Enough regulation (and entrenched interests/semi-monopolies) to make new entry in the field prohibitive, but not enough to force incumbents into e.g. line-sharing and local loop unbundling, compounded by incumbents holding great sway over politicians and (directly or indirectly) over those supposed to oversee them.
The geographical claims are cute, but they're either excuses or convenient misdirections:
* I hear americans go "states states states" all the time. Several states have european densities yet don't seem to have the service. Some big cities are in the ballpark's of HK's densities yet are nowhere near its quality/price ratio (New York City actually has a higher population density than HK)
* Alternatively, if the claim is federal equality across the land, the claim is invalidated by the terrible service in rural areas where speeds (at the same insane price as in more urban zones) are in ranges which have not been seen in a decade in western europe, when it doesn't get to dialup (in 2008, 10% of american adults were using dialup, and it seems this number grew with the recession to escape the high costs of DSL and cable; by comparison, in France in Q4 2008 dialup was about 5% and falling)
America's Congress, on the other hand, created a national scheme of myriad local cable "franchises" or monopolies, which are historically awarded to connected insiders. U.S. phone service, the other major source of broadband, is also highly regulated and only the courts (ATT Breakup, MCI long distance case) forced America's greedy political class from keeping telecom as a national monopoly.
Telecom, as an industry, is still the #1 or #2 source of political donations. That's why your broadband sucks.
Its not even in the top 30.
This project was completed in 6 years, cost $20 billion to build and was the largest in the world at the time, and included flattening two islands and reclaiming 10 square kms of sea bed. It also involved building a new high speed railway link to the city.
Can anyone imagine something like this being built in 21st century USA? At no time was the project held up by property disputes, political in-fighting, environmental disputes, corruption problems, lobbying efforts or anything else. They just decided to build an airport, found a spot for it, raised the money, awarded the contracts and then set about the serious job of running an airport efficiently, pausing only to collects endless awards.
In the UK, the public enquiries for Heathrow Terminal 5 took longer, as did the build (8 years for enquiries, 8 years to build), and that was just adding a new terminal to an existing airport, and the new terminal was a fraction of the size of the Hong Kong airport. Add to this the fact that the Hong Kong airport cost more than 10% of the country's GDP yet the country still has no net debt. When the financial crisis hit, the airport announced a $500million relief package for airlines to encourage them to continue operations. The airport now generates around $1 billion per year for the government, after paying down it's debts, which are rapidly dwindling.
Basically the people in south-east asia want to build the biggest and best infrastructure and have the best living standards in the world, and they're not sitting around pointing fingers and throwing buns and yelling at each other on TV while they go about it. Frankly I'm surprised they don't sit around laughing at the rest of us. There is no reason why things like the HK airport and broadband infrastructure can't be built, but they require a government to stop sticking it's fingers into lots of pies and get on with the basic provision of infrastructure.
In the streets of Mong Kok (very high density suburb), there are youngsters standing on the side of the street for the whole day trying to sell broadband packages. Those broadband companies don't have retail shops; They pay a small wage to people in their early twenties who did not get into university / cannot get another job, to just stand there in the street (equivalent to $800 USD a month, 4 days a month off), to provide support as well as sell internet to new customers.
In the afternoon there's this shopping street closed off to cars. The internet salesmen move into the middle of the road, set up their portable sign, and work. Sometimes they bring a small chair.
At least they have cheap broadband.
Source: I'm in Hong Kong at the moment.
P.S
If you had only 4 days a month off, and your friend only have 4 days a month off, then you have a 1.8% chance of having the same day off each month. It equates to having one day to go out with your friend once every 2 years.
It's probably Sunday or Monday. So they'll probably meet. Also they can meet intra-day to launch or dinner.
Its not as non-random as csomar suggested, since you could have the day off any day of the week. However you usually get a day off once a week. I guess it should be better estimated at 1/7 chance of having the same day of, per week. That gives roughly 1 day every 2 months
Bandwidth was pretty expensive in the UK back in the nineties, but then OFCOM (the regulator) forced British Telecom to be broken into two companies...one wholesale and one retail. BT retail has to buy from BT wholesale at the same price as everyone else, and even small ISP's could now offer ADSL, and were allowed to install their own equipment at the exchange.
Fast forward to today...I pay £10 p/month for 24/2. If you have a satellite package with Sky TV you can get 2Mbps for free, or 20Mbps for £5 p/m or so. BT is just launching a 40Mbps service for around £25 p/m. Normally in the UK we get stung on prices and everything else I can think of is 20-50% higher in cost than the US...so it's pretty amazing our broadband costs are more competitive than many other countries. There just happens to be very health competition in this category.
I pay $45 for 25/5 FIOS and never have a problem streaming Netflix in HD to my TiVo. That's over 802.11G wireless too.
FIOS has also helped to push competition with Comcast here too.
It's not a technical failure but just a reality of the economy and increased competition from cable with DOCSIS 3. To the same point cable has backed away from FTTx deployments. (not that they were ever that committed in the first place but most had serious plans on the drawing boards for the near future)
That's disheartening, but I suppose it makes sense if they thought they could just be selectively one-upped by the cable companies in every area they entered. That the cable companies are basically holding areas hostage that way is a pretty good argument for public internet infrastructure, though.
You really need to call them. What you find online is nothing compared to the deals you can get over the phone.
I don't even bother streaming HD on Netflix or youtube because of the burps and buffering.
I wonder how things can get done so seemingly fluidly in terms of technology and broadband adoption in other countries, where it's either super-socialist or statist (like Nordic countries) or mythical in its backroom, nepotistic corruption (like apparently Asia, including HK). How does anything get done in other countries if its so galactically hard to do so in the US, even in places with aboslute population density like NY and LA?
Is it really the federal government? Or is it local government? I'd hate to think it is. I mean that HK 1Gbps line _has_ to be somewhat funded or subsidized by their government, either by funding the laying of fibre or some other thing.
What's more, our wireless speeds are bad, too. I mean, my brother was recently in Vietnam and he said their 3G connection consistency and speed blew the US equivalent out of the water. Of course, 3G adoption is likely not as high as here in the US, but the point stands.