Just like a lot of people I know will tip 20% on a restaurant bill without even reflecting on the level of the service, because it's so ingrained into people that wait staff rely almost entirely on tips for their livelihoods so people feel guilty using this quality signal mechanism the way it was initially intended.
US tipping etiquette has nothing to do with good service and all to do with propping up underpaid staff.
As for US tipping etiquette, cactus2093's point was that current US tipping doesn't really reflect what was originally intended. But kingkawn made a claim that extended past the current US tipping practices.
The entirety of their livelihood is dependent on our judgements of their service.
But repeating the pattern, that's a state rule. Different parts of the state don't exempt jobs from minimum wage. (God, I'm glad I'm not a lawyer). In San Francisco, for example, the minimum wage is $15.59, and as far as I can tell, it holds whether you're tipped or not.
Federal minimum wage is 7.25 after taxes this is about 250 per week wherein most people in this situation are paid every 2 weeks. That is to say that one cannot expect to have more than 2 paychecks per calendar month for a grand total of $1000. If you didn't need food, clothes, medicine, or anything else this is about enough for rent.
What this means is that the employee/employer relationship not to mention the individuals ability to live indoors and have food is actually predicated on the ability to achieve greater than minimum wage. Tipping out even if they can do so isn't enough to keep anyone afloat. Not tipping in a state that has a tipped minimum wage is not that much different from dining and dashing its just not illegal because its never been illegal to screw someone if they are substantially poorer than you.
In general, it's been extremely difficult to read between the lines on reviews since they're all five stars, and sometimes you end up reading things unintentionally.
They’re not entirely explicit about it, but to leave anything less than 5 stars AirBnB you have to leave a text explanation of why you did. So it becomes clear quickly that 5 is the norm and less is for an actual problem.
Once Uber started asking me a thousand questions about why I was leaving someone 4-stars, I stopped leaving reviews entirely.
I also think that it's different for restaurants than for drivers. When looking for restaurants whether in my home city or traveling, of course we look at 4 stars or above. But never have I once looked a driver's rating, I just call a car and take the first one that is assigned to me, cancelling only for reasons not related to ratings at all. Maybe it's just me that does that?
> Today the average rating on Yelp sits in between “A-OK.” (3) and “Yay! I’m a fan.” (4).
src: https://blog.yelp.com/2018/09/restaurant-ratings-on-yelp-are...
Hosts must hate him.
At the end of the day most people just want to know if people think a service, movie, driver, seller, etc. is worth it or not * . If you need more info you are going to read the reviews anyway.
* An exception might be niche user review communities like myanimelist or rateyourmusic
You're looking at a jacket and you see that while some people rate it 5/5, most of the ratings are 4/5 and 3/5, and 85% of the reviewers say they would recommend the jacket to a friend.
So you read the reviews, and gather that most of the medium scores are because the arms are a little shorter than expected and the cut across the back is rather wide. You also notice that everyone is praising the quality of the fabric and worksmanship. Good information, since if you have short arms and the back muscles of a powerlifter, that jacket would probably be a good purchase.
That is good use of a scoring system, but it requires people to care about it and about writing reviews. It works for niche sites, but completely breaks down somewhere like Amazon, or on Uber/Airbnb where you get punished for anything less than a perfect score.
The difference between the critic rating and the user rating is useful information to have when making a viewing decision. If they are both low, that tells you something. If one is low and one is high, that tells you something.
The sane way to do it would be to ask yes no questions, but that would require thinking.
Nearly every time I have a bad experience with a company the problem is systemic, but a bad rating will be associated with the random person who served me. So I don't participate. If the problem is particularly bad I find another supplier.
Even if the company has systemic problems, they still need to pay bills as long as they still have the job.
Finding another company is a smart option. I'd also write to the management to explain why that problem is blocking you from doing business with them, without mentioning who you spoke with.
Basically the same as our current 5 star/1 star dichotomy but it makes things more clear to people who are tempted to give 4 stars.
I just mark favorite tracks and favorite albums. The track and album ratings are separate, because I might love an album as a whole, but also have a couple of individual favorite tracks on that album.
And I don't have any music in my collection that I don't like or am completely "meh" about. If it's in my library, I already love it, the question is whether it's an all-time favorite or not.
As a longtime Airbnb user I can't imagine staying at a place just because it has a good star rating. You have to read the reviews and see what people liked and didn't like. If a place has a bad star rating I generally wouldn't consider staying there at all, but a 4.8 star rating with lots of substantive reviews and no real complaints is very different from a 4.8 star rating with a bunch of people noting that there's deafening construction noise from 8AM to 8PM.
Also, how would anyone retaliate on Airbnb? You can't see the host's review until after you've posted your own.
I guess from a strategic point of view it might look better for the AirBnB's and Ubers of this world to have lots of '4.7 out of 5' ratings than 'xx% of people wanted the service provider to be punished', especially to first-time users. But yeah, if Uber in particular wanted to honestly represent what the ratings actually represented it'd be a simple upvote/downvote.
Ironically, on platforms more focused on allowing consumers to choose based on qualitative reviews than penalising based on quantitative scores, I tend to find 4* reviews are much more likely to be well-informed enough to influence me into buying the product than the 5* ones, as well as more likely to be a genuine reflection of the purchaser's sentiment.
Better for consumers but not better for AirBnB. The fact that potential customers assume that 5-stars indicates an exceptional rather than standard review is an advantage for AirBnB. Revealing the actual rating expectations would cheapen the perception of all the existing reviews.
Yelp is hated in the restaurant industry for similar reasons.
For me, it's pretty obvious that rating is arbitrary and depends on how optimistic/perfectionist/obsessive/etc. the reviewer is and that there is not much difference between 4 or 5 stars.
Obviously it's also more reliable in the context of other evaluations by the same reviewer which the platform has easy access to, i.e. if someone always gives 5 stars, then a 4 star review from him is much worse than one from someone who never gives 5 stars.
If I have a stay that's genuinely superior, I'll write an enthusiastic review. Other than that, "it was fine" or "don't come here" is really all I need to say.
Exactly. This is how CouchSurfing works. It's just another way of asking "Would you recommend this place / this person to your friend?". And that's what people really want to know, after all.
Hosts flip out all the time on 4-star reviews. They loose can "superhost" status and other such things after a couple non-5 star reviews. Giving a 1-star review is probably worse than causing $100+ in damage for some of a lot of these hosts.
Hosts will rarely rate guests < 5 stars, simply for fear of retaliation.
The problem here is that guests are never told that 5 stars = normal stay. This leads to problems. If AirBnB was more up front about expectations it would make their review system a lot better.