News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by calibas on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @11:01AM (#22414210)
If their legal argument is legit, it also means they just infringed upon the copyrights of most modern songs by attempting to release their melodies into public domain.

Someone who owns the copyrights to a song should sue them for a paltry sum, just to see how things play out in court.

Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by codeplea on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @12:20PM (#22415019)
For there to be infringement, someone needs to prove that copying took place. Because of the algorithm these musicians used to generate this, they can prove mathematically that copying did not take place.
Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by calibas on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @12:35PM (#22415178)
So if an algorithm you wrote produces a melody identical to a copyrighted work, you can claim copyright of the melody too?

I don't believe there's an objective right and wrong answer here, we're still figuring out how our legal system should adapt to modern technologies.

Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by tebruno99 on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @03:21PM (#22417025)
Part of the law is that the infringer has to have had access to the work that he/she is accused of "stealing"

An Algorithm has no access and could have never heard the work in question..

Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by mooman219 on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @07:46PM (#22419210)
The individual writing the algorithm certainly can have access. If I copy a song, I can't say that the tool I used didn't have access as a defense because that makes no sense.
Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by dwild on Monday March 02, 2020 @02:26PM (#22467853)
> The individual writing the algorithm certainly can have access.

Sure he can have access, but looking at the algorithm you can prove without a doubt that the algorithm couldn't have access to it.

> If I copy a song, I can't say that the tool I used didn't have access as a defense because that makes no sense.

You could have given access to the song to the tools that you used though.

Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by k__ on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @01:58PM (#22416055)
I think there is a difference in creating an algo that generates all possible solutions vs one that generates one specific solution.
Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by unnouinceput on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @07:00PM (#22418887)
No, it's not. One that generated a specific solution is given specific parameters. And those parameters can be, in their turn, just plugged in by a loop, hence generating everything.

Usually songs are between 2 and 5 minutes long. Therefore I can, theoretically speaking, write an algorithm, that can use linear interpolation, to generate all sounds, for all octaves, using 44KHz as sampling (the most usual track these days), and you can bet your rear latest pop or rock or whatever song will be generated as well - leaving me with only showing to court "here Your Honor, after looping through, my algorithm at mark xxx gazzilion generated this awesome piece of melody that you know from Youtube as <Lana Del Rey - Blue Jeans>"

Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by mygo on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @10:08PM (#22419919)
So the Library of Babel for music?

https://libraryofbabel.info/bookmark.cgi?eofpgjcg.ggyvpzpti,...

^ search that bookmarked page in the Library of Babel for “jeans” ;)

On another note, since melodies can be encoded into a text format, the Library of Babel has actually done this too.

Heck, there’s a page in the Library of Babel that reads “Your honor, Lady Gaga will one day steal this melody from the library of babel, encoded here in text format: {melody for ‘Shallow’}”

which may look something like this (search “lady gaga” https://libraryofbabel.info/bookmark.cgi?vakuygoqaattmqm315 )

Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by dr_dshiv on Friday February 28, 2020 @02:05AM (#22441066)
And discussed in 1692, by Bernoulli, Mersenne and Kircher

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1979HisSc..17..258K...

Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by unnouinceput on Wednesday February 26, 2020 @06:03PM (#22428430)
Sounds awesome. I agree with this 100% (both your sarcastic statement AND libraryofbabel)
Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by bathtub365 on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @08:37PM (#22419495)
Sounds a bit like parallel construction...
Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by Supermancho on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @04:12PM (#22417507)
> For there to be infringement, someone needs to prove that copying took place.

The argument isn't going to help. If you are creating every permutation in the purpose of publishing, you are inherently aware that you are intentionally copying published works (and are familiar with the concepts), even without specifically choosing to reproduce in each individual permutation.

Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by wpasc on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @11:50AM (#22414716)
What if a good actor who owned an infringed melody sued them with the intention of losing to set a good precedent?
Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by bluGill on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @01:10PM (#22415544)
See vidarh's very good post which I won't repeat.

A court trail is not much a precedent. The judge can decide to not allow you to mention it. Even if a sympathetic judge (meaning faking neutral but really biased) does allow it, it will be with instructions that allow the next jury to ignore it.

To get a precedent you need to go to court. Then you need to appeal, and a court needs to agree to hear/rule on the appeal. Here you have a problem though: even if you conspire to lose, someone else can file an "Amicus brief" https://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Amicus+brief and make a compelling argument that you overlooked. A first round appeal may not get this, but by the time it get to the supreme court (probably not even you - it generally takes dozens of different cases before it gets that far) there will be a lot of interest and your attempt to lose can still win because those who want to win can pour enough into their briefs.

Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by vidarh on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @12:39PM (#22415228)
Courts and bar associations tends to take a dim view of manufactured disagreements, so they'd better make sure to be good at just seeming incompetent.

But it's also not likely to be very effective unless you manage to trick a judge into issuing an overly broad judgement and manage to get it upheld on appeal.

The legally sanctioned version would be to seek a declarative judgement.

Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by johannes1234321 on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @11:33AM (#22414533)
They could, but what's the consequences of the court ruling in their "favor"? - Consequence would be that those artists have copyright to all future music, thus the one who sued couldn't create anything new and claim copyright in it but would have to pay royalties
Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by klyrs on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @11:38AM (#22414583)
I considered doing something like this project, but this was too big a red flag for me to ignore. It seems tractable to go through everything in the library of Congress, if it's already digitized, but that took this from pet project to big hustle
Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them... by ramshorns on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @04:19PM (#22417565)
Well, maybe it's fair use to pull just the melody out of a full song, but it wouldn't be in the other direction since the original works here are just the melodies.