News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by hugi on Saturday March 07, 2020 @07:08PM (#22515181)
Personally I'm sincerely grateful there's at least one company that gives a shit about my privacy. And I will never understand why some people choose to attack them for it.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by cageface on Saturday March 07, 2020 @07:19PM (#22515234)
Because no matter how much you trust Apple's good intentions now you also have to trust them in perpetuity. When you relinquish your own power and agency to a third party it can be very hard to get it back. Maybe you trust Apple and Tim Cook today but do you trust their next CEO and the next?

It's the same reason I don't let Google keep any of my browsing and location history even though I might benefit from that as a user today. I don't trust what they might want to do with that data later.

If you think any billion dollar company is acting in any interests but its own you're being naive.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by swayvil on Saturday March 07, 2020 @08:06PM (#22515524)
Srsly. For a corporation goodness is an investment in future badness. Like that Pink Floyd song, "Dogs".
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by sjwright on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:34AM (#22517372)
Your logic defeats your own argument. If we shouldn't trust billion dollar companies it stands to reason that the fewer few billion dollar companies we trust, the better. If you're already in the iPhone ecosystem, you're already placing a lot of trust in Apple. So using Sign In With Apple means trusting a company that you already trust.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by cageface on Sunday March 08, 2020 @09:28PM (#22522107)
I don't trust any of them. The point is Android gives me an escape hatch. If necessary I can use an Android phone and apps without ever logging into any Google service. This isn't possible on an iPhone
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by tatersolid on Monday March 09, 2020 @08:27AM (#22524808)
”If necessary I can use an Android phone and apps without ever logging into any Google service.”

I don’t think this is actually feasible in practice. I’ve never encountered a real person using a Google-free android device as their daily driver in the wild. I work in security, and actually ask android users I encounter if they are worried about GOOG data collection or whatever. Nobody ever responds with “I’m Google-free”.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by sjwright on Monday March 09, 2020 @04:00PM (#22529146)
You’re still placing a shitload of trust into Google if you’re relying on their binaries to keep your data private.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by hugi on Saturday March 07, 2020 @07:37PM (#22515369)
What data are you talking about? They're explicitly doing this to prevent the ad companies (Google and Facebook) from collecting data.

What data is Apple collecting?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by cageface on Saturday March 07, 2020 @07:42PM (#22515399)
My concern with Apple isn't about collecting data it's about removing choices. I can't sideload apps on my iPhone, even if they might be essential to fighting a totalitarian government (HKMaps). I can't use any browser but Safari on what is supposedly my phone. I can't buy books through the Kindle app without paying Apple a 30% cut.

Honestly this stuff scares me more than the data collection that Google does, for example, because at least I have some control there. And Apple's privacy controls are kind of moot anyway if I use iCloud and all my data is just one subpoena away from anybody that wants it.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by i386 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @01:51AM (#22516704)
> I can't sideload apps on my iPhone

Then don’t buy one. Highly competitive market where you can buy others where this is possible.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by saagarjha on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:34AM (#22516814)
Shutting down any conversation of "I'd like to be able to do this with my iPhone" with a condescending "don't buy it, duh" disregards any of the reasons why people might want to buy iPhones (some of which were mentioned in this very thread) and is, IMO, a lazy argument.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by kimsant on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:17AM (#22517126)
worst argument ever. Don't use Google, don't use Facebook, don't buy apple, and finally if you don't like NSA traking your calls leave America, this like it is, just leave if you don't like it... well, nop
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by m-p-3 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @10:01AM (#22518052)
So privacy or freedom, pick one.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Betelgeuse90 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:57PM (#22519061)
Just a sidetone about HKMaps - as far as I know it was always available on the mobile web.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by neotek on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:33PM (#22516367)
There are multiple ways to sideload apps on iOS, with and without a paid developer account, and without having to jailbreak.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by saagarjha on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:35AM (#22516816)
With a fairly annoying set of limitations if you don't have a paid account or won't use a jailbreak.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by mcphage on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:31PM (#22516355)
> I can't use any browser but Safari on what is supposedly my phone.

You can use one of a number of browsers on you phone. The browser developers are the ones who are constrained, having to use the WebKit rendering engine—but then, it’s not their phone.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by 43920 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:41PM (#22516386)
Does the distinction actually matter though? By constraining what developers can provide, you're automatically constraining what users can use, so I don't see how it makes a difference.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by millstone on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:00AM (#22516727)
Non-WebKit based iOS browsers are zero, and non-Chromium based Android browsers rounds to zero. So I don't think the distinction is very important, if it exists.

It's silly to cast the mobile browser wars in abstract terms, as if JoesOwnWebBrowser is going to be a thing tomorrow. It's Google and Apple, full stop. Google is leveraging their titanic web properties and mobile ecosystem control to push Chrome. Apple is using their control over the iOS ecosystem to retain Safari. The choice is whether the mobile web has two relevant players, or one.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by jeswin on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:53AM (#22516878)
There are other browsers with significant market share on Android, such as UC Browser. The reason they have chosen Chromium as the base is because it is easier for them to build on it, and not because Google enforced it as a policy on Android.

That's an important distinction. Apple's monopolistic practices prevent better software from succeeding on phones, and I'm disappointed that Apple's anti competitive behavior is excused.

Note: UC Browser is a huge privacy threat and please ask friends and family to uninstall it. But the point still stands.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by millstone on Sunday March 08, 2020 @04:59AM (#22517075)
I honestly can't tell if "Android enables better software like UC Browser which is terrible and please ask your friends and family to uninstall it" is satire or in earnest.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by jeswin on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:05AM (#22517283)
That's not what I implied. What's important is the possibility of something better having a shot at success. One could argue that a browser based on Chromium rather than Webkit, could work better for their needs on iOS. Unfortunately that can't happen on iOS.

And here's a real world example: even if v8 was a better runtime for React Native it still wouldn't be allowed into iOS.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by mcphage on Sunday March 08, 2020 @09:26AM (#22517899)
> Does the distinction actually matter though?

I think so, yeah. Or at least, the idea that the rendering engine is all that matters for a browser is not something I’d just accept without explanation.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by the_gipsy on Sunday March 08, 2020 @07:11AM (#22517476)
This is simply not true. Other browsers on iOS are nothing but wrappers around a worse webview than Safari.

Perpetually missing web features (PN) so that you are forced to make an app, for obvious reasons.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by lsaferite on Sunday March 08, 2020 @01:20AM (#22516622)
> but then, it’s not their phone

And apparently it's not your phone either.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @08:26PM (#22515624)
Well HKMaps is a bad example. You can get the same functionality from a web browser. If you don’t want to be locked into a vendors platform - create a web app.

Does Amazon allow third party book sellers on their Kindle devices? Again, the open web to the rescue. I can go to Amazon’s store from my browser and buy books.

In fact, I use the Kindle web reader on my iPad when reading books about AWS, because the Kindle app doesn’t allow embedded web links to Amazon (even AWS Informational links).

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by cageface on Saturday March 07, 2020 @08:34PM (#22515660)
You can't get the same functionality in a website because Apple has deliberately not supported some web standards like push notifications.

Again you can make the argument that this is to protect users but it also just happens to protect their native app ecosystem.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by floatingatoll on Saturday March 07, 2020 @08:47PM (#22515719)
Thankfully they don’t support web push notifications. What a horrendous standard that’s turned out to be.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by the_gipsy on Sunday March 08, 2020 @07:14AM (#22517484)
Why would it be any better with apps?

I had to uninstall many apps because there was no option to deactivate marketing PNs.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by floatingatoll on Sunday March 08, 2020 @01:54PM (#22519415)
All major mobile platforms let you disable all notifications from apps, sane as website push. Why were you forced to uninstall them to do so?
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by the_gipsy on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:21PM (#22519936)
Because I do want relevant PNs, like a chat message for marketplaces or billing issues, whatever. I couldn't disable something like "offers", "news", "marketing BS".

When I have to turn off PNs completely for an app, there is no reason to have that app installed anymore, I might just use the website.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by floatingatoll on Monday March 09, 2020 @11:18AM (#22526051)
Ah, so you didn’t “have to” uninstall apps, you simply chose to. I misunderstood your comment and retract my earlier “forced to” question, apologies.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @08:50PM (#22515734)
I made a mistake and turned on for Tom’s Hardware - a site that’s I thought was credible. They started spamming me immediately with advertising.

Push notifications only came in handy to keep the battery draining Slack “application” off of my computer.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by manigandham on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:35AM (#22517175)
How is it a bad example when people are using it to fight and evade an oppressive government as we speak?

They did make a web version but it lacks the offline and privacy features of the native app. Apple removing the iOS app is a perfect example of why these big companies can't be trusted with ultimate control.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @09:17AM (#22517864)
Local storage has been supported by mobile Safari since day one for offline usage.

How much more privacy did they get by an app that gets information from the internet than a website?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by manigandham on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:43PM (#22521160)
There are massive limits on local storage on Safari. It's nowhere near what you can do with an app. Also apps aren't limited to using HTTPS connections with unsecured DNS.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @08:24PM (#22521772)
The best I can tell is that you can safely use around 50Mb for local storage.

https://love2dev.com/blog/what-is-the-service-worker-cache-s...

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by floatingatoll on Saturday March 07, 2020 @08:46PM (#22515711)
Given the deal they signed with Radio Shack prohibiting resale of their customer list, I’m inclined to trust them in perpetuity. If they give cause otherwise then I might reconsider, but to date they haven’t.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by hellcow on Saturday March 07, 2020 @09:19PM (#22515875)
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by floatingatoll on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:35PM (#22516371)
I understand and accept that the FBI and other third parties may be able to non-consensually acquire any traffic I send over a network and/or to a third party, using a great many methods including legal summons emplaced against the network and/or third party for the data that I share.

I'm comfortable with that, because I understand the working agreement that exists with my network and third-party services providers (such as Apple), and I understand that they are bound by legal summons in many respects for the data they receive.

Note I don't consider this ideal, and I don't think it's the best possible outcome for society, but I've spent 20 years consciously managing my choices on such matters, ever since DejaNews was founded, and I understand where I stand versus my choices today.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by kyralis on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:46PM (#22516223)
That's FBI spin. Apple's reluctance to drop their own keys for backups is entirely based on the frequency with which they have to recover keys for nontechnical users who have lost their passwords, and you'll note that more and more features are being rolled out in such a way that Apple does not have access.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by sexpositiveuser on Saturday March 07, 2020 @09:11PM (#22515837)
There are porn apps I'd like to be able to create/run but Apple's disallows porn apps forcing me to use some other less private platform if I want to run sex positive porn apps which in effect makes my activity less private. Further, even if they did allow porn apps via the store Apple has a list of all apps I install so they know if I install "tooKinkyToBePublic.app".

They really do need to allow easy side loading and/or alternate stores. I shouldn't have to chose between Apple's nanny-state "no porn apps", "no political apps" allowed and "privacy"

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:16PM (#22516106)
So why do you need a porn “app”? Do I even want to ask what you could do with an app that you can’t do with a website?
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by sexpositiveuser on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:12AM (#22516460)
There are 1000s of porn apps on non-privacy oriented platforms that I'd prefer to be able to run on a privacy prioritized platform.

Examples include CG porn creation apps including Virt-A-Mate, TK17, Honey Select, etc... There are also real time 3D VR porn apps and even AR porn apps

Apple's platform currently limits freedom of expression. Sure you can watch any movie you want or read any website but the future will clearly include interactivity with real time VR, AR, 3D, etc...

Imagine if Apple invented the holodeck but their app store disallowed sex!??!? It's ridiculous that such a "progressive" company has just a poor position on sex positive apps. I get they don't want to sell them in their store which is why they arguably need to over alternatives.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:47PM (#22518991)
How much “privacy” would you get from an app that has access to the internet? iOS only allows you to block cellular access to apps.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by fragmede on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:27PM (#22516344)
Don't be obtuse. There are plenty of things an app can do that can't be accomplished by an website, including being listed in the Apple app store, for one.

Apple hides the ability to add a website to the home screen somewhere inside of Safari, instead of making it a first class feature and including a UI for it in the "App" "store". If they did that, a lot of apps could viably just be a website instead.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:15AM (#22516467)
That didn’t answer the question. What can a porn app do that a website can’t do?

Adding a website to the home screen has been prominent in Safari since 2007. Go to the share sheet and scroll up.

How many websites have a prominent pointer on iOS devices showing you how to do it.

But the App Store is not known to be a place of discoverability.

On top of that, how many mainstream platforms and physical stores allow porn to be prominent? The most popular video site - Youtube - doesn’t allow porn.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by oarsinsync on Sunday March 08, 2020 @04:37AM (#22517000)
> how many mainstream platforms and physical stores allow porn to be prominent

Less than 15 years ago, it used to be common in UK supermarkets for there to be a section at the entrance dedicated to newspapers and magazines. A good section of the top shelf would feature porn magazines. The printed covers of the magazines would generally be masked with some cardboard, so you couldn't see the explicit content by mistake, but could still see the title of the magazine.

Print media is generally in decline, so these sections no longer exist in quite the same form as they used to in supermarkets, but this is as prominent as it needs to be. In the past, this meant it was (literally) out of reach of children, but still readily available to adults, and only if they reach for it.

Why isn't that acceptable anymore?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @11:21AM (#22518430)
Can you buy anything pornographic at Walmart? The various console digital stores?
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Nullabillity on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:19PM (#22518826)
Does Walmart try to prevent you from stuffing anything from Target into the same fridge?
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:23PM (#22518855)
Well seeing that the iPhone is an integrated platform phone + marketplace just like a console + marketplace, when people buy an iPhone they know what tradeoffs their making.

Just like if you don’t like one console makers platform you have two more to choose from, if you don’t like Apple’s you have another one to choose from - the same one chosen by 85% of the market.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Nullabillity on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:28PM (#22518885)
Great, I can pick whether to die by the plague or cholera. The free market is wonderful! And now COVID-19 is giving us consumers even more choices!
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:39PM (#22518948)
It’s better than the government intervening. I can change phone platforms a lot easier than I can change governments. Besides, neither Google nor Apple can take my liberty or property.....
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by manigandham on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:37AM (#22517190)
That's a disingenuous argument. All major companies have created native apps for a reason, many after trying to just use a mobile web version. The features from privacy, offline abilities, data access, sensor access, and more are not available over the web. And users prefer apps over creating Safari shortcuts, if they even know how to do the latter.

Why is it good for a single company to determine what you can and can't do on your phone?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @07:48AM (#22517568)
Well seeing that Apple only has a 15% market share in the phone market, it’s kind of obvious that it’s not a single company controlling the market. Why would anyone who doesn’t like Apple’s policies not just by an Android?
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by manigandham on Sunday March 08, 2020 @08:06AM (#22517614)
The question was about your phone, not the entire market. And saying "just buy something else" isn't a great argument when there are a few massive tech companies controlling everything and enforcing ever more control. Apple has already shown their problematic approach with the situation in Hong Kong.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @09:03AM (#22517809)
But why complain about a phone that only controls 15% of the market, when 85% of phones out there run an operating system that does allow side loading.

And in the particular case of the HkMap app, what functionality did you not get on the website?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by manigandham on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:41PM (#22521145)
Because people want iOS (which has more and better apps) but with control. This is specifically about Apple controlling too much on their phones, and why that's acceptable.

HKMap needs strong offline support since it's an actual map showing dangerous/important areas and people. It also used mesh networking for updates from other devices. Neither is possible on Safari.

I would say that apps aren't as blocked as easily as a website either, but Apple proved that wrong which is the reason for the question on their control.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by saagarjha on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:38AM (#22516826)
> What can a porn app do that a website can’t do?

Oh, come on, you know very well why you'd want a native app: it's the exact same reason why you'd download a native app for anything else; they can be more polished, use platform APIs, download files…

> On top of that, how many mainstream platforms and physical stores allow porn to be prominent? The most popular video site - Youtube - doesn’t allow porn.

Because the ad platform it uses doesn't like it?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @01:48PM (#22519376)
They can be more polished but these days how many apps are using a cross platform framework and/or just wrapping a WebView?

You can upload and download files from Safari on iOS.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by saagarjha on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:34PM (#22521097)
> They can be more polished but these days how many apps are using a cross platform framework and/or just wrapping a WebView?

There's still a decent number that aren't.

> You can upload and download files from Safari on iOS.

The UX on this is significantly worse, even if you consider iOS 13's new downloads manager.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by kalleboo on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:43AM (#22516845)
> What can a porn app do that a website can’t do?

How well do AR/VR/3D applications run in Safari?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Nullabillity on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:27AM (#22517351)
Yes, the share sheet, right where I'd expect to find the install option. Of course! This must be why Apple's designers get paid the big bucks!
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @10:06AM (#22518074)
So how would you recommend that they surface options that are both built in and where third party apps can add extensions?

Some form of the hamburger button has been a standard UI convention since real web browsers came to mobile.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Nullabillity on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:17PM (#22518805)
A generic hamburger menu would be fine. Repurposing a menu that claims to be for something entirely different is not, and reeks of deliberate obtuseness[0].

[0]: https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/40705-but-the-plans-were-on...

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:43PM (#22518968)
Apple never calls it the share sheet in the interface. It’s been a standard option for over 12 years and mobile web designers have been telling users how to do it from before there was an App Store.

There are five buttons at the bottom of an iPhone. Only one brings up a menu.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by strictnein on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:34AM (#22516502)
The amount of tracking data that Apple devices collect is almost almost inconceivable.

It's just that Apple isn't collecting it, the apps on their appstore are, which Apple profits from directly and indirectly.

But, yes, they're doing a really good job marketing themselves as the "privacy" company.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by lstamour on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:53AM (#22516564)
The apps that have been the worst about sharing my private data or telemetry seem to be the same ones that are ad-supported. Apple’s App Store generally doesn’t make money if an app is paid for by ads.

Where Apple traditionally gets profit is in selling more devices, and they do that through controlling apps on the platform.

Alternative approaches could be just as successful. But their approach does differentiate them from other market leaders, while equally (as here) allowing them to play catch-up and advertise themselves alongside Google, Facebook, and other logins.

Apple does marketing, it’s true, but they also try to back up their security and privacy work with white papers: https://www.apple.com/privacy/features/

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by judge2020 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @07:20PM (#22515241)
We'd love everything to check every box (portable between hardware, federated, no lock-in, privacy respecting, etc) but I don't think that's possible.

In reality, this "sign in with apple" feature doesn't push Apple's ecosystem any farther than Apple Maps does. You can use sign in with apple via their web SDK on both desktop browsers and Android, and I wouldn't doubt putting "sign in with apple" in an Android app itself is trivial.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by st3fan on Saturday March 07, 2020 @07:29PM (#22515311)
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by atraac on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:44AM (#22516532)
This is applicable if tou use Firebase Auth. 90% of apps will have to implement it on their own. It's not that hard, but it's usually not trivial as well. It also costs time and money they wouldn't have to spend if they didn't want to include Sign in with Apple option originally. Yet they're now forced to.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Nullabillity on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:32AM (#22517368)
> Requirements:

> - Be signed in to iCloud on an Apple device.

This doesn't help users no longer carry around an Apple device.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by fragmede on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:32PM (#22516360)
Using a login (on multiple apps/sites) that is linked to Apple very much locks me into having Apple in my life for the foreseeable future. It's, like, the definition of vendor lock-in. Apple is currently being magnanimous enough to let me use that same login outside of my phone on their competitors product, but Apple's history of interoperability is not great, so that's not a feature I care to trust them with.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by neotek on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:37PM (#22516374)
So don’t use it. It’s offered alongside other third-party login options. If you trust Facebook more than Apple then by all means log in with Facebook, Apple isn’t stopping you or the people who develop the apps you choose to use.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by jariel on Saturday March 07, 2020 @09:29PM (#22515923)
" And I will never understand why some people choose to attack them for it."

Because it's possibly anti-competitive.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by neotek on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:38PM (#22516378)
In what sense could it be considered anti-competitive to require an additional login method alongside existing ones?
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by cageface on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:53PM (#22516412)
Because the other services have to be good enough to earn a place on that login screen. Apple is using their control over the app store to insist they get that place for free.

If their service is as good as they claim and it's something that users really want then why do they have to make it mandatory?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by jariel on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:03AM (#22516436)
Controlling one part of the value chain to force behaviour in a different part of the value chain.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by fierarul on Sunday March 08, 2020 @04:16AM (#22516931)
When what you are requiring is your own additional method?
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Kuinox on Saturday March 07, 2020 @07:29PM (#22515310)
Because they don't give a shit about your privacy, it's only marketing stuff. The only reason they can argue that it's because their income is not based on exploiting your data. Multiple time per year your can see articles on HN how Apple breached privacy of their users.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by conradev on Saturday March 07, 2020 @08:02PM (#22515500)
What people don't seem to realize is that Apple was actually pushing the envelope on privacy before they realized they could lean into it as an advantage.

They released per-app access controls in iOS 6[1] (which was huge!) in 2012 and didn't bother to mention it in their marketing[2]. The reviews of the update don't mention it either[3]. The same feature landed in Android 6.0 three years later.

[1] https://www.cultofmac.com/173128/new-ios-6-privacy-settings-...

[2] https://web.archive.org/web/20120615175407/http://www.apple....

[3] https://www.theverge.com/2012/9/21/3363060/ios-6-review

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Kuinox on Monday March 09, 2020 @12:17PM (#22526590)
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by millstone on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:38PM (#22516194)
Apple is leaving a ton of money on the table, because they care about privacy. There's a reason the adtech industry howls so hard when Apple pulls moves like this.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by hugi on Saturday March 07, 2020 @07:34PM (#22515352)
Really? I didn't know that. Please show me all the times Apple has breached my privacy.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by slivanes on Saturday March 07, 2020 @08:10PM (#22515540)
Apple's default search engine is Google - they sold it to the highest bidder, a company that absorbs your private info.

Chinese citizens do not receive the benefits of the rest of the world. Apple will remove apps from the store that could benefit its citizen's freedoms at the whim of that government to allow themselves to remain in that market.

Your iCloud backups are not encrypted on Apple servers.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by nemothekid on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:46PM (#22516222)
None of these are breaches. They are all explictily spelled out in the terms of service, and regarding the first option, you are free to change it.

Apple not doing things your way doesn't constitute a breach.

>Chinese citizens do not receive the benefits of the rest of the world.

How is this Apple's fault? The Chinese government explicitly prevents their citizens from having those benefits.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by alwillis on Saturday March 07, 2020 @09:07PM (#22515817)
Apple's default search engine is Google - they sold it to the highest bidder, a company that absorbs your private info.

And Safari stops Google and other 3rd-party ad providers from tracking you all over the web.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by CogitoCogito on Saturday March 07, 2020 @08:02PM (#22515499)
Apple sets an advertising ID by default that applications use to uniquely identify you. This allows mass surveillance. It is antithetical to all of Apple's claims to support privacy.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by jedieaston on Saturday March 07, 2020 @08:38PM (#22515684)
Limit Ad Tracking was turned on by default after a fresh install of iOS 13 on my phone. I don’t think they give you one by default.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by CogitoCogito on Sunday March 08, 2020 @01:00AM (#22516579)
I can't speak for iOS 13, but it's been reset to "off" for me (as in "don't limit tracking") both times I factory reset my phone. I've never heard of it being set to on by default. If that's some new change then they only made a mockery of their claims to support privacy for the last decade or so. Hardly impressive since they never should have had it by default anyway.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by CogitoCogito on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:45PM (#22518976)
Why am I receiving downvotes? I can't find any information supporting any claims that Apple is setting "limit ad tracking" by default on any versions. Here is some relevant information:

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT205223

I would be very curious (and happy!) to receive any information indicating that I'm wrong in my belief that ad tracking is not being limited by default.

edit: I am not sure if this source is correct, but it does agree with me:

https://threatpost.com/privacy-iphone-apples-targeted-ad-tra...

"A unique identifier is enabled by default on every iPhone that’s shipped, allowing advertisers to follow the phone’s activity across the web."

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Kuinox on Monday March 09, 2020 @12:16PM (#22526583)
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by aschatten on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:03PM (#22516056)
Apple is not the only company, that gives a shit about privacy. And if they are pnly marginally better: https://www.eff.org/who-has-your-back-2017
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Tomte on Sunday March 08, 2020 @04:32AM (#22516992)
I'm sorry, but a scorecard where Uber, of all companies, gets a perfect score, simply isn't credible to me.

Remember, that's the Uber that tracked people, identified by name, and showed their location to guests at a party on a map. Just for entertainment.

It's the same Uber that has had so many privacy and customer data scandals, I have lost count.

But sure, they "have our back".

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by mosselman on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:29AM (#22517159)
That list is a total joke. The EFF should be ashamed of it.