News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The EARN IT act is an attack on end-to-end encryption by KarlKemp on Saturday March 07, 2020 @02:00AM (#22510241)
This assumption comes up again and again: that criminals are somehow motivated and competent enough to use encryption even when the easiest way to do it are no longer available.

There’s no reason to believe that. Criminals are just as lazy and stupid as everyone else. If e2e requires an extra step, fewer will use it. If it comes with their phones’ built-in messenger, more will use it.

Every unencrypted E-mail, SMS, ICQ chat among criminals of the past is evidence here: they could have all used PGP, or one-time pads. But they didn’t. For the same reason nobody in this thread has ever used a custom one-time pad implementation for any real communication: it’s fun to imagine when you’re in the shower planning your evil empire, but it sucks in reality.

Note that I agree that this law is a particularly stupid idea, and that e2e encryption should be considered a universal right. It’s just this argument I don’t buy.

Re:The EARN IT act is an attack on end-to-end encryption by kag0 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:51AM (#22512500)
The thing you're overlooking is financial motive. If there's money to be made selling illegal secure communications software to criminal enterprises, then someone will make that software available and easy to use.

You and I don't use custom e2e software because there are good products already available.

To somewhat counter the point about unencrypted communication between criminals, see the leaked opsec guides of some terrorist organizations. They're fairly sophisticated and it seems unlikely that lack of legally available solutions would prevent them from acquiring replacements.