News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by mc32 on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @01:10PM (#21982694)
I think something like this should have remained within government. Deregulation here wasn’t necessary.

It’s small but has outsized impact on how the internet works.

That said maybe devolution was eventually inevitable.

Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by vorpalhex on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @02:45PM (#21983943)
> should have remained within government

The Obama admin's intent was to increase faith in ICANN by pulling it away from strictly American interests.

That does not appeared to have worked out.

Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by mc32 on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @03:21PM (#21984364)
I guess that raises the question, was there a problem with its governance in the first place?
Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by unapologetic on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @06:31PM (#21986457)
Yes, there always was. ICANN has always been a lousy system, now it's a lousy and extremely corrupt system.
Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by lostlogin on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @01:28PM (#21982923)
> something like this should have remained within government.

I agree, but even that is far from ideal because which government should control it?

Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by jszymborski on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @02:00PM (#21983348)
Maybe an organisational structure like the WTO?
Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by killjoywashere on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @03:30PM (#21984447)
For the uninitiated, the World Trade Organization is run by its member governments. Unlike FIFA, IOC, and ICANN, it does not sell a product to consumers. It facilitates the production of laws and agreements between member states. If you buy Bueno de Mesquita's selectorate theory, the WTO has a very small set of residents, which is identical to the selectorate and the winning coalition. The FIFA, IOC, and ICANN have a very large set of residents, a very small selectorate, and a very secure winning coalition, which is a recipe for corruption.
Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by mc32 on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @04:16PM (#21984966)
What’s your take on something like the ITU? My first reaction would be that because there’s a lot more riding on it, it’d be susceptible to intractable politics... but maybe I’m overthinking it.
Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by killjoywashere on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @04:49PM (#21985316)
ITU is under the United Nations, so it's more like the WTO.

I feel like that's the way ICANN should have gone, and it is probably worth it to just buy out the organization and put it under the UN. Either that or some version of decentralized DNS is going to start looking really attractive and ICANN will become the equivalent of a failed state.

Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by turtlecloud on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @04:59PM (#21985452)
Who else do you think? Globalists of course.
Re:ICANN extracts $20m signing fee for $1bn dot-com price in... by sangnoir on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:37PM (#21985893)
> I think something like this should have remained within government. Deregulation here wasn’t necessary.

The legal doctrine that established a nexus in the US simply because ICANN was controlled by the US government had long-term geopolitical repercussions. In the lead up, the FBI seized the domains belonging to sites that otherwise had no ties to the US under this doctrine. I suspect the long-term fear was that other countries would deploy their own root name server, which would not in the American national interest.