You're conflating the recorded fatality rate with the actual possibility for fatality, which is much higher.
The fatality rate is low among people 60 and under because the ones who suffer severe cases can reliably survive it with the aid of ventilators and round-the-clock medical care.
However, if the virus spreads enough to have a huge number of infections all at once, many of those severe cases that would have otherwise survived will die, because there's just not enough medical equipment or doctors for them.
See Italy, where the fatality rate is at a whopping 7.3% percent (much higher than even the 4.9% at the heart of the outbreak in Wuhan), because no measures were taken to control the spread until too late and so parts of the country have completely run out of ICU beds.
> The vast majority of the people most directly impacted by all this are essentially at zero risk of dying from COVID. And on April 7th it’s not like COVID will cease to exist... “Locking everything down” is an incredibly damaging and nonsensical action for the vast majority of the population.
Maybe, they are young and healthy. But unless they don't ever meet anyone with any comorbidities or advanced age, they will spread the virus to someone who isn't. Even if they are young and healthy and aren't aware of any risk factors, their immune system could overreact to the virus and kill them - its happened in china[0]. People who are afraid about the virus will not visit their establishment, or take classes from them, etc. This economic hit is not entirely artificial, it's coming for these people whether or not we close down service industry.
I think we have to take these drastic measures and also ensure the government treats this like the natural disaster it is, ready to restart the economy after the downturn by injecting cash and forgiving debt.
[0] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/13/world/asia/co...
This is the most important part.
Its not clear whats being done to prep for the end of lockdowns. Once everything resumes so will the spread (all) viruses
We don't have those available right now and are looking at disaster if we don't lock down. Our testing capacity will grow significantly and by later we can take those measures and get back closer to normal life.
So you tell me which is more damaging?
Also a lot of us have family over 35 that we care about.
but people aren't concerned with young folks being at risk. they are concerned that they will spread it. that's why schools are closed. they wanna "plateau the curve" or whatever they call it.
curious, can't personal training happen online? via i dunno, skype or slack?
if not, well, someone needs to make it happen.
We need to figure out something, fast, for these workers. The economics are terrifying and require resolve to accept that we will economically damage ourselves to protect others in our communities.
Are those of us over 35 somehow worthless? Should we segregate the entire population based on age until the vaccine is deployed in 18 months?
Until a vaccine is available, as someone over 35, and who has parents who are 70/72, I want as many 0-55 year olds to get COVID as soon as possible to establish herd immunity and ultimately limit the risk to the elderly population.
The 0-55 population by and large isn’t going to the ICU when they get exposed to this coronavirus. Most will report that they “don’t even know they had it”.
After they get it, the data we have shows that they won’t be able to get it again, or spread it.
There is not a 0.2% fatality rate in the 0-45 demographic. Even 45-55 is probably less than 0.1%.
No fatalities under 10, but 10 - 19 has fatality of 0.2%. 0.2 of the entire 10-19 population is a huge number.
The case fatality rate is the number of deaths divided by the number of known cases (positive tests).
What you are looking for is the IFR (infection fatality rate) which is not known, because of the number of infections in the 10-19 population which were asymptomatic or too mild to be tested.
It’s extremely telling, for example, that 99.9% of fatalities in Italy as of two days ago were 50+. Surely that is not because no one under 50 was infected, particularly since the younger population is more likely to be congregating at bars and clubs.
I’m happy to throw away karma to call out anyone multiplying a naive CFR by a population number every time. It’s totally incorrect to do that.
Now with this action, an entire segment of the economy is being wiped out for at least a month, and it happens to correspond to a segment which is extremely unlikely to have any PTO or sick time policy.
Most 25-35 year olds are not prepared to lose a month of income without suffering serious financial hardship. That’s reality. Not an “abdication of personal responsibility” at all.
The people taking it on the chin here are simply not the people at risk from this virus. Do I think they will literally starve? No, likely not. But they will be suffering serious financial hardship as a result of these actions, when they are in fact extremely unlikely to suffer health consequences from COVID.
Without employment it is difficult.
Do you think credit-card companies are looking forward to this?
Lending money is what banks do, so I don't see why they are going to be upset about people using credit...
How is anyone supposed to get 3-6months rent as savings waiting tables in or just out of college? These aren’t salaried tech employees. This pronouncement is utterly divorced from the economic realities of Americans[0], and to me seem breathtakingly insensitive.
[0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/christianweller/2019/07/30/are-...
Budgeting their income, not going out every single night and a myriad of other ways. You dont need a large tech salary to save money. You need common sense.
For an example - Say you rent a one bedroom in Boston for 2k, nearly half the average[3], and you share this one bedroom with a roommate making rent 1k/month. Minimum wage in MA is 12.75/hour - if you work part time, 30 hour weeks 50 weeks out of the year, you take home 1530 a month, leaving 530 a month for food, transportation, and student loans, while they continue your studies or interview for jobs. If they managed to spend just 430 on all those costs, and saved $100/month, it would take them 10 months to cover rent alone for just one month, forget about 3-6 months. Should this person be priced out of Boston schools and interviewing in the job market because they can’t save for a global pandemic shutting down all service jobs?
[0]
https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2020/02/07/millennials-...
[1]
https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(18)30003-5
[2]
https://www.cnbc.com/2019/01/09/shutdown-highlights-that-4-i...
[3] https://www.rentcafe.com/average-rent-market-trends/us/ma/bo...
Edit: fixed numbers, minimum wage in MA is actually 12.75, not 12
But spending two-thirds of your take-home pay on an apartment is also absolutely crazy.
I agree it's insane to be spending that much on rent as well - but short of raising the minimum wage and using pricing controls to stop rent increases, what can be done about it? Cities hold the good schools and the good jobs, and people aren't being irrational by moving there and trying to compete. This is the modern financial tightrope we ask people entering the workforce to walk.
Say they spend an additional $200/month on a used car they own outright, just between the price of gas, insurance, and parking, to get to work, and this lets them instead pay $500/month in rent living further out in a townhouse with more roomates. The new $400/month savings rate this allows them, if fully utilized, still takes nearly 7 months to save up 3 months of sitting in your apartment doing nothing but paying $500/month rent + the $430 we said you needed for food and all other expenses monthly.
This isn't just hypothetical for me. I had the great fortune to work during college at significantly above minimum wage in a very cheap area, and saving for me was still next to impossible. I have a sister who hustled waiting tables for almost two years after her degree in NYC before building up enough connections to start her professional career filming tv shows. She is now paying down the debt she accrued with a much, much higher paying job, contributing much more to the economy than she would have had staying in our sleepy state.
These kinds of success stories take not only the kind of panache and grit people like to prescribe to the working poor, they also take the ability to take large risks and the luck that they pan out. My sister and I were fortunate to know that if we failed, we had loving parents who could catch us with a place to stay until we got back on our feet. It's true we worked hard, but without that safety net, and much other luck, I don't think either of us would have walked to the end of the financial tight rope of rent in major cities. I think people who walked across the rope without fearing the fall often just don't get it.
But if you are spending two-thirds of your take-home on rent and don't have parents who can either support you or let you with them then you should probably make some life changes. When I graduated I didn't have a backup plan. I grew up with my grandmother and by the time I'd graduated she'd moved into an assisted living facility and sold her house. And I never would have dreamed of living in a place that would put me at that much risk like San Francisco or New York.
I was happy to move to Houston where even my waiter and bartender friends live very comfortable middle-class lives, and spend close to 25% of their income on rent.
There are lots of reasons someone won't have 6 months of expenses. Most are rare situations (most people are not just getting started in life). If everybody makes saving 6 months expenses a goal they work to before most people will achieve it. When it is only a minority that can't take care of themselves it is a lot easier on the rest of us.
I realize that there are exceptions. There are many minority scenarios that means many people don't have the above for reasons out of their control. However if the rest use the above it is a lot eaiser to help the rest. When someone with options doesn't use them it hides the existence of those without options and prevents help.
A lot of my friends are fresh college grads, moving into the world, and suddenly finding themselves without job opportunities. They haven't had time to get established in a career, much less build up a 3 to 6 month emergency fund.
There are plenty of people in the US who are living paycheck to paycheck, where an unexpected $500 expense would be financially difficult for them [1].
From a position of security and with the benefit of hindsight it's very easy to say "oh well, they just didn't prepare enough, it's their own fault" when in context that's a rather shortsighted take.
Part of it is poor financial literacy, I'll grant you that. We should take strides as a country to improve that.
But perhaps a larger potion is that simply most people don' t have the luxury of advanced financial planning, or the ability to actual act upon that planning.
Please have more compassion for your neighbors.
See also, this other comment from this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22588601
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=22588681&goto=item%3Fi...
This is incredibly out of touch. When I moved out of home at age 18, with unemployed parents, I certainly did not have a 3 to 6 month emergency fund. Students and part-time workers generally don't, and a huge fraction of the country is to poor to even contemplate it.
> And just because someone is not at risk of dying from COVID-19 doesn't mean they can't catch it and spread it around, thus possibly contributing to someone else dying
By your logic I could say "I feel for the 60+ demographic. However, if they are in a demo thats at risk thats on them."
The impact all these closures will have an hourly workers who dont even make enough money to build a 6 month nest egg is just as serious of an issue as the spread of COVID-19.
Except if they are homeless and jobless, they are a lot larger burden on society. Now play that out at a grand scale and you see the issue....
I hope the government is also planning to pay people’s rent, mortgage, electric, water, groceries, credit card interest, etc.
A friend of mine runs a small local restaurant. Not sure how he will pay rent. All of his servers are now temporarily unemployed and have no way to buy food or pay rent.
Another friend of mine is a personal trainer. Not sure how he will buy groceries next week.
The vast majority of the people most directly impacted by all this are essentially at zero risk of dying from COVID. And on April 7th it’s not like COVID will cease to exist...
“Locking everything down” is an incredibly damaging and nonsensical action for the vast majority of the population.