What? You see a motivated person with the resources and drive to pursue his dream and you're upset that he's not putting his vision aside to pursue what you think is important? Musk doesn't owe you anything.
He owns SolarCity, a solar panel company, Tesla, an electric car and battery company, and Boring Company, an attempt at creating a transportation system that mandates the use of EV.
The fact that all of this technology will benefit human existence on Mars should go ahead and show you how developing technology in order to survive a situation far more dire than Earth's, in a sustainable way, might also help us better survive our situation on Earth.
I'm just reacting strongly to this Mars madness. That is all.
Defending this project by saying its leader is also compassionate toward other goals isn't compelling to me.
That can be said about anything - why do you buy board games or watch sport events every night or learn to play piano - you should be saving the planet ffs...
But this is larger, as it seems to imply an escape from the problems of the Earth in a new world. A dream that will never become a reality.
Either we fix the Earth or we parish. There is no salvation in the stars, and no second coming of Christ.
Human effort isn't completely fungible. There is no guarantee that all of the people working incredibly hard at SpaceX would switch to work on whatever problem you want them to.
I will not support such efforts, and I feel quite comfortable being a detractor as well.
Who are you to tell me what to judge?! This argument gets you nowhere with me.
They dream of Mars as it is exciting and will lead to new knowledge, understanding, and meaning.
We did for a long time though, except for relatively recently. And Mars won't be able to live without Earth for a long time so it isn't really escapism as you paint it.
I don't think we deserve to disappear completely, but if we don't reverse climate change, we'll have a ton of loss of life but not likely total extinction except for some astronauts. That's probably "enough" as far as galactic justice goes. I'm always a little disappointed in this argument though because it's climate change that we should be judged by, rather than massive deaths from human made conflicts throughout history. Surely there's lots of previous events that qualify for "we don't deserve to exist at all".
Do we need another eccentric billionaire but for climate change though? Sure, bring it on.
I'm making a dramatic argument against large scale efforts to inhabit other planets, while ours is in a dire state.
You'll have to convince or force people to change their priorities. First is probably not possible, due to the slow moving nature of the threat, second has its own drawbacks as well.
I disagree strongly.
Progress in the wrong direction still teaches you things, and it means you're moving and you've overcome the inertia of doing nothing, which is half the battle.
Failure isn't trying and not reaching your goal. Failure is never trying.
Yes, learn from your mistakes. No, don't actively go in the wrong direction.
Now you're talking about if you need to consider any moral implications of the activity you're undertaking, which is a whole different discussion.
Obviously if it's a horrible moral choice (i.e. Hitler) then sure, it's best if nothing is done.
In the very vast majority of cases ( build a better car, spaceship, software, grow better food, get fitter, learn a new language, help our community, be a better friend, etc. etc.), then doing something is much, much preferable to not even trying.
"Morality (noun): principles concerning the distinction between right and wrong or good and bad behavior."
I encourage you to think more deeply about your argument. I struggle to agree that the "very vast majority of cases" are positive.
It sounds to me like you are sensitive to apathy and/or nihilism. I can understand that, especially these days, but just because it feels like nothing is being done doesn't mean things can't get worse.
Sorry, I'm a bit of a cynic these days.
there are plenty of reasons humanity should be multi-planetary other than escaping climate change.
I suspect any reasons you'll come up with are all still less urgent than the needs of our Earth.
I've heard the argument about learning to control the climate through taraforming (or whatever you want to call it), but I'm completely unconvinced that is an efficient method.
I'd be willing to be convinced otherwise, but I'm very skeptical.
Space & Solar System is big and has a lot of resources, much much more than what is available in on a terrestrial planet.
Asteroids, supervolcanoes etc.
I'm throughly uninspired... As a friend of mine once said: "progress when you're going the wrong direction, is turning around".
The idea that we'll settle Mars while the Earth burns in borderline sinister. It reminds me of the elite outpost from Kingsman (the movie).
We have a planet that is in dire need of this kind of motivated action, and yet Elon would rather be distracted by this dream.
Don't get me wrong, I can appreciate the "cool" factor of expanding to other planets. I too enjoy a good science fiction story. Who wouldn't want to escape the problems we've inherited, and proliferated.
But escapism solves nothing for "us", and it's foolish to think Mars is anything else. If we as humans can't live on Earth responsibly, we frankly don't deserve to exist at all.
(Perhaps we should pull a Titan A.E., and preserve some DNA in the vast wasteland of space. Just in case an alien species decides to give us another go)