News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by tsimionescu on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:17AM (#22289782)
Chomsky is anti-centralization, he is an anarchist (anarcho-syndicalist).

In general, his ideal end-goal world would include smaller states with more direct control by the populace, with worker-owned and worker-managed corporations, with free markets of goods and services between different corporations and different states, and of course freedom of movement. Strong environmental control would be almost implied if the people doing an economic activity were in charge of decisions and were also directly impacted by the effects of those decisions. Localizing and letting corporations be small would also put a natural cap on inequality, though democratically run states could impose additional safeguards where needed (minimum wages, estate taxes, non-discrimination clauses etc.)

Re:Mondragon Corporation by cies on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:55AM (#22290146)
I thought the workers in Mondragon could vote to have the CEO removed. Hence mgmt being under worker's control, ultimately.

I understand that workers also, at times, vote to externalize some costs, as their jobs may depend on it.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by einpoklum on Monday February 10, 2020 @06:25PM (#22294507)
> In general, his ideal end-goal world would include smaller states with more direct control by the populace

That's certainly not Anarchism, in which there are no states and no commercial corporations. And of course - no markets.

Now, as for what Chomsky supports personally - that's more difficult to say, since he's been known to support Democrats in US politics, to support a two-state arrangement in Palestine etc.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by zepto on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:48AM (#22290082)
Surely you would need a lot of rules and enforcement to prevent things simply aggregating?
Re:Mondragon Corporation by golemotron on Monday February 10, 2020 @10:56AM (#22290156)
That's where it falls apart. Systems tend to aggregate to seek efficiencies of scale.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by leto_ii on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:03AM (#22290237)
I tend to not agree with this line of thinking. This may be the case when you subject a company to financial market pressures by listing it on the stock exchange, but I don't think it's a natural imperative.

Many companies do just fine without growing to enormous proportions, being acquired, acquiring others etc.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by shadowgovt on Monday February 10, 2020 @02:14PM (#22292198)
In a world of low-friction exchange of information and goods, small firms are competing with every large firm that can touch their market. What you're describing (companies doing just fine without growing to enormous proportions) is the status quo until a Wal-Mart rolls into their market, in which case they tend to be consumed by the mega-firm that leverages economies of scale (and occasionally monopoly) to drive prices down.

A free market, lacking counter-pressure to maximizing firm size, favors large firms, and large firms becoming larger is a positive feedback loop. Note that this is an idealized model and there's plenty of room for counter-pressure in reality (can the large firm actually pull demand away from the smaller firm, or does the smaller firm have a leg-up in e.g. customer relations that the larger firm can't compete with?).

Re:Mondragon Corporation by TremendousJudge on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:45AM (#22290715)
Nations don't just aggregate like free market corporations. If there are many large bellicose empires in history, it's because taking things by force of arms is a successful strategy. In a world of many micro states, it only takes one to begin expanding aggressively for everything to fall apart
Re:Mondragon Corporation by zepto on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:18AM (#22290412)
It has nothing to do with stock exchanges. There have been plenty of giant growth oriented corporations that are private.

How do you account for that?

Re:Mondragon Corporation by leto_ii on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:29AM (#22290564)
Well, there's nothing to say that private corporations can't behave in the same way. I'm just saying that once you list these pressures are almost guaranteed to appear.

I also strongly suspect that they're less present, on average, in unlisted companies.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by zepto on Monday February 10, 2020 @03:23PM (#22292856)
Sure - but how does that matter? It only takes a few percent to be this way to create the ultra-competitive aggregating behavior we see in practice.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by CountSessine on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:06AM (#22290280)
I do wonder sometimes how different Chomsky's career and his academic work would have been if he'd been required to take a course in game theory while he was an undergraduate.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by danharaj on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:23AM (#22290487)
I guarantee you Chomsky knows more about game theory than you.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by allworknoplay on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:32AM (#22290588)
what is your point?
Re:Mondragon Corporation by shadowgovt on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:42AM (#22290687)
That Chomsky's ideal end-goal is unrealistic because it is inherently dynamically unstable. Small worker-owned cooperatives plus a free market is an ecosystem ripe for larger worker-owned cooperatives to create incentive structures that let them dominate the market, which lets them grow, which is a positive feedback loop in that incentive structure.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by tsimionescu on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @01:39AM (#22306451)
I think we have very little experience with how democratically-controlled organizations would behave and interact in the long term.

You may be right that centralization is inevitable for game-theoretic reasons.

On the other hand, I'm not sure how well game theory can model the decisions of large groups of people who participate in multiple organizations at the same time.

Definitely though, there are no examples from history of a society of democratic societies and how it might behave. Perhaps the closest examples are the ancient Greek cities and post-WW2 Europe (looking only at the state level, democratic corporations have not been tried to any large extent that I know of). In both those cases, there was no spontaneous centralization from within (i.e. one entity conquering the others), though for Europe it is still very early to tell, and there are future signs which may point to more centralization.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by monadic2 on Monday February 10, 2020 @01:30PM (#22291794)
Tbh I do not think Chomsky has written on his ideals the way others have, much of his positions are extrapolated from his critiques on other states (please correct me if I am wrong). However he has positively identified himself as an anarchy-syndicalist.

There are multiple ways an anarchist society might respond to a corporation growing too large: convincing its workers to split or find work elsewhere to avoid economic collapse, seizing its assets and forcibly splitting or shuttering its operations, denying it use of supply chains, of debt if the market has currency, etc. a critical aspect of anarchist societies is lack of private property and capital.

Trade unions can hold much of the power; I can’t speak to the concepts of anarchist states. In fact the idea of anarchist currency (anarchy-capitalism or market socialism, I guess?) is something I am unfamiliar with, in part because it obscures the cost in man time and effort it takes to produce a good or service—rather easy too, just consider subscription services where you pay a flat rate, or the labor it takes to get you chocolate or coffee vs how much it is valued in terms of your wages (presumably in a post-industrialization service economy if you’re on this forum). Similarly I do not know what an anarchist state is.

Regardless, the idea is founded in large part on the concept of mutual aid. There is certainly plenty of research into how mutual aid tends towards or away from stability. A quick google search turns up this, for instance: https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00275386/document

Re:Mondragon Corporation by shadowgovt on Monday February 10, 2020 @01:54PM (#22292029)
> There are multiple ways an anarchist society might respond to a corporation growing too large

I agree, but I believe a firm past a critical mass of size can defend against all of them, and defense breeds the resources for further defense.

> convincing its workers to split or find work elsewhere to avoid economic collapse

Unlikely if the firm's size lets it offer better life than alternatives

> seizing its assets and forcibly splitting or shuttering its operations

Hard if a firm's size grants it the ability to challenge monopoly on violence

> denying it use of supply chains, of debt if the market has currency, etc.

No longer possible if the firm is large enough to have vertical integration

Re:Mondragon Corporation by monadic2 on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:33PM (#22294150)
> Unlikely if the firm's size lets it offer better life than alternatives

How do you figure? This implies the compensation is different from other "firm"s.

> Hard if a firm's size grants it the ability to challenge monopoly on violence.

How do you figure? Monopoly typically implies private property.

> No longer possible if the firm is large enough to have vertical integration.

How do you figure? Monopoly typically implies private property.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by shadowgovt on Monday February 10, 2020 @06:17PM (#22294467)
How does one seize a firm's assets if a firm has no private property? That implies the firm has nothing to seize because it has nothing.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by monadic2 on Tuesday February 11, 2020 @12:39AM (#22296361)
> How does one seize a firm's assets if a firm has no private property? That implies the firm has nothing to seize because it has nothing.

Well the traditional linguistic connotations of possession certainly persist. Here "seize" simply means take control of.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by dls2016 on Monday February 10, 2020 @01:46PM (#22291964)
As opposed to the current US system where large shareholder-owned corporations dominate the market, which lets them grow, which is a positive feedback loop in that incentive structure?
Re:Mondragon Corporation by shadowgovt on Monday February 10, 2020 @02:06PM (#22292133)
Yes. The system that currently exists is very realistic, by definition.

To be clear, I'm criticizing the notion that small worker-owned / worker-managed corporations and a free market are an inherently stable structure (because free markets will favor consolidation). I'm not against large worker-owned / worker-managed corporations, and I think they could be a significant improvement on the ecosystem of shareholder-owned corps we find in the US.

Re:Mondragon Corporation by rapind on Monday February 10, 2020 @04:49PM (#22293762)
I would agree. I think overall big picture analysis is good too. But if we can agree that there's an improvement to be made we should start to work iteratively towards that improvement keeping an eye out for further improvements and lessons. For starters we could make it easier to start and run worker coops. Next step would be to implement some small incentives (even getting the money from cutting currently awful subsidies in corporate welfare!).
Re:Mondragon Corporation by TaylorAlexander on Monday February 10, 2020 @02:03PM (#22292092)
Thank you. So often when I talk about solutions people say “it won’t work” because of some problem they’ve identified. They completely miss whether the current system also has that problem and whether the proposed situation at least represents an improvement. I can’t solve every problem nor do I claim to! All human systems will have difficulties. But some systems are set up structurally to be more exploitative than others.
Re:Mondragon Corporation by EGreg on Monday February 10, 2020 @11:53AM (#22290813)
I know Chomsky. I went to meet him in MIT several years ago, when I was looking for advisors to Qbix. (Also met Tim Berners-Lee and his team at what was then known as Solid - a similar project to Qbix). The guy responds to email at 2am btw, quite cool for an 85 year old.

As I see it, open source technology IS the great decentralized of power. We just need people to build Good open source software.

My personal passion (which I poured a lot of money into) was qbix.com and intercoin.org . That’s also why I reached out to Andrew Yang back in early 2018 when he announced running and met him in May 2018. We agreed my company would build https://yang2020.app to support his campaign, and he would help introduce us to mayors of cities that want UBI locally (he knew a few dozen, like Michael Tubbs of Stockton, although since then Michael has not been a fan of Yang’s approach for various reasons).

I believe in UBI + Gift Economies / Collaboration as the best system, better than socialism or capitalism. But we have a while to get there.

Yang is trying to boil the ocean by going for UBI on a national level. I believe the future is in decentralization, and I talk about it extensively. I think UBI can be done via cryptocurrency on a local level. We can also do voting this way. I’m writing a piece about this at the moment, very apropos of the recent fiascos.

Printers, Email, Blogs, the Internet have replaced large corporate and state gatekeepers we used to have (newspapers, cable channels, telephone companies, printing presses etc) and costs went down to near zero. Technology decentralizes power.

We can have towns and cities run decentralized:

Solar power networks (resilient to EMPs and carrington events)

Mesh networks (better than cellphone networks)

Social networks (chat, events, appointments, everything that fb does but w local servers)

I’m trying to build the software to run on these networks (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI)

PS: sorry for all the links but honestly I am passionate about this stuff and need to illustrate it instead of talking. A video is worth a thousand words. To mitigate the shilling I will say that TimBL’s solid and MaidSAFE * IPFS and others are also working on decentralizing power

Re:Mondragon Corporation by mindcrime on Monday February 10, 2020 @01:46PM (#22291960)
Technology decentralizes power.

I would have agreed with that statement at one time. Now I'd qualify it to read "Technology can decentralize power." Unfortunately, it can also do the opposite. I'm at a point now where I'm torn on the question of whether or not technology inherently tends one way or the other. But in either case, I'm now convinced that human nature is much more a factor in the centralization / decentralization of power than technology.