If you have decent insurance, you pay your maximum out of pocket and insurance pays the rest (at negotiated rates).
If you don't have decent insurance, you declare bankruptcy and the hospital ends up paying for all except the few dollars they are able to get out of you. This is pretty much the same situation as when homeless people show up at an ER, which is legally obligated to help them regardless of ability to pay.
It might say that your hospital stay is covered on paper ... but then at the hospital the robot (or another doctor) might not be billed through the hospital and some outside group that is suddenly out of network.... there's no way to know.
The worst-case max out of pocket for any insurance plan in 2020 is:
$8,150 for self-only coverage
$16,300 for family coverage
In America, it is important to have liquid savings to handle life events like losing a job or a serious health issue. We get taxed less, have fewer safety nets, so we need to build our own safety net. You can argue that one way is better than another way as a big picture, but many people misconstrue the individualist vs. collectivist societies as a serious moral issue instead of a choice. Some of the details of each can be serious moral issues, but the big picture is simply a difference in priorities.
Bottom line: If you can come up with $16k/year to cover medical expenses for a serious issue, you won't go bankrupt.
The US median income is $63k... $16k would be 25% of that.
The difference is for people with no or low incomes as the tax is used to pay for these. Social security.
Lack of food (9 days), and lack of potable water (72 hours). Since we seem to be leaning towards the opinion that the gov't needs to provide everything for us and we should have minimal/no responsiblity for our own sustenance, repair, or longevity, where's the Free Sh*t Army slogans for no-cost food and water?
Interestingly enough, most economic studies of social security show that putting the same money into a low-risk index fund would've netted more gains, plus that money would've been available to the person with far fewer 'strings attached' (vis a vis able to be withdrawn earlier if desired, descendants/spouses able to withdraw in case of untimely demise, etc). Coerced gov't meddling, again, has proven to be the more-painful economic road to go down, as opposed to letting individuals choose what to do with what they've earned.
>folks on social security
I notice that you call some people "folks" while others are simply "receipients". Do you think poor people are human?
For example, the French tax bracket for income between $28k and $81k* is 30%
In the US the rate in that bracket is 12% up to $39k and 20% after. If I did my math right that averages to 18%.
That isn't high income earners saving on taxes, that's a 40% lower marginal income tax rate for the middle class in the US vs. France. There are also many other sources of tax outside income which are different and higher in countries with social medicine.
* converted from EUR to USD
(taxation is complicated and making apples-to-apples comparisons is hard. it is easy to argue about fiddly details and hard to avoid a long list of caveats)
The poor and lower middle class aren't in any better position to save tens of thousands of dollars for medical emergencies, despite the lower taxes. Lower rates don't help, when your income is low.
And in California, that difference is a lot less than 12%.
How / when you might hit it is an unknown from plan to plan for the reasons I noted.
If you hit the max it is irrelevant, I am talking about hitting the max and going bankrupt.
The costs of a given hospital visit is still an unknown leading up to the max... and how quickly you hit it is an unknown... and thus actually finding "descent insurance" is not easy.
As far as I can tell you seem to just be hooked on this concept that after you hit the max you're not paying and that somehow means something. Perhaps you feel that hitting the max is a trivial thing?
https://time.com/5555988/medical-bills-out-of-network/
This lady had insurance, and yet was stuck with a $227,000 'balance bill'.
I'm no mathematician, but $227,000 seems to be a bit higher than the 8.5k max that this thread keeps citing.
This kind of issue should be taken into account when choosing an insurance plan. If you choose one which has a restricted network, you have to be more diligent about where you get your care in emergencies.
Medical billing is nonsense though. Just because someone sends you a bill does not mean you owe it or will ever have to pay it. This is one of those details and rare occurrences which get way out into the weeds and doesn't really support the argument of which type of health care your country should provide. There are similar edge cases in social medicine where some situation or another is appalling. Extreme cases need to be handled, but unless they are common, they shouldn't drive the debate.
2. Did you notice the anecdote in another part of this thread where an approved, in-network procedure at an in-network hospital had an out-of-network anesthesiologist, because every single practicing anesthesiologist in the region is out-of-network?
3. As a buyer of health insurance, how can I even know, ahead of time, that there's a problem, like what was listed in #2?
4. As a non-buyer of health insurance (Because my employer chose which one to buy), even if I knew about #2, I don't even have any choice in the matter!
It's ludicrous to expect people to do all the research they need to do, to avoid getting bitten, in an industry that is as hostile to transparency as the medical billing industry. Where do you even start? [1]
> Medical billing is nonsense though. Just because someone sends you a bill does not mean you owe it or will ever have to pay it.
Is this legal advice? Because as I understand it, there are plenty of places which will happily garnish your wages over medical debt, and there are plenty of hospitals who won't write off outrageous balance bills if they discover that you actually have savings in the bank. (Oh, and the ones that will forgive it... Are robbing the public, because they get to claim that write-off on their taxes. As a taxpayer, that's my favorite part of 'charitable debt forgiveness'.)
[1] And even if you could do that research, the problem of balance billing comes from your insurer, and the hospital not agreeing on which services should have been paid for, and sticking you with the problem. You cannot predict that, at all, because it is always an after-the-fact case-by-case scenario.
My friends from other countries say, not really when you add everything. Then add the US's system of 'private taxes' which drive up the cost of things like health insurance, schools, etc.
When I had severe hypokalemia and was effectively paralyzed several years ago [1] (sorta comical read) they never once asked me about my dietary intake, instead they assumed I had some rare genetic disorder (in the ER the doctor literally told me "we're googling your symptoms") and once I was admitted they paraded 3 doctors through my room and billed me for 5 or 6 'consults'.
While I considered my insurance to be 'good' getting dinged for each of those 'consults', 2 times each, despite only ever having seen 4 doctors total (one an ER doc that was probably a year or two into his medical career) face to face once each I ended up paying 10-12 different 'consul' fees, then a portion of the ambulance, then a portion of the room, the two different physical therapists they sent by after declaring me a 'fall risk' since I came in functionally paralyzed, then a portion of all the tests. From the time I set foot in the ER until I left I was there about 37 hours.
All they had to do was give me some oral and IV potassium and I was fine. I actually diagnosed it myself, with no medical training whatsoever, in the ER unable to move 45 minutes before they did. My mother was there and after I'd somewhat calmed myself (I could not move, I could barely move my fingers) I told her it was probably a sodium potassium imbalance and I could probably still make it to work for overtime that morning. I ended up paying a little bit under 7k$, 1/4 of my gross income at the time, with my 'good insurance'. Took me 4~ years to pay it all off.
[1] https://www.ryanmercer.com/ryansthoughts/2013/2/19/flashback...
Another major annoyance -- if you have surgery, the hospital usually gets their money from you right away. However, you're going to spend the next 18 months receiving random bills from various different firms representing nurses, doctors, lab technicians, etc. related to your procedure, many of which come down to "stuff we decided to do while you were unconscious."
My cost was 10 times his. His whole family for less than half the cost of just myself. My initial suspicion was he got generic and I didn't. Nope, same box. He's said before he has 'good insurance' but it's almost always just talk. Guess it wasn't in this case.
Does that mean the entirety of your life savings and any liquidatable assets?
What about non-retirement investments? Aren't you only allowed to put so much into a retirement plan per year?
Yes, retirement accounts are limited in terms of annual contributions. But bankruptcy protection is one factor to consider in whether to max your contributions and/or to pay ahead on the mortgage on your primary residence.
Which tangentially makes all the Rand Paul bullshit about doctors being slaves under a universal healthcare system kinda moot.
I know intelligent people aren't making that argument but it's a reasonable counterpoint in case you come across one of them
If we accept the premise that being legally compelled to treat a patient makes a doctor a slave, it is perfectly reasonable for Rand Paul to argue against the expansion of such a law. Similarly, the current existence of such a law does not contradict his moral stance unless he advocates or supports the current system, which he does not.
He makes the argument entirely because he was searching for something to support his platform, not the other way around. He doesn't appear to even delve into the issue beyond healthcare == slavery but rather focuses on supporting his strange forever contradictory hyper-capitalistic vision. As such he waives any possibility to debate the issue from the position that he doesn't support the current solution because he doesn't support anything.
I think the OP's question was more: who decides this person gets treated by a state-of-the-art robot, while this person gets a prescription and told to go home and rest?
My mom worked in healthcare billing her whole career. My understanding is that half the reason medical bills are so high for normal people is they need to cover the costs for the people that need and have received care but were unable to pay.
In this particular case, it's a matter of national security, so I'm sure the needed funds would magically appear if needed.
Thing is the state hospitals will actually try to cure you; and they are fairly good at it. Harborview (part of University of Washington) is the only L1 trauma center in the region.
For-profit hospitals stick it to the taxpayers by doing this. It's a good argument for some form of universal healthcare, since we're paying one way or another.
Sounds totally fair and reasonable to the people who get crazy high bills for the one thing a year that they need it for, despite paying hundreds a month in premiums for the "privilege" of also paying for people who can't. What a system.
Otherwise the person could just choose to freely infect as many people as they want because they can't pay for specialized treatment.
Also the hospitals can write these costs off of their taxes in various ways. If outbreaks like this cost them millions in expenses they have tax loopholes and it ends up costing them nothing.
If a company spends X dollars on something, they don't pay X dollars less in taxes. They pay X dollars * their marginal tax rate less in taxes.
Now they may be able to apply for grants or other types of funding, but there is simply no way to "write things off" and then get them for free.
Is that not the case?
I'd assume the US has programs/budgets for this sort of contingency funded at the federal level?
I recall an article a few years ago about the google founders (?) paying for kids in San Francisco to get vaccinated. The comments were split between Americans praising the act and Canadians that were confused.
They were $20 or so in Quebec if you weren't in an at-risk group. https://www.quebec.ca/en/health/advice-and-prevention/vaccin...
In addition to that, workplaces also give out limited number of sick days, so people don't go to the doctor and go to work instead. They ride in public transportation to get there, maybe stop at the store on the way back if symptoms haven't gotten too bad, handle some produce and so on. Well we see where this is headed. I think once something like this virus comes to a large city in US, it just has a pretty good chance of spreading and in large to our broken healthcare system.
This page has a lot of good info:
https://www.federalregister.gov/d/2017-00615
Particularly the "Payment for Care and Treatment" discussion here, which talks about public comments and even gets into the ethics of what you can make someone pay for compulsory treatment or isolation:
https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2017/01/19/2017-00...
And the rules in 70.13 and 71.30 here and here:
https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2017/01/19/2017-00...
https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2017/01/19/2017-00...
Excerpt from the rules in 70.13 (which I think covers domestic stuff):
> Director may authorize payment ... Payment shall be secondary ... after all third-party payers have made payment in satisfaction of their obligations ... For quarantinable communicable diseases, payment shall be limited to costs for services and items reasonable and necessary for the care and treatment of the individual or group for the time period beginning when the Director refers the individual or group to the hospital or medical facility and ends when, as determined by the Director, the period of apprehension, quarantine, isolation, or conditional release expires.
In practice, that poor bastard is gonna get a huge bill for saving the rest of us from his illness. I hope at least his friends buy him free beers for a while.
Ambulance trips in the states are routinely $3,000. my trip to the ER after a wreck was $3800. If you dont have insurance, how do you pay for an "isopod" and a quarantine with a medical robot? What reasonable insurance company would ever cover these expenses? (mine hardly covers birth control.)
Healthcare is private here. When i go to the hospital they ask if "i am a member." Do these treatments take place at in-network facilities? is there such a thing as an in-network facility for being quarantined with an incurable new disease? Can I be compelled to pay for health services in this case if i DO NOT want them?
Its at least reassuring to see CNN is dancing around the HIPAA implicationf of misidentifying or identifying the patient...although I wonder if its only because they recently emerged from a slander/libel lawsuit for painting a highschool kid from kentucky as a racist during a rally.