News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by irthomasthomas on Monday February 10, 2020 @08:35AM (#22288934)
I thought Chomsky's quote was interesting.

"Take the most advanced case: Mondragon. It’s worker owned, it’s not worker managed, although the management does come from the workforce often, but it’s in a market system and they still exploit workers in South America, and they do things that are harmful to the society as a whole and they have no choice. If you’re in a system where you must make profit in order to survive, you're compelled to ignore negative externalities, effects on others."

Re:Mondragon Corporation by mcprwklzpq on Monday February 10, 2020 @01:37PM (#22291861)
This quote without context might give impression that Chomsky is critical of Mondragon. A bit of context around it helps to understand his point. From [1]:

“LF: So it sounds as if you might support something like the Cleveland model where the ownership of the company is actually held by members of the community as well as the workers…

NC: That’s a step forward but you also have to get beyond that to dismantle the system of production for profit rather than production for use. That means dismantling at least large parts of market systems. <<here this quote about Mondragon>>

Markets also have a very bad psychological effect. They drive people to a conception of themselves and society in which you’re only after your own good, not the good of others and that’s extremely harmful.

LF: Have you ever had a taste of a non market system — had a flash of optimism –– oh this is how we could live?

NC: A functioning family for example, and there are bigger groups, cooperatives are a case in point. It certainly can be done. The biggest I know is Mondragon but there are many in between and a lot more could be done.”

1 - https://www.counterpunch.org/2012/04/30/talking-with-chomsky...

Re:Mondragon Corporation by jp555 on Monday February 10, 2020 @09:13AM (#22289220)
Is the alternative 100% top-down central-managed solution to ensure no externalization happens ever? In theory that's appealing (especial from the view from Chomsky's academic ivory tower), but then in practice every time it's been tried it hasn't worked well at all.

Chomsky is smart, but not very useful because "In theory there's no difference between theory and practice, but in practice there is" - Yogi Berra

Re:Mondragon Corporation by tsimionescu on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:17AM (#22289782)
Chomsky is anti-centralization, he is an anarchist (anarcho-syndicalist).

In general, his ideal end-goal world would include smaller states with more direct control by the populace, with worker-owned and worker-managed corporations, with free markets of goods and services between different corporations and different states, and of course freedom of movement. Strong environmental control would be almost implied if the people doing an economic activity were in charge of decisions and were also directly impacted by the effects of those decisions. Localizing and letting corporations be small would also put a natural cap on inequality, though democratically run states could impose additional safeguards where needed (minimum wages, estate taxes, non-discrimination clauses etc.)

Re:Mondragon Corporation by cies on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:55AM (#22290146)
I thought the workers in Mondragon could vote to have the CEO removed. Hence mgmt being under worker's control, ultimately.

I understand that workers also, at times, vote to externalize some costs, as their jobs may depend on it.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by einpoklum on Monday February 10, 2020 @06:25PM (#22294507)
> In general, his ideal end-goal world would include smaller states with more direct control by the populace

That's certainly not Anarchism, in which there are no states and no commercial corporations. And of course - no markets.

Now, as for what Chomsky supports personally - that's more difficult to say, since he's been known to support Democrats in US politics, to support a two-state arrangement in Palestine etc.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by zepto on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:48AM (#22290082)
Surely you would need a lot of rules and enforcement to prevent things simply aggregating?
Re:Mondragon Corporation by golemotron on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:56AM (#22290156)
That's where it falls apart. Systems tend to aggregate to seek efficiencies of scale.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by leto_ii on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:03AM (#22290237)
I tend to not agree with this line of thinking. This may be the case when you subject a company to financial market pressures by listing it on the stock exchange, but I don't think it's a natural imperative.

Many companies do just fine without growing to enormous proportions, being acquired, acquiring others etc.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by shadowgovt on Monday February 10, 2020 @02:14PM (#22292198)
In a world of low-friction exchange of information and goods, small firms are competing with every large firm that can touch their market. What you're describing (companies doing just fine without growing to enormous proportions) is the status quo until a Wal-Mart rolls into their market, in which case they tend to be consumed by the mega-firm that leverages economies of scale (and occasionally monopoly) to drive prices down.

A free market, lacking counter-pressure to maximizing firm size, favors large firms, and large firms becoming larger is a positive feedback loop. Note that this is an idealized model and there's plenty of room for counter-pressure in reality (can the large firm actually pull demand away from the smaller firm, or does the smaller firm have a leg-up in e.g. customer relations that the larger firm can't compete with?).

Re:Mondragon Corporation by TremendousJudge on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:45AM (#22290715)
Nations don't just aggregate like free market corporations. If there are many large bellicose empires in history, it's because taking things by force of arms is a successful strategy. In a world of many micro states, it only takes one to begin expanding aggressively for everything to fall apart
Re:Mondragon Corporation by zepto on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:18AM (#22290412)
It has nothing to do with stock exchanges. There have been plenty of giant growth oriented corporations that are private.

How do you account for that?

Re:Mondragon Corporation by leto_ii on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:29AM (#22290564)
Well, there's nothing to say that private corporations can't behave in the same way. I'm just saying that once you list these pressures are almost guaranteed to appear.

I also strongly suspect that they're less present, on average, in unlisted companies.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by zepto on Monday February 10, 2020 @03:23PM (#22292856)
Sure - but how does that matter? It only takes a few percent to be this way to create the ultra-competitive aggregating behavior we see in practice.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by CountSessine on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:06AM (#22290280)
I do wonder sometimes how different Chomsky's career and his academic work would have been if he'd been required to take a course in game theory while he was an undergraduate.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by danharaj on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:23AM (#22290487)
I guarantee you Chomsky knows more about game theory than you.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by allworknoplay on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:32AM (#22290588)
what is your point?
Re:Mondragon Corporation by shadowgovt on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:42AM (#22290687)
That Chomsky's ideal end-goal is unrealistic because it is inherently dynamically unstable. Small worker-owned cooperatives plus a free market is an ecosystem ripe for larger worker-owned cooperatives to create incentive structures that let them dominate the market, which lets them grow, which is a positive feedback loop in that incentive structure.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by tsimionescu on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @01:39AM (#22306451)
I think we have very little experience with how democratically-controlled organizations would behave and interact in the long term.

You may be right that centralization is inevitable for game-theoretic reasons.

On the other hand, I'm not sure how well game theory can model the decisions of large groups of people who participate in multiple organizations at the same time.

Definitely though, there are no examples from history of a society of democratic societies and how it might behave. Perhaps the closest examples are the ancient Greek cities and post-WW2 Europe (looking only at the state level, democratic corporations have not been tried to any large extent that I know of). In both those cases, there was no spontaneous centralization from within (i.e. one entity conquering the others), though for Europe it is still very early to tell, and there are future signs which may point to more centralization.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by monadic2 on Monday February 10, 2020 @01:30PM (#22291794)
Tbh I do not think Chomsky has written on his ideals the way others have, much of his positions are extrapolated from his critiques on other states (please correct me if I am wrong). However he has positively identified himself as an anarchy-syndicalist.

There are multiple ways an anarchist society might respond to a corporation growing too large: convincing its workers to split or find work elsewhere to avoid economic collapse, seizing its assets and forcibly splitting or shuttering its operations, denying it use of supply chains, of debt if the market has currency, etc. a critical aspect of anarchist societies is lack of private property and capital.

Trade unions can hold much of the power; I can’t speak to the concepts of anarchist states. In fact the idea of anarchist currency (anarchy-capitalism or market socialism, I guess?) is something I am unfamiliar with, in part because it obscures the cost in man time and effort it takes to produce a good or service—rather easy too, just consider subscription services where you pay a flat rate, or the labor it takes to get you chocolate or coffee vs how much it is valued in terms of your wages (presumably in a post-industrialization service economy if you’re on this forum). Similarly I do not know what an anarchist state is.

Regardless, the idea is founded in large part on the concept of mutual aid. There is certainly plenty of research into how mutual aid tends towards or away from stability. A quick google search turns up this, for instance: https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00275386/document

Re:Mondragon Corporation by shadowgovt on Monday February 10, 2020 @01:54PM (#22292029)
> There are multiple ways an anarchist society might respond to a corporation growing too large

I agree, but I believe a firm past a critical mass of size can defend against all of them, and defense breeds the resources for further defense.

> convincing its workers to split or find work elsewhere to avoid economic collapse

Unlikely if the firm's size lets it offer better life than alternatives

> seizing its assets and forcibly splitting or shuttering its operations

Hard if a firm's size grants it the ability to challenge monopoly on violence

> denying it use of supply chains, of debt if the market has currency, etc.

No longer possible if the firm is large enough to have vertical integration

Re:Mondragon Corporation by monadic2 on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:33PM (#22294150)
> Unlikely if the firm's size lets it offer better life than alternatives

How do you figure? This implies the compensation is different from other "firm"s.

> Hard if a firm's size grants it the ability to challenge monopoly on violence.

How do you figure? Monopoly typically implies private property.

> No longer possible if the firm is large enough to have vertical integration.

How do you figure? Monopoly typically implies private property.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by shadowgovt on Monday February 10, 2020 @06:17PM (#22294467)
How does one seize a firm's assets if a firm has no private property? That implies the firm has nothing to seize because it has nothing.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by monadic2 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @12:39AM (#22296361)
> How does one seize a firm's assets if a firm has no private property? That implies the firm has nothing to seize because it has nothing.

Well the traditional linguistic connotations of possession certainly persist. Here "seize" simply means take control of.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by dls2016 on Monday February 10, 2020 @01:46PM (#22291964)
As opposed to the current US system where large shareholder-owned corporations dominate the market, which lets them grow, which is a positive feedback loop in that incentive structure?
Re:Mondragon Corporation by shadowgovt on Monday February 10, 2020 @02:06PM (#22292133)
Yes. The system that currently exists is very realistic, by definition.

To be clear, I'm criticizing the notion that small worker-owned / worker-managed corporations and a free market are an inherently stable structure (because free markets will favor consolidation). I'm not against large worker-owned / worker-managed corporations, and I think they could be a significant improvement on the ecosystem of shareholder-owned corps we find in the US.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by rapind on Monday February 10, 2020 @04:49PM (#22293762)
I would agree. I think overall big picture analysis is good too. But if we can agree that there's an improvement to be made we should start to work iteratively towards that improvement keeping an eye out for further improvements and lessons. For starters we could make it easier to start and run worker coops. Next step would be to implement some small incentives (even getting the money from cutting currently awful subsidies in corporate welfare!).
Re:Mondragon Corporation by TaylorAlexander on Monday February 10, 2020 @02:03PM (#22292092)
Thank you. So often when I talk about solutions people say “it won’t work” because of some problem they’ve identified. They completely miss whether the current system also has that problem and whether the proposed situation at least represents an improvement. I can’t solve every problem nor do I claim to! All human systems will have difficulties. But some systems are set up structurally to be more exploitative than others.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by EGreg on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:53AM (#22290813)
I know Chomsky. I went to meet him in MIT several years ago, when I was looking for advisors to Qbix. (Also met Tim Berners-Lee and his team at what was then known as Solid - a similar project to Qbix). The guy responds to email at 2am btw, quite cool for an 85 year old.

As I see it, open source technology IS the great decentralized of power. We just need people to build Good open source software.

My personal passion (which I poured a lot of money into) was qbix.com and intercoin.org . That’s also why I reached out to Andrew Yang back in early 2018 when he announced running and met him in May 2018. We agreed my company would build https://yang2020.app to support his campaign, and he would help introduce us to mayors of cities that want UBI locally (he knew a few dozen, like Michael Tubbs of Stockton, although since then Michael has not been a fan of Yang’s approach for various reasons).

I believe in UBI + Gift Economies / Collaboration as the best system, better than socialism or capitalism. But we have a while to get there.

Yang is trying to boil the ocean by going for UBI on a national level. I believe the future is in decentralization, and I talk about it extensively. I think UBI can be done via cryptocurrency on a local level. We can also do voting this way. I’m writing a piece about this at the moment, very apropos of the recent fiascos.

Printers, Email, Blogs, the Internet have replaced large corporate and state gatekeepers we used to have (newspapers, cable channels, telephone companies, printing presses etc) and costs went down to near zero. Technology decentralizes power.

We can have towns and cities run decentralized:

Solar power networks (resilient to EMPs and carrington events)

Mesh networks (better than cellphone networks)

Social networks (chat, events, appointments, everything that fb does but w local servers)

I’m trying to build the software to run on these networks (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI)

PS: sorry for all the links but honestly I am passionate about this stuff and need to illustrate it instead of talking. A video is worth a thousand words. To mitigate the shilling I will say that TimBL’s solid and MaidSAFE * IPFS and others are also working on decentralizing power

Re:Mondragon Corporation by mindcrime on Monday February 10, 2020 @01:46PM (#22291960)
Technology decentralizes power.

I would have agreed with that statement at one time. Now I'd qualify it to read "Technology can decentralize power." Unfortunately, it can also do the opposite. I'm at a point now where I'm torn on the question of whether or not technology inherently tends one way or the other. But in either case, I'm now convinced that human nature is much more a factor in the centralization / decentralization of power than technology.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by dbingham on Monday February 10, 2020 @09:37AM (#22289430)
No, that's not the alternative. The alternative is a system that isn't profit driven, where all the companies are worker cooperatives.

In that system, there are no stock holders demanding ever greater returns, those doing the work are always completely in control. They can choose to do "just enough" to live a good life. Or they can choose to focus on the more fulfilling aspects of their work, and not on the profit.

In that system, it's easier to pass regulations that prevent the worker cooperatives from externalizing, because the survival pressures aren't nearly as intense.

But it's not top-down centrally managed.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by andreilys on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:16AM (#22289772)
“ The alternative is a system that isn't profit driven, where all the companies are worker cooperatives.”

Enforced by a central top-down bureaucratic organization.

In this hypothetical world would you let foreign companies motivated by profit compete in your country that only has worker co-ops? Or would you have a closed down market, similar to North Korea that only Approved Co-ops would be allowed to work in?

Re:Mondragon Corporation by paulmd on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:36AM (#22290626)
This is unnecessarily dismissive. The USG routinely enforces regulations and tariffs on companies and imports that fail to comply with US regulations. If this was extended to company structure or labor standards, so what?

Under your standard, all regulation is "top down bureaucratic driven". In practice this has not proven to be incompatible with market driven economics. Not that libertarians don't scream about it anyway.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by dbingham on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:54AM (#22290822)
The current structures we allow today are "top down bureaucratic". How do you think the C-corp and S-corp got defined? The LLC, the partnership, the sole-proprietorship are all organizational forms defined and allowed by the government. The government defines the shape of the market, and then actors are free to operate with in that shape.

This is the same thing, just a different shape.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by anoncake on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:43AM (#22290038)
> Enforced by a central top-down bureaucratic organization.

The comment you selectively quoted ends with "But it's not top-down centrally managed.".

Re:Mondragon Corporation by jp555 on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:04AM (#22289657)
Forcing no profits is central management at it's very worst - Setting prices causes many downstream derangements to markets.

A complex interconnected system will adapt in unforeseeable ways, causing novel externalities for which we have no built up immunity. Ask a soviet.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by abathologist on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:55AM (#22290832)
"not profit driven" does not mean "forcing no profits". The former means that your highest driving purpose and governing logic is not oriented around the accumulation of profit. The latter means you make it impossible to accumulate profit.

We can pursue self-organization that pursues escape from the pathological patterns of profit driven production without advocating for, striving for, or tolerating a totalitarian, bureaucratic nightmare. See, e.g., https://thenextsystem.org/start-with-worker-self-directed-en...

Re:Mondragon Corporation by spamizbad on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:06AM (#22289683)
Forcing profits is bad too. Just look at Boeing to see where the naked pursuit of profits can lead. It literally kills people.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by whatshisface on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:14AM (#22289749)
If they had pursued profits harder and more effectively, they would not have had the accidents whose effect was to reduce their profits. Although there are some examples of outright malice or criminality out there, Boeing is closer to an example of an ineffective management culture than an evilly effective one.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by leto_ii on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:08AM (#22290307)
> If they had pursued profits harder and more effectively, they would not have had the accidents

I think this is a bit simplistic or at least too optimistic. The pressures of being listed on the stock market are such that management is more or less compelled to pursue short-term goals.

Indeed in the very long run a lot of corporations are harming themselves by harming the environment, impeding innovation etc. but in the short run firing people, cutting R&D budgets, digging up more coal, oil etc. can be very effective. And shareholders really only care about what your profits are gonna be in the next few quarters, not so much about what's gonna happen decades down the line.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by whatshisface on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:45AM (#22290718)
If you buy a stock and then use your influence to destroy its value, you're punishing yourself for your own bad decision. A lot of real human tragedy is caused by self-destructive behavior.

Now, here's an interesting thing to consider. You bring up coal and oil - both industries that are on the way out in the long term. Would it be wise for shareholders to push these companies to invest in R&D to improve their long-term capabilities? No, if coal and oil are on the way out, then the best financial strategy would be to run the companies into the ground as you slowly liquidate them, ideally so that there's nothing left on the very day that fossil fuels are no longer needed. In that case, short-termism is the best strategy.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by alfromspace on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:21AM (#22290454)
No. Whatever effect the 737 MAX grounding has had on Boeing's profits pales in comparison to the benefit gained by rushing the plane out the door to get in front of Airbus and thus making billions in sales contracts. There has been virtually no effect on Boeing's stock price, and the plane will probably be back in service within the year.

All in all, putting lives at risk was a good move for Boeing, and they'll surely do it again.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by jungturk on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:28AM (#22290544)
I'm assuming by "more effectively" you mean "less shortsightedly"?

In any case, such judgement is only clear in hindsight (that is, calculating effectiveness implies a time window over which effects are to be tabulated).

Most charitably, the executives perhaps felt they were making judicious, acceptable tradeoffs that would maximize business outcomes over the time horizon they were concerned with - periods measured in quarters or years or even decades.

How would we incentivize people to only take profits over an arbitrarily long (and ever-widening) window? What happens when a black swan occurs and significantly drives down the effectiveness of prior decisions (which until then had been deemed quite effective)? Are profits clawed back?

Re:Mondragon Corporation by whatshisface on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:40AM (#22290669)
>In any case, such judgement is only clear in hindsight (that is, calculating effectiveness implies a time window over which effects are to be tabulated).

If the judgment was really only clear in hindsight then no power structure could have altered it. What's clear only in hindsight to a CEO is clear only in hindsight to a union boss, or a collective, anyone else.

>How would we incentivize people to only take profits over an arbitrarily long (and ever-widening) window?

The corporation is already incentivized: in exchange for thinking about long-term profits, it is rewarded with long-term profits. However, executives often have different goals than the corporation they're supposed to represent. If you could figure out how to better align the interests of executives with their corporations, you would see more effective profit-seeking, which would include less killing due to blunders but more killing due to tobacco-industry style exploitation. Giving executives the freedom to put their own interests first (the source of next-quarterism and next-bonusism) is necessary if you want to give them the freedom to pursue ethical goals. You either trust them to make the right decisions or you don't.

>Are profits clawed back?

Yes! That's what happens when something causes you to lose money.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by naravara on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:25AM (#22289876)
Some people will argue the issue there is time-horizons. If Boeing was worried about profitability indefinitely into the future, these sorts of repetitional disasters would factor in. But if everyone is looking quarter-to-quarter or year-to-year they won't.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by spamizbad on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:29AM (#22289915)
The project timeline for the 737 MAX was at least 6 years. It was announced in 2011 and entered service in 2017. So you can run into this problem even when thinking 5+ years ahead.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by rayiner on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:29AM (#22289916)
Nobody is forcing profits. If you want to start a non-profit aerospace company, nobody is stopping you.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by ianleeclark on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:35AM (#22289959)
> Nobody is forcing profits.

Shareholders?

> If you want to start a non-profit aerospace company, nobody is stopping you.

Yeah, just found an aerospace company. You don't need anything beyond hard-work and a can-do attitude. Definitely don't need decades worth of relationships, unimaginable capital, or readily hirable talent. You just gotta believe in yourself.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by rayiner on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:41AM (#22290026)
> Shareholders?

The system doesn't force anyone to make a profit. If you borrow capital from people, your investors may demand a profit. But that's between you and your investors. Nobody is forcing you to take investment or sell equity in your company on the public markets.

> Yeah, just found an aerospace company. You don't need anything beyond hard-work and a can-do attitude. Definitely don't need decades worth of relationships, unimaginable capital, or readily hirable talent. You just gotta believe in yourself.

My point is to contrast a system where everyone is forced to be a non-profit or co-op (@jp555's hypothetical), and our system, where you are free to be a non-profit or co-op, if you want to. If you can't raise capital or hire top-notch employees under that structure, then that's a problem with the non-profit/co-op organization, not a shortcoming of our economic system.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by Apocryphon on Monday February 10, 2020 @02:14PM (#22292202)
> The system doesn't force anyone to make a profit. If you borrow capital from people, your investors may demand a profit. But that's between you and your investors. Nobody is forcing you to take investment or sell equity in your company on the public markets.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shareholder_primacy

Re:Mondragon Corporation by tptacek on Monday February 10, 2020 @03:42PM (#22293049)
You're begging the question. His point is that shareholder demands aren't relevant if you simply don't accept random shareholders, which is something a number of large firms have successfully done.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by ianleeclark on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:51AM (#22290106)
> The system doesn't force anyone to make a profit. If you borrow capital from people, your investors may demand a profit. But that's between you and your investors. Nobody is forcing you to take investment or sell equity in your company on the public markets.

If you want to just completely change the conversation, and hyperfocus on the individual, then you're free to do so, but I don't want to be brought along for the ride. You responded to a comment concerning Boeing, not some fresh-faced up-and-comer of your own creation.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by rayiner on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:01AM (#22290219)
We're not talking about Boeing, we're talking about economic systems, with Boeing being an example. @jp555's comment addressed economic systems that "force no profits." @spamizbad then states "forcing profits is bad too," using Boeing as an example. My comment clarified that our system (in which Boeing exists) does not "force profits" (as distinguished from @jp555's example of a system that "forces no profits"). Our system allows profit-seeking companies as well as non-profit-seeking companies. The fact that Boeing feels compelled to earn a profit is a by-product of the financing arrangement by which Boeing was created. Nothing about our system would have prevented Boeing from having been founded as a non-profit.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by ianleeclark on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:05AM (#22290264)
That's my bad, I did misread the chain.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by dls2016 on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:04AM (#22289661)
Is the alternative to bank robbing a top-down central-managed solution? No, we simply penalize the behavior. We could do the same and penalize exploitation by corporations. Hold individuals accountable. Extreme fines. You may argue this would be complicated, but so is a lot of existing legislation surrounding international trade.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by TOGoS on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:39AM (#22289999)
I won't say it would be 'complicated', because in theory that sounds very simple.

In practice, powerful corporations have enough influence over the government that regulating them in that manner isn't possible without flipping the whole system on its head (i.e. removing the profit motive that drives monopolization and cost externalization).

Re:Mondragon Corporation by jp555 on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:13AM (#22289737)
Doesn't Tort do that already?
Re:Mondragon Corporation by dls2016 on Monday February 10, 2020 @01:54PM (#22292031)
I actually don't know. This is based off my own observation of the set of things for which one can end up in jail. Once you really think about the things in that set (shoplifting vs. wage theft) it's impossible to believe the system isn't rigged. To be fair, governments and militaries have always been used to protect the interests of the wealthy. But evidence suggests things have changed radically for the worse since the 70s (in my US-centric view).
Re:Mondragon Corporation by naravara on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:28AM (#22289901)
>Is the alternative to bank robbing a top-down central-managed solution? No, we simply penalize the behavior.

Penalizing the behavior sounds like a top-down solution to me. Government decides it's bad, then government sends the police to come get you if you do it.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by paulmd on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:44AM (#22290707)
Then that describes all regulation and "top down" is a meaningless standard.

I dump some chromium waste on my property, pretty soon this "government" is saying it's bad and sending police to come get me saying that "the green goo is making people sick". I hate that top-down big gubmint telling me what I can and can't do!

I refuse to employ black people, pretty soon there's a top-down big gubmint telling me that's "discriminatory" and "violates labor laws"! What's next, telling a man what he can and can't do with his own business!?

Re:Mondragon Corporation by naravara on Monday February 10, 2020 @02:45PM (#22292503)
>Then that describes all regulation and "top down" is a meaningless standard.

Yes. Regulation from a central source of authority is what a top-down model is. I'm not sure what your contention is here.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by paulmd on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @04:38PM (#22313074)
Then "top down" is a widely deployed and not particularly notable model, such that it's not worth throwing a fit over.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by jancsika on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:34AM (#22289953)
> especial from the view from Chomsky's academic ivory tower

"I don't like Erik Satie or any of that stuffy, high falutin' classical stuff."

In both cases, the writer is unwittingly saying very little about the subject and very much about their ignorance.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by nickbauman on Monday February 10, 2020 @09:57AM (#22289596)
Have you ever noticed that once you pierce the walls of "big corp", you find a command economy that's driven dictatorially from the c-suite? Capitalism and "free" markets are great for everyone else. Dictatorship is de rigueur inside the company.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by rayiner on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:32AM (#22289933)
That's not a novel observation. Ronald Coase addressed this more than 80 years ago in the context of neo-liberal economics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_the_firm
Re:Mondragon Corporation by andreilys on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:19AM (#22289803)
Thankfully dictators of a company are less likely to use violence to coerce me to buy their products/services.

Governments on the other hand have a monopoly on violence, so I am more wary of handing them power over the choices I can make in my life.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by WBrad on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:54AM (#22290825)
They are less likely but that does not mean it hasn't happened. The first air strike on united states ground was the national guard striking miners at the behest of the company.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Blair_Mountain#Battl...

If you're in another country working for a U.S. corp you're in much worse shape. Coca-Cola can murder you for forming a union in another country and get away with it!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinaltrainal_v._Coca-Cola_Co.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by Ericson2314 on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:53AM (#22290123)
No, Corporations absolutely do do violance to their employees. Contrariwise, dictators seldom use violence outside their borders unless they are powerful enough.

In both cases, borders matter.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by antsoul on Monday February 10, 2020 @09:46AM (#22289504)
Wait a minute, you state something that Chomsky never said (the "alternative 100% top-down central-managed solution") , and then call him "not very useful" for this fake statement? He's not saying Mondragon is bad, just that within capitalism, these solutions are still fucked on the long term.

If you really want to judge him on his real-world solutions, then take at look at Michael Albert's Participatory economics that he's been supporting for a while : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Participatory_economics

But according to me, what Chomsky lacks in his analysis is some hegelian stuff, so I'd recommend to go further and dig some Slavoj Zizek and Deleuze and so on..

Re:Mondragon Corporation by jp555 on Monday February 10, 2020 @09:52AM (#22289552)
I questioned, not stated.

I mean that I find him too theoretical - His thinking is all very smart and appealing but useless in practice.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by antsoul on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:15AM (#22289752)
Considering that no solution exist anywhere to the global problem we face, I'd reconsider the value of "useful/useless".

Fake easy-solutions are good to make you feel better before work, but it prevents you from going into deep thinking from which real solutions may emerge.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by eeZah7Ux on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:05AM (#22289666)
"Why are you being so dense?" is an example of a question that includes a statement.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by MagnumOpus on Monday February 10, 2020 @08:41AM (#22288985)
While of course companies that operate in a non-market system and could take into account negative externalities, such as systemically important PRC or NorK SOEs, would never exploit workers or create bad working conditions - at home or in South America...
Re:Mondragon Corporation by coliveira on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:08AM (#22289703)
Exploiting workers is a negative externality.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by rayiner on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:35AM (#22289957)
No. A negative externality is a cost to a transaction that's not borne by one of the parties to the transaction (and thus cannot be priced into the transaction). "This job really sucks" is not an externality -- that fact is priced into what the worker demands in payment for performing that job. "Building this factory will incerase the risk of Terry down the street getting cancer" is an externality -- Terry is not a party to the transaction and cannot demand payment as compensation for the increased risk.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by chishaku on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:05AM (#22290263)
This textbook response doesn't address what often happens in reality.

Wages don't always capture the true costs of production. The public burden of the coal miner who gets lung cancer can be viewed as a negative externality.

Indeed, many labor protections in the US seek to specifically address this type of externality.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by tptacek on Monday February 10, 2020 @03:40PM (#22293031)
No, it doesn't address the phenomenon that the grandparent comment was concerned with (worker exploitation). But it doesn't claim to. It simply, and correctly, establishes that worker treatment isn't an externality. "Textbook" definitions have nothing to do with it.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by chishaku on Monday February 10, 2020 @04:59PM (#22293851)
> it doesn't address [worker exploitation]

This is my point. Ignoring concerns of worker exploitation and focusing on textbook definitions comes off as dismissive, even if that wasn't the intent.

Similarly, your comment comes off as dismissive which highlights the importance of the context that I added.

Worker exploitation does result in negative externalities, even if the exploitation itself is not an externality.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by tptacek on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:10PM (#22293935)
All 'rayiner said was that worker exploitation isn't an externality. The comment to which he was responding said literally nothing other than that worker exploitation was an externality. Worker exploitation is not an externality. I'm not sure how you're finding a way to object to this.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by chishaku on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:19PM (#22294021)
I've not objected to the definition. I'm adding nuance that you're still trying to dismiss.

Worker exploitation does result in negative externalities, even if the exploitation itself is not an externality.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by H8crilA on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:14AM (#22289748)
Capitalism itself cannot solve the problem of externalities. That's what the government is for.

I don't understand why would anyone think that it can. This is not just my opinion but an opinion of famous capitalists (for example Buffett or Soros).

Re:Mondragon Corporation by abvdasker on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:04AM (#22290248)
The classical argument is that when trying to address externalities you can turn to either regulation or strong property rights (if your factory pollutes a lake the citizens using it for drinking water will sue). Regulation can sometimes lead to inefficiency.

Free-market evangelists tend to strongly favor the property rights solution. But one of the interesting things about the property rights case is that it seems to fall apart when both the responsibility and cost are diffuse. Probably the best example would be climate change. It's impossible to address with property rights because there would be so many plaintiffs and so many defendants that attributing who did what would be impossible. Climate change is the ultimate externality.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by orthecreedence on Monday February 10, 2020 @02:21PM (#22292262)
Right, ancaps argue for privatization of everything because that will eliminate externalities, but I see absolutely no way to prove that the carbon being pumped into the atmosphere is derived by some company/individual at some percentage, and then of course you don't actually have courts or a legal system but silly things like Dispute Resolution Organizations that are somehow supposed to enforce the decision of some court case across the globe?

It's all kind of insane.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by pdonis on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:51AM (#22290105)
> Capitalism itself cannot solve the problem of externalities.

True.

> That's what the government is for.

False. Government can't solve the problem of externalities either, because government is even more at the mercy of the perverse incentives that create them than free market participants are.

There is no "solution" to the problem of externalities, if by "solution" you mean some system we can put in place that will magically prevent them from happening or from doing harm. The only way to deal with externalities in general is to remove them wherever possible, by enforcing property rights and minimizing transaction costs.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by chishaku on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:27AM (#22290534)
> Government can't solve the problem of externalities

Do you enjoy the the benefits of the Clean Water Act and the Clean Air Act?

In your view, does government at least partially solve the problem of some negative externalities?

(Based on your bio, I assume you're in the US.)

Re:Mondragon Corporation by pdonis on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:59AM (#22290882)
> Do you enjoy the the benefits of the Clean Water Act and the Clean Air Act?

I like having clean water and clean air. That's why I have air filters in my house and don't drink tap water.

> does government at least partially solve the problem of some negative externalities?

Government can certainly change incentives in ways that will, at least temporarily, reduce particular negative externalities. But to say that "solves the problem" implies that, once that particular government solution is put in place, we can stop worrying about that particular negative externality and move on to ther things. I do not think that is the case.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by chishaku on Monday February 10, 2020 @12:14PM (#22291000)
> That's why I have air filters in my house and don't drink tap water.

I'll assume this is a joke.

> we can stop worrying about that particular negative externality

I'm not sure who said this. In any case, we're all in agreement that the government plays a key role in addressing negative externalities.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by pdonis on Monday February 10, 2020 @12:41PM (#22291334)
> I'll assume this is a joke.

It's not.

> I'm not sure who said this.

I'm not sure what "solved" means if you still have to keep worrying about the negative externality.

> we're all in agreement that the government plays a key role in addressing negative externalities.

I don't think our agreement is as broad as you seem to think it is.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by 8bitsrule on Monday February 10, 2020 @06:52PM (#22294682)
Maybe it's up to the servants to shop around for new filters and facemasks?

I've been enjoying this quote for a week:

"If you think the economy is more important than the environment, try holding your breath while counting your money. - Guy McPherson"

Re:Mondragon Corporation by Ericson2314 on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:01AM (#22290204)
> if by "solution", you mean some system we can put in place that will magically prevent them

Only a distributed system like capitalism rises to your bar of "magically prevent[ing]". Centralization is not magic, but when it works, it works. I prefer distributed systems too, but when it's hard to make the right incentivizes, we shouldn't throw in the towel.

Surely the parent post doesn't use a definition of "solution" that trivially invalidates their point. I think you are projecting your own preference for distributed systems as an inevitability.

In fact, I've thought of a "'race to the top' tariffs" system, which does at least create the right incentives between nations. If you are big market (e.g. US) put tariff on the difference between the manufacturing country's externalizes tax, and your own. This holds the total punitive disincentive constant, no matter who receives the revenue. The exporting country is now incentivized to raise their externalities tax so the tax revenue goes to them rather than the importing country. So simple!!

Re:Mondragon Corporation by pdonis on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:19AM (#22290424)
> a distributed system like capitalism

How is capitalism a distributed system? It concentrates capital in the hands of a small minority.

A free market is a distributed system, but "free market" is not a synonym for "capitalism".

> Centralization is not magic, but when it works, it works.

I guess we have very different definitions of "works".

Re:Mondragon Corporation by tathougies on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:42AM (#22290691)
Revenue is dictated by the various consumer demands of mainly individuals and families.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by pdonis on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:52AM (#22290795)
In a free market, yes. Again, "free market" is not the same as "capitalism". The robber barons who got the US government to grant them monopolies of railroad routes in the late 19th century were capitalists; but their revenue was not "dictated by the various consumer demands of mainly individuals and families".
Re:Mondragon Corporation by tathougies on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:23PM (#22294061)
Robber barons are not part of 'capitalism' either. If you have a free market of goods and a free market of labor, then you inevitably have capitalism, since someone will acquire enough money to hire labor to operate his productive goods.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by macspoofing on Monday February 10, 2020 @08:41AM (#22288979)
It's easy for anyone to take potshots from the sidelines, but surely Chomsky sees the economic, and humanitarian disasters that non-market based systems ALWAYS result in. What's the alternative here?
Re:Mondragon Corporation by ianleeclark on Monday February 10, 2020 @09:26AM (#22289336)
The quote there seems to have issues with the profit motive, not market systems.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by wuliwong on Monday February 10, 2020 @09:59AM (#22289619)
In my mind a "market systems" implicitly includes prices which means there would then be profit and loss. I could imagine a market of 100% barter and no generally accepted currency but I do not think that is what most people mean when they use the term "market systems."

There is a lot I'm unaware of, possibly market systems without prices is one of those things?

Re:Mondragon Corporation by macspoofing on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:51AM (#22290101)
>I could imagine a market of 100% barter and no generally accepted currency

Even under a barter system, there is an intrinsic profit. If you're a farmer, after you feed your family, what's leftover is the surplus (i.e. profit) that you use to trade for other essentials. The difference that matters between a currency system and a barter system is that bartering is less flexible (if someone doesn't want your apples for their furniture, you're not getting that furniture) - but the same forces apply.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by kiliantics on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:42AM (#22290689)
Profit is what's left over after all costs are taken out from the price, including labour costs. Profit, by definition, is what the capitalist gets to keep for having done nothing but owning the capital that was used to generate the profit.

So like when Bezos makes $4M+ per hour, it's not a wage because he is not working for it, he could be sleeping or shitting and he would make the same money. He gets that just because it's his name on all of the capital that generates this profit. The actual work is being done by the many people working for amazon, peeing in bottles in fulfillment centres because of lack of breaks and whatnot. They get paid very little, so there are low costs, so there is great profit to line Bezos' pockets.

Since co-ops like Mondragon need to compete with companies that are run like Bezos' in order to survive, they are under pressure to do similar things in their management structure, even though they want to share all "profit" with all workers, since all workers are owners (which is why it's not really "profit" for co-ops, since there are no non-working capitalists that earn it). Therefore, it is the profit motive, rather than the market system, which forces co-ops to act in ways that are inconsistent with their mission statements (worker control, fair pay, etc.)

Re:Mondragon Corporation by tathougies on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:45AM (#22290725)
And laborers generate a profit when their cost of living is below their total wage. At that point the cost of producing their labor (food, water, shelter) is below their revenue.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by kiliantics on Friday February 14, 2020 @06:15PM (#22331393)
That is not a profit because it is not generated from capital. "Cost of producing labour" is not just food/water/shelter/etc. it is the literal time you have to give up in order to perform the labour. Someone who owns capital gets the profit which the capital generates at zero cost or time spent.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by macspoofing on Monday February 10, 2020 @12:07PM (#22290936)
>Profit, by definition, is what the capitalist gets to keep for having done nothing but owning the capital that was used to generate the profit.

No. That is a dishonest distortion.

If providing and owning capital is such a nothing, why don't you try it and see how easy it is. Capitalization carries with it immense risk, which Communists conveniently ignore. Whereas the labourer gets a salary regardless of how the business performs, the one who capitalizes does not have this privilege. I've seen first hand how much work and how difficult it is to start and run a business. You only need to look at bankruptcy stats to see how many businesses fail and take down all the capital that was invested. It's not very pleasant to run a business, sink your life savings into it, only for it to go under with your savings and years of life.

>So like when Bezos makes $4M+ per hour,

That is another dishonest distortion.

Bezos does not make $4M+ per hour. He holds stock in Amazon that rises in value at that rate (Amazon's actual profit is on the order of 2% after close to two decades of 0 profit). The value of stocks stems from the fact that there are people who are willing to buy it at that price. This carries risk, because this willingness by others to buy the stock is subject to many factors, and it can go down to zero. Again, if you think it's easy, feel free to dump your savings into Amazon stock and see how easy it is for you to live of that or even make a good return - though I'm sure in your fictitious communist reality this would mean you would make millions without doing anything!

Re:Mondragon Corporation by ianleeclark on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:24AM (#22289865)
> In my mind a "market systems" implicitly includes prices which means there would then be profit and loss.

Why does a price necessarily include a profit or a loss? This is a self-referential belief: my price includes a profit or loss because a prior price includes a profit or loss which would earlier ... etc, etc.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by macspoofing on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:46AM (#22290059)
>Why does a price necessarily include a profit or a loss

It includes a profit or a loss because you need to eat and provide for yourself. If you're making chairs but the cost of materials is larger than what you sell those chairs for, how are you going to provide for your family? If you want to save up for a house or a car, or family vacation, how are you going to do that if you don't sell your chairs with a surplus (i.e. a profit)? A market-based system necessarily implies a profit motive.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by ianleeclark on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:53AM (#22290125)
> If you're making chairs but the cost of materials is larger than what you sell those chairs for, how are you going to provide for your family?

This is the "self-referential" thing I was referring to. You're entering into this thought experiment with a pre-defined conception of how an economic mode of production must operate. You're presupposing the profit motive.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by macspoofing on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:16AM (#22290393)
Feel free to suggest an alternative.

The one that comes to mind is Communism (and its many flavours), and we've seen what a humanitarian and economic disaster that turns out to be.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by ianleeclark on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:28AM (#22290552)
Political economy is a wide field with something for everyone. Consider it a choose your own adventure.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by macspoofing on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @08:31AM (#22308626)
Right. So no actual alternative.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by orthecreedence on Monday February 10, 2020 @02:22PM (#22292272)
> What's the alternative here?

Look into libertarian socialism if you're actually interested.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by macspoofing on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @08:38AM (#22308687)
In my early 20s I got really into all those boutique political theories. Our world is big and complicated, and these marginal and fringe ideas have never been actually tested at any reasonable scale. Anarachism-flavours tend to be universally terrible because they pre-suppose unnatural behaviour on people and in practice will devolve into some flavour of top-down collectivism.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by orthecreedence on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @09:46AM (#22309170)
You think capitalism is natural? And is top-down "individualism" better than top-down collectivism?

Also, there are real-world examples of libertarian socialism, like the Zapatistas and Rojova. Not ideologically pure, no, but certainly not authoritarian shitholes or capitalist dystopias.