Re:Musicians algorithmically generate melodies, release them...
by bluGill on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @01:10PM
(#22415544)
See vidarh's very good post which I won't repeat.
A court trail is not much a precedent. The judge can decide to not allow you to mention it. Even if a sympathetic judge (meaning faking neutral but really biased) does allow it, it will be with instructions that allow the next jury to ignore it.
To get a precedent you need to go to court. Then you need to appeal, and a court needs to agree to hear/rule on the appeal. Here you have a problem though: even if you conspire to lose, someone else can file an "Amicus brief" https://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Amicus+brief and make a compelling argument that you overlooked. A first round appeal may not get this, but by the time it get to the supreme court (probably not even you - it generally takes dozens of different cases before it gets that far) there will be a lot of interest and your attempt to lose can still win because those who want to win can pour enough into their briefs.
A court trail is not much a precedent. The judge can decide to not allow you to mention it. Even if a sympathetic judge (meaning faking neutral but really biased) does allow it, it will be with instructions that allow the next jury to ignore it.
To get a precedent you need to go to court. Then you need to appeal, and a court needs to agree to hear/rule on the appeal. Here you have a problem though: even if you conspire to lose, someone else can file an "Amicus brief" https://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Amicus+brief and make a compelling argument that you overlooked. A first round appeal may not get this, but by the time it get to the supreme court (probably not even you - it generally takes dozens of different cases before it gets that far) there will be a lot of interest and your attempt to lose can still win because those who want to win can pour enough into their briefs.