Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing
by ovi256 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @03:18PM
(#22048831)
>you're talking about millions of dollars
I never meant millions of dollars. This argument applies to middle class incomes too.
Re:Why So Many Londoners Live in 'Two-Up, Two-Down' Housing
by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:23PM
(#22049856)
Middle class income is below 37 percent marginal tax in the US, and they're not super high anywhere I'm aware of. "steeply diminishing returns" definitely does not apply.
And it's likely that whatever they're doing to get money should simply be counted as income too.
> This clearly disincentivizes creating additional value for society through an additional unit of effort at that job
Whatever they do instead might create less value for society, or it might create more value for society. I have no idea what the average is.
Also we have to look at the opportunity cost. By taxing one person with a huge income more, you can tax dozens of people with lower incomes less. In most cases that's a huge boon for society.
> Progressive taxation sets up steeply diminishing returns on that marginal effort.
Steeply? Bah. When you're talking about millions of dollars, removing 37 percent (or 50 or 70) still leaves an enormous incentive.
The thing that actually causes significant diminishing returns is that every dollar you earn benefits your life less than the previous dollar.