News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by Niten on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:02AM (#2245836)
> To be clear, we believe you have every right to push forward such a policy. In our view, it’s your hardware and your channel and you can put forth any policy you like.

It isn't Apple's hardware; let us not forget the hardware belongs to the people buying the iPhones and iPads out there. Apple's enforcement of what can and can not run on these devices is not some fundamental property right, but an artificial construct.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by brk on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:46AM (#2246027)
It isn't Apple's hardware; let us not forget the hardware belongs to the people buying the iPhones and iPads out there.

Sort of. It's all a matter of licensing. Technically, you might own the hardware, but you are licensing the OS running on it.

A better argument would be if you took your iOS device and wrote your own stack for it. In that case, I don't think Apple would have much claim to what you could/could not run on "your" hardware. But in the current scenario you're buying iron-wrapped software (or I guess plastic-and-glass-wrapped software). Apple is really controlling what happens with the software, not the hardware.

This is an importnat distinction, IMO, because I don't believe any of the "I paid for it so it's mine" arguments out there really pass muster until you also create your own (not jailbroken) software stack.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by akashs on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:27PM (#2246513)
I think you're half correct. While Apple certainly has every right to try to put mechanisms in place to prevent you from doing certain things on your device, the fact that you purchased it gives you the right to legally circumvent any of those protections to run whatever software you would like as long as the software is also legally obtained. That's why exempt from the DMCA rules are:

"Computer programs that enable wireless telephone handsets to execute software applications, where circumvention is accomplished for the sole purpose of enabling interoperability of such applications, when they have been lawfully obtained, with computer programs on the telephone handset."

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by lamnk on Monday February 21, 2011 @12:29PM (#2246233)
I don't think so. Just imagine Microsoft try to apply the same terms to Windows ...
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by GHFigs on Monday February 21, 2011 @12:36PM (#2246281)
You mean like Zune, Windows Phone, and Xbox?
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by jrockway on Monday February 21, 2011 @06:50PM (#2247877)
Minor problem: nobody uses Zune or Windows Phone.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by brk on Monday February 21, 2011 @12:44PM (#2246330)
I'm not sure what you mean. "Windows", to me, refers to the desktop OS, which is certainly licensed, and has no corresponding hardware component available from Microsoft directly.

Microsoft definitely has their own crazy and draconian licensing and "ownership" issues, but I can't tell from your comment which one of the thousands of possible example cases you're referring to.

If you have a well-reasoned counterpoint, please post it. I'd honestly love to hear a different perspective.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by lamnk on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @09:19AM (#2249917)
> I don't believe any of the "I paid for it so it's mine" arguments out there really pass muster until you also create your own (not jailbroken) software stack.

If I understand correctly, you argue that users don't "own" the device because Apple sells it as a whole stack or because they write the iOS and license it to users. My point is that even with licensed OS users should be free to do whatever they want on the device. When I buy an iPhone, the iOS is already installed so I assume I have also bought the right to use it (like Mac OS?). It doesn't matter whether the OS that comes with the device is written by the hardware manufacturer or not; hence the Microsoft analogy and that's why i disagree with you.

Now when it comes to the subject of App Store, someone has pointed out correctly that App Store is a distribution channel and Windows or iOS is an operating system. It was not my comparison. Here I do agree that Apple has every right to charge developers for any amount they want, or the right to deny any app they don't see fit in the App Store. However Apple don't allow any other channels on their system. That is still in their right to do so, but it will raise some issues when the iPhone/iPod Touch reaches a certain market share.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by webwright on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:54PM (#2246627)
Not a great comparison. Windows is an OS, the App Store is a channel.

A better example would be Google. What would happen if Google tried to own some of the dollars that flow through the organic search channel? /shudder

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by bergie on Monday February 21, 2011 @02:12PM (#2246705)
> Not a great comparison. Windows is an OS, the App Store is a channel.

It is a pretty good comparison as long as App Store is the only way to install anything on iOS

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by marchdown on Monday February 21, 2011 @06:37PM (#2247834)
For somebody new to the whole iTunes Store ecosystem it is neither faster nor less mentally challenging to set up a new ITS account than it is to jailbreak their new device.

It may strike you as obviously false, and it may well have been so two years ago, but when I got my new iPad after moving to another country I've spent about twice as much time getting iTunes to let me pay for apps in foreign App Store than I've spent researching jailbreak options and caveats and then actually pwning the device.

So no, App Store is far from the only way to distribute iOS software, even though it still is the default and sometimes the only apparent way.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by pak on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @11:24AM (#2250319)
Jailbreaking comes with all sorts of downsides. You may have gotten lucky, but also observe that every jailbreaking tutorial on the web has hundreds of comments from people who didn't get everything to work right and pleading for advice from others that will never come.

From my experience, it turns older iPhones into a stuttering laggy mess and breaks visual voicemail, and makes you paranoid about every iTunes update.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by isleyaardvark on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @04:09PM (#2251579)
Whether it's easy or not is irrelevant. There are other ways to do it, and Apple is under no obligation to support those methods or make it easy for them.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by _b8r0 on Monday February 21, 2011 @04:28PM (#2247272)
Better than you think. The original XBox ran a modified Windows 2000 Kernel.
[deleted]
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by nkassis on Monday February 21, 2011 @12:58PM (#2246393)
A monopoly isn't required to act anti competitively. Creating monopoly takes time and many anti-comptitive moves. Apple's rule of not letting a app vendor charge more on iPhone direct sale than on a web or android sale is anti competitive in my book. It prevents Android from competing by only asking 5% or something and making the in app subscription cheaper.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by rimantas on Monday February 21, 2011 @03:16PM (#2246966)
What? Offer your app for Android only, and charge whatever you want.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by jellicle on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:26PM (#2248731)
This isn't a good summary of the law as it is, and it isn't a good summary of how the law should be.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by exit on Monday February 21, 2011 @06:28PM (#2247797)
i don't follow this argument. software doesn't exist in some alternate metaphysical reality. software is just as much a configuration of matter as the rest of the device.

can apple "license" the physical shape of the device and charge 30% on all sales of protective sleeves?

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by brk on Monday February 21, 2011 @07:47PM (#2248067)
If you read through most software licenses, whether click-through or break-the-seal arrangements, the wording comes down to you are being granted a license to use the software, not a transfer of ownership of any actual property.

Hardware is different. Unless you specifically sign a contract like a lease that makes some arrangement other than the traditional you bought it, you own it scenario you can do whatever you want with a piece of purchased hardware. The have been cases in the past, for example DirecTV receivers where the hardware purchase price had a built in subsidy, requiring you to sign up for a subscription. When people started paying cash (instead of the usual credit card sale for a $300 item) and not activating the hardware (because they were easy to hack) DirecTV changed the way retailers were allowed to sell the hardware.

People keep getting the iOS software, and the related devices confused, thinking of them as a single entity. You own your hardware, but you don't own the underlying software. Among other things, the lawsuits targeted at the company that was selling OS X loaded on clone hardware (forget the name) also seemed to prove this out.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by commandar on Monday February 21, 2011 @07:26PM (#2248002)
Isn't that pretty much how the "Made for iPod/iPhone" program works?
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by bigiain on Monday February 21, 2011 @10:39PM (#2248590)
Didn't Apple just lose that argument in court trying to claim jailbreaking your own iPhone was illegal?
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by fauigerzigerk on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:49AM (#2246038)
All contracts are artificial constructs. There are no natural contracts. So the question is simply whether the kind of contract Apple has with its customers is legal or not and if it is whether the law should be changed.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by _delirium on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:17PM (#2246467)
I wonder if there's a name for this class of contracts that seems suspect, some of which are actually illegal and others of which are legal but give people pause more than normal contracts. They mostly seem to have something to do with exclusion or tying, that if you do A you can't do B, and/or if you do A then you must do B.

Various examples that aren't allowed: EULAs that purport to prohibit resale of books (first-sale doctrine), labor agreements that purport to prohibit the employment of members not from the contracting labor organization (union closed shops), deed restrictions that purport to prohibit resale of property to a class of people ("no reselling this house to blacks"), noncompete agreements in some states, exclusivity contracts entered into from a position of market dominance (the Microsoft and Intel OEM cases), certain kinds of explicit tying even when not in a position of market dominance, bequests that contain ongoing conditions on the heirs' behavior (rule against perpetuities), etc.

One example that is also in the "seems related" area but is legal in the U.S.: resale price maintenance, where a manufacturer can prohibit a retailer from selling a product below a certain price. One that's currently being debated is the vague set of issues around "network neutrality", related but not identical to the last generation's debate over "common carrier" status. Gray area: EULAs that purport to prohibit decompilation and reverse engineering.

I know it's a category with vague edges, but it seems like there should be some name for it? These kinds of contracts, even the ones we decide are allowed, seem different in kind from pure exchange contracts of the form, "I give you $100, and you agree to provide me with 2 hours of consulting".

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by joe_the_user on Monday February 21, 2011 @02:59PM (#2246906)
I think the word is "unconscionable". Or at least that's the term for when a contract is so abusive it is not valid.

The thing is that, as you say as I understand it, whether a contract is considered unconscionable is normally a complex question; for example, terms that are unconscious in a residential real estate contract can be included in a commercial real estate contract because a commercial renter is considered more sophisticated (and so if you rent commercially, you better be sophisticated and count your fingers after every hand shake). One guiding question is whether the signer really knows what he getting into.

By that token also, I believe a number of terms are considered unconscionable if you click through them on a website. I would speculate that if a vendor sent an actual devil who blew smoke out his ears and demanded a video-taped signing in blood celemony, that vendor would have a stronger claim that "the signer knew exactly what he was getting into".

Will Apple employ Devils in the future? I think Microsoft may have them all tied up...

IANAL of course...

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by itsnotvalid on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:33PM (#2246541)
First the first time you use your iPhone you need to accept agreements in iTunes. Second, originally cracking iPhone to install custom firmware was prohibited by DRM, which was bounded to DMCA, and now becomes one of the exceptions.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by quizbiz on Monday February 21, 2011 @12:27PM (#2246214)

   > There are no natural contracts.
Do not kill?
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by bartonfink on Monday February 21, 2011 @12:33PM (#2246258)
More than almost anything else, killing seems fundamental to nature as I understand nature. I would, in fact, say that "kill or be killed" is THE natural contract.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by jimbokun on Monday February 21, 2011 @06:30PM (#2247807)
And you could argue that civilization has been one long exercise in striving to replace the contracts of nature with something better.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by bartonfink on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @09:52AM (#2250000)
And I would agree with you. I like not worrying that the guy in the apartment next to me is going to rape me to death just because he can.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by locopati on Monday February 21, 2011 @03:41PM (#2247074)
I'd amend that to say 'go about your activity without being killed'. For some animals (e.g. carnivores), killing is part of their activity. For humans, it's a choice on where each of us draw the line.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by siglesias on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:27PM (#2246514)
Oh, please. We are advanced beings with complex neocortexes that are capable of ethical reasoning. Surely we can agree on an system in which we can find solutions to our fundamental needs without resorting to killing one another.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by bartonfink on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:47PM (#2246593)
Of course, but said system would be unnatural and artificial. Real, yes - but artificial.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by siglesias on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:56PM (#2246638)
I think your use of the term artificial, while apt in the sense of "not existing in non-human nature," is really banking on a series of connotations of artificial that don't apply to the non-natural sense of artificial. Artificial, for example, connotes: unnecessary, inferior to the non-artificial, superfluous, inauthentic. Your point is really something along the lines of linking an ethical system of non-killing to these connotations, which really have nothing to do with whether ethics can be found in non-human nature (which is, of course, a trivial point).

What really matters is why we should inform our thinking with how animals treat each other.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by bartonfink on Monday February 21, 2011 @03:39PM (#2247065)
I think you're either misunderstanding or reading too much into my point, siglesias. I'm not suggesting that "kill or be killed" is a great basis for society or an ethical system. Just like with many other facts of nature, we can and often do improve on them by creating structures and constraints atop those facts we find unpleasant. However, those structures and constraits are inherently manufactured in the strictest sense of the word. Society is just a thin veneer atop a very ugly picture, and it's almost always in our best interests to keep that veneer in place. But it is, ultimately, just a veneer.

Frankly, this has little to do with the original post - I just made my original comment in response to someone saying "don't kill" is an example of a natural contract.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by siglesias on Monday February 21, 2011 @04:04PM (#2247170)
I just think that describing our ethical system as "artificial" is a tremendous misapplication of the term, and I think it would give most people evaluating your statement pause.

On the other hand, I do find my aversion to killing rather natural in the sense that I needn't justify too much beyond my own instinct (and, if you should know, ethics as instinct is the subject of research with promising theories[1], but I'm not even talking about that).

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by teilo on Monday February 21, 2011 @03:22PM (#2246992)
There is a distinction between rights and contracts. There is a natural right to life, liberty, and property. There is not a natural right to the terms of a specific contract. This is Common Law 101.

One of the natural rights protected by the Common Law is the right to enter into contracts and have the terms of those contracts enforced in a court of law. But a contract cannot abrogate a natural right, or such contract is null and void. Thus you cannot enter into a contract to take the life of another person.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by relic17 on Monday February 21, 2011 @12:06PM (#2246125)
Sure, the hardware belongs to the people buying the device. They can sell it, give it as a gift, break it. But they can't use the device every way they want. The device does only so much. The fact is: everyone bought a device in the full knowledge of all its limitations. Before purchase, Apple never promised a stream of wonderful applications and content at a price that the customer deems appropriate. They did not guarantee a great App Store, they did not even guarantee that they won't shut down the App Store and let the device be just a piece of hardware. The customer knew the limitations and bought the device anyways.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by tygorius on Monday February 21, 2011 @05:13PM (#2247492)
Changing the rules once you have a large installed base is always a delicate issue. How many current iPad owners knew their Kindle app (and others) might be deactivated by Apple in a couple of months because Apple decided it wanted a 30% cut?
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by rimantas on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:09AM (#2245861)
There was another part that you omitted "and your channel". Or did people buy that also?
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by generalk on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:31AM (#2245956)
No, of course they didn't buy the channel. But that's not the point.

When Apple sells you an iPhone, it ceases to become their phone and becomes your phone. You're not leasing it, you aren't renting it, you've paid for it and it's yours.

This is somewhat orthogonal to the original point, which was that Apple is free to reject whatever applications they like from their application delivery channel, just as I'm free to choose my clients, but it's important to remember.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by OpieCunningham on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:04PM (#2246413)
You are free to do whatever you want to your iPhone/iPad hardware. You can build a Linux distro and install it, there's already an Android distro for it, you can smash it, tear it apart, put it back together, wallpaper your room with them, etc. Nothing prevents you from doing those things. It's not Apple's duty to make it easier for you by building a boot loader into the device, adding double sided tape on the back so it will stick to your wall or putting a hammer in the package to make smashing it easier.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by generalk on Monday February 21, 2011 @02:38PM (#2246818)

  > It's not Apple's duty to make it easier for you by building 
  > a boot loader into the device [...]"
Nobody said it was. In fact, I think for the most part nobody has ever said that it's Apple's duty to do anything. A bunch of folks have said it'd be nice if Apple did allow third-party distribution channels, and a handful of hackers went ahead and made one, but I don't think anyone's ever claimed that Apple had a responsibility to make that easy.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by OpieCunningham on Monday February 21, 2011 @03:56PM (#2247134)
I've seen plenty of people in this very thread claiming they own the hardware so they should be able to do whatever they want.

But all of those people already have that right. So the complaint is: Apple is required to do more to allow me to do things I can't manage on my own.

It is an implicit claim that Apple is duty bound to provide features that Apple has no interest in providing.

My toaster doesn't make ice, nor does it heat my living room. Simply because I own the toaster doesn't mean there is any logic in my complaining that the manufacturer didn't provide a means for me to do those things with my toaster. If the toaster manufacturer decides there is a market it wants to be in for a toaster that makes ice, it can build that toaster. It's not obligated to build that ice-making toaster even if there is a huge market for it.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by Natsu on Monday February 21, 2011 @04:30PM (#2247276)
> But all of those people already have that right.

Not legally. A limited amount of iPhone jailbreaking has been exempted under the DMCA, but that won't absolve you for the offense of trafficking in the tools to do so. And there are a million other EULAs and such that at least purport to take away that very right. IANAL, but I've seen people dragged into court over them. Whether or not they're legal is pretty much academic if you have to go through the expense of fighting it out in court against a giant company.

The point is that the vendors are taking away our legal right to do all these things and occasionally adding some screw-you technology to make them technically difficult as well. They're not passively thwarting your ability to do what you like, they're actively opposing it both technically and legally and that's why people worry.

My response has been not to buy devices like that and to boycott those vendors wholesale, but the way the market is going, that's not going to be possible forever. We need a good first sale type right to eliminate all this nonsense.

We would never have made it this far if those nonsense book licenses that publishers tried back in the day had actually been successful.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by OpieCunningham on Monday February 21, 2011 @04:42PM (#2247327)
You're correct, but the limitations you are referring to are specific to software.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by Natsu on Monday February 21, 2011 @05:20PM (#2247530)
It's their control of the software that allows them to control what people do with the hardware both via technical and legal means. It is, after all, a computing device.

While I suppose that people wouldn't have this problem if they were using it as, say, a doorstop, that's not really the issue people are having here.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by OpieCunningham on Monday February 21, 2011 @05:35PM (#2247599)
That's not accurate. Apple's only control of the hardware is how you use it via their software. The hardware is not sold to you under the provision that you must only use Apple's software with it. Replace their software with your own and Apple has no control over the hardware. Therefore, Apple has no control over the hardware - you do.

The claim "I bought the hardware, I own it, therefore I should be able to do what I want with it and Apple is preventing me", which is the general argument being made, is fundamentally false. You bought the hardware, you own it and you can do what you want with it.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by Natsu on Monday February 21, 2011 @06:04PM (#2247704)
> Apple's only control of the hardware is how you use it via their software. The hardware is not sold to you under the provision that you must only use Apple's software with it.

You have to jailbreak an iPhone to install other software, or so claims PC World. That's definitely a technical barrier, just like I explained. And a legal one, with the DMCA "trafficking" problem. Having established that their opposition is not merely passive, your complaint rings hollow, unless when you said that, you were trying to say that they were less than upfront about disclosing the restrictions?

No link will be given to those instructions. They're incredibly easy to find, but I don't want to run afoul of the nebulous contributory infringement claims like "inducement." My recommendation is for people like me with a problem with this to avoid buying the products to begin with. It's the approach I have selected.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by OpieCunningham on Monday February 21, 2011 @10:17PM (#2248547)
There are an assortment of technical barriers that limit my ability to convert my toaster into an ice-making toaster. Starting with those annoying screws which were clearly put there to prevent me from easily accessing the inside of my toaster!

That's not the manufacturers problem.

The govt has already declared that jail breaking your phone is legal.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by Natsu on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @02:15AM (#2249102)
> There are an assortment of technical barriers that limit my ability to convert my toaster into an ice-making toaster. Starting with those annoying screws which were clearly put there to prevent me from easily accessing the inside of my toaster!

That's a terrible argument to make in Apple's case:

http://www.techdirt.com/blog/wireless/articles/20110125/0207...

It wasn't accidental, necessary or even cheaper to make the iPhone require a jailbreak before you could install your own stuff, after all.

> The govt has already declared that jail breaking your phone is legal.

That's a very misleading way to put it.

I already explained why the Librarian of Congress' exemption for jailbreaking an iPhone is useless because they do not (and cannot) exempt anyone from the ban on trafficking in such tools.

You can read more about how the DMCA works here: http://www.freedom-to-tinker.com/blog/blakereid/new-dmca-exe...

Hopefully that will be enough that you can understand why the Librarian of Congress wrote, "Nor is this rulemaking about the ability to make or distribute products or services used for purposes of circumventing access controls, which are governed by a different part of section 1201."

Source: http://www.copyright.gov/1201/2010/Librarian-of-Congress-120...

That's the statement in which the Librarian of Congress exempted people from the ban on circumvention (but not trafficking) things like iPhones. The specific phone exemption is exemption #2.

Now then, how does one jailbreak an iPhone legally if they're not allowed to make or distribute the means to do so?

If you read the Freedom to Tinker article, you'll remember that the DMCA says that you cannot "manufacture, import, offer to the public, provide, or otherwise traffic in any technology, product, service, device, component, or part thereof" that is "primarily designed" to circumvent, has only "limited commercially significant" non-circumvention purposes, or is "marketed" for circumvention purposes.

That word "manufacture" is the sticky one, not that you can't run afoul of the others. Damn hard to circumvent things when you can neither make nor import the tools to do so.

The DMCA is one big catch-22. Claiming that the government has declared this legal is very dangerous. IANAL and you need proper legal advice before dealing with this stuff.

I solve it by not owning an iPhone in the first place.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by Kylekramer on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:11AM (#2245874)
That is part of the artificial construct. There is no reason for the channel to be Apple's except that they enforce ridiculous rules like this rejection to maintain complete control. And the channel loses value every time they pull something like this.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by rimantas on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:21AM (#2245909)
I don't get your argument.

  > There is no reason for the channel to be Apple's
How about the reason that it is Apple's? And why would they not want to have their rules on their channel? I am also not sure about ridiculousness of the rules; and finally "losses value"—it depends. One can argue that this is true for some segment wanting to participate in Apples ecosystem, but it is offset by another, larger, segment which actually benefits from it.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by lambda on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:44AM (#2246015)
The issue is that Apple is artificially tying their channel to your hardware; they sold the hardware to you, but they sold it, not leased it, so its still your hardware. However, they've artificially retained control of the channel via DRM, software that doesn't allow you to install whatever you want on your own hardware.

If you had the option of buying apps through another channel, this wouldn't be a problem. Most people don't have much of a problem with any of the Android Market's policies, since you can install other apps or even other markets on your own phone if you so choose.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by GHFigs on Monday February 21, 2011 @12:41PM (#2246306)
However, they've artificially retained control of the channel via DRM, software that doesn't allow you to install whatever you want on your own hardware.

Why don't you just remove Apple's software and install your own?

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by jammur on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:58AM (#2246088)
As another person commented, it may be your hardware, but it's not your OS. You license the right to use iOS, but you don't own it. The app distribution channel is tied to the OS, not the device. If you want to install a different firmware on the device, and can figure out how to do it, there's nothing Apple can do about that.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by natrius on Monday February 21, 2011 @02:55PM (#2246890)
Have EULAs been upheld in court? The idea that I need special permission to use software that I've purchased seems a bit ridiculous. Kind of like a EULA on a car that restricts my driving to Ford toll roads.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by jammur on Monday February 21, 2011 @03:03PM (#2246918)
You didn't purchase the software. You purchased a license to use it, which included agreeing to Apple's terms. To use your car analogy, it would be more like renting a car, and the rental company saying you have to stay in your state/province/country/etc., which is perfectly legal and pretty standard. You didn't buy the car, but instead purchased the right to use it.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by natrius on Monday February 21, 2011 @05:57PM (#2247672)
That's not true. Before you rent a car, you sign a long contract agreeing to all the various restrictions. When you buy software, you typically don't agree to anything until you run the software. At that point, you already own the software, and as far as I know, no court has held that you must abide by the license in order to use the software.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by jammur on Monday February 21, 2011 @07:59PM (#2248106)
That's correct, when you run the software, you agree to the license. But before that, you still don't own the software. At no point do you ever own the software. You simply pay for a license to use it. This is the same with OSX, Windows 7, etc.

You are correct that consumer EULAs haven't really been tested in court, but that is irrelevant to this discussion. This isn't about the EULA. Apple is not stopping you from putting a third party app store on the device. They are stopping you from putting a third party app store on the stock iOS. If you jailbreak, then you can put Cydia on it.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by Kylekramer on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:32AM (#2245957)
It is kind of a circular argument to answer "there is no reason for Apple to own the channel" with "But Apple owns the channel". I know Apple does. And Apple should place their own rules on their channel, I don't deny that. My problem is there is no competition allowed.

And who is this larger segment that benefits from this decision (besides Apple employees and shareholders)? Is there a group of people who hate to have the chance to use Readability?

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by gaustin on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:30AM (#2245954)
>How about the reason that it is Apple's? And why would they not want to have their rules on their channel?

The only viable channel at this point is Apple's. If there were a way to access non-Apple blessed applications without rooting your device, then people might not complain so much. Savvy consumers don't appreciate monopolies.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by jammur on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:51AM (#2246049)
I'm not sure it's reasonable to use the monopoly argument at arbitrary level of granularity. For instance, while Apple has a monopoly on iOS app by definition, Ford also has a monopoly on Ford cars. Monopolies are only a problem when there is no viable competition. In this case, the competition is Android et al. By saying you only want an iPhone, you are restricting your own choice. That said, it's perfectly fine to complain about the policies Apple implements. Complaints are part of the free market process, and in many cases bring about change for the better.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by montagg on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:55AM (#2246073)
iOS is like a magazine, Apple are the editors, and the developers are the writers. Apple has every right to do whatever they want with their channel, even if it's a stupid move. You wouldn't tell "Time" they have no right to publish who they want and keep others out, would you? Likewise, I don't buy a magazine and then demand that I be able to print my own stories in it. I buy the magazine because it has stories in it already that I want to read.

That said, Readability's claim that this "smacks of greed" is totally right. Apple is not acting in its users' best interest, because more than other moves, this actually affects their developers' business models, and it's going to drive high quality, innovative apps away from the App Store.

There are two viable moves Apple can make:

1) Allow subscriptions outside the app without requiring one in the app

OR

2) Lowering the 30% fee for in-app subscriptions

Both of these options keep value in the App Store while providing Apple with some benefit. If they don't adopt one of these, the long term viability of the App Store is in jeopardy.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by lwhi on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:17PM (#2246465)
No .. iOS is a global marketplace and Apple are the gatekeepers for that marketplace.

Comparing the iOS with a magazine is slightly disingenuous because the scale is much so larger.

I think all markets should involve a certain amount of freedom - and Apple's decision making process actively inhibits market freedom.

EDIT: iOS/App Store

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by neutronicus on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:45PM (#2246579)
No .. iOS is a global marketplace and Apple are the gatekeepers for that marketplace.

The "global marketplace" is the one in which you can purchase a piece of hardware, install software of your choice on that hardware (albeit sometimes with a great deal of effort), possibly licensed from a third party (again, albeit sometimes with a great deal of effort).

Apple sells a service - they make it easier to install certain software on the hardware you purchased (from them, although that's irrelevant), to the extent of pre-installing iOS and various applications, and they facilitate discovery of individuals willing to license software to the owner of the hardware and transactions between said individuals and the owner of the hardware.

They are free to provide or not provide this service as they see fit.

If you really believe that Apple should provide this services gratis to developers as some kind of latter-day addition to the Bill of Rights, perhaps you should lobby the government to purchase the App Store infrastructure and oversee it instead?

Comparing the iOS with a magazine is slightly disingenuous because the scale is much so larger.

All of his points map exactly onto TV stations. Is that large enough scale for you?

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by lwhi on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:59PM (#2246651)
Once you have purchased your hardware, and have purchased a catalogue of software titles, you are effectively 'locked in'.

It's a bit naive to state that people have choice - because if you have a iOS based device, you (effectively) only have one place to make purchases. Jail-breaking and third-party software sources are beyond the reach of most consumers.

For all intents, if you have an iOS based device, the AppStore is your marketplace - and it is a marketplace which trades globally.

--

"All of his points map exactly onto TV stations. Is that large enough scale for you?"

A TV station purchases or licenses content on behalf of their customers. Apple doesn't operate in this way.

I honestly believe the most useful analogy is a 'marketplace' - however, if this is accepted, perhaps Apple's policies seem more disagreeable than they do if 'tv station' or 'magazine' is used as a comparison. Maybe this is why Apple's supporters seem unkeen to make the comparison?

--

"If you really believe that Apple should provide this services gratis to developers as some kind of latter-day addition to the Bill of Rights, perhaps you should lobby the government to purchase the App Store infrastructure and oversee it instead?"

I think Apple should be forced to allow third party App Stores.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by neutronicus on Monday February 21, 2011 @03:29PM (#2247022)
Jail-breaking and third-party software sources are beyond the reach of most consumers.

If you think that's something most consumers would desire and are incapable of achieving, then go into business jailbreaking iPhones. You can install an app store while you're at it.

I think Apple should be forced to allow third party App Stores.

Again, they can't stop you. Open up a brick-and-mortar store where you jailbreak iPhones and put your own app store on the iPhone. Sell kits online.

I honestly believe the most useful analogy is a 'marketplace'

What does 'marketplace' even mean? If you're selling stock on the NYSE, someone's collecting vig. If you're selling consumer goods at a mall, someone's collecting rent. If you're selling something on Amazon, they're collecting vig. How does calling it a 'marketplace' support your argument when just about every privately owned 'marketplace' involves someone collecting vig?

- however, if this is accepted, perhaps Apple's policies seem more disagreeable than they do if 'tv station' or 'magazine' is used as a comparison. Maybe this is why Apple's supporters seem unkeen to make the comparison?

Apple supporter? I am an Android phone owner who is keen to know why you don't buy an Android device, and write apps for it.

What this all boils down to is that consumers are perfectly capable of escaping lock-in and installing whatever software for which they can get a license. However, they both trust Apple's imprimatur enough and value individual apps lowly enough that they don't. Consumers don't want <app> enough to venture outside of Apple's convenient payment and discovery service. You are attempting to disguise this reality by saying that Apple restricts the consumer's choice, but this is a canard. <App> is simply not compelling enough for most consumers to jailbreak their phones, or buy Android, to get it.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by bad_user on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:50AM (#2246040)
The only channel possible on iPhones without jailbreak is Apple's.

Users own the iPhones bought. Therefore Apple should either let users subscribe to third-party channels, or release their channel in the hands of users (i.e. let them approve or ban apps).

Otherwise, if there will ever come a day when Apple will have a monopoly on his hands, a big lawsuit will also happen.

And really, I can see why Apple wants to control their channel, but why should I be restricted to their channel only? Why should I jailbreak my phone, which is dependent on kernel / various other exploits and risk bricking my device and losing the warranty if I want to be freed from Apple's channel?

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by xentronium on Monday February 21, 2011 @05:14PM (#2247507)
Imagine a phone without third-party apps / any kind of app-store. Does your manufacturer have to provide some kind of software channel for your phone? No.

It's just another service, separate from the phone, you're free to use it, or not use it.

The answer to your why's is probably "because they can".

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by bad_user on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @04:17AM (#2249299)
That's not what's happening here.

iOS is a platform for third-party apps. That's how it's now sold (right on their website: "The world’s largest collection of mobile apps").

That's a lock-in mechanism. Switching between phones with no third-party apps is a lot cheaper that switching between the iPhone and a Blackberry.

They could do this if they wouldn't have allowed any third-party apps at all; if the popularity of the platform for third-party apps wouldn't be one of the reasons iPhones are selling like crazy.

And I also don't get this apologetic behavior from people in regards to Apple's actions. Do you miss the 90s when all you could use and target was Microsoft's OS? Do you miss the whims of Microsoft and the iron grip they had on the industry?

What, do you feel too much freedom of choice now? You think it's unhealthy or something?

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by xentronium on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @09:14AM (#2249906)
I personally think that apple's behaviour sucks; I just argued that they don't have any obligation to put whatever third-party apps they don't like.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by nhangen on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:56PM (#2246642)
I tend to think of it as Verizon/ATT's hardware, because they are subsidizing the purchase of it.

Maybe it's a stretch, but I don't feel like I own it until my 2 years is up.

Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by adsr on Monday February 21, 2011 @07:29PM (#2248014)
It has nothing to do with the hardware. Apple gives access to a sales platform, similar to let's say Amazon. They charge for the use of that platform. And are now preventing someone to use it as a mere "springboard" to somewhere else. Nothing is stoping anyone from creating a web app to take care of this by them selves, independent of the app store.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by Synaesthesia on Monday February 21, 2011 @01:01PM (#2246402)
I suppose you'll have to do the Android on iPhone thing though. They're still kind of struggling with a lot of issues, like power management for one.
Re:An Open Letter to Apple on the Readability App rejection by cma on Monday February 21, 2011 @03:36PM (#2247054)
Property rights are artificial constructs too.