News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by rrauenza on Thursday February 06, 2020 @10:59AM (#22257003)
Isn't increasing workspace density the real reason this is done with collaboration just used as the public rationale?
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by ken on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:00PM (#22257765)
No, that's just another public rationale. Programmer salaries are much more expensive than even private offices.

In a past life, when I wrote software for a living, I would ask my managers how much it cost, so I could pay out of pocket for my own private office. In every case, when pressed, they admitted it wasn't about the money at all. They just needed me to be a Team Player.

It wasn't even about built-out cost. The private offices already existed, and were sitting empty, in anticipation of future sales team growth -- even though I don't think we were hiring for that yet. Everyone on the business side always got a private office. Come to think of it, I don't remember ever hearing management try to explain why the sales team apparently didn't need to be team players.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by 0xffff2 on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:18PM (#22257968)
I am in no way advocating for open offices in any circumstance, but one common complaint I've heard from open-office dwellers is how they sit right next to the sales team who are always on their phones.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by Hamuko on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:22PM (#22258016)
We have sales people in a room, but there's support people next to the developers. And Bose sells another pair of QuietComforts.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by dsr_ on Thursday February 06, 2020 @04:25PM (#22260517)
As a person who is frequently called by that sales team: I can tell immediately when I'm talking to someone who is in an open-office, and I associate them with phone spammers.

So, sales people: you're losing money because of that open-office environment.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by Hamuko on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:34PM (#22258145)
>I don't remember ever hearing management try to explain why the sales team apparently didn't need to be team players.

Because it's a free-for-all for those signup bonuses/commissions.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by commandlinefan on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:23AM (#22257302)
Constant surveillance is another part of the real reason with collaboration used as the public rationale. I mean, it doesn't make sense, but it makes them feel more like slave-owners, and that makes them happy.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by fernandotakai on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:52AM (#22257673)
>Constant surveillance is another part of the real reason with collaboration used as the public rationale

when i worked on an open plan office, that was huge. it seems like my boss' favorite hobby was checking everyone's screen to see what they were doing.

once, i was watching a yt video on a monitor while i worked on the other. normal right? nope. my boss came to my "desk" and said i had to shut it down because it was bothering people (it wasn't anything offensive. it was literally a science podcast).

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by anthonypasq on Thursday February 06, 2020 @03:22PM (#22259893)
my boss has literally never walked by to look at my computer. He doesnt even know what im working on day to day.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by whalabi on Thursday February 06, 2020 @05:19PM (#22261062)
Definitely a quittable offence
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by closeparen on Thursday February 06, 2020 @10:52PM (#22263082)
Amateurs. Everyone knows you are supposed to do productivity surveillance in JIRA EasyBI.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by Scarblac on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:17AM (#22257247)
It was originally. Now I think there is no reason anymore, it's just the default option.

When the company I work for was looking for an extra office close by, they were all open plan. Changing that was never a topic of discussion.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by cagenut on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:11AM (#22257159)
not just density, but "easier" for the decision makers. Its easier to rent a big open room than to figure out an office plan and seating plan and construction schedule. Its easier to move desks around like musical chairs than to have to mutate rooms and halls.

People will almost always take the near-term cheaper and easier option, even when its worse and more expensive in the long run.

Incidentally, this was the one thing I liked about we-work. Room sizes were genuinely appropriate for 2 - 5 people (ofc sold as 3 - 10).

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by LeSaucy on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:23AM (#22257311)
Coincidentally I am sure that the decision makers would love to hear about your concerns, in their closed offices.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by ergothus on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:28AM (#22257365)
Another trend I've seen is "our CEO/VP sits in the same open floor plan"

...except they are actually in meetings 90% of the time, and may even have a dedicated meeting room (which is just an office by another name).

Actually hours at their open floor plan desk are easily in the single digits per week, of not per month.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by waylandsmithers on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:26PM (#22258061)
CEO at my company did that and seemed to actually enjoy it, but other executives basically forced him to get an office because he was too often discussing confidential information out in the open.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by commandlinefan on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:40AM (#22257491)
> actually in meetings 90% of the time

Or working from their home office. Which isn't an option for the common people.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by Mikeb85 on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:00AM (#22257019)
Pretty much. Real estate is expensive.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by montagg on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:12AM (#22257165)
I’d be really curious how much of a hit to people’s salary they would be willing to take, or the reduced capabilities of their business, to get an open office environment.

I worked with an internal team that created a brand new office for a decently-sized tech company. We had this exact debate: open or closed. We explored closed, or versions of it (see Spotify’s team rooms as a great example of a compromise), but the end result was the same: if we expected to grow substantially and expand our business a lot, real estate would be the biggest bottleneck. We’d literally have to pay people less and deliver slower if we wanted to make that trade off, and all the companies we talk to who had gone with some form of closed office had shifted to open over time because the costs were huge.

We did the next best thing, because we definitely heard the concerns of people that getting work done at work really was harder than it should be: we created as much private space for 1-2 people as possible that lots of people could use, so you got to decide whether you were in at your desk mode or heads down mode. Several years later, this seems to work all right. There’s still a desire to work from home occasionally, and my teams are pretty understanding about that. Even with the open office plan, though, we still have to rent virtually every open space around us.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by 0xffff2 on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:14PM (#22257918)
My example is skewed because I also really enjoy my work, but I fully intend to stay in my current position for the rest of my career because I have a real office with a door. I work in Silicon Valley and just cracked 6 figures in total compensation this year. By far the biggest reason that I have no interest in considering moving is the seeming impossibility of getting a cubicle, much less an office, anywhere else. So empirically, I will give up anywhere from ~50k-200k to do work I enjoy in an office with a door.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by MisterOctober on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:25AM (#22257334)
I've worked in both open and closed office environments -- currently have my own office, and it is _much_ easier for me to be productive without distractions in this arrangement. Huge improvement in quality of work and quality of life. It's possible that I could be persuaded to go back to an open-office environment, but it would require a _lot_ of additional compensation -- like maybe 50+%.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by falcolas on Thursday February 06, 2020 @01:20PM (#22258604)
It wouldn't have to be much of a salary cut. If you amortize the up-front cost for around a 110 square foot office, the total is only about $5,000 a year (more than an open office).

45 additional square feet at (a vastly overestimated) $100 per year per square foot for rent. $5,000 construction costs amortized over 10 years.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by montagg on Thursday February 06, 2020 @02:49PM (#22259604)
The way we thought about it was primarily butts in seats. For simplicity, if open office = about 1000, a reasonable closed office environment for us would have housed about half of that. If we needed 1000 to deliver product X, we’d either deliver product X over double the time or for double the (real estate) cost plus the non-local collaboration cost (not insurmountable, but it’s part of the tradeoff).

We’d need to see a closed office productivity increase of double or more to justify it, and we just couldn’t, even talking to other companies that had the kind of collaborative environment we thought of as ideal if we had infinite space. They didn’t see increases at that level.

To be clear, I’m seriously simplifying here. There are so many other considerations like workplace happiness, some amount of creative “collision” differences, churn and burnout, different individual needs for privacy, whether certain collaboration styles enabled by space fit the company culture, the type of work that’s happening, how likely that team structures will be the same in 1 year, 5 years, 10 years. Ultimately, we bet on space flexibility and giving teams more control over their space than giving everyone an office or team room. It’s hard to say what the alternate history would have been, but we do pretty regular surveys about workplace happiness and have seen significant positive increases compared to our old office (also open but much more rigid, far fewer private spaces) and general happiness with people’s access to private space and ability to get work done.

Edit: I also don’t want to overgeneralize. This made sense for us, but I think there are lots of situations where it does not make sense to have an open office, especially if you have a smaller company stocked primarily with very, very high performers doing individually-driven but very deep creative work (in the sense of integrating a lot of information). I would hope all companies would be more thoughtful about it, but I wanted to provide a little look at how a company that values privacy and enabling deep work might still arrive at an open office.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by loco5niner on Friday February 07, 2020 @11:17AM (#22267447)
> giving teams more control over their space

Unfortunately, in an open environment, the most important factors are uncontrollable.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by JohnFen on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:56PM (#22258366)
After trying it twice, I'm pretty sure that there is no amount of compensation that would get me to agree to work in an open office space.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by SpicyLemonZest on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:20AM (#22257281)
I'd easily take a 10% paycut to get a cubicle again. (Whether 10% actually covers the extra costs, I don't know.)
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by usefulcat on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:48PM (#22258281)
In Austin, I can get a modest 1-2 person private office for around $2k/month. At an annual salary of $120K, that's only 10-20% of developer costs. So the upper bound on the potential real estate savings of an open plan is on the order of 10-20%. Maybe a bit more if most devs are relatively inexperienced and therefore cheaper.

So while the savings is not nothing, when it's that small any potential productivity hit becomes even more of a big deal.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by brianpayne2 on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:39AM (#22257487)
I was talking with a friend who works at a company HQ'd in NYC and he said that the average cost per person/desk was over 60k/yr. It was a lot higher than I was expecting.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by phonon on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:16PM (#22257949)
No way...a nice sized cubicle is 100 sqft, and Class A rents in Manhattan are under $100/sqft/y. So the actual office space is something like $10,000 or less per year.

Of course there is other overhead, but space itself is in that range. So the max savings, in the most expensive market in the US, is under $10k per year.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by beart on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:31PM (#22258117)
But you don't rent by cubicle, you rent by floor or building. So adding a new employee when you have hit your max means you have to figure something out or sink a whole lot of money into a new building for one person.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by coredog64 on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:46PM (#22258257)
Office in NYC was remodeled to open office, and the limits were determined by fire code, bathrooms, etc. In the end, a whole bunch of valuable floor space is sitting empty as relaxation rooms, a puzzle table, and funky couch areas that nobody wants to sit at because it’s next to a big boss’s office.

Practically speaking, most people are treating the shift as an implicit agreement that employees can work from home 90+% of the time.

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by mprovost on Thursday February 06, 2020 @12:52PM (#22258326)
That size seems high. 100 sqft would be a nice sized office. Cubicles are more like 30 square feet. Douglas Coupland gave cubicles the name "veal fattening pens" in Generation X but they're actually smaller now - calf enclosures are 30-35 sqft. The latest fad with standing desks is even smaller.

https://www.wired.com/2000/05/is-your-cubicle-shrinking-too/

Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by phonon on Thursday February 06, 2020 @02:38PM (#22259507)
Yes, that's my point--the cost of raw office space for a single large cubicle/small office in Manhattan is under $10k/year. Other overhead is basically the same for a shared bench vs. large cubicle.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by slumdev on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:53AM (#22257674)
I'd be surprised if this is just real estate. HR and other things get rolled into overhead cost numbers.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by phonon on Thursday February 06, 2020 @02:40PM (#22259525)
But the portion that is ascribed to the raw footage would be under $10k/y...the other costs are not really correlated with shared bench vs cubicle vs private office.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by olau on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:59AM (#22257756)
Compared to the salary of skilled workers, it isn't really that much.
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by collyw on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:41AM (#22257509)
So is developer time. You would think someone would try and cost the difference in productivity drop (maybe they did already).
Re:Open-plan offices decrease face-to-face collaboration: study by DevKoala on Thursday February 06, 2020 @11:00AM (#22257017)
I am convinced too.