News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by WJW on Saturday March 14, 2020 @03:31PM (#22577980)
Well clearly. Almost everyone alive today is an "electricity native", but it's only a very small minority that can safely install wiring and the like. Everyone else just interacts with the consumerized version of it where everything interesting but potentially dangerous has been abstracted away. There is no reason to believe that younger people are more savvy about the workings of digital technology just because they grew up with consumerized versions of it.
Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by echelon on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:33PM (#22578444)
It's worse today than it was in the 90s and early 2000s. Back then the web was an indie experience. If you wanted your own blog, you had to host it. Or if there was a platform you could use, it let you customize the HTML and CSS. An entire cottage industry of websites hosting code snippets sprung up, and all the kids were using HTML and tweaking it.

If you wanted a video game forum, you needed to host it. You had to learn how Linux servers worked, what MySQL was and how tables and migrations functioned, and might even need to write a little PHP on the side.

When I was a teenager, I had a PHP website that did game matchmaking, lightweight article publishing, and custom (non-phpBB) forums. I put this under Subversion source control and let several of the members that were code literate contribute. We built a lot of stuff and had a whole thing going. Multiple websites. And then we stood up an IRC server, which gave way to bots and log ingestion and archival.

We ran a MediaWiki instance (http://strategywiki.org), we knew the folks that wrote the Gamecube LAN adapter tunnel.

When it came time for college, I was way ahead of the curve. I blew through all of the upper level courses before my electives, and I was a TA in my freshman year. (Second semester!) This let me take a lot more biology and chemistry classes (something I wasn't previously skilled with, but had a deep interest in learning).

This isn't as widespread anymore since there are platforms that do everything. Even though the learning curve has dropped and the barrier to entry is lower than ever, the barriers of interest and necessity have been raised.

Kids don't need to hack around as much, and it's sad.

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by cortesoft on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:02PM (#22578663)
I think you are overestimating the total number of kids that did the things you did.

A higher percentage of kids that were on the internet had the skills you are talking about, but they weren't a higher percentage of the overall population.

For example, there might have been 5% of young teens doing what you were doing, and that might have made up half of the internet users... now, it is still 5% of the total population, but that is now only 1/18th of the total internet population of that age range.

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by hombre_fatal on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:15PM (#22578756)
Seriously. I think their comment is good example of patting themselves on the back for their interests while being completely wrong about reality.

I happened to run my own phpbb/vbulletin forums as a kid and I can confidently say I was the only kid even close to doing that in my high school. I also didn't need to know anything to do it except press buttons on CPanel and phpmyadmin, things I didn't really understand. And I was scared to tell other guys at school about this stuff because I'd be an instant loser. Even in uni I rarely met anyone with those interests.

Meanwhile, these days, it's completely cool to spin up your own Discord server for your friends. It's totally mainstream to be into that sort of thing. Even gaming is cool now. And there's more kids these days doing more of what the grandparent post glamorizes because it's more accessible than ever.

I'd be surprised if grandparent commenter was even working off any real experience with modern kids and instead just wanted to glamorize their own nostalgia. I mean, surely modern kids aren't as cool as he was.

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by echelon on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:41PM (#22579301)
> surely modern kids aren't as cool as he was.

Surely.

I don't get why you folks have to be so rude. It diminishes your argument. I was with you until you had to poke fun at me. I'm a human being capable of making mistakes and reevaluating my ground truths. Why be like that?

> patting themselves on the back

While there's a lot of nostalgia in my anecdote, it's mostly spurred on by my dislike of platformization and centralization. I think they produce many negative externalities.

But thanks, now I'll clam up and stop talking about my personal experience.

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by novok on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:29PM (#22578861)
I think the more modern equivalent would be making games with various javascript game engines (twine, etc) in a web browser or similar and making art with medibang paint and so on.

Then there is the entire linus tech tips make a cool RGB flashy gamer computer and poke at shit, where those kind of tech youtubers make get a million views per video.

Or buy a rasberry pi at 13 and poke at linux on the internet.

You have to realize, that even back then, only %0.5 of a school population is going to be into computers enough to install linux on anything. At my small high school, I was the only one basically.

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by alexpetralia on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:02PM (#22578662)
I initially sympathized with this line of thinking, but someone recently convinced me otherwise. The logic is as follows:

* Do programmers still fool around with Cobol or Assembly or Fortran? Not so much

* How important is C nowadays? Yes - everything runs on it - but that is because for the most part it is rock solid, and we need fewer and fewer C developers

* The set of "primitives" required has moved up a layer of abstraction. New skills include: website builders, data pipelines, infra-as-code, cloud infra, web frameworks, etc.

If people are still hacking the same way as they were 20 and 30 years ago, that is a problem. Yes, the hacking today surely looks different than it did decades ago - the primitives are larger and higher leverage - but there is hacking all the same.

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by bsanr2 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:56PM (#22578615)
It's also assumed that anyone not using the "low barrier to entry" platforms is a professional (or else, trying to make a professional product), which, ironically, raises the barrier to entry for anyone trying to get out of the sandbox.
Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by eropple on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:57PM (#22578627)
> If you wanted a video game forum, you needed to host it.

InvisionFree started in 2002 and was incredibly, bonkers-popular.

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by fastball on Saturday March 14, 2020 @03:55PM (#22578165)
That's a great point and something I've never thought about.

I think it's something that would be helpful to think about when I'm raising my kids.

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by Eldandan on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:18PM (#22578319)
I'm under 35 and consider myself very 'digitally native'. It wasn't until I helped my 19 year old niece set up her laptop that I realized exactly the same thing. They're fine with youtube and spotify from a tablet or phone. She could pick things up fairly quickly for school assignments (Office, etc.). I think it was her hunt-and-peck typing that made me realize my assumptions were off. (I don't think typing classes in middle and high school are much of a thing anymore in my region.)
Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by WalterBright on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:31PM (#22578429)
Watching professionals hunt-and-peck all day drives me mad.

I took a 2 week typing class in the summer after 8th grade. We learned on big heavy mechanical typewriters where you really had to hammer the key to get an impression. It was time well spent, as it has paid off for me continuously ever since. For example, I wrote this entirely with touch typing (not looking at the keyboard).

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by beefield on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:45PM (#22578528)
I have occasionally thought to time to learn proper touch typing. But I never seem to get over the idea that my bottleneck is not in the fingers, but in the brain trying to figure what to type in the first place... Can someone prove me wrong and make me motivated to learn?
Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by hackinthebochs on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:51PM (#22580089)
I'll assume you're a programmer. Have you ever been in a situation where your IDE, text editor, or other tools were extremely slow and unresponsive? You're trying to perform some task and there's this external bottleneck slowing down everything you are doing. Instead of completing the subtask quickly so that your train of thought flows smoothly into the next unit, the flow is interrupted by having to wait. And once you're out of the flow, there's mental effort required to get back into it. But if your tools present a constant bottleneck, then you are permanently stuck in this less efficient mental state. Essentially the bottlenecking tool becomes a part of your mental model, and that useless chunk of mental real-estate reduces what can be accomplished by the same mind unburdened by this useless detail.

But all of this goes just as much when a lack of typing skills is the constant bottleneck. If you can't type at the speed of thought, the quality and complexity of your thoughts suffer since a part of your working memory is consumed by the process of typing. This has real implications for what you're able to accomplish.

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by bsanr2 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:05PM (#22578696)
It's the same as any other higher-level skill: the faster you can perform the lower-level functions, the faster you can iterate.

Your medium of expression also influences the speed of your thought. You'll notice that people who speak for a living seem to be wittier than those who don't; they're able to form thoughts and translate them into expression very quickly. Typing/writing is already much slower than speaking, but its advantage is the ability to revise a thought before conveying it. If you're typing slowly, you're probably forming thoughts slower than someone who types quickly. Anecdotally, spending so much of my time communicating via keyboard stunted the development of my ability to express vocally, because it lowered the rate at which I had to generate and, internally revise, and expel thoughts. It would be even worse if I could not touch type.

That's my layman's take, anyway.

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by WalterBright on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:27PM (#22579203)
Touch typing really pays off when you're typing in things like notes. It literally doubles the speed because you can do it in one operation rather than two.

The touchscreens of today make touch typing impossible.

Also, with my laptop and its cramped, wretched keyboard, I use a full size bluetooth one (they are surprisingly hard to find) to touchtype on. I hate how every keyboard maker has to "innovate" by moving all the non-Qwerty keys around randomly.

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by redwall_hp on Sunday March 15, 2020 @01:18AM (#22581496)
This is what infuriates me so much about the new Mac portables...they clearly were designed by hunt-and-peck peons. Software "keys" that you have to look down to reliably hit, word suggestions (implying you should looking down at the keyboard instead of the screen, which is flat out wrong...) and scrolling emoji. Never mind the key failures...
Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by jkinudsjknds on Saturday March 14, 2020 @07:09PM (#22579480)
I'm surprised you say this. I have no problem touch typing with one, or two thumbs on almost any phone displaying a qwerty keyboard after orienting myself to it.

I'm wondering if you have very specific muscle memory outputs for your fingers vs. an intuition of where each key is relative to each other. E.g., I'm typing this sentence with only my pointer and middle finger on my right hand. Would that cause a problem for you?

Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by 2snakes on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:51PM (#22578572)
Find an alternative perspective like typing games.
Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by Avamander on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:37PM (#22578482)
I saw a lot of kids using caps lock to type capital letters, that is even more painful. Thankfully they quickly utilized the new knowledge about shift key, I like to think I changed the way they use computers, but who knows if they actually have the motivation to learn further.
Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by jjeaff on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:29PM (#22578412)
Is this in the US? I thought absolutely everyone was taking typing.
Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by microcolonel on Saturday March 14, 2020 @03:53PM (#22578152)
If anything, there's kinda a middle ground age right now where you can expect greater general understanding of computing concepts, with both people young and older than that being more ignorant.
Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by rjbwork on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:00PM (#22578200)
Yep. When I was 2 my parents got an old computer from my uncle's business that he was replacing and set it up in their living room for me. I was learning the command line as a toddler. I'm certainly no guru, but that kind of formative experience was certainly a big part of my choosing this career path. Kids of today grow up with ipads and iphones and have no cause to go poking around and experimenting with the basic functionality of their computers.
Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by DBYCZ on Saturday March 14, 2020 @04:06PM (#22578233)
Same here, some of my earliest memories are of an old ms-dos mickey mouse game, where you were required to look through a booklet and enter in codes to perform actions.
Re:Not all young people are ‘digital natives’ by xnyan on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:34PM (#22578887)
Learned how to spell quite young to use a CLI, first word was "DOS" lol.