It’s small but has outsized impact on how the internet works.
That said maybe devolution was eventually inevitable.
The Obama admin's intent was to increase faith in ICANN by pulling it away from strictly American interests.
That does not appeared to have worked out.
I agree, but even that is far from ideal because which government should control it?
I feel like that's the way ICANN should have gone, and it is probably worth it to just buy out the organization and put it under the UN. Either that or some version of decentralized DNS is going to start looking really attractive and ICANN will become the equivalent of a failed state.
The legal doctrine that established a nexus in the US simply because ICANN was controlled by the US government had long-term geopolitical repercussions. In the lead up, the FBI seized the domains belonging to sites that otherwise had no ties to the US under this doctrine. I suspect the long-term fear was that other countries would deploy their own root name server, which would not in the American national interest.
Was it ICANN that sued/was sued by one of its own _board members_ to not have to show them their finances?
> This is a classic case of regulation being abused by those in power to give each other a bonus.
He dropped regulation and oversight, and the result is we now suffer because of regulation?
Their value doesn't, so why should renewals go down?* It's not like registration is related to anything like cost of operation...
*: I'm not in favour of this, but living in a capitalist market, I'm surprised things haven't gotten much worse, e.g. a sliding scale cost for domains, so Amazon would have to pay $50,000,000/year for its domain, for example.
If ICANN really wants more money, they'd increase the renewal fee for parked domains every year until it's actually put into use.
and how do you differentiate a parked domain from a non-parked domain?
at which point the government suddenly feels an urgent need to step in.
It would seem like it should.
Why? The value of a dollar goes down over time, but the value of a domain does not.
Value and Cost are very different things. ICANN is a governing organization, and once they're allowed to extract funds greater than what it costs them to operate, just means they're abusing their power.
The value of high-demand domain names should increase on the secondary markets. But, the price of unregistered names should be decreasing.
Domains are more like real estate. They can become almost arbitrarily expensive on the global market because they represent a somewhat exhaustible resource of phrases that people can actually remember.
As with any system where you have private resource owners controlling a basic need you should expect corruption and abuse of the customer base. From Water Barons to Landlords to Cable/Broadband companies the pattern repeats itself time and time again. This is why we have regulated industries.
In 2014 the Obama Admin decided to cede control of ICANN.
ICANN is run like a classic Italian mafia org, with corruption at every level and zero accountability.
This year the Trump Admin rubber stamped a price increase on .com because.... reasons?
The price of domains should trend down. not up. This is a classic case of regulation being abused by those in power to give each other a bonus.
Running a global address book has gotten cheaper and easier with automation and yet we're allowing these orgs to just increase prices willynilly instead of trying to make internet hosting more accessible.