News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:16PM (#22516106)
So why do you need a porn “app”? Do I even want to ask what you could do with an app that you can’t do with a website?
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by sexpositiveuser on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:12AM (#22516460)
There are 1000s of porn apps on non-privacy oriented platforms that I'd prefer to be able to run on a privacy prioritized platform.

Examples include CG porn creation apps including Virt-A-Mate, TK17, Honey Select, etc... There are also real time 3D VR porn apps and even AR porn apps

Apple's platform currently limits freedom of expression. Sure you can watch any movie you want or read any website but the future will clearly include interactivity with real time VR, AR, 3D, etc...

Imagine if Apple invented the holodeck but their app store disallowed sex!??!? It's ridiculous that such a "progressive" company has just a poor position on sex positive apps. I get they don't want to sell them in their store which is why they arguably need to over alternatives.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:47PM (#22518991)
How much “privacy” would you get from an app that has access to the internet? iOS only allows you to block cellular access to apps.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by fragmede on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:27PM (#22516344)
Don't be obtuse. There are plenty of things an app can do that can't be accomplished by an website, including being listed in the Apple app store, for one.

Apple hides the ability to add a website to the home screen somewhere inside of Safari, instead of making it a first class feature and including a UI for it in the "App" "store". If they did that, a lot of apps could viably just be a website instead.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:15AM (#22516467)
That didn’t answer the question. What can a porn app do that a website can’t do?

Adding a website to the home screen has been prominent in Safari since 2007. Go to the share sheet and scroll up.

How many websites have a prominent pointer on iOS devices showing you how to do it.

But the App Store is not known to be a place of discoverability.

On top of that, how many mainstream platforms and physical stores allow porn to be prominent? The most popular video site - Youtube - doesn’t allow porn.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by oarsinsync on Sunday March 08, 2020 @04:37AM (#22517000)
> how many mainstream platforms and physical stores allow porn to be prominent

Less than 15 years ago, it used to be common in UK supermarkets for there to be a section at the entrance dedicated to newspapers and magazines. A good section of the top shelf would feature porn magazines. The printed covers of the magazines would generally be masked with some cardboard, so you couldn't see the explicit content by mistake, but could still see the title of the magazine.

Print media is generally in decline, so these sections no longer exist in quite the same form as they used to in supermarkets, but this is as prominent as it needs to be. In the past, this meant it was (literally) out of reach of children, but still readily available to adults, and only if they reach for it.

Why isn't that acceptable anymore?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @11:21AM (#22518430)
Can you buy anything pornographic at Walmart? The various console digital stores?
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Nullabillity on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:19PM (#22518826)
Does Walmart try to prevent you from stuffing anything from Target into the same fridge?
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:23PM (#22518855)
Well seeing that the iPhone is an integrated platform phone + marketplace just like a console + marketplace, when people buy an iPhone they know what tradeoffs their making.

Just like if you don’t like one console makers platform you have two more to choose from, if you don’t like Apple’s you have another one to choose from - the same one chosen by 85% of the market.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Nullabillity on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:28PM (#22518885)
Great, I can pick whether to die by the plague or cholera. The free market is wonderful! And now COVID-19 is giving us consumers even more choices!
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:39PM (#22518948)
It’s better than the government intervening. I can change phone platforms a lot easier than I can change governments. Besides, neither Google nor Apple can take my liberty or property.....
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by manigandham on Sunday March 08, 2020 @05:37AM (#22517190)
That's a disingenuous argument. All major companies have created native apps for a reason, many after trying to just use a mobile web version. The features from privacy, offline abilities, data access, sensor access, and more are not available over the web. And users prefer apps over creating Safari shortcuts, if they even know how to do the latter.

Why is it good for a single company to determine what you can and can't do on your phone?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @07:48AM (#22517568)
Well seeing that Apple only has a 15% market share in the phone market, it’s kind of obvious that it’s not a single company controlling the market. Why would anyone who doesn’t like Apple’s policies not just by an Android?
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by manigandham on Sunday March 08, 2020 @08:06AM (#22517614)
The question was about your phone, not the entire market. And saying "just buy something else" isn't a great argument when there are a few massive tech companies controlling everything and enforcing ever more control. Apple has already shown their problematic approach with the situation in Hong Kong.
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @09:03AM (#22517809)
But why complain about a phone that only controls 15% of the market, when 85% of phones out there run an operating system that does allow side loading.

And in the particular case of the HkMap app, what functionality did you not get on the website?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by manigandham on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:41PM (#22521145)
Because people want iOS (which has more and better apps) but with control. This is specifically about Apple controlling too much on their phones, and why that's acceptable.

HKMap needs strong offline support since it's an actual map showing dangerous/important areas and people. It also used mesh networking for updates from other devices. Neither is possible on Safari.

I would say that apps aren't as blocked as easily as a website either, but Apple proved that wrong which is the reason for the question on their control.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by saagarjha on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:38AM (#22516826)
> What can a porn app do that a website can’t do?

Oh, come on, you know very well why you'd want a native app: it's the exact same reason why you'd download a native app for anything else; they can be more polished, use platform APIs, download files…

> On top of that, how many mainstream platforms and physical stores allow porn to be prominent? The most popular video site - Youtube - doesn’t allow porn.

Because the ad platform it uses doesn't like it?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @01:48PM (#22519376)
They can be more polished but these days how many apps are using a cross platform framework and/or just wrapping a WebView?

You can upload and download files from Safari on iOS.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by saagarjha on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:34PM (#22521097)
> They can be more polished but these days how many apps are using a cross platform framework and/or just wrapping a WebView?

There's still a decent number that aren't.

> You can upload and download files from Safari on iOS.

The UX on this is significantly worse, even if you consider iOS 13's new downloads manager.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by kalleboo on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:43AM (#22516845)
> What can a porn app do that a website can’t do?

How well do AR/VR/3D applications run in Safari?

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Nullabillity on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:27AM (#22517351)
Yes, the share sheet, right where I'd expect to find the install option. Of course! This must be why Apple's designers get paid the big bucks!
Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @10:06AM (#22518074)
So how would you recommend that they surface options that are both built in and where third party apps can add extensions?

Some form of the hamburger button has been a standard UI convention since real web browsers came to mobile.

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by Nullabillity on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:17PM (#22518805)
A generic hamburger menu would be fine. Repurposing a menu that claims to be for something entirely different is not, and reeks of deliberate obtuseness[0].

[0]: https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/40705-but-the-plans-were-on...

Re:iOS now requires Sign On with Apple alongside other auth ... by scarface74 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:43PM (#22518968)
Apple never calls it the share sheet in the interface. It’s been a standard option for over 12 years and mobile web designers have been telling users how to do it from before there was an App Store.

There are five buttons at the bottom of an iPhone. Only one brings up a menu.