going to have after a night of drinking Karkov.

Source: I was poor in college and had the misfortune of dancing with Karkov on more than one occasion.

For those of you who have never had the misfortune (it only comes in plastic bottles): https://www.wine-searcher.com/find/karkov+vodka+usa

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by jerrysievert on Friday March 20, 2020 @11:08AM (#22638112)
> That's ignoring the headache you're going to have after a night of drinking Karkov.

typically from cutting the heads too shallow. ethanol's boiling point is 173ºF, where the alcohol that is giving you your headache is lower. cutting the heads (or lower evaporating alcohol) too shallow gives you more of that alcohol.

now, as to taste, I disagree a little bit with the gp post in that enough complex sugars also make it out in that slurry if you're using a pot still (even triple distilling), or even using a reflux still, that there can be a marked taste difference between "neutral" spirits.

source: I've made quite a lot of vodka (most of which has been turned into gin)

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by 01100011 on Friday March 20, 2020 @08:57PM (#22643315)
Eh... you would expect more acetone and ethyl acetate I think. I'm guessing IPA and methanol might show up too, assuming you had any in the mash. The 'other alcohols' AFAIK, mostly show up in the tails. Those are the fun ones like butyl and pentyl alcohol, which have different subjective effects and may actually suppress a hangover.

Let's be honest, ethanol gives you a hangover. Your body breaks it down into acetylaldehyde. Ethanol is a pretty shitty alcohol to use as an intoxicant. People have played around with making hangover-free alcohol from the higher alcohols over the years but it never went anywhere.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by trevyn on Friday March 20, 2020 @09:16PM (#22643409)
Why did it never go anywhere?
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by 01100011 on Friday March 20, 2020 @09:39PM (#22643500)
Not sure. I can't find a link to it right now. There is 'alcosynth', but AFAICT that's something different. About 5-7 years ago I was really into this stuff but I stopped drinking a couple years ago and slowly forgot it all. There are a number of studies on fusel oils/heavier alcohols and hangovers if you want to google it. Tryptophol and the like are also interesting(yeast produce them under certain nutrient conditions).
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by hutzlibu on Friday March 20, 2020 @12:03PM (#22638660)
"typically from cutting the heads too shallow. ethanol's boiling point is 173ºF, where the alcohol that is giving you your headache is lower."

Can you explain that a bit? I thought alcohol is ethanol. C2H6O. And headaches in bad stuff comes from bad distilling ethanol, so different (even dangerous) byproducts like methyl alcohol can be inside that make you feel bad.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by jerrysievert on Friday March 20, 2020 @12:22PM (#22638824)
> I thought alcohol is ethanol

ethanol is an alcohol, but not all alcohol is ethanol.

an apple is a pome, not all pome are apples.

amyl (isobutyl carbinol: C5H12O) alcohol is also an alcohol, that has a boiling point of 131.6ºF - that means it comes in the heads (lower temperatures). methanol comes in at 148ºF.

other alcohols come in the tails, but typically have more of an oily texture to them.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by jcelerier on Friday March 20, 2020 @02:22PM (#22640004)
> an apple is a pome, not all pome are apples.

coming from a language where "pomme" is the translation of "apple"... wat ?

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by mturmon on Friday March 20, 2020 @02:34PM (#22640187)
An analogy is a literary device, but not all literary devices are analogies.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by erik_seaberg on Friday March 20, 2020 @07:37PM (#22642853)
A simile is like a metaphor.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by DoreenMichele on Friday March 20, 2020 @07:39PM (#22642861)
Pomme de terre -- "apple of the earth" aka "potato"

Pomme frites -- "french fries"

Not all pomme are apples. Sometimes they're potatoes.

(Though this could be utterly irrelevant and have nothing whatsoever to do with what was intended by the GP.)

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by jacobolus on Friday March 20, 2020 @10:59PM (#22643962)
A potato is not a pome. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pome
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by klodolph on Friday March 20, 2020 @03:02PM (#22640498)
If you look up “pome” in an english dictionary, it’s a botanical term that refers to fruits such as apples and pears.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by jerrysievert on Friday March 20, 2020 @03:37PM (#22640847)
yeah, I chose it to be more specific and try to stop "but an apple is not a fruit!" comments :)

can't win them all.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by jacobolus on Friday March 20, 2020 @10:57PM (#22643947)
An apple is definitely a fruit.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by klodolph on Saturday March 21, 2020 @03:20AM (#22645144)
A ton of these words have different technical definitions when used by botanists.

https://www.quora.com/Why-is-an-apple-called-a-false-fruit

E.g. a strawberry is not a berry, but a pineapple or a banana is a berry. A pepper, cucumber, pumpkin, or squash is a fruit. An apple or pear is not.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by hootbootscoot on Friday March 20, 2020 @06:01PM (#22642088)
So, you will be approaching the boiling point of ethanol and a lot of other stuff you don't want (methanol is 65c, where ethanol is 78c) will boil off along the way, but time is a factor here, and also the fact that you are not likely maintaining a precisely even temperature along the entire column until the condensing stage, and so one will typically account for real-world pollution by discarding the first material, instead of being a cheapskate and blinding people... for example.

bear in mind that there are other substances that ALSO boil around 80c-90c and that fermentation of a given substance or mixture or solution of substances will be varying byproducts (from your ethanol-questing perspective...)

the sheer notion of distillation being some precise and quantized quantifiable process is likely suspect...

think of cooking, and how the ingredient list is only part of how a given dish may turn out...

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by gunshai on Friday March 20, 2020 @11:17AM (#22638208)
>source: I've made quite a lot of vodka (most of which has been turned into gin)

My assumption here is because gin tastes good. :grin:

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by jerrysievert on Friday March 20, 2020 @12:16PM (#22638766)
or, as some like to call it: flavored vodka
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by gunshai on Friday March 20, 2020 @04:58PM (#22641592)
I mean ya I agree, my pedantic side couldn't help itself though.

>(c) Class 3; gin. “Gin” is a product obtained by original distillation from mash, or by redistillation of distilled spirits, or by mixing neutral spirits, with or over juniper berries and other aromatics, or with or over extracts derived from infusions, percolations, or maceration of such materials, and includes mixtures of gin and neutral spirits. It shall derive its main characteristic flavor from juniper berries and be bottled at not less than 80° proof. Gin produced exclusively by original distillation or by redistillation may be further designated as “distilled”. “Dry gin” (London dry gin), “Geneva gin” (Hollands gin), and “Old Tom gin” (Tom gin) are types of gin known under such designations.

>i) Class 9; ... flavored vodka, ... “flavored vodka,” ... vodka, to which have been added natural flavoring materials, with or without the addition of sugar, and bottled at not less than 60° proof. The name of the predominant flavor shall appear as a part of the designation. If the finished product contains more than 2 1/2 percent by volume of wine, the kinds and precentages by volume of wine must be stated as a part of the designation, except that a flavored brandy may contain an additional 12 1/2 percent by volume of wine, without label disclosure, if the additional wine is derived from the particular fruit corresponding to the labeled flavor of the product.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by guyzero on Friday March 20, 2020 @04:26PM (#22641303)
every single Seagrams product is just flavoured vodka - they all start as neutral spirits
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by jerrysievert on Friday March 20, 2020 @08:31PM (#22643164)
that actually didn't used to be the case: https://www.cincinnatimagazine.com/high-spirits-blog/mgp-ing...

their whiskey was world-class. shame they never sold any of it without blending it into their product. thankfully the distillery did after it was sold, and ended up being some amazing product.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by freehunter on Friday March 20, 2020 @03:45PM (#22640929)
Flavored vodka is a big business. Just wander down any liquor aisle.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by auiya on Friday March 20, 2020 @01:21PM (#22639389)
Is there any way to "fix" cheaper vodkas by holding it at the proper temp for sufficiently long enough? Or are they beyond salvageable by that point in the process?
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by tw04 on Friday March 20, 2020 @02:44PM (#22640325)
I'd tell you to just buy Svedka if you want something cheap but quality. Haven't had it in years but I know we had at least one long cabin weekend and that was the drink of choice - pretty smooth and no headaches.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by RussianCow on Friday March 20, 2020 @02:45PM (#22640340)
I have heard of people putting cheap vodkas through a carbon filter (like Brita) a few times to improve smoothness. I haven't tried it myself, but I am skeptical, because if the fix is that easy then it seems like the producer would have done it. MythBusters did a double-blind taste test[0] in which only the "vodka expert" was able to correctly rank the samples, and they found that the chemical composition of the cheap vodka was the same before and after filtering. Based on that, I would say the answer is most likely "no" and you should spend a few more bucks.

[0]: http://kwc.org/mythbusters/2006/04/episode_50_bullets_fired_...

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by poidos on Friday March 20, 2020 @03:08PM (#22640569)
I did this in college and all it accomplished was to temporarily ruin the filter -- pretty brutal to wake up after a night of drinking the filtered vodka, stumble hungover to the pitcher for some water, and take a big swig of vodka flavored water!
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by Enginerrrd on Friday March 20, 2020 @06:58PM (#22642598)
I was very impressed by how accurately the vodka expert ranked the taste of the vodka by how many times it had gone through the Brita filter.

To me that was quite telling.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by KingMachiavelli on Friday March 20, 2020 @03:49PM (#22640957)
Yes & no. While you could redistill it and be extra generous with the amount of head (& tail?) thrown away. Or you could build a activated carbon filter; if you search around there is a lengthy PDF describing the proper dimensions & volume of carbon filtration needed. The cost of the activated carbon is probably going to exceed just buying slightly more expensive such as Costco/Kirkland vodka. It's not as cheap as the plastic bottle brands like Taaka but save for really high consumption levels it's probably cheap enough.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by shawnz on Friday March 20, 2020 @06:49PM (#22642525)
Why does the carbon filtration only remove the side products and not the desired products?
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by jerrysievert on Friday March 20, 2020 @07:22PM (#22642753)
last I looked (can't verify locally since Costco can't sell spirits here) their vodka was belvedere. is that still the case?

personally, I prefer monopolowa, but it's mostly personal preference at that point - but I find the price of $19.95 is a little more palatable (wow, it was $9.95 last time I bought some!)

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by hootbootscoot on Friday March 20, 2020 @06:04PM (#22642110)
I know a guy in Aarhus, Denmark once that was triple distilling floor cleaner. He still had his vision and all organs intact, but I still did decline the offer of a drink at his house...
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by jerrysievert on Friday March 20, 2020 @03:17PM (#22640655)
it's not really about holding it at a proper temperature, it's where things boil and evaporate. if you redistill a vodka, you can typically remove more impurities.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by bryanbuckley on Friday March 20, 2020 @01:27PM (#22639445)
I've done double blind vodka tastings and some of the cheaper vodkas come out on top. e.g. Barton's is as good as top-shelf (that were in the tasting)
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by RussianCow on Friday March 20, 2020 @02:20PM (#22639977)
Anecdotally, I've found that vodkas made by smaller, local distilleries tend to be really good for the price. I'm assuming this is because vodka is generally not their core product, but they're making a pure, neutral spirit as a base for other things (e.g. gin) anyways, so they might as well bottle it and try to sell it. Since they're not spending excessive amounts of money trying to market their vodkas, they tend to be pretty cheap.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by burmer on Friday March 20, 2020 @12:19PM (#22638786)
I thought you had to use a column still to make vodka, and that if you use a pot still, it's basically (white) whiskey.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by jerrysievert on Friday March 20, 2020 @12:27PM (#22638876)
> I thought you had to use a column still to make vodka, and that if you use a pot still, it's basically (white) whiskey.

a column, typically a reflux still, is generally what is used, yes. it provides a much higher alcohol concentration to be extracted in one single pass. at highest efficiency, you'll get 95% alcohol as a return.

you can also make multiple (5-10) passes in a pot still to get the same purity, it's just nowhere near as efficient (because of the multiple runs).

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by tyingq on Friday March 20, 2020 @11:15AM (#22638187)
If you can't tell the difference, try McCormick vodka. $6 US for a liter. It is vile. I have no idea who couldn't tell the difference with that. https://www.totalwine.com/spirits/vodka/vodka/mccormick-vodk...
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by anamexis on Friday March 20, 2020 @11:46AM (#22638504)
While this is true, try the same test between Stoli and Grey Goose (at roughly twice the price of Stoli).

Bottom-shelf vodka is bad, but anything above that is virtually indistinguishable.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by guntars on Friday March 20, 2020 @01:09PM (#22639261)
That's funny, I haven't heard of Karkov before, but where I'm from Stoli is bottom shelf so I thought it's one of the fancy brands. Guess not!
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by bryanbuckley on Friday March 20, 2020 @01:28PM (#22639459)
Yep, Stoli is definitely a bottom-tier vodka (not in price, though)
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by tj-teej on Friday March 20, 2020 @03:07PM (#22640550)
You're right, garbage vodka is garbage.

However the difference between a $20 bottle and a $45 bottle of vodka isn't that noticeable, especially when you consider the difference between equally priced tequila, whiskey or wine.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by prostheticvamp on Friday March 20, 2020 @10:50PM (#22643893)
I find this really funny, because Stoli is literally short for “table vodka” (“stol” is table.) In Russia, it was a super cheap shit vodka.

I wonder if they’ve gotten better - or if just their marketing has.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by Sileni on Friday March 20, 2020 @06:28PM (#22642332)
I had completely forgotten about that bottle. You just gave me flashbacks to a house party in 2010. Complete with nausea and regret. Well done.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by NikolaeVarius on Friday March 20, 2020 @11:43AM (#22638476)
Send it through a filter. Thats what my Dorm did and it worked just fine.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by frandroid on Friday March 20, 2020 @02:55PM (#22640436)
Like, a paper filter for coffee?
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by jfengel on Friday March 20, 2020 @04:21PM (#22641262)
An activated carbon filter, like a Brita pitcher.

I've heard mixed results on the reports. It's certainly removing some things, and leaving others. The results likely depend on just how bad it was when you started. But given that Brita filters aren't exactly cheap, you might have better luck just buying the $20 vodka rather than the $10 vodka.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by binarycrusader on Friday March 20, 2020 @10:51AM (#22637955)
This is not quite accurate. Planet Money recently did a special on this. The difference is indeed in the “tails”:

https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/02/23/588346329/epis...

https://www.npr.org/transcripts/588345420

The short version is there are certain chemical compounds that some individuals can taste or have an allergic reaction to that might be present in those tails and there are measurable differences between distillers.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by gunshai on Friday March 20, 2020 @11:02AM (#22638053)
Ya I've listened to that. However you left out the portion of that where they dive into the route origins of high end vodka.

And the part at the end where they compare high end to other vodkas.

My ultimate point is in marketability, no vodka markets it self as "the one that gives you less of a hangover" nor do they even report the compound composition to inform of consumer choice.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by binarycrusader on Friday March 20, 2020 @12:08PM (#22638706)
I did not “leave anything out”.

The argument was that Vodkas “all basically have to be the same by law and you probably can't reliably identify a difference in a double blinded application”.

My sole point was that particular assertion wasn’t wholly accurate.

The law effectively only applies to the first two parts (heads and hearts).

The Vodka origins do not detract from my point at all. Yes many Vodkas have similar origins, but not all of them do, and so they can vary subtly in taste and effects because of the tails which do vary between different Vodkas as noted in the podcast. And yes a cheap Vodka can actually be rated higher from a subjective chemical composition standpoint. But note I never claimed that a “high end vodka” was better.

I won’t claim to be one of those people but based on that report I think it’s plausible that some or many people can tell a difference.

In short, there is a measurable chemical difference between some Vodkas and some test labs assert that those differences are where differences in taste and effects lie.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by shanecleveland on Friday March 20, 2020 @11:34AM (#22638393)
And there part where they rate the makeup of the high-end vodka as inferior to at least on of the other samples.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by blakesterz on Friday March 20, 2020 @11:43AM (#22638478)
Mythbusters did 3 episodes on Vodka that were pretty interesting. One of them was a blind taste test and they were able to tell the difference between vodkas they had filtered at different rates. I think they concluded that's the big different, expensive vodkas are filtered more.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by ken on Friday March 20, 2020 @03:18PM (#22640664)
I really don't think it's that hard to sell ethanol. This is a substance which is regularly purchased by 70% of the population.

You don't even have to be "not worst". "Worst" often also means "cheapest", and there's lots of people who seek out the cheapest option.

It's well known that wine with pictures of animals on the label outsell non-animal-labelled wines by more than 2:1. This is not a particularly sophisticated market on the low end.

Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by eu7durb3rjdur on Friday March 20, 2020 @03:33PM (#22640785)
It's hard to do without breaking the market because it's so cheap. Reagent grade ethanol is dirt cheap and for this reason also spiked with chemicals to penalize people who drink it. Without sin taxes and regulations that accomplish similar ends you could probably sell 1.75L of vodka for 2 dollars. But then poor people could afford to have fun in a non-puritan fashion and Americans hate that for some reason.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by fenwick67 on Friday March 20, 2020 @10:36AM (#22637823)
Anecdotal but, I feel like I can tell good vodka from cheap vodka easier than good wine from cheap wine.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by dEnigma on Friday March 20, 2020 @11:16AM (#22638200)
There shouldn't be a clear line between "good" and "cheap" for vodka as well as for wine. There is good stuff being sold quite cheaply and the other way around.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by anon73044 on Friday March 20, 2020 @04:12PM (#22641177)
I'd put a $5 bottle that's been aerated against a $50 that hasn't any day of the week.
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by easytiger on Friday March 20, 2020 @07:34PM (#22642833)
Wine or vodka?
Re:An Oregon creamery making vodka from milk by anon73044 on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @05:09PM (#22753543)
Wine, should have specified. But, really, who wants aerated vodka?