And in the next sentence you're questioning why CEOs get paid so much. A good CEO or CFO or CMO can generate value for the company at a scale that's much much larger than what a single programmer does.
During Satya Nadella's reign as the CEO, Microsoft went from people speculating its impending demise to a trillion dollar company. Don't you think he deserves a billion from that $700bn rise in market cap?
TSLA stock will tank the moment Elon Musk decides to step down? In a cynical world, maybe he's just a figurehead and there are others running the show behind the scene, but creating such persona is still something that a CEO has to do.
This is the same old Tesla vs Edison discussion. It's a common misconception among people that it's enough to be a genius lone worker to be able to provide value to a company.
If you're a bad programmer, your failures aren't public and you can job hop to the next gullible company.
I don’t really think that is true at all.
Bad CEOs get a severance package on millions and go working elsewhere.
No, nobody deserves a billion dollars, I don't care what they do.
You mean the employees should have asked for higher salaries and refused to work for his company if the company refused to pay? I don't think a single person has claimed that Bloomberg has paid them a single cent less than the salary specified in their contract.
That's the rub, isn't it? This is a protest against market forces, not against people. If I write a book and everybody in the world pays a dollar to read it (JK Rowling), how on earth could anyone say that I shouldn't have a billion dollars? Shouldn't they be ranting at the all the people who gave me the money of their own accord?
In Bloomberg's case, every employee made a conscious decision to work for the company to increase its value, and every employee was paid what they signed up for. What's unfair about it?
The second assumption is that people join companies to "increase their value". That may be true for some people on this forum, but most people join companies for a paycheck, because they can't live without income. If no one had to work to live comfortably, I doubt anyone would care about billionaires.
So he summoned it out of thin air
Leadership is the other side of that coin.
If somebody single-handedly invented a cure for all cancer and made it free to the world... you'd have a hard time convincing me that person didn't deserve a billion dollars.
Nobody can actually spend/consume more than ~10% of 1Bn. But if someone is smart enough to make 1Bn, it's probably a good bet for society to "promote that person to being in charge of how most of that 1Bn gets allocated". In most of the civilized world 1Bn doesn't automagically translate into "you're a god now, you can buy off the police and the judges and the government and do whatever". (Now sure, in a corrupt country one could fully spend 1Bn by "buying out" lots of people and institution and making himself a god, but in "the civilized world" it doesn't work, or would require significantly more than 1Bn.)
The alternatives are bureaucracies / central-planning committees. For some things they work well, for some they are catastrophic, but for most thing they are simply very very very suboptimal / wasteful and non-innovative!
Hence we "bet on capitalism" and let the guy "keep" his billion.
(There are issues ofc, one could spend a significant part of the money outside of the "legal market of civilized society" or use them to subtly "bend the system"... hence it's probably a good idea to cap personal wealth at 1Bn or smth like that and force other forms of power be shared or politically mediated. Or to just monitor that the use of the money is on goods and services that are actually legally buyable and are "bought to be used or sold at a profit" instead of "bought to profit the buyer and buy his servitude" or other schemes, or not on fake donations that buy influence.)
[0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/hbsworkingknowledge/2015/11/18/...
Both programmers and CEOs (and others) can be "force multipliers". If they're really good, they can help their company do better than the sum of the parts.
If the programmer is mostly working on code it's usually easy to discover if they're detrimental. Though if they're doing more fleeting stuff like design, it can be more difficult because the effects are less direct.
In a similar way, a CEOs performance can easily be masked by other factors, such as the market in general and good employees. Say the company increases sales by 10x, but most other candidate CEOs could have done 20-30x or more.
That said, I do think there's some other factors at play when hiring CEOs, as some with known repeated terrible histories still get hired etc.
Based on the numbers, usually it's luck. It isn't to say that there are some outstanding CEOs. But the majority are in the mediocre camp and just get lucky.
https://www.inc.com/will-yakowicz/study-luck-looking-the-par...
EDIT: I'm not suggesting a large company is going to hire me as CEO...
Since the OP mentioned Matt Levine's Money Stuff, here's a fun little bit from today's newsletter [1]:
> Every time you read about a workaholic billionaire and think “boy, not me, if I had a billion dollars I’d be on the beach,” the answer is always “well that’s why you don’t have a billion dollars.” If you have the characteristics that enable you to make a billion dollars, you don’t usually turn them off once you get there.
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-02-03/amazon...
But yeah, give me a few millions and I'll slave away for one year, then retire.
This is an extremely optimistic view of the majority of developers who are essentially building glorified Wordpress themes.
A glorified Wordpress theme for a cornershop isn't valuable. The same thing for a redesign that materially affects the decisions of millions of consumers may be super valuable.
According to one theory, if you overpay the guy at the top, it makes all the underlings work harder to try and climb up that greasy pole. The more grossly and obviously overpaid that top guy is, the more desirable it is to try and somehow work your way to his position.
Could you expand on this? I would be interested in what part you find 'rare' -- I find there are tons of different niches/archetypes that a SWE can have.
- Attention to detail
- High frustration barrier
Over the course of a career those become less and less important as one learns to use the appropriate tools (e.g. linters) and processes, but you still need them to get to that point. Especially for beginners, those two in practice most often break the "everyone can learn to program" trope, that I'd like to be true.
Indeed. Everyone can learn to write code. Not everyone can learn to program.
http://www.eis.mdx.ac.uk/research/PhDArea/saeed/SD_PPIG_2009...
The person who for some reason is up on a Saturday night reading the NGINX source code in C to better implement their company's Lets Encrypt integration.
The person who actually stepped through Kelsey Hightower's Kubernetes the Hard way just because they thought Kubernetes was really cool.
The person who writes code for personal projects during "social hours" where others may be out with friends, out with their significant others, etc.
EDIT: I'll leave it for the integrity/honesty of the comment, but here are some descriptors I wish I'd used in the first place instead of 'autism':
* On the spectrum
* Extreme Introvert
* Socially disconnected
* Ties self-value to work-output in extreme ways
* Seeks joy from work versus social interaction & status
(1) Classical autism
(2) Autism spectrum disorder (ASD)
(3) Broader autism phenotype (BAP)
If people were to understand you as talking about (3), well I don't think you said anything inaccurate. You obviously weren't talking about most individuals included under (1). As far as (2) goes, well at one end (2) includes (1), and at the other end (2) has a very vague boundary with (3).
Everyone seems to be missing this. It doesn't have to be in the DSM criteria, the parent poster is talking about the popular view.
I don't necessarily agree – I don't seek joy from work but I do things that others (my wife included) would consider as "work". The moment you tackle that label on them – or whenever I lose control of what I'm supposed to be doing – I'll no longer have the same joy.
> The person who for some reason is up on a Saturday night reading the NGINX source code in C
Sigh
Now this I have issue with. I think the best programmers I know will do something like this out of their own self interest. Maybe they are setting up some elaborate and over-engineered system for their own amusement.
If this is for work, though? You bet your ass I'll be reading that NGINX source code, if I have to, during work hours, however loosely defined those are. There are exceptions, of course. Sometimes your mind will be so focused on something that it _just won't let go_. In which case, fine, Monday can't wait and I'll try this thing. As long as there is no expectations from the part of the company.
Saturday night I'll be mucking around with 3d printing, game engines, programming my own blog software for the 30th time in a new Scheme dialect, anything. Just not work.
I wouldn't identify any of your examples as signs for someone being on the autistic spectrum.
(And the boundary between BAP and ASD is rather ill-defined and subjective anyway.)
Sure, it might be a little harder, but to me its absurd to claim the salary difference makes any moral sense.
But why do we even discuss it when there is a whole cohort of salaries that actually make no sense in comparison: All of the VP's, CEO's, etc... even stock holders just wasting efficiency collecting dividends from existing wealth and the productivity of others. Why are tech people trying to defend their salaries when we could just point at the next people up the chain?