There’s no reason to believe that. Criminals are just as lazy and stupid as everyone else. If e2e requires an extra step, fewer will use it. If it comes with their phones’ built-in messenger, more will use it.
Every unencrypted E-mail, SMS, ICQ chat among criminals of the past is evidence here: they could have all used PGP, or one-time pads. But they didn’t. For the same reason nobody in this thread has ever used a custom one-time pad implementation for any real communication: it’s fun to imagine when you’re in the shower planning your evil empire, but it sucks in reality.
Note that I agree that this law is a particularly stupid idea, and that e2e encryption should be considered a universal right. It’s just this argument I don’t buy.
You and I don't use custom e2e software because there are good products already available.
To somewhat counter the point about unencrypted communication between criminals, see the leaked opsec guides of some terrorist organizations. They're fairly sophisticated and it seems unlikely that lack of legally available solutions would prevent them from acquiring replacements.
You can't blame someone for not knowing what they don't know, but lawmakers are supposed to enact laws based on the benefit for their citizens. Seems not to be the case here.
Am I missing something?
Your pre-shared OTP can be a rack of 8TB hard drives delivered to an embassy by the Marine Corps which covers a whole lot of documents and media before it's exhausted.
After exchanging keys and pads in person, plug the device into a computer like a flash thumbdrive, and (with hypothetical software support) both people can now use the keys for end-to-end encryption without having to worry about authentication, and a utility could perform OTP while keeping track of how much random pad is remaining. If they want more pad, leave the devices plugged in longer. The actual encryption should be performed on the device, so the host computer never sees the keys/pad.
As long as crypto is hard to use, people will rely on centralized men in the middle. A key chain dongle that you could simply connect to your friend's dongle for a few seconds (or longer, if desires) is easy. Instead of trying to solve the entire authentication problem with PKI or web-of-trust, you let people solve the authentication problem themselves, using the social skills they already have. Yes, this isn't useful for communicating with someone you cannot meet physically; use some other solution for those situations.
(Imagine if this became popular and you could simply go to the local branch of your bank and plug your crypto dongle into a kiosk that generates a few months worth of random pad data so all of your online banking is secured by OTP)
[1] OTP requires truly random data, which probably requires some type of hardware entropy generator. Perhaps something like this: http://holdenc.altervista.org/avalanche/
Yubikey fits pretty close, I think. What purpose would you need it to be battery powered if it's USB?
The Yubikey has similar storage features and is the perfect size and shape. Unfortunately, it's missing the main feature I'm talking about: easy inter-device communication.
> What purpose would you need it to be battery powered if it's USB?
It needs to be self powered because
>> The key feature of the device is that touching two of the devices together
I want people to be able to protect their communication with someone simply by meeting them in person and touching their USB crypto devices together. It should be a device someone stores on their person along with their other security devices like their house/car keys. The goal is to make the crypto easy so the individual can use it in situations where they already solved the authentication problem. If exchanging keys with someone depends on something complex like a computer or phone, a lot of people won't use it.
I've mentioned this before, but I'd like to write a children's book that teaches one-time-pads. The book ends with little Jimmy getting hauled away by the feds for doing illegal math. Fun for children and parents!
The point of course, is to make clear how futile encryption restrictions are, and to perhaps make people wonder if it's really "the land of a free" when a child can commit a crime by doing some math. Fortunately, I think we're still a ways off from encryption being a crime.
I absolutely love this. Animal Farm comes to mind.
Please write this, our descendants need those echoes from the past.
In this case, you'd only need the asymmetric encryption to distribute the one-time pads.
No tinfoil hat needed unless we ask why Barr has made this a personal crusade.
To speak to your point on Barr, and I'll try to be neutral here, his motivations might very well be positive to protect the US people but the method is really panning out to be damaging long term.
Realistically, it will amplify signals/readings, so, it's outdated.
Anyway, what happens when messaging with ciphertext becomes illegal?
Back in the late 90s, Ron Rivest proposed Chaffing and Winnowing [0]. In that scheme, no ciphertext is transmitted and therefore no encryption is involved; only plausible plaintext is transmitted. The receiver filters out the chaff, leaving only the intended message. Perhaps one could construct an end-to-end winnow-chaff scheme (E2EWC) to replace existing E2EE schemes.
Does that mean that implementing your own protocol becomes illegal too? And even your own programming language.
> Anyway, what happens when messaging with ciphertext becomes illegal?
Those who have nefarious intentions don't really care what the legality is.. Also those who are not nefarious encrypted aren't identified because they're encrypted.. Thats why this argument seems very.. Moronic at best.
Honestly, with my cynical hat on, I feel this is actually being pushed by the marketing and advertisement lobbyists, such as Facebook, google and others, in order to data mine for advertisers into your communications..
Maybe my tinfoil hat is a little bit too big, but I really use encrypted communications so that at least there is one dialogue that's not being warped into advertisements for me.
I genuinely fear for future generations privacy, in all regards. It's worrying and it really does deserve more attention. It's so crazy to my younger nieces and nephews that when I was their age, I didn't have a phone. It blows their minds. And I'm only in my 30's.