News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Li Wenliang by simonh on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:44PM (#22301966)
Understandably there’s a lot of anger directed against the police and administrators that censored Dr Li. Of course they will be convicted of corruption or misconduct or something, but that just makes them victims too. They were doing their jobs exactly the way they were trained and incentivised to do it. I’m not justifying them, actively supporting a corrupt system is a corrupt thing to do, but them being punished by the system they worked for is bullshit.

I just hope Chinese people realise that the censorship of their protests about this is exactly the same as the censorship of Dr Li. It’s the same system run by the same people for the same reasons.

It’s crap like this that the HK protesters are trying to keep out of HK. Most Chinese mainlanders swallowed the party line about HK. I hope this gives them cause to reconsider that attitude.

Re:Li Wenliang by tomphoolery on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:27PM (#22302444)
> but them being punished by the system they worked for is bullshit.

It's not bullshit, it's comeuppance. This is what happens when you just follow orders. The punishment fits the crime.

Re:Li Wenliang by derefr on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:53PM (#22302710)
So, in your opinion, being coerced to kill someone with a gun to your own head would make you guilty of a crime? Most systems of law disagree.

There is a large difference between "orders" that disobedience to results in being fired, or a dishonorable discharge from a military; and "orders" that disobedience to results in being disappeared. The latter is plain-and-simple coercion, no different than being held hostage and being told to do something by your hostage-taker.

Re:Li Wenliang by thaumasiotes on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:04PM (#22303926)
> So, in your opinion, being coerced to kill someone with a gun to your own head would make you guilty of a crime? Most systems of law disagree.

I'm not so sure about this. There are many legal and law-like systems that would agree you've done something wrong by committing the murder, even if you had a good reason.

I'd expect more agreement as to the idea that punishment should be light than that your behavior wasn't wrong in the first place.

Re:Li Wenliang by lostmsu on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:17PM (#22303557)
But there is no gun to their head. Even in China refusing to comply with an order will not give you a death sentence.

Also, being allowed by law does not make stuff automatically justified.

Re:Li Wenliang by Nextgrid on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:41PM (#22302596)
“Following orders” should IMO be graded against the surveillance capabilities of the state.

Disobeying orders on moral grounds was way easier before, but nowadays the people “following orders” are subject to the same surveillance as everyone else so dissent and disobedience is harder and can be squashed easily.

Re:Li Wenliang by simonh on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @06:30AM (#22307944)
I'm not saying they are blameless, or should face no consequences. I tried to make that clear. I'm saying that the system that made them do what they did punishing them for doing it, and then carrying on the same way training and incentivising others to do the same all over again, is not justice. It is a sham facade of justice being used as a distraction from the real injustices of the system.
Re:Li Wenliang by kingludite on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @07:39PM (#22304582)
Someone living in a dictatorship (I dunno which) told me there is one advantage to it: No one believes the official news. He got the impression people in the west really believe everything they read while in reality our western news is as propagandized as theirs if not more.[sic] I don't know how gullible the Chinese are but I assume they find the official narrative pretty suspicious.
Re:Li Wenliang by simonh on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @06:48AM (#22308034)
At least in the west you get to choose your propaganda. There is no single party line all the media have to toe, and different media outlets frequently disagree vigorously with each other.
Re:Li Wenliang by kingludite on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @09:59AM (#22309283)
It's not what they say it is that they dance around the same narrow narrative. How many billions of news worthy topics would there be? We both come to HN in our search for something interesting to read or talk about. After the limited, carefully designed scope has been injected into the collective here too people cant resist pumping it to the front page. If there are specially hot topics that everyone must talk about and everyone is looking at the left hand the right hand is doing all kinds of highly news worthy malicious things that no one talks about.
Re:Li Wenliang by simonh on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @12:13PM (#22310588)
If you think you can do a better job than the mainstream media, go ahead and do it. Nobody will stop you, but you don't get to tell people what to be interested in or care about, any more than the Chinese authorities should.
Re:Li Wenliang by kingludite on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @12:50PM (#22310923)
Not sure what you mean with better. However great the content is doesn't matter. Producing great content consistently is already going to cost money. Buying readers is going to cost even more. How much would it cost to take on say newscorp? But say for sake of argument you happen upon a pile of money at the end of some rainbow. If you then chose to publish rebellious unflattering articles about the status quo there will be infinite funds available to silence you. Not that you will ever get to that point.

I look at things like facebook likes and youtube views for US presidential candidates. There are lots of candidates! The amount of attention they get drops to 200 views per video at the green party. Slightly further down they don't have the likes or views to account for direct friends and relatives.The numbers are so incredibly low that we can see non of the journalists around the world even took notice.

The system is perfect, you cant do better than this.

Re:Li Wenliang by theseadroid on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:05PM (#22302229)
Off the topic, but I feel somehow because HKer only wanted to keep the bad things out of HK, that made the mainland Chinese less sympathetic toward them. To fight against the bad things HKer have to ally with mainland citizens to fight together, which I don't think is being considered even. There's no 独善其身 in this.
Re:Li Wenliang by godelski on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:58PM (#22302769)
I'm not a HKer, but I often her them say things along the lines of "country over party" or "love the country, not the party". I definitely have heard discussion about a desire to unite with mainlanders, but my understanding is that they are having a hard time spreading the message to the mainland. I think reasons for that should be apparent given this particular discussion about censorship.
Re:Li Wenliang by yorwba on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:08PM (#22302877)
FWIW, I have mainland Chinese friends who generally identify as patriotic, but who also use VPNs etc. to better inform themselves. They went to Hong Kong during the National Day celebrations and shared their observations on Weibo. They took note of the fact that there was lots of graffiti, but the only vaguely patriotic slogan was "love the country, not the party". The post wasn't taken down, as far as I know, so the message spread at least slightly, despite the censorship.
Re:Li Wenliang by theseadroid on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:57PM (#22303874)
If possible could you please provide some sources? Or it’s just heard in person? I’ve been living outside of China for years and read many pro independent sources especially during the protests but haven’t seen any on uniting with mainlanders. And during the protests I’ve seen reports of protesters trashing businesses that are related to mainland and infrastructure connecting to mainland. I don’t think they think every mainland business is CCP sponsored don’t they?
Re:Li Wenliang by godelski on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:27PM (#22305469)
https://www.reddit.com/r/HongKong/comments/crn4qr/im_startin...

I'll admit, on /r/HongKong the "unify with mainlanders" posts don't rise up. It is not trendy. Probably because a lot of people interact with mainlanders that are against their movement. Which my understanding is that this is a selection bias (mainlanders that support them aren't seen). But this is going to happen in any movement that has a lot of fear in it (there is clear justification for the fear).

Re:Li Wenliang by theseadroid on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @09:37AM (#22309103)
Communicating/Interacting with ppl who have different opinions is hard enough. But what I meant by allying is even harder than that. It's to help them get the freedom they wanted first. It will be a long process but I think that's the only solution. Only when China is more free then HK will surely not lose its freedom. It's some effort to protest and wave US/UK flags during a protest. It's some effort to get US/UK to have economic sanction against CN. It's some effort to say we have done our best to inform mainlanders of what's going on. Not all of those effort will help and for the ones that help they are probably not enough. Only mainland citizens can make China more free. We can install a "democracy" in China tomorrow but if the citizens don't have the knowledge to use it then HK might end up in a worse situation, facing the full strength of the tyranny of the majority.
Re:Li Wenliang by simonh on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @06:46AM (#22308026)
There were protests at the border checkpoints trying to reach out to mainlanders and inform them of what the protests were about, and counteract mainland government propaganda.
Re:Li Wenliang by theseadroid on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:33AM (#22309597)
Informing is good, but that's far away from uniting/allying them.
Re:Li Wenliang by im3w1l on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:04PM (#22302218)
I can see where you are coming from, but don't these police and administrators have some level of discretion?
Re:Li Wenliang by rebuilder on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:51PM (#22302693)
Enough rope to hang themselves.

Create a culture where it's clear how you need to exercise your discretion, and refrain from giving direct orders. Voila, scapegoats.

Re:Li Wenliang by mc32 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:14PM (#22302308)
Also factions will use these sorts of events to push other factions out.

Depending on the scale of things we might see some changes at the top. It’s no accident that mr Xi is putting one of his lieutenants in charge of the response (to have separation and also convenient pint to blame —but that only goes so far).

Re:Li Wenliang by keanzu on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:20PM (#22302977)
> I’m not justifying them, actively supporting a corrupt system is a corrupt thing to do

Ok, I'll justify them. There is almost no chance that anyone in the saga decided to do the evil thing because they wanted to watch the world burn. Not the government policy makers nor the police who carried out their orders. Every person is doing what they believe is the right thing. Some of the people were mistaken. With the benefit of hindsight we can see that Li Wenliang was not mistaken.

How many SARS II hoaxes has the government stomped on that we never heard about. How many doctors or patients in a nation of ~billion people have misidentified an outbreak of the common cold as "the next SARS" in the last 17 years. They aggressively stamp out the embers of a rumor before it gets going and becomes a raging fire of panic. This time the government erred, it wasn't a misidentification, the virus was real. They aren't evil or corrupt or murderous. They are fallible humans and they make a mistake.

Re:Li Wenliang by edanm on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:26PM (#22303050)
That's a false dichotomy. It isn't either a hoax, or real.

More importantly, it isn't that either the government decides to stamp out info, or hoaxes/misidentifications will become a "raging fire of panic".

In most of the western world (among other places), everyone is free to say what they like. The government doesn't get the right to decide what you can and can't say. And yes, hoaxes happen. Misinformation happens. But I don't think there have been these massive problems that you're foreseeing. And what's more, it's not clear that the government has the right to decide what's worse - these kinds of problems, or potentially more people dying.

Re:Li Wenliang by keanzu on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:35PM (#22303145)
I was trying to suggest that human are fallible - doctors, patients, police and policy makers all; however I used the word hoax way too much as both responses focus on that. I've reworded. Hopefully that addresses the issue?

> the government decides to stamp out info

There are other ways, as you've described, but I believe this is the way the Chinese government has demonstrated that they prefer to handle it. You can argue it is a wrong choice but I can't accept the OP's characterization of it as a corrupt choice.

Re:Li Wenliang by throwaway1997 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @07:16PM (#22304441)
That would maybe work if he wasn't arrested for talking about this problem in a private WeChat group. Li wasn't trying to announce it to the world at this point, he was just discussing with his peers.
Re:Li Wenliang by radicaldreamer on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:22PM (#22303007)
What hoaxes would have involved 7-8 doctors in the same city, at the same time?
Re:Li Wenliang by datashow on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:36PM (#22302549)
Also remember lots of things changed under Xi. China never allows political dissidence, but it is under Xi where everything in WeChat is heavily monitored and people get arrested for all sorts of minor things. So Xi is personally responsible for the Wuhan coronavirus outbreak.
Re:Li Wenliang by chaostheory on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:46PM (#22302652)
Before XJ, China seemed to be gradually opening up. IMO it was inevitable that one of their metros would eclipse Silicon Valley. Now with XJ in power, a lockdown on freedom of expression, and a more perfect execution of state policy; I no longer see it happening. It’s more likely that India will have Silicon Valley’s successor in the future, if anyone can produce one
Re:Li Wenliang by keanzu on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:57PM (#22302765)
That's a technological advance and not a policy change. WeChat didn't exist prior to 2011 and Xi Jinping rose to power in 2012.
Re:Li Wenliang by datashow on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:05PM (#22302840)
There were other popular social media platforms in the past, such as Sina Weibo and other online discussion boards, which were not heavily monitored as WeChat is.
Re:Li Wenliang by keanzu on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:12PM (#22302907)
Fair enough. At that time, and we are talking going back 10 years now, did the government lack the will or the technical capability to carry out the large scale monitoring?
Re:Li Wenliang by datashow on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:19PM (#22302967)
I don't think it is a technical thing.

Remember niubo, which ran from 2006 to 2013? https://baike.baidu.com/item/%E7%89%9B%E5%8D%9A%E7%BD%91 It is just a website, there is no technical difficulty to shut it down.

Re:Li Wenliang by simonh on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @05:36AM (#22307673)
My wife is Chinese and we used to use Skype to video-chat with her family. From about 2008 the only version of Skype you could download in China was called TOM Skype, a modified version with back doors enabling Chinese state surveillance of communications. Links to regular Skype download sites were blocked and redirected you to TOM Skype.

So none of this is really new. As technology and platforms have developed, the Chinese state has improved and expanded it's surveillance and suppression apparatus. I'm no fan of Xi and the situation has definitely worsened under him, but this is how the system works.

Re:Li Wenliang by AareyBaba on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:08PM (#22302869)
When Fury Overcomes Fear by Xu Zhangrun - is a good read. The professor who wrote this has been suspended.

http://www.chinafile.com/reporting-opinion/viewpoint/viral-a...

Re:Li Wenliang by allovernow on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:53PM (#22302094)
> Of course they will be convicted of corruption or misconduct or something

What? No such thing will happen. This is an authoritarian regime. The government will never admit wrongdoing. They'll attempt to sweep it under the rug and continue operating with a "perfect" record.

Re:Li Wenliang by heavyset_go on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:03PM (#22302813)
> What? No such thing will happen.

We're already seeing it happen with Beijing blaming the mishandling of the virus outbreak on local authorities in Wuhan. The people are rightfully looking for a witch to burn, and the CCP will give them one that doesn't upset their hold on power.

Re:Li Wenliang by keymone on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:55PM (#22302104)
Authoritarian regimes often punish scape goats to appease public.
Re:Li Wenliang by allovernow on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:04PM (#22302214)
Good point. I hadn't considered that. What a terrifying way to live - serving your government knowing that at any point you may be thrown under the bus for following orders.
Re:Li Wenliang by timc13 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:12PM (#22302283)
Re:Li Wenliang by davidw on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:28PM (#22302458)
Indeed, I feel terrified these days. I'm old enough to have seen various administrations, but nothing quite like this in scope and quantity.
Re:Li Wenliang by jedmeyers on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:50PM (#22302690)
Which orders did Vindman follow and later was punished for, exactly? I would actually put Snowden as an example of a regime punishing the whistleblower.
Re:Li Wenliang by keanzu on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:02PM (#22302803)
Snowden didn't follow the orders to the letter and then get punished. He wasn't a scapegoat for following a broad government policy which later became inconvenient/unpopular. He became an enemy of the state for opposing a government policy.
Re:Li Wenliang by harikb on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:06PM (#22302850)
Did you ask that same question above about Snowden? Like “what orders did he follow”?

If we are talking about whistleblower protection, it should be same whether the delivered news is favorable to you/us or not

Re:Li Wenliang by jedmeyers on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:09PM (#22302881)
> it should be same whether the delivered news is favorable to you/us or not

The question is usually "is it favorable to the CIA/NSA or not?".

Favorable (Vindman/Cia<mare>lla) -> whistleblower

Unfavorable (Snowden) -> leaker

Re:Li Wenliang by harikb on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:43PM (#22303226)
whistleblower, working for a non-spy org, reporting what he believes to be illegal conduct to congress one one side.

second is a guy who stole secrets he wasn't even supposed to have access to, ran with it and leaked to a russian mob controlled outlet.

whatever

Re:Li Wenliang by jedmeyers on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:49PM (#22303828)
> reporting what he believes to be illegal conduct to congress one one side.

“Former” cia analyst that was directly involved in the events being investigated by the administration is reporting through his friends to an associate in Congress about an “illegal” conduct. Sounds a bit more like covering up former shady deals for his political friends.

Re:Li Wenliang by seppin on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:02PM (#22302805)
Snowden famously avoided any type of punishment by fleeing. Vindman was fired but will surely land on his feet somewhere.
Re:Li Wenliang by jedmeyers on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:11PM (#22302895)
> Vindman was fired but will surely land on his feet somewhere.

Was he "fired" or just reassigned? As far as I understand he is still an officer in the armed forces.

Re:Li Wenliang by davidw on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:03PM (#22303410)
The admin is now making noise about 'disciplinary action' against him, I read just now. That seems to be very recent, so we'll see if it's the full story.

FWIW, his brother was turfed out, too.

Re:Li Wenliang by SolaceQuantum on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:10PM (#22302268)
As long as you're not the scapegoat you're in a position of power relative to the proles, though.
Re:Li Wenliang by tartoran on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:01PM (#22302187)
Thats a known tactic of authoritarian regimes. And people don’t get it, they’re brainwashed and powerless
Re:Li Wenliang by wefarrell on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:12PM (#22302287)
It's human nature and isn't unique to authoritarian societies. People prefer to know that a problem was caused by a villain rather than a systemic failure.

Authoritarians are particularly good at getting people to take the blame.

Re:Li Wenliang by keanzu on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:28PM (#22302463)
> Authoritarians are particularly good at getting people to take the blame.

Everyone is guilty of something, you can get people to take the blame for things they didn't do even in a democracy.

"Most of the defendants were persuaded that they had repressed memories of the crime."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beatrice_Six

[dead]
Re:Li Wenliang by dmoy on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:56PM (#22302115)
It's more nuanced than believing China can do no wrong.

I have family (edit: living in mainland) that will admit personally that Xi Jinping is probably crazy and bad for things (maybe I shouldn't put that in writing?). But at the same time, there's a lot of faith given to the government that's increased literacy from 50-98%, increased GDP per capita from $100/yr to $10k/yr, built all the infrastructure, etc etc, in like less than 50 years, without major armed conflict.

Remember that prior to 1950, China had a couple centuries spotted with wars, rebellions, etc that killed tens and tens of millions of people.

Stability and prosperity buys a lot of good will.

Edit: because I just threw out numbers without comparison, the $100-$10k growth in 50 years is comparable to the period in the US from literally before the US was a country (pre 1800s) to about 1950 ish. That's how long it took the US to get from $100-$10k (real) per capita GDP. China did it in 50 years. US didn't have literacy rates below 50% since like before 1850 (actually it looks like already 70% literacy by 1850?), and only got to 98% literacy by ~1960.

Growth, stability, and prosperity doesn't excuse things, but it does explain why people are maybe more forgiving than we are looking in.

Re:Li Wenliang by whatshisface on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:01PM (#22302178)
>Stability and prosperity buys a lot of good will.

The other side of this is that if hard times ever come, there will be no true believers in the system around to hold things together until the situation improves.

Re:Li Wenliang by dmoy on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:33PM (#22302522)
I personally agree.

If the gravy train of growth ever stops, I think it could very quickly get very, very scary.

On the other hand, if the gravy train just coasts a bit and slows down gradually, after prosperity increases another say 4x, and is accompanied by gradual relaxation in liberties and other measures of quality of life (looking at you, Beijing air quality), then maybe it'll be ok.

Nobody can predict how it will pan out imo.

Re:Li Wenliang by thaumasiotes on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:11PM (#22303968)
Indeed, this was and to a certain extent is a major problem for the Qing dynasty (the last one), which consisted of widely-hated foreigners who had conquered China.

The Japanese have a certain ability to resist cultural messages from the West by looking to the legitimacy of the Emperor, which notionally goes back 2600 years. The Chinese have a long cultural tradition to draw on in a similar manner, but it's much more challenging when the legitimacy you're trying to invoke petered out in the 17th century. Vowing to maintain the traditions that obtained under the despised invaders just isn't as moving of a message.

More recently, the Soviet Union also fell apart after everybody stopped believing in it... but was that a bad thing?

Re:Li Wenliang by MagnumOpus on Friday February 14, 2020 @04:21AM (#22325137)
> if hard times ever come, there will be no true believers

That is where brain washing and xenophobia come in. Just like in Russia, the CCP is already preparing for the hard times by blaming ills on the Other. I.e. the US (especially around trade war, and military alliances in the pac rim), Japan (reviving WW2 resentment), Western Europe (propaganda around "century of humiliation"), Taiwan, HK and so on.

The strategy is to create brainless followers who will reject foreign media output just because it comes from "the enemy".

Re:Li Wenliang by monkeycantype on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:01PM (#22303387)
I'm always surprised to hear that the government, rather than the people of China are credited with the recent lift in quality of life in China. It was Deng Xiaoping's decision to reduce government control of the economy and people's lives, giving Chinese people greater freedom to make their own decisions that has unleashed some of China's potential. We shouldn't be surprised if China becomes the wealthiest nation in the world. We should expect a nation with China's cultural and intellectual wealth can draw competent leaders that govern with competence, what should be surprising is that it was once so brutally and chaotically governed that it was ever poor.
Re:Li Wenliang by malandrew on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:38PM (#22302570)
It's not as hard to do it in 50 years when you're starting with the sum total of knowledge available 50 years ago. Doing it in 150 years, starting 220 years ago is far more challenging and impressive.

Otherwise, I agree with the rest of what you wrote.

Re:Li Wenliang by em500 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:56PM (#22302749)
Perhaps the more apt comparison is democratic India, which had the same sum total of knowledge available 50 years ago and was at similar poverty level. Yet authoritarian China ended up roughly 3 to 5 times richer today.

Even if all you need to do is catch-up growth, rapid implementation is far from given. It's not the idea but the execution that matters, as techies would say.

Re:Li Wenliang by yorwba on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:21PM (#22303002)
If you look at GDP per capita figures for China vs. India, they were mostly comparable until about 1990 (India was actually slightly in the lead): https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?end=1990...

After 1990, China really took off: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?location...

Of course China didn't suddenly turn authoritarian in 1990, so this is not a democracy vs. authoritarianism issue. Rather, it's that the authoritarian decided to change the way they were doing things. (Deng Xiaoping's "reform and opening up".)

Re:Li Wenliang by em500 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:32PM (#22303109)
> Of course China didn't suddenly turn authoritarian in 1990, so this is not a democracy vs. authoritarianism issue.

Given the development of India, we might conclude that a democratic/non-authoritarian government is neither sufficient nor necessary to gain a good standard of living.

Re:Li Wenliang by dmoy on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @05:43PM (#22303792)
Oh for sure, it's way easier.

Especially with certain... methods... of IP transfer.

The fact that china relinquished communist economic models in favor of capitalism most certainly helped a lot too.

Re:Li Wenliang by aianus on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:11PM (#22302274)
If their values are stability and prosperity then why do they look down on Western governance which has resulted in both more stability and greater prosperity than China?
Re:Li Wenliang by dmoy on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:30PM (#22302486)
It's kind of like (and this is a terrible metaphor/analogy, so sorry) why some companies have a higher market cap but lower revenue and profit. Trajectory matters.

I don't know why you get downvoted for asking that, it's an eminently reasonable question to ask.

Also most Chinese I've talked to don't look down on Western governments or structure of government, they just don't have any particular motivation for thinking it's better for them. I can't say what the average person in mainland actually thinks, of course.

Re:Li Wenliang by dirtyid on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:52PM (#22302707)
Because successful western governance is predicated from stability and prosperity developed through state capitalism. Not the other way around. Almost everywhere western governance model has been applied without first developing domestic industries via state directed mercantilism, the country either fails or stays poor. You need an authoritarian government phase to rapidly build a base. China is following the proven Asian Tiger model, it just takes longer to uplift 1.4b people, if that's possible at all. Almost every rich western country today behaved like China during their industrial revolution. Also they're not blind, every Chinese can look to Indian and know democracy + huge population either doesn't work or doesn't work fast enough.
Re:Li Wenliang by aianus on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:18PM (#22304039)
> Almost every rich western country today behaved like China during their industrial revolution

I'm not a historian so please correct me if I'm wrong but the US gained independence, democracy, and the rule of law well before the industrial revolution. I'm pretty sure 90%+ of the population were still subsistence farmers back then.

Outside of the world wars I'm not sure the US ever practiced state capitalism either. They didn't even have a central bank until 1913.

Re:Li Wenliang by the-dude on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:52PM (#22302074)
In the U.S. this is called 'American exceptionalism'.
Re:Li Wenliang by allovernow on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:00PM (#22302168)
Absolute nonsense to equate the idea of American Exceptionalism with Chinese nationalism. We don't get "admonished" or sent to work camps for being insufficiently or even anti-nationalistic. Our schools regularly even have curricula where American exceptionalism is questioned, unlike the Chinese model where the government is beyond questioning lest you risk a lowered social credit score and a trip to the gulag.

I swear people don't understand how good we have it in the West and how differently people think in China when they are subject to fervent brainwashing from birth. It is extremely difficult to even think to question the government when you have been explicitly and implicitly conditioned from birth to tow the line. Ask a Chinese national coworker about Coronavirus right now and how things are going there and watch them not even flinch when they tell you that everything's fine and under control - just know that if you do so you are putting them on the spot. They are so used to having their digital and in person communications monitored that they wouldn't risk even telling you the truth in person.

Re:Li Wenliang by yorwba on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:15PM (#22302319)
> Ask a Chinese national coworker about Coronavirus right now and how things are going there and watch them not even flinch when they tell you that everything's fine and under control

In my WeChat feed, I've seen a lot of panic about not being able to buy face masks or Shuanghuanglian and other kinds of traditional medicine, as well as outrage about the city of Dali intercepting shipments of face masks destined for other regions. "Everything's fine and under control" looks more like a minority opinion. Of course that could be biased by me attracting a certain kind of people, but ironically the harshest critics of the government in this case have been people I think of as "strong China" patriots/nationalists. Turns out they react especially negatively to government failures.

Re:Li Wenliang by thaumasiotes on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:35PM (#22303139)
My contacts agree with you. (To be fair, I'm going off what I hear from ~4 people.)

Nobody believes everything's fine. Views of the government are at rock bottom. Trust in the government is zero or negative.

Here are some things that have been said to me (though this is private messages, not public feed posts):

> the government is shit! [2020-01-24, followed by much unsolicited venting about the state of things in Wuhan as reported through unofficial channels]

> 我觉得这次的疫情好像已经时空了 [I think it looks like we've already lost control of this epidemic] [2020-02-05]

> 封闭了小区,外面的人不允许进来。每天还消毒(Me: 内面的人可以出来吗?)可以的,但是要有“出入证” [Our apartment complex has sealed itself, outsiders cannot enter. We disinfect every day. (Me: Can insiders leave?) Yes, but you need an exit/entry document] [2020-02-10]

> 如果说,现在社会忽然流传某种说法,然后政府辟谣,然后大家就知道,这个说法是真的 [If a rumor suddenly spread through society, and then the government denied it, everyone would know it was the truth.] [2020-02-10]

Social trust is down too; I also hear rumors of escapees from Wuhan concealing their sickness (this one's easy to believe) and of sick people striking back at the society that failed them by spreading their saliva on elevator buttons and doorknobs.

Re:Li Wenliang by allovernow on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:44PM (#22303229)
Thank you for this small window into another world.
Re:Li Wenliang by thaumasiotes on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:18PM (#22304036)
Something that stuck with me (from long before the current crisis) was when I asked a friend how she thought Chinese people generally perceived America. The response was much as you'd expect: some people see it as a faraway paradise, some feel pretty negative, many don't really care.

But she specifically mentioned one guy from her workplace who fell into the "relentlessly negative" camp, always criticizing America if he got the opportunity. She said even he admitted the US did one good thing that deserved the thanks of the Chinese people.

That thing was publishing air pollution numbers based on measurements in American consulates in China.

I usually think about this in terms of the apparently huge diplomatic win it presented for very minor effort, but it also says something about the level of trust in the Chinese government pre-crisis.

Re:Li Wenliang by thaumasiotes on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @07:09PM (#22304399)
post-edit-window edit: the typo 时空 ("spacetime") for 失控 ("lose control") is mine, not my correspondent's.
Re:Li Wenliang by dwohnitmok on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:29PM (#22302479)
I'm also seeing some more critical views of the government show up on my WeChat feed. I think neutral views of the government/exhortations to stay positive among my contacts on my feed still wins out slightly, but there's definitely some pretty harsh criticism and in some cases, disillusionment.

The Chinese government is probably keenly aware of the growing discontent and is unlikely to overplay their hand and crack down hard on communications, at least at the moment. For example, they could've decided to block all mentions of Li Wenliang from the Chinese internet (as has happened with many other things in the past), but they haven't, at least not obviously. If they did, I suspect discontent would explode.

Re:Li Wenliang by thaumasiotes on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:39PM (#22303181)
> The Chinese government is probably keenly aware of the growing discontent and is unlikely to overplay their hand and crack down hard on communications, at least at the moment. For example, they could've decided to block all mentions of Li Wenliang from the Chinese internet (as has happened with many other things in the past), but they haven't, at least not obviously. If they did, I suspect discontent would explode.

Censorship on the topic is apparently being felt. https://www.unz.com/jderbyshire/still-90-chance-coronavirus-...

> Dr Li died on Wednesday or Thursday from exposure to the coronavirus. He leaves behind a pregnant wife and a young child. He is being dramatically mourned on social media sites, faster than the censors can scrub them. [Widespread Outcry in China Over Death of Coronavirus Doctor, by Li Yuan, NYT, February 7, 2020]( https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/07/business/china-coronaviru... ) There have even been demands he be given a state funeral.

> That bagpipe band playing “Amazing Grace” that I heard while crossing my living-room was a popular nonverbal way to mourn. The censors rely on keywords in text; it takes them longer to figure out nonverbal protests.

Re:Li Wenliang by allovernow on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:53PM (#22302722)
I appreciate your perspective. As an insider, do you think we can trust recently published literature from Chinese sources regarding the virus? This article[1] for example is somewhat reassuring but I don't know if the numbers are trustworthy. On the other hand I imagine academia is at least somewhat insulated from the reaches of the government and academics are probably more likely to be willing to take risks to communicate truth.

1.https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.02.06.20020974v...

Re:Li Wenliang by dwohnitmok on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:14PM (#22302927)
I'm not sure how much I'd consider myself an insider... luckily I happened to not be in China when all this happened so I'm watching from afar as well (although I would like to go back for a bit when all this blows over).

No real idea sorry. I mean things look more transparent than what happened with SARS (which I can get into detail about if you want) and there's way more discussion in various different online venues this time around (more people also have access to the internet), but I don't really think I have a more trustworthy opinion beyond that weak assertion.

And on the ground, well there's a lot of conflicting reports as happens in any major event.

Re:Li Wenliang by ashwinaj on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @10:01PM (#22305334)
> In my WeChat feed, I've seen a lot of panic

This is the problem, everything is hush hush or online. No one has the _____ to stand up and say this is not right. I'm only contrasting this with democratic govts. (However flawed the system is) have a voice to stand against a govt. This is non existent in China.

Re:Li Wenliang by yorwba on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @02:59AM (#22306832)
> everything is hush hush or online. No one has the _____ to stand up and say this is not right.

What do you even mean by this? Online is how you reach the largest audience, so of course people are speaking out online if they want others to hear what they have to say.

Re:Li Wenliang by ashwinaj on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:33AM (#22309599)
> Online is how you reach the largest audience

So? Is this going to cause any change in the government's behavior: No.

This is the literal definition of a paper tiger.

Re:Li Wenliang by minikites on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:06PM (#22302232)
>We don't get "admonished" or sent to work camps for being insufficiently or even anti-nationalistic.

Colin Kaepernick was blackballed from the NFL for kneeling during the Pledge of Allegiance. Look at what happened to the Dixie Chicks:

> On March 10, 2003, during a London concert, nine days before the 2003 invasion of Iraq, lead vocalist Maines told the audience: "We don't want this war, this violence, and we're ashamed that the President of the United States (George W. Bush) is from Texas," which garnered a positive reaction from the British audience but led to a contrasting negative reaction, and ensuing boycotts, in the United States, where talk shows denounced the band, their albums were discarded in public protest and corporate broadcasting networks blacklisted them for the remainder of the Bush years.

Re:Li Wenliang by readarticle on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:19PM (#22302362)
It is a genuine human accomplishment that in the west, we hold being left unemployed by a sports league or uncovered by broadcasting networks comparable to state level abuses of human rights.

It’s not often I feel “pride” for where I was randomly born, but your comment brought a bit of it out through this shift in perspective, thank you.

Re:Li Wenliang by allovernow on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:24PM (#22303037)
Do you feel like you are risking your livelihood, reputation, or personal safety for publically posting comments critical of the U.S. government and/or U.S. culture? Because I guarantee the average Chinese citizen does. That's the critical difference.

Corruption exists in the U.S. but thankfully authoritarianism does not (yet).

Re:Li Wenliang by yorwba on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:33PM (#22303123)
> I guarantee the average Chinese citizen does.

How do you make this guarantee? The average Chinese citizen I know expects critical comments to be deleted, but getting a visit by the police is rare. I know one person to whom that happened, in the early 2010s. He didn't suffer any major repercussions beyond being told to stop posting like he did.

Re:Li Wenliang by minikites on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:40PM (#22303190)
Decades of red-baiting propaganda warps people's ideas of what these countries are actually like.
Re:Li Wenliang by simonh on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @07:11AM (#22308163)
My wife is Chinese and I know from her and her family exactly what it was like for them. When my father in law talks about the hardships inflicted on their family he tears up. You clearly have absolutely no idea what it's actually like.

Equating arbitrary detention, re-education camps and political executions to being boycotted by some TV stations is a shameful farce.

Yes in the west things can go badly wrong, innocent people can get chewed up and hurt much more than a trivial example like the Dixie Chicks. Good grief, that's the best you could come up with? But the Chinese system is based on knowingly trashing people's lives systematically on a massive scale.

Re:Li Wenliang by allovernow on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:56PM (#22303341)
There are millions of immigrants from the former Soviet Union who will tell you exactly what it is like to live under an authoritarian socialist regime.

Life in other countries can be very different from what you've experienced in the U.S.

Re:Li Wenliang by allovernow on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:47PM (#22303264)
......you think that's ok? You don't think after being reprimanded he feels that way now? You don't think his social credit score likely took a hit, if it existed back then?

Perhaps visits from police are rare because it's enough to be warned with the implicit threat of punishment for future transgressions? That alone, being forced by the government to delete material (i.e. no first amendment right) is what I'm talking about.

Re:Li Wenliang by yorwba on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @08:22PM (#22304823)
I don't think it's ok in the sense that it's not some kind of acceptable trade-off to make for a society-wide benefit or something like that, but I think it's ok in the sense that it's just a minor annoyance that doesn't make life unlivable. China is not some kind of dystopian hellhole where citizens constantly feel the government's boot on their necks. The government doesn't allow people to express themselves freely, but that doesn't stop many from doing it anyway. There simply aren't enough police officers to react to every violation. It doesn't exactly cow people into submission. My friend obviously wasn't praising the government when he told me how they tried to make him shut up.

I think you should be careful not to assume too much about life in a foreign country you haven't experienced for yourself.

Case in point, you talk about the social credit system as if it were operational, maybe even back then. In reality, nation-wide rollout is planned for this year, and many details are still up in the air. There are local pilot projects, but all of them are different and many are limited to providing data on companies (often not much, essentially just putting the company register online). Any stories you may have heard about people being punished by the social credit system are actually low-tech solutions without scores that have been rebranded, presumably so someone can claim to be on schedule implementing the master plan.

Re:Li Wenliang by mrosett on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:59PM (#22302772)
Kaepernick landed as the face of Nike with a massive endorsement deal for his trouble, which I guess is sort of like being sent to a a work camp.
Re:Li Wenliang by erik_seaberg on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:14PM (#22302304)
This is "don't piss off half the customers", not top-down censorship.
Re:Li Wenliang by runarberg on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:59PM (#22302773)
Though true, it needs clarification why this difference is important. I’m not entirely convinced that it is.

Edit, to paraphrase: Why is it any different that control comes top down from a government or from a board of directors of a company?

Re:Li Wenliang by aianus on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:22PM (#22304061)
You can buy things from a different company or work for a different company or lobby your government to go after the company and stop their behavior.

It's much much harder to move countries, if they even let you.

Re:Li Wenliang by runarberg on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @05:03PM (#22313305)
Though I agree that there is a difference in scope, I’m not entirely sure what you say applies to the NFL. I guess Kaepernick would have to move to Australia if he wants to keep playing professional football.

This supposed option of choice only applies if there is non-monopoly and there is an equal power dynamic between consumers/workers and heads of company. Neither is true of the NFL.

Re:Li Wenliang by minikites on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:10PM (#22302888)
So being governed by corporations is superior to a government of the people?
Re:Li Wenliang by uwuhn on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:09PM (#22302259)
Was anyone in either of your two examples imprisoned because of what they said or did?
Re:Li Wenliang by beerandt on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:22PM (#22302392)
Also, I don't think most people cared about their political beliefs. And that's why it blew up, in both cases. They cared because they were customers, who were paying for entertainment, but receiving a lecture/statement on politics.

When you're an entertainer, you risk your livelihood by upsetting your fans. That's not government censorship; it's a bad business decision.

Re:Li Wenliang by minikites on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:02PM (#22302806)
Does the punishment need to meet a certain severity level to be "bad"? The parent comment I replied to made it sound like criticizing the government is free from any consequences in the West, which is patently false.
Re:Li Wenliang by uwuhn on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:38PM (#22304177)
It's not about the severity of the punishment so much as who administers it.
Re:Li Wenliang by ashwinaj on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:56PM (#22302123)
Sure, but people can openly criticize the US govt and it's policies. Can they do this in China?

A sense of national pride should not trump objectivity.

Re:Li Wenliang by the-dude on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @02:59PM (#22302158)
Of course they can criticize the US govt in China.
Re:Li Wenliang by ashwinaj on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:15PM (#22302318)
I am talking about Chinese citizens criticizing the Chinese govt. __in China__ the same way as American citizens can criticize the American govt. in America, if it wasn't obvious. And by criticizing I mean openly criticizing in public, not hiding behind some pseudonym online
Re:Li Wenliang by PeterisP on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:25PM (#22302424)
It comes off as a play on the old Cold War joke (crude translation of how I remember it being told in the 1980s in Russian) with an American and a Russian discussing about their regimes; and the American proudly says - we have freedom of speech, I can go next to the White House with a banner saying "Reagan is a fool!" and that's going to be okay; to which the Russian responds - so what, that's not any advantage, I can also go to the Red Square with a banner saying "Reagan is a fool!" and there won't be any problems...
Re:Li Wenliang by the-dude on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:26PM (#22302438)
An American and a Russian are sitting in a bar, arguing over whose country was better. The American argues,

"See, in America, I am free to do whatever I want. If I wanted to, I could walk right into the White House, slam my fist on the President's desk, and say 'Mr. President, I don't like the way you are running our country.'"

The Russian then said, "I can do the same thing."

"Really? You can?" asks the American.

"Yes," continues the Russian, "If I wanted to, I could walk right into the Kremlin, slam my fist on the General Secretary's office, and say 'Mr. General Secretary, I don't like the way President Reagan is running his country.'"

Sourced from https://upjoke.com/ronald-reagan-jokes

Re:Li Wenliang by tenpies on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:04PM (#22302216)
Perhaps, but at the same time I have never met such self-hating people as urban Americans post-2016.

The exceptionalism might be the degree of freedom it allows in thoughts about their own Americanism, and the seeming ability to believe both ends of the spectrum at the same time.

Re:Li Wenliang by jbay808 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:31PM (#22302508)
They don't hate themselves, they hate their non-like-minded compatriots.

Just like when one sees a big pickup truck festooned with american flags and the pledge of allegiance plastered across the rear window, it's not to express their sheer joy in being American, but to admonish their non-like-minded compatriots for being insufficiently 'American'.

Re:Li Wenliang by kelnos on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:51PM (#22302696)
I don't hate myself; I hate the series of events and conditions that has turned the US into a severely-divided nation where half of the country has been brainwashed into voting for people who believe that rights and empathy and power should only be granted to straight cis-gendered white people and/or "true Americans", for whatever arbitrary definition of that they've decided on in a given week.
Re:Li Wenliang by woodgrainz on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:54PM (#22302734)
There is no freedom of speech, press, religion, or assembly in China. There is no comparison to be made.
Re:Li Wenliang by catblast on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @04:03PM (#22302811)
Which Chinese Citizens in the US are you referring to?
Re:Li Wenliang by theseadroid on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @06:04PM (#22303928)
Chinese are sooo brain washed. Trump supporters are sooo brain washed. Seems there’s a tendency that for people we don’t really understand their motives, can’t take their perspectives we just assume they are brain washed. Like with that assumption we can just ignore any opinions that are different?
Re:Li Wenliang by noobermin on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @03:11PM (#22302279)
You don't need to look very far in the US to see similar abuses and well, a complete failure of oversight. I hope I don't have to enumerate the failures but, in no short order, Iraq and WMD, Vietnam, Iran Contra, Trump's impeachment, the generalized legalized bribery of campaign finance contributions in the US...