News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Disturbing Power of Information Pollution by dredmorbius on Saturday January 11, 2020 @03:09AM (#22018821)
There's a distinction between facts and narrative which can be important.

Facts stand or fall on their own, for the most part, in conformance to some external reality.

Narrative is the thread or story that's created, not just from individual facts, but the relationships which are drawn between them. It's possible to tell a false story (e.g., not truth), from a set of true facts, by misrepresenting the relationships between those facts.

This is how much (bad/false) conspiracy-theory stories get constructed -- if they're not totally true, they're a mix of truth and falsehood, but the narrative by which they're strung together is almost wholly false or misleading. This creates a huge cognitive load in addressing as you've got to sift through and sort the truths from falsehoods, both atomically (for any given event, place, person, thing, etc.), and for the relationships between elements.

There's a particularly insidious (and extremely long) bullshit conspiracy theory, "Everything is a Rich Man's Trick", tying everything from WWII to JFK to Nixon and beyond together, which operates on this basis. There are a great many indisputably true facts (several quite interesting ones) in the piece. But the relationships are bullshit, with one of the early lies being that JFK's "Secret Society" speech addressed anything other than the Soviet Union -- which listening a few seconds outside the clip included in the video makes clear.

Among the problems usual approaches to debunking encounter is that fact-checking individual items within such stories fails to address the overall narrative.

There's also the case that a story can be constructed of fictitious events, and yet be fundamentally true or accurate. This can show up in science (Gregor Mendel's genetic inheritence research appears to have been at least in part fabricated), in journalism (elements and facts in many stories are incorrect, though the overall narrative is often roughly accurate), in fiction (historical, political, or other fiction can create a highly-accurate or realistic picture of events or conditions) etc.

Where facts and narrative both align with reality, they're often quite compelling.

Re:The Disturbing Power of Information Pollution by hutzlibu on Saturday January 11, 2020 @05:57AM (#22019280)
"There's a particularly insidious (and extremely long) bullshit conspiracy theory, "Everything is a Rich Man's Trick", tying everything from WWII to JFK to Nixon and beyond together"

Oh no, the conspiracy goes back way longer. When the secret cult started building pyramids all over the world and then they hijacked Jesus teachings and corrupted it and when they brought down the roman empire, just after Atlantis ...

I can recomend Illuminatus! by Wilson and Shea. It was written under the hilarious assumption that all the conspiracies are true ..

Re:The Disturbing Power of Information Pollution by dredmorbius on Saturday January 11, 2020 @02:42PM (#22021835)
My point is that for the specific instance I'd noted, the mechanism is evident and known to me.

Not that it is original or unique.