Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by 8bitsrule on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:31AM
(#22573200)
Animal food markets in China (and nearby in SE Asia) are unlikely to be shut down. They are regional phenomena. I guess they accept that risk. What will keep them from fathering pandemics?
The ships plying global sea trade started spreading plague epidemics no later than the 1500s. (Not to mention colonization, or Columbus.) War made the so-called Spanish flu widespread. We're not sure yet whether that one started in Kansas.
Both moved a lot slower than today's airplanes. They've become the disease's vector of choice ... and hugely bear the responsibility for accelerating regional epidemics into global ones.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by wrycoder on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:50AM
(#22573464)
At least temporarily during the epidemic, the Chinese government has banned the raising and consumption of wild animals. However, it appears the ongoing trend in China is to eliminate these practices.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by tyjen on Saturday March 14, 2020 @05:52AM
(#22574238)
This is what I'm reading/hearing so far. After reviewing the DNA sequences available to date, experts determined the virus was unlikely to be a human created bioweapon, but instead a virus that jumped from a wild animal to humans. Supposedly the pangolin, but they haven't honed in exactly on which animal carried the original virus.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by Leary on Saturday March 14, 2020 @03:09AM
(#22573706)
How much did China lose due to this outbreak?
$1 trillion at least.
You think they can't do something to reduce the risk of this calamity from happening again?
Cultures can change. Ancient practices that had limited risks when everybody lived in remote villages must change to adopt to the modern society. There is a lot of people in China that want to ban these markets. I'm not sure about Southeast Asia.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by norswap on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:31AM
(#22575970)
I doubt the Chinese government will be so attached to these traditions (?) that they choose to preserve them over increased probability of catastrophic risks.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by xxpor on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:45AM
(#22573450)
if you start talking about them causing pandemics that cause millions of deaths, you start approaching a situation where it could be argued it'd be moral to bomb them to oblivion, even if that led to a war. maybe not with china since they have nukes, but for every other SEA country? idk.
I feel like this makes me sound like John Bolton, and that's kind of scary.
Lab breaks of SARS, another coronavirus have happened a number of times, and likely caused the original SARS outbreak (according to WHO)
This regional phenomena happens to be right across the river, 20 miles, next to the only BSL4 level lab in the region.
That same lab also happens to have published hundreds of synthetic coronavirus genomes. They also ran gain of function research that was banned by NIH until recently, due to it's highly questionable ethics and biosafety in principle.
It's just another lab break, why is it so hard to accept that industrial accidents happen?
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by 01100011 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @02:31AM
(#22573602)
It is odd, and it could hint that the virus escaped the lab. It could also hint that a foreign power decided to release a pathogen there to disparage the government. It also could just be a coincidence. I don't think it benefits anyone to speculate. We will probably never find out the truth behind it.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by internet_user on Saturday March 14, 2020 @02:41AM
(#22573625)
They've had enough biosafety incidents to have the WHO themselves call them on it in the past.
SARS, according to WHO, was a lab break too.
What kind of damages would China be liable for 50-60% globally infected, with 3-4% deaths?
That is why the evidence will be suppressed, and the inconvenient voices silenced.
We don't need new drugs.
Outbreaks will continue on happening as long as we have gain of function research programs in place.
They will literally try to come up with new strains resistant to current treatments, if such research continues to be done.
Time for international oversight, just like with nuclear.
We need to stop unethical gain of function research. It should only ever be approved if the outbreak can be actually contained and victims treated - with monetary penalties in place for consequences.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by meowface on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:55PM
(#22576694)
Original SARS outbreak was zoonotic, not a lab escape, and SARS-CoV-2 very likely is, too. It is an odd coincidence that it appeared to start near a research lab which contained SARS samples, but maybe the lab was created in that area in the first place due to it being a region full of biological diversity, including among viruses?
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by dharma1 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @03:00AM
(#22573674)
If you are interested in the details of how SARS-CoV-2 works, the history of discovery of the ACE2 receptor it binds to, and a potential treatment based on human recombinant ACE2 that has been through phase I and II human trials previously and is now starting trials in China for covid19 - I highly recommend this video lecture from Dr Josef Penninger from earlier this week.
You might need to register (it's free) to watch but it's worth it.
The idea is that by adding soluble rhACE2 to the serum, the virus will bind to that rather than real ACE2 in the cells, reducing viral load.
This is not the flu - it can attack multiple organs where ACE2 is expressed - deep in the lungs, heart, stomach lining, kidneys. I've seen other studies which indicated it can affect the central nervous system too. It's not as deadly as SARS but much more contagious. And we still don't have a clear picture what permanent lung/organ damage is inflicted to some recovered patients.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by forkexec on Friday March 13, 2020 @11:26PM
(#22572948)
No mention of Camostat plus E-64d that is already known to blockade TMPRSS2 and ACE2. E-64d needs full clinical trials while Camostat needs enhanced Phase IV trials since it's already Rx in Japan.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by boulos on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:39AM
(#22573235)
I get that you're frustrated. But there are lots of parts of the world that eat bushmeat for various reasons. They persist due to economic challenges that last generations. If you grew up eating a chimpanzee or bat or whatever, because at that time you had to, you might still do it decades later even if you're now wealthier and don't need to.
This isn't specific to China. The most probably cause of SIV => HIV transmission is also bushmeat [1]. The challenge is that many regions of the world have become mobile and interconnected faster than they've removed high-risk "survival activities" (the portion of China near Wuhan is apparently filled with bats, making them an historically important food source). China has banned all wild animal markets, like they did after SARS [2], but it's important to remember that many folks grew up with an incredibly different setting than today in the China/India/Equitorial Guinea of their 1960s childhood.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by boulos on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:01AM
(#22573306)
Sorry if I was unclear: it's not that China is still a poor country, but people develop habits and customs generations ago. For some fraction of the people (who are now wealthier), it's variously seen as a status thing, something mystical, or whatever else. That doesn't change the reality that this probably isn't a habit that would develop today, but would persist without action. 60 years ago is a long time, economically speaking!
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by officialjunk on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:32AM
(#22573409)
The real thing to note here is China is a country that has a track record of squashing outbreaks before they get out. Even with all that experience, this sars-cov-2 got out in a major way. This one is different. And many countries didn't take advantage of a 3 month warning. Now it is even more of an issue because the world didn't prepare and is not acting properly yet.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by MaupitiBlue on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:25AM
(#22573168)
Then they are only paying a small fraction of the mess they’ve created. What about the lives lost in Korea, and Italy, and Iran? Why should those countries suffer because China won’t practice basic hygiene and eats unsafe food?
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by asdfasgasdgasdg on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:29AM
(#22573191)
All of these other countries, including my own, had the opportunity to see what China was dealing with and to act quickly and decisively to prevent having to suffer the same pain. Instead, we sat on our thumbs for a month trusting I don't know what, destiny? Moral superiority? To protect us. And now we will pay the price.
Nobody with any power to censure China is able to point fingers, since these politicians and leaders have failed to protect their own people at least as much as China failed to contain the virus, and with less excuse. Also, practically speaking, there is just no mechanism to enforce any kind of sanction on China for this.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by MaupitiBlue on Saturday March 14, 2020 @12:44AM
(#22573244)
> All of these other countries, including my own, had the opportunity to see what China was dealing with and to act quickly and decisively to prevent ...
You’re missing my point. Why should the other countries have to keep acting to clean up China’s mess? Shouldn’t China be responsible for that?
Also, given that China concealed the full extent of the outbreak for as long as they could, I disagree that the rest of the world had a fair opportunity to deal with it.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by thatswrong0 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:09AM
(#22573331)
The first US case of coronavirus was confirmed on January 20th. That's 53 days.. it took 53 days for the president of the U.S. to officially address the issue publicly. Most other countries were complacent as well.
We have had a fair opportunity to deal with it and prepare. We knew how contagious and dangerous it was. We could have screened all people coming into the United States internationally, and we could have started creating way more tests and have been testing people at a much greater degree and tracing people's connections to figure out who is at greater risk, and maybe even considered quarantining people as a precaution for a few days. The first case confirmed in the U.S. literally was in Wuhan and came back on January 15th. But we didn't do shit, and we still haven't really done shit, because we have been complacent and have been waiting to see what happens, like most other countries.
I get in concept what you're trying to argue for, but there's really nothing we can do to punish China for the corruption that allowed the wildlife markets to exist in the deplorable state they did that initially transferred the virus. And while they probably did try to cover it up for a bit, they also probably didn't know what they were dealing with at first. And they were also trying to squash it and implemented pretty draconian measures by our standards to put a stop to it.. they had many fewer cases than the U.S. currently does before implementing them.
I mean we could issue sanctions I guess.. but you would have to think about how that would affect our economy because we are so interconnected to them via trade. At this point I don't think our economy needs even more chaos and turmoil.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by scurvy on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:19AM
(#22573373)
>We have had a fair opportunity to deal with it and prepare. We knew how contagious and dangerous it was. We could have screened all people coming into the United States internationally<
How? Keep them at the airport for two days while the test results were out? Temperature screening here proved ineffective.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by cryptonector on Saturday March 14, 2020 @02:50AM
(#22573640)
Given the difficulty we've had getting a testing program going, the only thing that could have been done here in the U.S. is to shut down international travel -- not just to affected areas, but ultimately, everywhere, for a while. We're generally very reluctant to do that sort of thing, and yet the government did shut down travel from China.
BTW, January 15 was around the time of impeachment, wasn't it. Ah yes, the articles were sent the day after. For many of the 53 days you mention, our collective attention was utterly consumed here by the trial. Everyone knew non-removal was a forgone conclusion, and that the trial was distracting. Now I wonder if it distracted from responding to covid-19.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by scurvy on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:16AM
(#22573360)
To be fair, you're right that China embargoed virus samples from leaving the country. That did put other countries at a disadvantage from creating functional test kits.
They also covered it up until the whistleblower came along.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by imiric on Saturday March 14, 2020 @03:14AM
(#22573719)
The difference is that those social practices don't introduce novel viruses to humans, whereas the handling of wild animals does. There are popular beliefs in China that consuming certain animal parts will bring health and well-being: tiger heart for courage, bear paw as an aphrodisiac, etc.
While unhygienic social practices are common around the world, and will cause further spreading of the disease, the mythology around food and more importantly the very unsanitary ways wild game is prepared and sold in China is what causes outbreaks of this kind.
I don't believe any sort of retribution towards China because of this is necessary, but they need to be pressured into banning these cultural customs and educating their people.
Re:Understanding SARS-CoV-2 and the drugs that might lessen ...
by BubRoss on Saturday March 14, 2020 @01:14AM
(#22573355)
It isn't the million muslims imprisoned in modern concentration camps that they should be held accountable for? That is actually something the government is actively doing, not just something that originated inside of china.
The ships plying global sea trade started spreading plague epidemics no later than the 1500s. (Not to mention colonization, or Columbus.) War made the so-called Spanish flu widespread. We're not sure yet whether that one started in Kansas.
Both moved a lot slower than today's airplanes. They've become the disease's vector of choice ... and hugely bear the responsibility for accelerating regional epidemics into global ones.
How long did it take to shut down air travel once Wuhan happened? Why is that? Taiwan was expected to be badly hit. Take a close look at Taiwan's route to success. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2762689
https://fox5sandiego.com/news/china-makes-eating-wild-animal...
[0]: https://ncbiinsights.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2020/01/13/novel-coron...
[1]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/genbank/sars-cov-2-seqs/
A zoonotic virus could have been isolated and stored.
$1 trillion at least.
You think they can't do something to reduce the risk of this calamity from happening again?
Cultures can change. Ancient practices that had limited risks when everybody lived in remote villages must change to adopt to the modern society. There is a lot of people in China that want to ban these markets. I'm not sure about Southeast Asia.
https://www.history.com/news/why-was-the-1918-influenza-pand...
I feel like this makes me sound like John Bolton, and that's kind of scary.
If nuclear can be supervised and contained - you can contain gain of function research too.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC416634/
https://www.the-scientist.com/news-analysis/sars-escaped-bei...
https://www.voanews.com/archive/who-beijing-lab-blame-sars-o...
Lab breaks of SARS, another coronavirus have happened a number of times, and likely caused the original SARS outbreak (according to WHO)
This regional phenomena happens to be right across the river, 20 miles, next to the only BSL4 level lab in the region.
That same lab also happens to have published hundreds of synthetic coronavirus genomes. They also ran gain of function research that was banned by NIH until recently, due to it's highly questionable ethics and biosafety in principle.
It's just another lab break, why is it so hard to accept that industrial accidents happen?
SARS, according to WHO, was a lab break too.
What kind of damages would China be liable for 50-60% globally infected, with 3-4% deaths?
That is why the evidence will be suppressed, and the inconvenient voices silenced.
We don't need new drugs.
Outbreaks will continue on happening as long as we have gain of function research programs in place.
They will literally try to come up with new strains resistant to current treatments, if such research continues to be done.
Time for international oversight, just like with nuclear.
We need to stop unethical gain of function research. It should only ever be approved if the outbreak can be actually contained and victims treated - with monetary penalties in place for consequences.
You might need to register (it's free) to watch but it's worth it.
https://connect.myesr.org/course/novel-coronavirus-outbreak-...
The idea is that by adding soluble rhACE2 to the serum, the virus will bind to that rather than real ACE2 in the cells, reducing viral load.
This is not the flu - it can attack multiple organs where ACE2 is expressed - deep in the lungs, heart, stomach lining, kidneys. I've seen other studies which indicated it can affect the central nervous system too. It's not as deadly as SARS but much more contagious. And we still don't have a clear picture what permanent lung/organ damage is inflicted to some recovered patients.
https://youtu.be/jAW6VBWTiAA
https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(20)30229-4
Or just stop the page loading when it shows the full text, before it gets hidden by the JS popup.
This isn't specific to China. The most probably cause of SIV => HIV transmission is also bushmeat [1]. The challenge is that many regions of the world have become mobile and interconnected faster than they've removed high-risk "survival activities" (the portion of China near Wuhan is apparently filled with bats, making them an historically important food source). China has banned all wild animal markets, like they did after SARS [2], but it's important to remember that many folks grew up with an incredibly different setting than today in the China/India/Equitorial Guinea of their 1960s childhood.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simian_immunodeficiency_viru...
[2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/china-bans...
Nobody with any power to censure China is able to point fingers, since these politicians and leaders have failed to protect their own people at least as much as China failed to contain the virus, and with less excuse. Also, practically speaking, there is just no mechanism to enforce any kind of sanction on China for this.
You’re missing my point. Why should the other countries have to keep acting to clean up China’s mess? Shouldn’t China be responsible for that?
Also, given that China concealed the full extent of the outbreak for as long as they could, I disagree that the rest of the world had a fair opportunity to deal with it.
We have had a fair opportunity to deal with it and prepare. We knew how contagious and dangerous it was. We could have screened all people coming into the United States internationally, and we could have started creating way more tests and have been testing people at a much greater degree and tracing people's connections to figure out who is at greater risk, and maybe even considered quarantining people as a precaution for a few days. The first case confirmed in the U.S. literally was in Wuhan and came back on January 15th. But we didn't do shit, and we still haven't really done shit, because we have been complacent and have been waiting to see what happens, like most other countries.
I get in concept what you're trying to argue for, but there's really nothing we can do to punish China for the corruption that allowed the wildlife markets to exist in the deplorable state they did that initially transferred the virus. And while they probably did try to cover it up for a bit, they also probably didn't know what they were dealing with at first. And they were also trying to squash it and implemented pretty draconian measures by our standards to put a stop to it.. they had many fewer cases than the U.S. currently does before implementing them.
I mean we could issue sanctions I guess.. but you would have to think about how that would affect our economy because we are so interconnected to them via trade. At this point I don't think our economy needs even more chaos and turmoil.
How? Keep them at the airport for two days while the test results were out? Temperature screening here proved ineffective.
Israel also expelled all tourists. We're dealing with very different legal systems and mindsets.
BTW, January 15 was around the time of impeachment, wasn't it. Ah yes, the articles were sent the day after. For many of the 53 days you mention, our collective attention was utterly consumed here by the trial. Everyone knew non-removal was a forgone conclusion, and that the trial was distracting. Now I wonder if it distracted from responding to covid-19.
They also covered it up until the whistleblower came along.
Don't Italy and Iran both practice a kiss greeting? A ka "la bise"?
Koreans have a rich history of sharing meals and eating from the same pot.
Could hardly call those practices hygenic. But the point is they've existed forever and probably aren't about to stop because of this.
Watch throwing stones in glass houses.
While unhygienic social practices are common around the world, and will cause further spreading of the disease, the mythology around food and more importantly the very unsanitary ways wild game is prepared and sold in China is what causes outbreaks of this kind.
I don't believe any sort of retribution towards China because of this is necessary, but they need to be pressured into banning these cultural customs and educating their people.
https://www.history.com/news/why-was-the-1918-influenza-pand...
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC340389/