It seems quaint now, but in 2016 when the term was publicized, it was very specific and direct: there was an epidemic of utterly fabricated political clickbait being shared from anonymous websites. Stories that were literally no more than unattributed fiction were widely circulated on social media, seen by millions, and a huge proportion of those people were taking them to be genuine (if politically motivated) news reporting.
Maybe at the time, it seemed like someone would do something if they pointed out that this was happening.
Of course, what someone did was immediately adopt the term to describe (what they saw as) low-quality, poorly-sourced, or overly-opinionated political reporting. And then a bunch of people who thought that reporting was actually pretty good started throwing the term back at what they thought was overly-opinionated, and suddenly the discourse was about bias in the mainstream media, and no one seemed to care much anymore about the tsunami of literal fantasies being deliberately spread by propagandists unknown.
Personally, I don’t care. If the most popular use of a term is nonsensical, I use next most popular meaning that has some sensical usage.
I don’t buy this whole “you can’t use the words ‘racist’ or ‘cloud’ because they’re so overused as to be meaningless” thing. Words are (briefly) overused all the time. And then they’re not, and we can carry on using them according to their original purpose.
It used to be that the truth was constrained by the information that gatekeepers in positions of power or media let us see, and all it took to be reasonably informed was to watch or listen to a reputable media outlet for half an hour in the evening, and ignore whatever they believed the bad outlet to be.
This masked the complexities of reality for most of the population.
The internet has exposed the turbulence beneath the surface of publicly accessible knowledge. Thanks to social media, the subjects of journalism can now respond to it, or head it off with nearly the same amount of reach as journalists themselves. The sane can be said of anybody with a half-formed opinion on anything.
Many journalists have seemingly gotten so busy responding to the gnats and the niggles, and the affronts to their authority that they didn't realize they'd been caught in the undertow (see Twitter and facebook's community's influence on what is/isn't covered).
This has become increasingly visible in their work, even as their platforms are being chipped away thanks to competition in an increasingly fragmented landscape with incentives aligned towards catering to increasingly niche constituencies.
As a result, the adversarial nature of our information landscape has been laid bare to a swaths of the public.
Does realigning our expectations as to where, how, and if we'll find the truth redefine it? Not literally. But from a cultural perspective it does.
For the better? I don't know. I doubt it. Esp. in the US, too many of us weren't prepared to operate in such an environment and we're culturally already predisposed to conspiratorial thinking (rich coming from me). But it's where we're at right now.
Observations ('sense data' and personally-acquired life experience) are what we can (conceivably at least) fully agree on. 'Sam has hair'. 'Don't kick boulders.' Those upon which we can agree are the foundations of (that terribly-abused word) 'truth'.
We need to careful about using the word 'perception' as a stand-in for 'interpretation'. When we talk, we agree to pretend that we understand what each of us is saying. But when the words from my reality-tunnel cross the threshold of your reality-tunnel, your ears will likely hear my sounds, but then your brain interprets them. Danger, Will Robinson!
Facts stand or fall on their own, for the most part, in conformance to some external reality.
Narrative is the thread or story that's created, not just from individual facts, but the relationships which are drawn between them. It's possible to tell a false story (e.g., not truth), from a set of true facts, by misrepresenting the relationships between those facts.
This is how much (bad/false) conspiracy-theory stories get constructed -- if they're not totally true, they're a mix of truth and falsehood, but the narrative by which they're strung together is almost wholly false or misleading. This creates a huge cognitive load in addressing as you've got to sift through and sort the truths from falsehoods, both atomically (for any given event, place, person, thing, etc.), and for the relationships between elements.
There's a particularly insidious (and extremely long) bullshit conspiracy theory, "Everything is a Rich Man's Trick", tying everything from WWII to JFK to Nixon and beyond together, which operates on this basis. There are a great many indisputably true facts (several quite interesting ones) in the piece. But the relationships are bullshit, with one of the early lies being that JFK's "Secret Society" speech addressed anything other than the Soviet Union -- which listening a few seconds outside the clip included in the video makes clear.
Among the problems usual approaches to debunking encounter is that fact-checking individual items within such stories fails to address the overall narrative.
There's also the case that a story can be constructed of fictitious events, and yet be fundamentally true or accurate. This can show up in science (Gregor Mendel's genetic inheritence research appears to have been at least in part fabricated), in journalism (elements and facts in many stories are incorrect, though the overall narrative is often roughly accurate), in fiction (historical, political, or other fiction can create a highly-accurate or realistic picture of events or conditions) etc.
Where facts and narrative both align with reality, they're often quite compelling.
Oh no, the conspiracy goes back way longer. When the secret cult started building pyramids all over the world and then they hijacked Jesus teachings and corrupted it and when they brought down the roman empire, just after Atlantis ...
I can recomend Illuminatus! by Wilson and Shea. It was written under the hilarious assumption that all the conspiracies are true ..
Not that it is original or unique.
EDIT: Looks like they haven't posted the first episode yet, just the 2 minute preview. I guess they're delaying the podcast in favor of the on-air broadcast.
A fact can't be misleading; it's the argument that uses it that might be misleading. So this really just points to us keeping up our abilities to ferret out the actual arguments and using critical thinking to oppose them if they are invalid.
I made https://en.howtruthful.com/ to facilitate presenting the core structure of an argument concisely, with the true parts and false parts appropriately marked.
Unfortunately, I don't think there is a succinct consensus quite yet.
Speaking of, I recently started listening to the Philosophize This podcast, which attempts to give basic overviews of some major philosophers and schools of thought in a generally chronological order. I'm really enjoying it so far, and while it's probably easier to download and organize them with itunes or an app, the episodes are here:
Another somewhat more in-depth but possibly slightly more boring podcast is "A History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps". There's at least one spin-off on African Philosophy. I really enjoyed the almost-boring slow-paced nature of its approach.
I've spent a lot of time watching media of all stripes misrepresent politicians of all other stripes by selectively misunderstanding what they said and picking up on pithy but misleading quotes. It is a key part of how the game is played.
Reading through Reddit, someone asked what sites you can go to which are like Breitbart but to the left. One answer I thought was interesting was something like "all other news sites."
There are a small number of sites which seem to get pretty close to middle. I would still want to follow a mainstream and right left leaning site to get my bearings though.
However, I do think it's useful to know the narratives which are being spun out of the facts. Then when you have a discussion with someone, you understand how they arrived to whatever crazy beliefs they might have.
This is only true from a very rightwing point of view. If you want a real left wing point of view, read actual left wing sites like www.wsws.org a real socialist site. They have not much in common with CNN.
In general, if I am interested in a certain topic I try to read both sides. Russia, China and co. have also english newspapers. Then I usually find out that both sides lie or disconnects facts from context to a point that I think I got a basic understanding of what happened, but are disgusted by all of it and leave.
Anecdotally, most of the "Fake News" that has been shown to me as examples of "lies/falsehoods" are actually stories written in such a way that people jump to a conclusion. Sometimes they are designed that way for clicks/buzz/bias. Other times the author simply didn't mention any mitigating circumstances.
Ultimately, I think we all need to realize that there is no universal truth when it comes to politics and humanities. It's all about persuasiveness.