News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by sgt101 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @03:21AM (#22042846)
Mandating a large proportion of units constructed to be high density 3 bedroom would change the London housing market. Currently young couples get a 2 bed (with one bed being a box room) and have to move out once the second baby comes (the pressure when a first baby gets to three is high as well). Three beds would make for long term family viability and would knock the pressure out of the housing market.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by rwmj on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @03:41AM (#22042930)
These houses already exist, so without going back in time this isn't possible. However it's very easy to add a third bedroom either at the back or in the loft which is what many owners do.

Would recommend this book: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_Buildings_Learn

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by mytailorisrich on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @03:43AM (#22042938)
A big issue in London and the UK is that everyone wants a house and garden, and flats are usually poorly designed and poor quality.

One reason many couples move out of London when they have children is that it is impossible for most to afford such a house in London.

This also makes housing quite low density, which leads to longer commute and more expensive public transport.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by J-dawg on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:04AM (#22043369)
Another reason why everyone wants a house is so that they can have a freehold.

People are understandably frightened of situations like this:

https://www.reddit.com/r/UKPersonalFinance/comments/eo9qim/l...

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by Findeton on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @03:50AM (#22042973)
Housing is low density because you can't build higher by law, in most cases. It's one of the socialist aspects of the UK.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by altacc on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @04:45AM (#22043282)
> socialist aspects of the UK

I think you're thinking of the other UK, the imaginary one that right-wing commentators make out to be a hellish nightmare of bad teeth inflicted upon the populace by fiendishly free health care. Instead of the real UK, with it's right-wing, capitalist, free-market friendly, populist government.

Building regulations aren't in any way socialist, they are pretty much global and many countries, including the "freedom" loving USA, have extensive government-mandated building codes which include height restrictions or mechanisms to limit height.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by eru on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @09:02AM (#22044756)
You are right that building codes aren't a sign of socialism at all.

The UK however has a pretty interventionist state. (But yes, they are less interventionist than eg the French. Low bar, though.) And eg re-nationalising the railways is perennial popular with the population. Luckily, no government has been crazy enough to do it, nor has it even featured much in election campaigns.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by tomatocracy on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @12:33PM (#22047051)
Not sure that's right re railways. Railtrack was de facto renationalised by the Blair government (becoming Network Rail) in the early 2000s, and we had an election one month ago where the main opposition party campaigned on a promise to not relet the private sector passenger franchises, ie de facto take them back into public ownership at the end of their terms. That isn't quite all of the railways (you've still got a few privately owned pieces of infrastructure, freight operators and rolling stock leasing) but it's pretty close.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by eru on Wednesday January 15, 2020 @02:41AM (#22052389)
Interesting, thanks! Please imagine I added the appropriate hedge words in my comment above.

With your corrections, it does move Britain a bit more into the interventionist state direction.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by lawtalkinghuman on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @12:08PM (#22046799)
No, the reason people don't build taller residential buildings is because a lot of mortgage providers often won't lend to leasehold buyers in high-rises, which limits residence to cash-only buyers and council tenants.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @04:23AM (#22043169)
Could you point out what law you're referring to?

Some early 20th century (and some earlier) housing in my UK city is 3 or 4 storeys. Many of the newer buildings are 4 storey, a few tower blocks (60s/70s).

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by michaelt on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:07AM (#22043388)
National laws, not so much that I know of.

But if you read through The London Plan [1] policy 7.6 says: "Buildings and structures should [...] not cause unacceptable harm to the amenity of surrounding land and buildings, particularly residential buildings, in relation to privacy, overshadowing, wind and microclimate. This is particularly important for tall buildings"

So if you're filling in a gap in a Victorian terrace, planning officers will be checking whether you're going to be able to see into your neighbours' gardens more than existing buildings can, or cast shadows onto other homes.

Meanwhile, policy 7.7 calls for "tall and large" buildings to "generally be limited to sites in the Central Activity Zone, opportunity areas, areas of intensification or town centres that have good access to public transport" and to "only be considered in areas whose character would not be affected adversely by the scale, mass or bulk of a tall or large building"

And as some sources describe a tall building as "1½ times or more the height of their context" [2] tall building rules are easily activated in a two-storey area.

Of course, it's not completely restrictive - if an existing Victorian terrace has two-storey buildings with lofts, I've seen people get permission for a building with a basement, three above-ground stories and a flat roof - and if it's a house rather than a block of flats, that's a lot of stairs already.

[1] https://www.london.gov.uk/sites/default/files/the_london_pla... [2] https://planningconsult.rbkc.gov.uk/gf2.ti/f/276546/18804485...

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by gvjddbnvdrbv on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:11AM (#22043407)
UK law respects property rights of the neighbours including e.g. right to light.

This is explicitly not socialism.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by eru on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @08:39AM (#22044596)
That's all pretty low. You could build ten storey building everywhere in London and have enough demand to sell them profitably.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by sgt101 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @03:59AM (#22043033)
That was true in the last century, but it just isn't the case now. It's rather the structure and economics (artificial) of the market that are creating this particular inefficiency.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by andybak on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @04:55AM (#22043322)
> It's one of the socialist aspects of the UK.

Yes because building density regulations are one of the hallmarks of socialism.

Wat?

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @04:19AM (#22043152)
>Currently young couples get a 2 bed (with one bed being a box room) and have to move out once the second baby comes //

I guess you've never heard of bunk beds?

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by PaulRobinson on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @04:34AM (#22043229)
Which are unsuitable for very young children? Yes, we have those in England, we just don't put toddlers in them. What sort of monster are you? :)
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @08:43AM (#22044632)
Precisely that sort of monster! You got me ;o)

"We" clearly do.

[I'm also in UK, fwiw]

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by downtide on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:23AM (#22043471)
'Legislation states if children over the age of 10 of the opposite sex are sharing a bedroom they should have their own rooms – otherwise this is considered overcrowding.'

https://www.nspcc.org.uk/keeping-children-safe/in-the-home/s...

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by gambiting on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @06:51AM (#22043922)
Even the website you linked says explicitly that it's not illegal for children to share a bedroom, even if they are over the age of 10 and of opposite sex. It's considered overcrowded for purposes of various statistics but it's not illegal in the slightest.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by downtide on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @02:30PM (#22048353)
I didn't say it was illegal.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by eru on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @03:36AM (#22042915)
Why do there need to be mandates?

The article itself mentions that mandates themselves made the low density configuration persist.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by mytailorisrich on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @03:55AM (#22043002)
Those mandates persist because people don't want flat, and flats tend to be low quality.

There needs to be a change of perception, expectations, and better flats.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by downtide on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:26AM (#22043480)
I think some of the earlier built flats are really good quality. With thick floors between too. Modern flats and houses in Britain can be built to very low standards. I watched a terrace go up near Bradford, with timber and stud walling between properties. Our bricked terrace is a nightmare with noise, but in those they must be able to hear each other fart.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by gvjddbnvdrbv on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:08AM (#22043392)
People don't want flats because of leasehold.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by sgt101 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @03:58AM (#22043025)
Also a low density unit commands such a premium and so is cheaper to build than several high density units that would sell for a similar price.

Developers would far rather build a couple of "Exclusive Modern Mansions" rather than two blocks of four three bedroom flats. They make more money, but create far less value.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by ovi256 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @04:14AM (#22043117)
>make more money, but create far less value.

If the market structure doesn't allow reaping profit proportional to the value you create, the less profitable thing doesn't get done, even if it creates more value for society. It's a market failure.

The implications of that for progressive personal income taxation are left as an exercise for the reader. They're usually not explored for ideological reasons.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @04:31AM (#22043205)
> The implications of that for progressive personal income taxation

I don't think there are any. An individual doesn't get to choose between a high tax job and a low tax job. The only way to get more money in your pockets is to get paid more money, regardless of whether you're taxed at 15% or 50%.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by nicoburns on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @07:36AM (#22044199)
There are: wealth inequality (caused by income inequality) causes massive inefficiencies in the market (by for example incentivising wasteful luxury housing), because it means that buying power is not even close to proportional to genuine need.

Thus we ought to massively increase taxation on the highest earners in order to rebalance our economy.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by ovi256 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @07:02AM (#22043986)
>more money in your pockets is to get paid more money

Sure, I agree with you on that. You have to consider the effects on an additional unit of effort put in at that job. Progressive taxation sets up steeply diminishing returns on that marginal effort. And incentives to spend that effort on alternatives with better returns, like shopping for tax-sheltered investments. Because a salary's not the only income professionals have. So you can effectively make tradeoffs between revenue streams with different tax rates, one of which happens to be your job.

This clearly disincentivizes creating additional value for society through an additional unit of effort at that job, and it's a result of market structure.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @07:27AM (#22044138)
What revenue streams does someone have that don't count as income and take a notable amount of time input? Most investments don't take any significant amount of time to set up.

And it's likely that whatever they're doing to get money should simply be counted as income too.

> This clearly disincentivizes creating additional value for society through an additional unit of effort at that job

Whatever they do instead might create less value for society, or it might create more value for society. I have no idea what the average is.

Also we have to look at the opportunity cost. By taxing one person with a huge income more, you can tax dozens of people with lower incomes less. In most cases that's a huge boon for society.

> Progressive taxation sets up steeply diminishing returns on that marginal effort.

Steeply? Bah. When you're talking about millions of dollars, removing 37 percent (or 50 or 70) still leaves an enormous incentive.

The thing that actually causes significant diminishing returns is that every dollar you earn benefits your life less than the previous dollar.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by ovi256 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @03:18PM (#22048831)
>you're talking about millions of dollars

I never meant millions of dollars. This argument applies to middle class incomes too.

Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:23PM (#22049856)
Middle class income is below 37 percent marginal tax in the US, and they're not super high anywhere I'm aware of. "steeply diminishing returns" definitely does not apply.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by eru on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @08:37AM (#22044573)
I don't think that's true. In places like London it's not construction costs, but land, that really determines overall costs.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing by eru on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @08:36AM (#22044562)
If people don't want flats, why do they need a mandate against them? I'm a bit confused. Just don't rent nor buy them, if you don't like them?