A common narrative in western news is that surveillance in China is developing too quickly and that social credit and other systems are being introduced rapidly, introducing societal risk.
It's possible that's true - and that the U.S. and sillicon valley in particular - while good at developing technology rapidly - are actually on a similar risk trajectory. Within the tech news bubble it's all communicated very differently, of course - it's about innovation, improving lives, and changing the world by disrupting old industries. But perhaps the systems that are being implemented are, in fact, similar.
And to look at the situation from another angle: despite all of these advances in technology, how much has life really changed? We all still have family, friends, education, work, accommodation, food sources and requirements.. there is "nothing new under the sun".
There's a lot to be said for taking some pause and seeing how technology develops, and after careful consideration, selecting the options which lead to clear improvements, while avoiding the options which seem to introduce large negative impacts for individuals and society.
- use US credit card in an app store, - ask a third party to resend me a device.
I am not aware of many innovative products or services that are first available in the EU, and it takes more than a year to appear in the USA (examples are welcome).
I do not say that the EU is bad, as there are quite a few things in which it is progressive (human rights, environment).
> despite all of these advances in technology, how much has life really changed?
For some, a lot. If it weren't for the internet, most likely I would end up living very lonely and miserable. (Well, it give me a window to discover people having different religion than my family and neighbors, to discover that I am not the only weirdo, but there are much more neurodivergent people, etc).
Each single things progress is not a life changer. Collectively, they change the way we live.
Yes, I am aware that one should weight the pros and cons. Just, IMHO, in Europe it is tilted to "way too conservative" (in its original meaning, "preserving"), with the approach more of a government plan (acting in years or decades) than hackathon/startup, where it is an order of magnitude faster.
I am the most afraid of slowing the progress of medicine, which do require data.
Do you have anything like Klarna yet? They let ordinary people buy stuff online on invoice and handle the risk for the merchants. This makes buying stuff online very convenient. It is a Swedish company which has been active in Europe for almost 15 years.
Spotify, while not as innovative, also took many years before they entered the US market. It is pretty normal for Swedish tech companies to focus on the EU market first before entering the US market many years later.
This does not apply only to tech but to everything and I personally think it is a good idea to not barge into something without considering it. We've done so much damage in the past by acting before thinking.
Where has this happened in Social Media?
Where is the EU's evidence that FB/Inta etc. have launched products that have caused individual, social harm?
We require 'lighting equipment' to be approved ahead of time because people could get shocked and die otherwise.
There's no such risk in social media products.
What's more, that the EU is being more conservative here, in no way implies that it's citizens are actually 'safer'.
For example, the OP's point about cookie notices: they have not materially changed anything other than creating a UI headache. Nobody has changed their behavior due to this notice. In retrospect, there are perhaps other ways this should have been implemented.
The EU should make regulations where harm is a real possibility, and ensure that companies are adhering to such laws, but that's a far cry from companies having to provide every country notice ahead of time of product features and services.
Every product or service involves the management of at least some kind of personal information, is Ireland prepared to 'review' every feature of every little startups SaaS app, or of the millions of niche little social apps?
No. Better to hire some people to investigate claims and breaches of privacy, and to develop good laws.
This is ridiculous. Facebook is a social network that allows people to share information with one another, almost always in the terms that the user wants i.e. users have control over their own privacy level.
Unlike so many places, Facebook does not sell or share any data with anyone. They don't need to, because they have their own advertising engine.
That's it.
The list of concerns in this Wikipedia article are mostly misguided or misrepresentative.
Most concerns are actually critiques of social media in general, such as "Students have a hard time coping" because they're caught up in social media is a social commentary about new technology, not Facebook.
'Envy' 'Stress' etc. - this is 'Facebooks' fault for allowing people to share information about their lives?
The vast majority of people are able to handle their 'social media account', and there's a very easy answer for those who don't want to deal with it - which is to not have an account with Facebook, moreover, this is a general concern, not a Facebook-specific issue.
Almost all of the other issues in kind 'Tax Avoidance': FB pays 100% of the taxes they are owed, and don't pay taxes they don't need to. In the context of this article consider that the architect of the EU's ostensible loopholes was Jean Claude Junker (!!!) literally the Pres of the EU Commission who created all these shenanigan rules when he was PM of Tax Haven Luxembourg! It's 100% the EU's fault that their tax laws are wack. If they want a more thoughtful approach to taxation than they should change their laws.
Facebook is critiqued for some content moderation issues, as though it's 'their fault' that someone bullies some other person? Again, this is a general social media issue, not a Facebook issue, moreover, everyone would just like clarity on how to deal with the issue. Governments don't provide clear direction, and the press/twitterverse will be in outrage mode whatever happens one way or another.
Most hypocritically, the most popular 'solution' around here seems to be 'decentralization' - as if when there is no 'authority' modering content these problems will be solved? Just the opposite! A 'decentralized' social network will be the most unruly place imaginable where all these problems are considerably worse. Imagine ISIS with their 'execution' videos willy nilly, NAZI propaganda, ex-husbands and wives doing a terrible thing to one another, pedophiles, stalkers galore.
Facebook is a social network where people can 'share stuff' almost entirely on their own terms. They moderate, but not perfectly and there will never be perfect moderation because nobody can agree on what that is.
They are not a bad company, nor is it really even bad technology, like anything, most people use it for fairly benign, normative stuff like sharing cat and wedding videos.
They got websites and developers to embed their spyware like the tracking pixels, Like buttons, app SDKs everywhere so they can get IP address and device data which is enough to track you across apps and websites with very high accuracy.
They also track who knows you based on other Facebook users (often unintentionally, thanks to dark patterns) share their contacts list with your number in there. They can basically infer your entire social graph without you even being aware nor consenting to it.
That has nothing to do with Facebook or social media.
I would love if someone passed a law or made some relevant and intelligent regulations concerning this, but's completely beyond Facebook making a dating app.
Facebook is not a malicious company. They're just a big social network with all the crap that comes along with that.
I'm sorry, wat?
There's zero need to regulate Facebook. It's about the least harmful company in the world today. Its products have no safety implications. If it has an extended outage GDP probably goes up rather than down as people stop goofing off work. It's half way to being an entertainment company.
The only reason this comes up at all is because the European political elites are immersed in a form of groupthink in which they cannot and will not engage with their citizens actual concerns (top concern by the EU's own polling: immigration). So they cast around trying to understand why anyone in the UK would vote to leave the EU and come up with some theory about how it's all Facebook's fault, despite that the EU always loses referendums when people are given a chance to object. So now anything Facebook does must be bad.
The EU will continue to be dominated by US tech firms that don't care about what the Commission think for the forseeable future. The only obvious change on the horizon is that a new generation of tech firms, having seen what happened to companies that hired too many employees in Europe, will simply choose to serve the market entirely from abroad where they can ignore EU law at will.
That's the whole point of the precautionary principle, you need to consider it carefully before barging in. You need to find the evidence that it is ok not that it is not ok.
But in this case there is already evidence that social media can at least be a catalyst for increasing individual and social harm. I'll just link the first result from googling "facebook myanmar" [1]. There are also cases where leaking of data from dating websites (more relevant to the topic at hand) causes great individual harm [2].
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebo...
One of the leading causes of deaths of healthy people in every nation is cars!
Do you think we should put the CEO of Volvo in jail for mass murder?
Why are you not trying to get GM and Ford shut down immediately for all of the death they care to enable?
And consider the vast environmental impact!
This notion of 'proving something causes no harm' before using it is unecessary for anything other than literally dangerous products. So foods, chemicals, things that involve electricity, there's very good regulations for those things.
But are we going to ban 'Spotify' until you can figure out the long-term effects of that economic model and how it might affect the music industry artists?
No. Social Media is a new form of human interaction that has come about for a variety of reasons, and we're going to have to figure it out. People are not dying in the streets, more importantly, those who have challenges with it simply don't have to use it. In between those grey areas, we have to work things out - but this is not specifically a Facebook problem.
There are a number of thoughtful regulations that the US or EU could implement, but almost none of them are being suggested, and the example provided in this article proves this to some degree. Ireland is not protecting anyone or accomplishing anything at all with this specific regulatory apparatus.
Banning Facebook until they can 'prove they cause no harm' is ridiculous, i.e. the OP's reference to 'do no harm' or 'conservative principle'.
Also, though GDPR is mostly good, a lot of other regulations are not, for example, the one in this article wherein Ireland needs to approve Facebook's dating app.
The malaise from general social media is a new social problem, and almost nothing FB does will mitigate it. We need to learn to live in a new world where general social media products exist.
On dating apps you are not forced to put your real name and exact address but in FB people already have the full names, relatives, school and work colleagues so a bad actor that would find a lot about somebody compared to a random dating website where they can find your contry and region and your preferences.
As a European, I don't feel at all behind the USA.
Even less so since a few years, since I see all the very-USA-specific stuff that's been fed to us as "universal", while it was actually more because most of the production/distribution/media means were sourced from there.
Exceptionalism is its own curse.
I don't know why you're getting downvoted so bad. Your opinion is valid and well stated, even though I disagree.
Erm, that's exactly why we have governments: to solve society-level problems.
As the quote goes, "A government big enough to give you everything you want, is a government big enough to take away everything that you have.". People think "oh it couldn't happen here"; well that's what people in Germany thought in the 1930s.
I do not see a problem here, EU forces websites to inform me and ask for permissions, I can click agree to everything and I am in the same boat as Americans. So it seems Facebook was lazy and did not prepared the documentation.
True, but why on earth is the government deciding on your behalf what this trade-off is?
It's the government's job to make sure the trade-off is apparent, within reason, and then let people decide for themselves.
For example, I don't want to be on Facebook ... so my magical solution is that I don't use it.
Facebook also collects other user's contacts lists (thanks to dark patterns) which means they can infer his social graph based on his other friends who do use Facebook even if he himself doesn't use it.
Overall I'm unsure if the EU is doing good here or if it's just posturing and getting in people's way. I guess the truth is somewhere in between. There are clear advantages to the way the US handles this stuff but perhaps the EU will dodge a bullet or two.
I do think it's a wholeheartedly positive thing that the US and the EU take different approaches. It would be truly awful if there were no differences in our attitudes toward technology and its adoption.
The US is leading in eCommerce with FAANGs. With this trade comes very valuable data mining and 'Surveilance Capitalism' where intimate user behaviours and trends are translated into further competitive advantage.
When you look at the FAANGs. The US gets all the upside (as well as some of the downsides), but the EU gets only downsides. e.g. Amazon will hollow out retail and logistics, as well as computing infrastructure, the economic efficiencies are returned to the US as well as the rich user data.
The EU is struggling to respond in a contructive way. It really needs to create a few tech hubs, and promote new ventures.
Instead, its doing what the EU does best. Kicking the can down the street, and adding bureaucracy to appear to be doing something.
In my personal opinion, Europe (in which I live) as an "Amish bias" [1], i.e. by default being more cautious about introducing new technologies. I am already annoyed by the constant cookie pop-ups that significantly affect my browsing experience but on mobile.
Yes, there are risks with all technologies. But with the current mindset, Europe is setting itself way back comparing to the USA... which is much more cautious than China. Or in other words, Europe sets itself to be the World's calm countryside, in which people live as they used to.
Some (maybe even the majority) may like it. Personally, I am asking myself from time to time - when it is time to move to Asia.
[1] https://kk.org/thetechnium/amish-hackers-a/